Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should dogs be allowed in more places?

538 replies

Patchworkknitter · 05/08/2021 17:44

I'm a bit hurt today but I don't know if I'm being completely unreasonable.

A friend and I were trying to arrange to meet up. We had sorted what we were doing and then she changed her mind and wanted to change where we did something which would have added another 90 minutes onto the day.

I couldn't do that as my dog would already have been left all day (with 2 dog walks from a dog walker). Even with the dog walker, he couldn't do another 90 minutes. My friend got a bit cross and said I should just get my parents to look after him but they're already looking after him the day before so it wouldn't be fair. I don't like to ask them too often, a bit like people don't like to look after their children too often.

It just seems we always do child friendly places (I'm not a Mum but I try my best to be understanding of her childcare needs). She says she can't afford any additional childcare to that which she already needs for work but I can't afford additional dog care either (I pay £400 a month and don't have a partner to share any costs).

It got me thinking how restrictive it can be having a dog as a single person. I wouldn't change him for the world but it's incredibly difficult. If it was childcare I feel people would be much more understanding.

If I was a mum I could take my children pretty much everywhere.
As a dog owner, I can no longer go to the cinema, to most pubs, to restaurants, to the theatre, shopping, etc without paying out for extra dog care.

I feel dogs should be allowed in more places, more shops, more cafes, more pubs etc. Aibu?

OP posts:
tigger1001 · 08/08/2021 14:02

@TheFoundations you said it's good to train your dog but only because others are irresponsible. No. It is the mark of a responsible dog owner to train their dog regardless. Responsible owners ensure their dogs are not being a nuisance to others, be it human or animals. Failure to do so can have tragic consequences. Far too many owners seem to think others love their dog as much as they do.

Taking your analogy earlier of women going out in the dark. Should a man (or another woman) act in an aggressive manner then you have the right to protect yourself. Same thing. If a dog minding its own business is on a lead (or not) and another bounds over to it - then that dog can protect itself. It's the one not on the lead that is out of control. Not the one protecting itself from a strange dog it doesn't know.

I find your views very odd, and thankfully at odds with the responsible owners I know,

Turn it around. Your dog hasn't been well or is recovering from injury. They are not quite themselves so you are walking them on a short lead. Another dog, not on a lead comes bounding over and gets in the face of your dog. Your dog snaps and bites it. You ok with having your dog removed from your care? Because after all it's your fault as you are being irresponsible for walking your dog on the lead.

Sadiecow · 08/08/2021 13:57

@TheFoundations keep your dog under control and stop saying "it's socialising" it's not for a lot of dogs it's stress.

It's owners like you that have made me get a "I need space" jacket. I don't want your dog near my puppy. Keep it by your side or on a lead.

stevalnamechanger · 08/08/2021 13:42

Just find a trusted friend to have him or sign up to borrow my doggy!

Loads of options

TheFoundations · 08/08/2021 13:39

Out of the two posters debating this, I think you are the irresponsible one and not the one who keeps their dog on a short lead

The dog that attacks is a dog who attacks. It doesn't really matter if you think I'm irresponsible. I haven't abdicated my responsibility for anything, and you have quoted me saying it's good to train your dog not to bound up to other dogs.

I think the issue here is that there's a difference in what people think provocation is. Keep your dog away from mine if it's likely to attack, and I'll be making sure, as I have always, that my dog isn't actively provoking other dogs.

Don't try to lay the blame on me if your dog attacks another dog because it feels threatened by it walking past or offering a peaceful hello in the dog friendly area of the park, where the dogs are mostly off lead and enjoying playing happily together. Your dog needs a muzzle if it's likely to attack in these circumstances.

People are so black and white, and situations aren't.

tigger1001 · 08/08/2021 13:13

"agree that it's a good idea to train your dog no to go bounding up to others, but that's only because there are irresponsible owners like yourself around, who think that everybody else should be taking responsibility for your dog's behaviour."

A dog that bounds over to another person or dog is the one out of control. It's funny you say that it appears to be everyone else responsibility to ensure a dog on a short lead doesn't attack another dog, yet fail to see that it's also your responsibility to ensure your dog doesn't go near other dogs/people and has good recall or have said dog on a lead, rather than blaming everyone else if yours gets bitten due to your irresponsible behaviour by not ensuring it's trained properly or on a lead, to stop it jumping on others.

Out of the two posters debating this, I think you are the irresponsible one and not the one who keeps their dog on a short lead.

A dog getting up in the face of another dog risks getting bitten. Even the most placid dog could bite if frightened by an out of controlled dog. Take your own advise and be a responsible owner and either train your dog properly to not jump on others or keep it on a lead.

tigger1001 · 08/08/2021 13:05

@Sadiecow

A dog that approaches another without invitation is the one not under control.

You're one of those bad owners that gives it "he is friendly".

My puppy is friendly, but I will not allow her to approach other people, dogs, horses etc. She is by my side and that's where she stays.

It's people like you that should not have dogs.

As previous PP says the on lead dog has the right to defend itself.

Totally agree. Yet owners who don't do this and their dog gets bitten because of its own bad behaviour then try to blame others, as is evidenced on this thread. Rather than take responsibility to ensure their dog is well trained and has good recall. Far too many owners do the whole "he's just being friendly" as their out of control dog jumps over other dogs/people.

No it's not just being friendly. It's out of control and being allowed to be so by an irresponsible owner.

It's often the same with dogs caught by farmers sheep worrying. Some owners blame everyone apart from themselves if the farmer shoots the dog.

gogohm · 08/08/2021 11:22

Never had an issue with finding dog friendly activities myself, there's so many places you can take them, but then I have a well trained dog, whose fine left in the car (not in hot weather obviously) sits under tables in pubs etc and loves visiting people. If we had a special occasion we would leave plenty of food and water at home and leave him for a longer period (normally he was left 5 hours each day anyway) and he was just fine - we did try kennels but that stressed him out, he much preferred just being home alone but he's rather keen on he's own company anyway disappearing on his own even when we were home

liveforsummer · 08/08/2021 11:01

@StrangeToSee

And by socialisation I don’t mean letting your dog bound up to stranger’s dogs in the park. Socialisation is introducing your puppy to lots of dogs with CONSENT from the owners, so they learn to read canine body language and how to play (without annoying or frightening nervous dogs, and avoiding dogs they don’t know).
This, whilst teaching them to ignore the majority of dogs including every strangers dogs. Puppy play mates should be well matched and well thought out in terms of temperament and size etc not just letting all load of random dogs charge about.

Just today I was walking my little 6 kilo dog to heel on a lead along the path and this huge doodle type dog comes bounding up to her. She lunged, snarled and barked but only when he approached so close that he was right in her space. Owner gasps and says disapprovingly 'he only wanted to be friendly' aarggghhhhh!!

TheFoundations · 08/08/2021 11:01

A dog on a short lead is under control

A lead does not denote control. A dog on a short lead that attacks is an out of control dog, and the owner is responsible for the attack.

My solution has nothing to do with have dogs put to sleep.

My solution is that people like yourself who think that their dog's attack is the victim's responsibility need to have their dogs removed from them, and the dogs need to be rehomed with people who can keep them under control.

The law is not on your side. If you can find the legislation that says a dog on a lead is classed as 'under control', even whilst it's attacking somebody/another animal, please do post a link.

I agree that it's a good idea to train your dog no to go bounding up to others, but that's only because there are irresponsible owners like yourself around, who think that everybody else should be taking responsibility for your dog's behaviour.

It's a bit like saying that women shouldn't go out alone after dark; it is safer to abide by that guidance, but not because the women would be responsible if there was an attack.

If an on-lead dog feels threatened and gets hold of the harassing dog by the throat, there’s nothing a responsible owner can do other than order their dog to drop it, pull their dog away and hope the other dog doesn’t keep returning. And of course yell for the owner to intervene

You're right. That's why responsible owners don't allow this situation to occur in the first place, by making sure that their dangerous dog is appropriately muzzled.

LST · 08/08/2021 10:54

[quote TheFoundations]**@StrangeToSee* @LST* @Sadiecow

It really doesn't matter what you think or what I think. The fact is that regardless of whether your dog or my dog is on a lead, a dog that attacks is a dog that attacks. The owner is responsible for making sure a dog does not attack, and responsible for any damage done or injuries caused if it does.

If you own a dog and think that your dog attacking someone could be anyone's responsibility but yours, you need your dogs removing from you, because a dog that attacks is not under control.[/quote]
If you let your off lead dog approach another dog on lead then it is your responsibility. The law agrees.

Sadiecow · 08/08/2021 10:52

A dog that approaches another without invitation is the one not under control.

You're one of those bad owners that gives it "he is friendly".

My puppy is friendly, but I will not allow her to approach other people, dogs, horses etc. She is by my side and that's where she stays.

It's people like you that should not have dogs.

As previous PP says the on lead dog has the right to defend itself.

StrangeToSee · 08/08/2021 10:51

And by socialisation I don’t mean letting your dog bound up to stranger’s dogs in the park. Socialisation is introducing your puppy to lots of dogs with CONSENT from the owners, so they learn to read canine body language and how to play (without annoying or frightening nervous dogs, and avoiding dogs they don’t know).

StrangeToSee · 08/08/2021 10:46

The fact is that regardless of whether your dog or my dog is on a lead, a dog that attacks is a dog that attacks. The owner is responsible for making sure a dog does not attack, and responsible for any damage done or injuries caused if it does. If you own a dog and think that your dog attacking someone could be anyone's responsibility but yours, you need your dogs removing from you, because a dog that attacks is not under control

I disagree (as does the law).

All dogs have the potential to attack, that’s why I think they should all be on leads in public spaces.

Lots of reactive dogs only attack other dogs when they feel threatened (eg when an off lead dog gets in their face and won’t go away). What’s your solution, have all dog-reactive dogs PTS?

A dog on a short lead is under control. A dog that bounds up to on-lead dogs to be ‘sociable’ is way out of control, a danger to itself and a nuisance.

If an on-lead dog feels threatened and gets hold of the harassing dog by the throat, there’s nothing a responsible owner can do other than order their dog to drop it, pull their dog away and hope the other dog doesn’t keep returning. And of course yell for the owner to intervene!

My dog was attacked by a pair of staffie-types when he was younger. So no, he’s not muzzled as if attacked he needs to be able to defend himself. Being a rescue he missed the crucial socialisation phase dogs go through (he was locked in a flat with young kids and no other dogs pre-rescue). So he often perceives a friendly charge from a strange dog as an attack.

PizzaPiePizzaPie · 07/08/2021 23:43

It might be a replacement child to you, to everyone else, it’s a dog.

I grew up with dogs. My dad said a dog is the most annoying/difficult child you can have. I wish more people realised how difficult a dog can be and how much time they can take up, and how they can limit your activity.
It’s fine if you realise that.

TheFoundations · 07/08/2021 23:13

@StrangeToSee @LST @Sadiecow

It really doesn't matter what you think or what I think. The fact is that regardless of whether your dog or my dog is on a lead, a dog that attacks is a dog that attacks. The owner is responsible for making sure a dog does not attack, and responsible for any damage done or injuries caused if it does.

If you own a dog and think that your dog attacking someone could be anyone's responsibility but yours, you need your dogs removing from you, because a dog that attacks is not under control.

LemonRoses · 07/08/2021 18:23

[quote TheFoundations]@StrangeToSee

If you are holding your dog on a lead and restraining him, and he still manages to injure another dog, it is still the case that your dog was out of control. That's nobody's responsibility except yours.

Unless another dog (off lead or otherwise) attacks him, it's all on you, and it's unreasonable of you to suggest that dogs should be trained not to approach other dogs. It's one of the reasons we take our dogs out; so that they can socialise with other dogs.

It's not all about you. If you feel uncomfortable about the risk that your dog presents to others, you need to restrain/muzzle appropriately. It's a shame your dog feels the way he does, but that doesn't mean that if he attacks, it's the victim's fault.[/quote]
Sounds like you don’t have proper control of your dog. You shouldn’t be taking your dog out to inflict them on others. Socialisation is not about being happy to bounce up to other dogs or sniff them. It’s about teaching them to ignore other dogs unless they have been told they are allowed.
If an owner suggests you call your dog back, it should return to you immediately. If you see it pestering other dogs, people or ducks on a pond you should call it back immediately.
If you cannot manage that, your dog should be on a lead whenever outside.

StrangeToSee · 07/08/2021 18:07

If you feel uncomfortable about the risk that your dog presents to others, you need to restrain/muzzle appropriately. It's a shame your dog feels the way he does, but that doesn't mean that if he attacks, it's the victim's fault

It’s the other dog’s fault (or rather the owner’s fault) if they let their dog try to ‘socialise’ with one on a lead.

Provided the reactive dog is fine with people (like mine) there’s no need to muzzle him in public. The other dog is not a ‘victim’ it’s an off lead out of control dog harassing one on a lead. This is why I wear a go pro for walks, in case someone tries to claim my dog was off the lead.

I can pull him backwards but I can’t stop your dog.

StrangeToSee · 07/08/2021 17:52

If you are holding your dog on a lead and restraining him, and he still manages to injure another dog, it is still the case that your dog was out of control. That's nobody's responsibility except yours

No it’s not my responsibility. Letting you dog run free so it can ‘socialise’ with other dogs (or get into the face of on-lead dogs) is having an out of control dog.

I won’t muzzle mine because he needs to be able to defend himself if attacked by another dog. Which also happens more often than you may realise.

If I’m holding him back, trying to drive the other dog away and it keeps running up to him, I can’t save the other dog from injury. The owner should be there to recall it (before it approaches him ideally!)

PearlclutchersInc · 07/08/2021 14:35

As much as I love my pets I wouldnt want them to be in pubs, restaurants etc - its not fair on them. Some spaces are just not suitable eg busy, loud etc. In other spaces they can be a trip hazard.

What's that, your pet is really well behaved would stay close to you, is calm and wouldn't get spooked. Yeah, thats what they all say.....

Grellbunt · 07/08/2021 14:26

What I don't understand is how some owners that I see with huge dogs would be able to control the dog if they decided to really just run away. Surely big dogs are really strong? A lot of the owners seem to struggle holding them back when the dog lunges eg at another dog - isn't it a bit risky for those small owners having such a powerful dog?

LST · 07/08/2021 14:03

[quote TheFoundations]@StrangeToSee

If you are holding your dog on a lead and restraining him, and he still manages to injure another dog, it is still the case that your dog was out of control. That's nobody's responsibility except yours.

Unless another dog (off lead or otherwise) attacks him, it's all on you, and it's unreasonable of you to suggest that dogs should be trained not to approach other dogs. It's one of the reasons we take our dogs out; so that they can socialise with other dogs.

It's not all about you. If you feel uncomfortable about the risk that your dog presents to others, you need to restrain/muzzle appropriately. It's a shame your dog feels the way he does, but that doesn't mean that if he attacks, it's the victim's fault.[/quote]
Wow you're so wrong. You shouldn't let your dog approach other dogs on lead or off lead unless the owner says it's ok. If you can't recall your dog then it shouldn't be off the lead. Full stop.

CounsellorTroi · 07/08/2021 13:38

I didn’t say it wasn’t a choice but bit ridiculous to call it a ‘lifestyle choice’, it’s just being used to disparage those with children.

The only time I hear it said that having children is a lifestyle choice is when it's being used to argue against fertility treatment being provided on the NHS. Funny that.

Sadiecow · 07/08/2021 13:23

[quote TheFoundations]@StrangeToSee

If you are holding your dog on a lead and restraining him, and he still manages to injure another dog, it is still the case that your dog was out of control. That's nobody's responsibility except yours.

Unless another dog (off lead or otherwise) attacks him, it's all on you, and it's unreasonable of you to suggest that dogs should be trained not to approach other dogs. It's one of the reasons we take our dogs out; so that they can socialise with other dogs.

It's not all about you. If you feel uncomfortable about the risk that your dog presents to others, you need to restrain/muzzle appropriately. It's a shame your dog feels the way he does, but that doesn't mean that if he attacks, it's the victim's fault.[/quote]
Of course you shouldn't let your dog approach an on lead dog! My puppy is in training, she wears a give me space jacket. She is being trained to ignore other dogs, but ridiculous owners like you still let their dogs approach her.

So irresponsible!

nosyupnorth · 07/08/2021 13:11

Of course you can leave a dog for a few hours to do other things. I get that the recommendation is not regularly leaving them alone all day, but it won't do them any harm if you're out for five hours instead of four on occasion as long as they've had exercise beforehand and ideally a dog flap or other provision for their toilet needs. They manage 8+ hours overnight while their caretakers are sleeping after all.

TheFoundations · 07/08/2021 12:18

@StrangeToSee

If you are holding your dog on a lead and restraining him, and he still manages to injure another dog, it is still the case that your dog was out of control. That's nobody's responsibility except yours.

Unless another dog (off lead or otherwise) attacks him, it's all on you, and it's unreasonable of you to suggest that dogs should be trained not to approach other dogs. It's one of the reasons we take our dogs out; so that they can socialise with other dogs.

It's not all about you. If you feel uncomfortable about the risk that your dog presents to others, you need to restrain/muzzle appropriately. It's a shame your dog feels the way he does, but that doesn't mean that if he attacks, it's the victim's fault.

Swipe left for the next trending thread