Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should dogs be allowed in more places?

538 replies

Patchworkknitter · 05/08/2021 17:44

I'm a bit hurt today but I don't know if I'm being completely unreasonable.

A friend and I were trying to arrange to meet up. We had sorted what we were doing and then she changed her mind and wanted to change where we did something which would have added another 90 minutes onto the day.

I couldn't do that as my dog would already have been left all day (with 2 dog walks from a dog walker). Even with the dog walker, he couldn't do another 90 minutes. My friend got a bit cross and said I should just get my parents to look after him but they're already looking after him the day before so it wouldn't be fair. I don't like to ask them too often, a bit like people don't like to look after their children too often.

It just seems we always do child friendly places (I'm not a Mum but I try my best to be understanding of her childcare needs). She says she can't afford any additional childcare to that which she already needs for work but I can't afford additional dog care either (I pay £400 a month and don't have a partner to share any costs).

It got me thinking how restrictive it can be having a dog as a single person. I wouldn't change him for the world but it's incredibly difficult. If it was childcare I feel people would be much more understanding.

If I was a mum I could take my children pretty much everywhere.
As a dog owner, I can no longer go to the cinema, to most pubs, to restaurants, to the theatre, shopping, etc without paying out for extra dog care.

I feel dogs should be allowed in more places, more shops, more cafes, more pubs etc. Aibu?

OP posts:
TedMullins · 05/08/2021 19:36

I have a dog, I’m also single and live alone (with my dog) I’m obsessed with my dog but YABU. Where I live 99% of pubs are dog-friendly. If I want to go somewhere without him he stays at home for up to 4 hours alone. Sometimes he goes to the dog walker, sometimes my neighbour has him. It sounds like your problems are more to do with where you live not having many leisure facilities nearby and your friend being selfish and unreasonable, rather than dogs not being allowed in enough places. (While we’re here, though, I would happily see fewer places allow children)

RossPoldarksWife · 05/08/2021 19:35

No, too many entitled dog owners take their dogs everywhere with no regard to anyone else.
Their not “your child” it’s a bloody dog, an animal.
You chose to get a dog and all the responsibilities it brings. Just like other people choose to have children with all the responsibilities they bring. Both mean missing out on some things.
The entitlement of dog owners is unbelievable.

BaublesAndGlitter · 05/08/2021 19:35

I don't think dogs should be allowed in more types of establishment (ie theatres or cinemas etc) but having more dog friendly pubs / hotels / cafes to choose from can make all the difference IMO.

Last year we took Ddog on holiday to Scotland and it was lovely to be able to still go out for a meal / stop for a drink / stay at a fancy b&b and bring DDog with us. Saved a bloody fortune in kennelling fees too - but we were only comfortable to do that because BaublesDog is older, completely unflappable and quiet.
Compete opposite to where I live where there is 1 dog friendly cafe that I'm aware of.

Also, all this dog v children nonsense are missing the point I think. Both children and pets need someone (parent or owner) to look after them and ensure their needs are met. Neither can just be left alone while parent / owner goes out for dinner etc but people are aware and give leeway for childcare - not so much for pets.
And the whole 'you chose to have a dog' doesn't wash either because a fair amount of people chose to have children too.

As an aside, I've spent many an evening at a cinema / restaurant etc and had the experience interrupted or ruined by badly behaved children!

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 05/08/2021 19:34

Blossomtoes assistance dogs only automatically limits number of dogs and excludes poorly trained dogs (as long as the American model of any animal is an assistance animal if its owner says it is, is avoided).

Goldbar · 05/08/2021 19:33

No, they're already allowed in more than enough places.

But your friend should accommodate you and meet somewhere dog-friendly.

budgun · 05/08/2021 19:33

@Blossomtoes

Of course there is a difference

There isn’t. If you have a dog allergy or phobia it doesn’t magically disappear if the dog is an assistance animal. A dog is a dog.

I'm not sure why this is the angle you have decided to attack but it is very clearly not what anybody was saying when they said assistance dogs are different.

RickJames · 05/08/2021 19:32

@crazycatgal

We live in Germany. Dogs are taken very seriously here and everyone goes to puppy school. I struggle to recall a time when I've seen a dog misbehave in public indoors.

I personally don't do all the puppy school and rigid rules but then I only keep mild-mannered dogs. I don't go for big, fancy breeds. I must admit, i often walk past people bent backwards anchoring GSDs and Cane Corsos, foaming at the mouth on the lead. But you'd never see these dogs in a shop or restaurant. I just assume they are home protection dogs.

The dog laws here are very strict. You have to register your fog with the tax authority. That probably helps with responsibility.

Blossomtoes · 05/08/2021 19:31

Of course there is a difference

There isn’t. If you have a dog allergy or phobia it doesn’t magically disappear if the dog is an assistance animal. A dog is a dog.

Sxxyfing · 05/08/2021 19:30

Dogs should be allowed in less places in my opinion as well as being made to stay on a lead in any public place. I'd even go so far to muzzle certain breeds in public. People and their children should be able to enjoy life without having to experience other people's pets

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 05/08/2021 19:30

crazycatgal I've lived in Germany for 14 years and never seen a dog in a restaurant or bar here, very, very occasionally in a cafe, more often outdoors in beer gardens (where you'd see them in the UK too) maybe once a year I see a small "toy" type dog in a clothing shop - once and once only a totally inappropriate large muddy dog on a long lead with an owner paying no attention to it. There are fewer dogs per head of population than in the UK and owners legally have to register them with the council and importantly are legally obliged to have insurance for any damage or injury they might cause.

I've noticed on visits to the UK in recent years that there are far more dogs than 20 years ago and they're everywhere - people used to leave them at home - and there are far more untrained dogs treated like very over indulged children by owners who appear not to really know that's not in the dog's - never mind anyone else's - best interest.

StrangeToSee · 05/08/2021 19:29

If I was a mum I could take my children pretty much everywhere. As a dog owner, I can no longer go to the cinema, to most pubs, to restaurants, to the theatre, shopping, etc without paying out for extra dog care. I feel dogs should be allowed in more places, more shops, more cafes, more pubs etc. Aibu?

You can’t compare a human child with your pet dog. A child is a citizen, a member of society. Your dog is an animal.

I say this as a mother AND a dog owner; train your dog to be able to stay home alone for longer periods. It’s the core of training. As long as she has access to the garden and plenty of water, someone taking her for a walk, she should be fine. If she’s not then something’s gone wrong in her training.

Our dog (rescue) has his own heated kennel in the garden. He doesn’t come everywhere with us. We can leave him for a day and he’s content.

I want to be able to take my kids to the cinema, restaurants, shops and cafes without dogs around.

Dogs are smelly and shed hair, often wee and poo in inappropriate places; imagine how revolting it would be in a small cafe in warm weather, fluff drifting through the air to land in your cake. Or the smell of dog poo in the cinema!

Not to mention what happens when lots of dogs are allowed in the same place; dog fights, sudden ear splitting barking, people treating their dogs like humans and letting them sit on the seats etc. Dogs wandering about licking and sniffing random people, trying to snatch food, terrorising kids (and adults) who fear dogs.

How would you like a pet pig wandering around the restaurant? Or a goat?

We need more dog free spaces not less! People want to be able to enjoy going out without dogs around. Personally I hate it when I see dogs on the train or bus, it seems so inappropriate and unhygienic.

lazylinguist · 05/08/2021 19:29

Sorry but YABU. The fact that you don't have children does not make your dog your child. Your dog is your dog. And I say that as a devoted dog owner.

It's great that dogs are allowed in some pubs and cafés. They should not be allowed in cinemas, theatres, formal restaurants etc. And ideally they shouldn't be allowed in all pubs and cafés, because some people are scared of or allergic to dogs.

Having a dog is a choice, as having children is a choice. They are both restrictive in their own ways. But it would be naïve to expect people to give your dog equal consideration to a child.

Heyha · 05/08/2021 19:25

Actually thinking about it the cinema is a really shit environment for most dogs so why on earth anybody would want to take one (assistance dogs aside, they obviously have the training and temperament to go with the flow) is beyond me.

budgun · 05/08/2021 19:24

@Blossomtoes

There is a massive difference between an assistance dog and a pet dog

There isn’t. But one of the things prospective dog owners have to bear in mind is that they curtail your freedom. Ours can be left for four hours or so and that means we can go just about anywhere we want to. Otherwise she has to have a night in kennels.

Of course there is a difference

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/08/2021 19:24

Maybe we should say “well humans are allowed in so many places, all buildings in fact, so I thin dogs should be. Plus my friend always wants to meet up in human friendly cafes which I think is unfair.”

Couchbettato · 05/08/2021 19:24

"Lots of children have accidents. The pool I swim at has regularly been closed due to child poo."

As the owner of a dog and a child I can absolutely assure you my dog shits in places it shouldn't more than my child.

1forAll74 · 05/08/2021 19:24

I think that a lot of people should maybe not have a dog/dogs. if the dog has to be alone, or looked after by someone else. But anyway, there has to be some limits, where you can take a dog.. I was in some fancy tea room place some while ago, sat outside., and a woman came and sat at the table next to me, with her two little dogs, She kept speaking to them like they were little babies, and giving them pieces of cake all the time, they then both went under the table, and both did a messy crap under there, which smelt foul in the hot weather. She then walked off to the car park and drove off, with everyone outside complaining about her, and the tea shop owner left to clear up the sloppy mess.

LondonJax · 05/08/2021 19:24

I know you've said you're out OP but in case you're lurking. I perfectly understand the 'my dog is my child' remark. Before I met DH and was lucky enough to have a very late child, my cat was - well not my baby, but I was very attached to him.

But like your dog, he wasn't allowed in places. If I adopted an elephant and kept it in my garden, it wouldn't be allowed into places. Most animals aren't. We, as humans, know that. So it's something that needs to be considered before you get a pet.

We now have a cat. She can be left overnight but no more than that. The spontaneous 'shall we see if we can book a hotel for the weekend' that we used to do before we got her has ended. If we want to go away for a weekend we need to find a cattery or someone reliable to feed her and let her out. That's what owning a pet is about.

Like having a child means an 18 year plus commitment to keeping that child safe. We just let children in everywhere because we know how to handle them, we can tell when a child is losing it's temper or about to misbehave. We can, usually, tell if they need to use the loo or are tired. Most of us don't know those signs in dogs because we don't own one. And that is then dangerous for children - who are much closer to bite level. Quite apart from the hygiene issues. It's sometimes hard enough going to cafes, cinema etc when you have a family who let their kids run riot. Having an animal doing the same is not on really. And, even with kids, some places are off limits. You don't see many kids in spas, nightclubs, pubs (the saloon bit)...and if you have a child those things are off limits unless you can find someone to have your kids or pay someone to do so. That's life - we can't all get what we want.

tigger1001 · 05/08/2021 19:23

@Sparklingbrook

There is a massive difference between an assistance dog and a pet dog

I agree. In people's perceptions, they understand that the dog is there for an essential reason. They are well behaved and have a job to do. No point in having an assistance dog and leaving it at home-like you can do with a non assistance pet dog.

Totally agree.

Assistance dogs are not the same as pet dogs, and are there to help its owner.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/08/2021 19:22

My children are not equivalent to dogs, and more than you or I are.

ReeseWitherfork · 05/08/2021 19:22

I'd leave my toddler at home while I went to the cinema if it was acceptable to do so. Plus if I knew he'd just curl up and sleep (possibly lick his balls a bit) like my dog does when I'm not home.

RickJames · 05/08/2021 19:22

@pinkcircustop

Yeah, obviously, thats why I said non-allergenic, not allergy proof. Nothing is 100% allergy proof because there's always someone who is hyper-allergic. All I know is she doesn't make anyone, we've ever met, itchy and sneezy. And folks do have a habit of huggjng her and kissing her so I think we are pretty non-allergenic. Many dogs are, but most aren't.

Sparklingbrook · 05/08/2021 19:19

There is a massive difference between an assistance dog and a pet dog

I agree. In people's perceptions, they understand that the dog is there for an essential reason. They are well behaved and have a job to do. No point in having an assistance dog and leaving it at home-like you can do with a non assistance pet dog.

Grellbunt · 05/08/2021 19:18

@crazycatgal

I don't know why most people are piling on like allowing dogs in more places is an absurd idea.

In Germany dogs are allowed inside shopping centres and most bars and restaurants.

I don't think that is true at all.
Grellbunt · 05/08/2021 19:17

@AssistanceDogOwner

As a disabled person and assistance dog owner this thread makes me very sad.
Your dog is well trained and has an important role helping you! It isn't comparable.