Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should dogs be allowed in more places?

538 replies

Patchworkknitter · 05/08/2021 17:44

I'm a bit hurt today but I don't know if I'm being completely unreasonable.

A friend and I were trying to arrange to meet up. We had sorted what we were doing and then she changed her mind and wanted to change where we did something which would have added another 90 minutes onto the day.

I couldn't do that as my dog would already have been left all day (with 2 dog walks from a dog walker). Even with the dog walker, he couldn't do another 90 minutes. My friend got a bit cross and said I should just get my parents to look after him but they're already looking after him the day before so it wouldn't be fair. I don't like to ask them too often, a bit like people don't like to look after their children too often.

It just seems we always do child friendly places (I'm not a Mum but I try my best to be understanding of her childcare needs). She says she can't afford any additional childcare to that which she already needs for work but I can't afford additional dog care either (I pay £400 a month and don't have a partner to share any costs).

It got me thinking how restrictive it can be having a dog as a single person. I wouldn't change him for the world but it's incredibly difficult. If it was childcare I feel people would be much more understanding.

If I was a mum I could take my children pretty much everywhere.
As a dog owner, I can no longer go to the cinema, to most pubs, to restaurants, to the theatre, shopping, etc without paying out for extra dog care.

I feel dogs should be allowed in more places, more shops, more cafes, more pubs etc. Aibu?

OP posts:
godmum56 · 05/08/2021 19:51

oh PS I don't think that children should be given free access to public places either :)

Hopeisallineed · 05/08/2021 19:51

Dogs are not children, as much as I love them I think it’s totally wrong to treat one as such. Honestly believe this is part of a huge problem of badly trained animals across the size ( and beyond).

gotalottolose · 05/08/2021 19:50

I’m a dog owner and I wouldn’t want dogs to be allowed everywhere. I know a couple of people with allergies and it would make life so much harder for them. I also wouldn’t been keen about seeing them in places like food shops.

Dog crèches would be useful though! Build them in town centres and let people drop off their dogs to play while they shop, without feeling guilty or needing to rush back.

godmum56 · 05/08/2021 19:50

I am a dog lover, my beloved boy is getting old and can't be left alone at all and I still said yabu. Most of the examples you give are places that the dog will not enjoy at all. Assistance dogs learn to tolerate them after intensive training but I think wanting to take your dog to theatres and cinemas is not fair at all on the dog. Yes it is VERY restrictive having a dog as a single person but you chose to do it, same as I did.

TheFoundations · 05/08/2021 19:49

My dog is my child. The only one I'll ever have

Do you think that makes it the same as a human?

I have a dog. I love her to bits and take her everywhere I can. I'd love to take her everywhere full stop, but I recognise that there are hygiene issues, and also that not everybody thinks the same way as I do.

The fact that you haven't had a child doesn't mean that dogs don't drop hair, carry fleas, cock their legs inappropriately, and stare at people who are eating. Why do you think the fact you don't have children affects those things?

WildBluebell · 05/08/2021 19:47

I was bitten by a dog recently. It was on a leash, with its owner, and just decided to randomly attack me behind my back.
So no, I don't want more of them everywhere.

YABU

As a dog owner, I can no longer go to the cinema, to most pubs, to restaurants, to the theatre, shopping, etc without paying out for extra dog care.

Well, a dog is a luxury. Lots of people would like to have a dog, but are not getting one because of reasons like these.

Hopeisallineed · 05/08/2021 19:46

There’s was a dog at the cafe I went to today, it barked constantly. I’m
Not sure that would work at the cinema or the theatre? 😂

Lockheart · 05/08/2021 19:46

OP, there are plenty of dog-friendly options around if you do your research. You just need to be flexible in your planning. Do the dog-friendly stuff when you have care for it.

Your dog is not a child substitute and if you treat your dog like a child you'll end up with a dog with severe behaviour issues.

I also agree with other posters, a happy and stable dog CAN be left for a few hours. Not a whole day, but I'd say up to 6 hours is fine.

PetronellaPea · 05/08/2021 19:46

No they definitely shouldn’t be allowed in more places. I say that as dog lover. Over the last two weeks I’ve witnessed three instances where dogs have been incredibly disruptive in a public place (pub/restaurant). It’s really not acceptable and none of the owners removed their dogs from the vicinity which would have been the right thing to do.

Yes other people’s children are incredibly irritating a lot of the time, and most dogs are very well behaved. Most. When they’re not though it really impacts everyone else in a big way. Certain cultures also can have an aversion to dogs, and others are allergic or may have hygiene concerns so I don’t think it’s right they’re given as free access to public places as children are.

Ttbhappy · 05/08/2021 19:45

Dogs happier outside more than umm say shops as more natural because they are animals after all.

Lockheart · 05/08/2021 19:44

@Greencharge

I avoid anywhere that allows dogs inside, they are filthy.
All places must allow guide dogs in by law.

So that means you must never go anywhere.

SpeakingFranglais · 05/08/2021 19:44

No, I don’t want dogs in more shops and cafes and restaurants. Heaven forbid they start popping up in theatres when many of the seats were built for tiny Victorian bodies or the cinema, panting over my popcorn

I like dogs but this is ridiculous. Where do you draw the line? Bring the cat, the parrot gets lonely take it to the cinema, my horse needs exercising tether it up in the beer garden whilst I have a pint.

cakewench · 05/08/2021 19:42

I mean this kindly, though I'm not sure you're on the thread anymore.

A dog isn't a child. I've had dogs. They can absolutely be left for the amount of time you'd need for a trip to the cinema and a meal. Unfortunately, children cannot. Also, children need/ want that kind of stimulation as part of their growth into bigger humans. Activities your dog will enjoy will probably involve a local park, and most of the large ones I've been to have dog friendly areas where they can roam around off lead and have a grand time sniffing other dogs bums.

We lave loads of cafes in our town that love dogs, so no, I don't feel as if we need more.

GSD20 · 05/08/2021 19:41

We have just been to the lakes and took our very well behaved dog (trained therapy and obedience dog)
He sat under the table as we ate and we spent most of the holiday walking. It was camping so no hotels etc.
Ours was on lead the whole time and approached nobody without them asking to touch him first. We also didn’t take him anywhere indoors because he’s too big to avoid him touching things.

However, I was quite shocked at how many badly behaved and untrained dogs were around and how unbothered the owners were.
We saw some very aggressive ones in public places, had a chihuahua launch for our dogs face, saw some filthy ones in shops and lots of off lead ones running up to our dog/children and shoving their noses in our faces when it wasn’t wanted.
I also had to listen to some of them barking constantly and another couple breaking their own necks on flexi leads to run at other dogs in the town centre.

As a dog lover I can 100% understand why some people hate dogs in public as by the end I was sick to death of them! Owners need to be responsible enough to judge whether their dog would actually be okay in that type of environment and whether it’s behaviour will effect someone else. Clearly some owners are unable to do this!

I would think a normal well trained dog should be able to be left alone for 5 hours or so while we go out to eat or go to the cinema so it wouldn’t even cross my mind to take it!

Goldbar · 05/08/2021 19:40

Well, it comes down to the preference of the business owner, doesn't it? All businesses have the right to ban dogs/children if they choose. If it would benefit their business to allow dogs, they would (as many country pubs do). And I seem to remember a couple of pubs banning children.

Knittingupastorm · 05/08/2021 19:40

@Blossomtoes

Of course there is a difference

There isn’t. If you have a dog allergy or phobia it doesn’t magically disappear if the dog is an assistance animal. A dog is a dog.

No, but the benefits then outweigh the negatives because the need for someone to have their assistance dog with them overrules someone with a fear of dogs having to temporarily step outside. Someone just wanting to take their dog with them, just because, doesn’t overrule someone else’s phobia.

Besides, such a severe phobia would be rare. More people who are scared of dogs would be able to cope with a dog that they know is really well trained, it’s unknown dogs, off lead, jumping around that would be more of an issue.

Cillmantain · 05/08/2021 19:40

I love dogs but please don't compare them to children.
Most towns and villages are much more dog friendly than years ago.
It's not the dogs that are the problem it's their owners who think I want to share my space with them.
No thanks that's why I left my own dog at home.
I will agree your friend is unreasonable to change plans,at such a late stage though

Wouldyoudothesame · 05/08/2021 19:39

If the issue is that there aren't many dog friendly places near you perhaps you should move sonewhere more dog friendly? Lots of people choose to move somewhere more child-friendly before having kids if they have the freedom to do so. If you don't feel you can leave your dog for that long, move somewhere closer to amenities I guess... possibly something you could have considered before getting a dog though. It is a big responsibility so comes with its sacrifices.

Greyrootszerohoots · 05/08/2021 19:39

Only if I can also take my 2 cats and yukka plant to the library.

NoNameNoOne · 05/08/2021 19:38

Not a fan of dogs in food places or on buses. Not a fan of kids in them either... but... seeing as I'm a mum myself with zero assistance on the childcare front I have to put up lol 😆

1stTimeMama · 05/08/2021 19:38

Absolutely not. And we have a dog.

Blossomtoes · 05/08/2021 19:37

@RossPoldarksWife

No, too many entitled dog owners take their dogs everywhere with no regard to anyone else. Their not “your child” it’s a bloody dog, an animal. You chose to get a dog and all the responsibilities it brings. Just like other people choose to have children with all the responsibilities they bring. Both mean missing out on some things. The entitlement of dog owners is unbelievable.
I completely agree. We’re currently on holiday and the dog’s in kennels.
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/08/2021 19:37

I do also think your friend should be more accommodating though

TedMullins · 05/08/2021 19:37

@BaublesAndGlitter

I don't think dogs should be allowed in more types of establishment (ie theatres or cinemas etc) but having more dog friendly pubs / hotels / cafes to choose from can make all the difference IMO.

Last year we took Ddog on holiday to Scotland and it was lovely to be able to still go out for a meal / stop for a drink / stay at a fancy b&b and bring DDog with us. Saved a bloody fortune in kennelling fees too - but we were only comfortable to do that because BaublesDog is older, completely unflappable and quiet.
Compete opposite to where I live where there is 1 dog friendly cafe that I'm aware of.

Also, all this dog v children nonsense are missing the point I think. Both children and pets need someone (parent or owner) to look after them and ensure their needs are met. Neither can just be left alone while parent / owner goes out for dinner etc but people are aware and give leeway for childcare - not so much for pets.
And the whole 'you chose to have a dog' doesn't wash either because a fair amount of people chose to have children too.

As an aside, I've spent many an evening at a cinema / restaurant etc and had the experience interrupted or ruined by badly behaved children!

Yes, all of this! Dogs and children are BOTH lifestyle choices, all the people acting like they’re single handedly ensuring the survival of the human race by having children need to get a grip
LST · 05/08/2021 19:37

@Sxxyfing

Dogs should be allowed in less places in my opinion as well as being made to stay on a lead in any public place. I'd even go so far to muzzle certain breeds in public. People and their children should be able to enjoy life without having to experience other people's pets
No one has to experience my dog apart from look at him if they choose. He goes off lead and he certainly isn't muzzled