Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should dogs be allowed in more places?

538 replies

Patchworkknitter · 05/08/2021 17:44

I'm a bit hurt today but I don't know if I'm being completely unreasonable.

A friend and I were trying to arrange to meet up. We had sorted what we were doing and then she changed her mind and wanted to change where we did something which would have added another 90 minutes onto the day.

I couldn't do that as my dog would already have been left all day (with 2 dog walks from a dog walker). Even with the dog walker, he couldn't do another 90 minutes. My friend got a bit cross and said I should just get my parents to look after him but they're already looking after him the day before so it wouldn't be fair. I don't like to ask them too often, a bit like people don't like to look after their children too often.

It just seems we always do child friendly places (I'm not a Mum but I try my best to be understanding of her childcare needs). She says she can't afford any additional childcare to that which she already needs for work but I can't afford additional dog care either (I pay £400 a month and don't have a partner to share any costs).

It got me thinking how restrictive it can be having a dog as a single person. I wouldn't change him for the world but it's incredibly difficult. If it was childcare I feel people would be much more understanding.

If I was a mum I could take my children pretty much everywhere.
As a dog owner, I can no longer go to the cinema, to most pubs, to restaurants, to the theatre, shopping, etc without paying out for extra dog care.

I feel dogs should be allowed in more places, more shops, more cafes, more pubs etc. Aibu?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fashionesta · 09/08/2021 08:53

This is interesting as I've just come back from a country where dogs are allowed in most cafes and just seem to be everywhere. I personally don't have an issue with a dog on a lead in a public place.

Hopeisallineed · 09/08/2021 08:48

Yes, dogs should be allowed in less places if anything or at least be under stricter control.

StrangeToSee · 09/08/2021 04:55

However, the time she was attacked and killed she was on the lead and I was trying to be responsible keeping her under control but I think this was worse as she couldn't outrun these dogs

I’m so sorry, that must have been dreadful and so traumatic.

It’s cases like these make me think all dogs need to be on lead in public places, with stricter rules and punishments for people who let them off. And a legal requirement for all dogs to be chipped, registered to an owner, vaccinated and insured. Higher penalties for owners who let their dogs bound up to people and cause alarm, chase, bite, scratch, knock people over or generally invade their space.

More parks that are dog free!

When my dog was attacked on lead by two staffie types I had to drop his lead to allow him to defend himself. Which he did but only because he’s large and agile with an aggressive streak towards dogs who get in his face. As soon as they approached he went rigid and got ready to fight, if he didn’t have quick reflexes he’d probably be dead. Because there were two of them I worried he might not get the upper hand so I got one by the collar and twisted while he took care of the other. When the owner finally came he just whistled to call them off and said something about dogs being dogs 😡 As if they’d all been playing off lead together and had a scrap, not his 2 attacking an on lead dog out of sight! Mine injured both of them but he was also injured and had to have a lot of stitches.

A smaller or timid dog wouldn’t have stood a chance against those two. I reported it but without the owners identity they couldn’t do much.

cleocleo16 · 08/08/2021 23:05

Having had my dog attacked and killed whilst on the lead by two dogs not only off the lead but with no collars on either, I strongly believe there are too many out of control dogs and they should be in LESS areas. My dog struggled with recall and I was young and a bit silly and I did try to train her but she would just run and run because of this she was chased a lot by other dogs which made it worse. These people never ever tried to call their dogs off mine and I was young and didn't confront them over it. These days I am much braver. In hindsight I think it was only a matter of time before my dog was attacked. However, the time she was attacked and killed she was on the lead and I was trying to be responsible keeping her under control but I think this was worse as she couldn't outrun these dogs. Other dogs should never be allowed to approach a dog on the lead who are off the lead. The dog is on the lead for a reason. I hate out of control dogs and they seem to be everywhere.

I would like much more restriction on dogs abs dog only areas. My dcs are scared of dogs after this incident. I get dogs getting in my way, jumping up on me all the time when I am out for a run. Why shouldn't I be able to go for a peaceful walk with my dcs without being hassled by a dog and having them hiding behind me? The situation is a disaster waiting to happen. There should be lots more no dogs places where people can go who don't want dogs hassling them. Those people who want to socialise their dogs can do so elsewhere.

StrangeToSee · 08/08/2021 18:49

But dogs will continue to be kept as pets for the foreseeable future

Hopefully stricter laws will come in soon about dog ownership and training, as the dog population seems to have exploded (along with the number of untrained dogs running free). As a dog owner I’d be delighted if they passed a law that said all dogs must be on leads in public places!

I feel really sorry for people who have a fear of dogs. It restricts people’s use of parks, woodland walks, nature trails. Cyclists and runners frequently get chased and nipped by out of control dogs. The amount of dog poo (even in bags dumped near the bin) is disgusting.

We often go for a family day out and leave the dog at home. It would be great if more places were dog-free zones so people could picnic or play sports in peace.

RedToothBrush · 08/08/2021 17:48

Dog owners who are completely oblivious to the fact that other people dont want their uncontrolled creature around their ankles sniffing them or nosing them.

Keeping them under control means just that - not harassing other people. Especially when you have a small child.

DeadGood · 08/08/2021 17:04

@Mxflamingnoravera

No, I'm terrified of dogs after being badly bitten as a child. I hate them and believe their place is outside on a farm or working in the countryside.
Lol, ok 😂 it’s ok to be fearful of them, and I’m sorry for what happened to you. But dogs will continue to be kept as pets for the foreseeable future, so it would probably do you good to accept that?
Mxflamingnoravera · 08/08/2021 16:28

No, I'm terrified of dogs after being badly bitten as a child. I hate them and believe their place is outside on a farm or working in the countryside.

StrangeToSee · 08/08/2021 15:26

This! I spat my coffee out at the brick comment

I spat my coffee out the other day at the image of bricks flying through windows with that message written on it 😂

StrangeToSee · 08/08/2021 15:24

Equally, if a dog is liable to nip and bite then being on a shorter lead doesn't cut it. Anything could startle a dog that's particularly nippy and reactive. The owner can't take the appropriate of my dog was on a short lead so it being snappy isn't my responsibility

If it has a tendency to nip or snap at humans (especially children) I agree a short lead isn’t enough and a muzzle or PTS or keep it on private land are the only options. You can’t stop toddlers bumping into your dog or children rushing to pet them so any dog in public needs to be tolerant of this.

But dogs reacting aggressively to dogs who get into their face when on a short lead, that’s not a reason to muzzle. Every dog has a right to defend itself. Not all dogs can tell the difference between a friendly approach and an aggressive one. If you’re holding your dog-reactive dog on a short lead and another dog won’t leave him alone, the owner can’t or won’t recall in time and your on-lead dog attacks... that’s entirely the fault of the owner who let their dog approach yours!

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 08/08/2021 15:15

[quote TheFoundations]@StrangeToSee

People need to realise dogs are pets and nothing like children

Why do they? People can think what they like, can't they? As long as they're not throwing bricks through your windows with 'Dogs are the same as children' written on them, it's not your business to be telling people what they need to realise.

Or is it? Have I missed something, and you're the Boss of Thinking, now?[/quote]
This! I spat my coffee out at the brick comment Grin

StrangeToSee · 08/08/2021 15:07

it's unreasonable of you to suggest that dogs should be trained not to approach other dogs. It's one of the reasons we take our dogs out; so that they can socialise with other dogs

All dogs should be trained not to approach other dogs, unless both owners give their dogs permission to socialise. Letting your dog socialise with dogs you don’t know puts your dog at such a risk.

Maybe you need more friends with dogs of a similar size and temperament, so you can meet on private land and let them play together?

LolaSmiles · 08/08/2021 15:04

**can't take the approach

LolaSmiles · 08/08/2021 15:04

All dog owners have a responsibility to make sure they take appropriate steps regarding their dog.

Nobody should be allowing their off lead dog to bound up to anyone or on lead dogs.
Equally, if a dog is liable to nip and bite then being on a shorter lead doesn't cut it. Anything could startle a dog that's particularly nippy and reactive. The owner can't take the appropriate of my dog was on a short lead so it being snappy isn't my responsibility

StrangeToSee · 08/08/2021 14:56

The dog that attacks is a dog who attacks

Any dog can attack. Even yours could. They’re animals and unpredictable.

juice92 · 08/08/2021 14:55

I don't think dogs should be allowed in more places, no, I actually really dislike how commonplace it has become to see dogs in pubs, cafes etc.

But I do think your friend is being pretty unreasonable if she expects you to work around her circumstances, but she won't work around yours.

StrangeToSee · 08/08/2021 14:53

I think the issue here is that there's a difference in what people think provocation is. Keep your dog away from mine if it's likely to attack, and I'll be making sure, as I have always, that my dog isn't actively provoking other dogs

That’s why dog-reactive dogs are kept on short leads, to keep them away from other dogs! If I have to pass another person with a dog on a narrow path I take mine off the path and hold him tightly, giving them plenty of space. I don’t take him to dog parks. My friend owns a secure field and he enjoys running free with her large dogs, under our close supervision. He’s known her dogs for years and they all get on reasonably well (other than the odd quarrel over toys).

Even in a dog park you should never let your dog say a ‘friendly hello’ to strangers’ dogs, unless the owners agree. And never let your dog approach an on-lead dog and get in it’s face. It could be dog-reactive, injured, old, having a bad day or just feel vulnerable on a lead when yours isn’t. It’s surprising how many calm looking dogs will spin round on a lead and snap at approaching dogs.

As others have said, don’t let your dog off until it can be trusted to give other dogs and humans plenty of space. If she’s still at the stage of bouncing up to unknown dogs with a ‘friendly greeting’ she needs to be on a lead for her own safety.

My dog gives plenty of warning he’s not friendly to other dogs.
Other dog-reactive dogs aren’t as vocal and may not growl, bark, lunge or show aggressive body language until it’s too late.

ShitPoetryClub · 08/08/2021 14:42

We used to pay for doggy day care whilst I worked (part time) and he hated going.
Then my mother came to stay. Mum is in her 80s and an old farmer. She was aghast at the day care and told me that the dog needed to step up and guard the house, like he was bred to do.
She said no wonder he Hayes going to day care he wants to stay in his home and keep it safe.
Amazingly we trialled leaving him home and he was far more settled, he has his radio, his cat for company and his toys.
My advice would be to try and get him used to being home alone for short periods, so you can get on with your life.

SheABitSpicyToday · 08/08/2021 14:35

I don’t know a single person in real life who doesn’t just leave their dog at home. Why all the drama? It’s a dog?

Sadiecow · 08/08/2021 14:30

@TheFoundations next time someone runs up to you in the street, shouts in your face.... don't react, just let them do it!

Your posts are contradictory one saying you should not expect dogs to be trained not to approach other dogs. The other suddenly you decide you do!

I think you're going because your the only person agreeing with you.

TheFoundations · 08/08/2021 14:22

@Sadiecow

Those things are not contradictory. No point me debating this any further - it doesn't really matter if we disagree.

Over to you for the last word, if it matters to you.

Sadiecow · 08/08/2021 14:07

*Unless another dog (off lead or otherwise) attacks him, it's all on you, and it's unreasonable of you to suggest that dogs should be trained not to approach other dogs. It's one of the reasons we take our dogs out; so that they can socialise with other dogs.

And

I think the issue here is that there's a difference in what people think provocation is. Keep your dog away from mine if it's likely to attack, and I'll be making sure, as I have always, that my dog isn't actively provoking other dogs.*

Both the above stated by you @TheFoundations

Completely contradictory and you clearly let your dog approach other dogs!

WaltzingTilda · 08/08/2021 14:05

No

StrangeToSee · 08/08/2021 14:02

That's why responsible owners don't allow this situation to occur in the first place, by making sure that their dangerous dog is appropriately muzzled

Dangerous dog? 🤔 A dangerous dog is one that attacks humans, or actively seeks out other dogs to attack. Not a defensive, reactive rescue who is always on a short leash in public.
No responsible owner muzzles their dog ‘just in case’ another dog harasses it and gets bitten for invading their leashed dog’s space. An on-lead dog has limited means to defend itself. If it’s muzzled too then it’s vulnerable to being attacked and killed. And likely to get more anxious and defensive because the owner has taken away it’s only form of self defence.

A lead does not denote control. A dog on a short lead that attacks is an out of control dog, and the owner is responsible for the attack

Provided the lead is strong and the owner can hold their dog... and back off from the unwelcome intrusive dog... a short lead is classed as ‘close control’. A dog can’t move far on a short lead, but it can still bite and pin another dog down if that dog gets very close. The other dog would have to be within touching distance.

The responsibility for an attack that happens when the attacker is restrained on a short lead lies entirely with the owner who let their off lead dog get so close.

MaMelon · 08/08/2021 14:02

offering a peaceful hello in the dog friendly area of the park, where the dogs are mostly off lead and enjoying playing happily together

Your dog shouldn’t be offering any form of hello to an on lead dog - get it better trained and show some manners and understanding of basic etiquette. ‘Dog friendly’ doesn’t mean ‘off lead dog friendly’.

Swipe left for the next trending thread