Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want DS to be a ‘dad’

234 replies

fomentin · 05/08/2021 14:24

My eldest is 18, almost 19, his girlfriend is 19.

She found out she was pregnant when they were in year 11 with her then boyfriend, DS supported her as the actual father didn't want anything to do with her or the baby. DS also supported her when the baby was born and she is now almost 2.

DS and his girlfriend have been in a relationship for almost a year, and recently the little girl has been calling him daddy. Except, DS isn't her dad.

AIBU to not want him to be her ‘dad’ especially as he's so young!

OP posts:
AlmostSummer21 · 05/08/2021 15:19

@nimbuscloud

Are they both working?
How does that affect whether she calls him Daddy or not?
Kokeshi123 · 05/08/2021 15:18

Also the fact that he is 18 means sweet fuck all, I was 18 when I got with my DH and we have been together 14 years and thats without the baggage these kids already carried.

I'm thrilled for you, but you are a statistical anomaly. Relationships like the OP's son's almost never end well.

paisleydot · 05/08/2021 15:18

That's so tough - I completely understand where you're coming from and in my heart, I'd also be sad and concerned over what happens in the long term. However, I just don't think there's much you can do - if you raise concerns, he may just dismiss them. Did the little girl start calling him daddy on her own accord or was it instigated by your son/his gf? I'd think that if everyone just stuck to calling your son by his name, that be fine - she's 2, she'll treat it as normal (for now at least)?

Kokeshi123 · 05/08/2021 15:13

Some of the responses here are just so Peak Mumsnet.

Look, he's 18. He's technically an adult, his right to do what he wants, blah blah. But yes, I'd be pretty horrified. It's not a lovely and upstanding thing to do, it's bloody stupid.

He needs to be focusing his time, energy and resources on getting himself set up. Is he providing financial support (either formally or informally?) in this setup? Unless he has inherited a lot of money from somewhere, it's pretty hard to imagine an 18yo having the resources to do this without shortchanging himself. If he's working, he won't have much money. If he's in full time education, where is the money coming from right now (Mum and Dad, I'm guessing).

Even in cultures where people marry younger than we consider usual, it's pretty out-there to be the "father" of a 2yo at age 18. This is way too young to be playing the father role to a toddler.

The odds of this relationship surviving long-term have to be close to zero. I don't think he should be playing daddy to this child and encouraging a parent-child type relationship when he is very unlikely to be in the child's life long-term; nor should he be deluding this young woman into folding believing that she's got a new partner and "father" to her child.

And a very young single mother of a two year old should be focusing on her child and on setting herself up to provide for a child, not on dating and forming new relationships right now. Stepfathers and mums-boyfriends are risk factors for children--the obvious risk being abuse, but also the more subtle risk of emotional involvements between the child and the guy, which can leave the child devastated when the relationship breaks up. I'm sure the OP's son isn't an abuser, but the risk of emotional entanglement is absolutely there. This is not good for children.

Is the biological father of this child at least paying financial support? I bloody well hope so. We have DNA tests for a reason.

I hope to hell that this couple are doubling up on birth control (hormonal BC AND condoms), because otherwise there could be another pregnancy in the near future and the OP's son will be well and truly stuck.

1forAll74 · 05/08/2021 15:13

It doesn't really matter what your views are. now that this situation is ongoing. You are not likely to alter anything.. If you can see that all things are going well with your Son, and girlfriend and child, and there are no major problems at all, you can only hope for the best for them.

Whinge · 05/08/2021 15:12

but just because of age your going to assume they cant be mature enough to handle the piffly ass problems that break up most teen relationships.

OPs DS would have no rights to access, and could easily be cut out of the little girls life. That's not a piffy ass problem that results from most teenage break ups. Confused

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 05/08/2021 15:12

I wouldn't like this either. Aside from the fact he's way too young to be getting involved in another man's child, the whole pretending to be daddy thing just doesn't sit well with me. Will you be expected to call this child your granddaughter?

vivainsomnia · 05/08/2021 15:12

Do they live together. If not, it's very wrong. If they do and are very committed and he is acting as a dad, it's more difficult because he himself is probably getting attached to her.

On one hand, it makes things much more difficult if they were to break-up. It would be lovely if they don't and build a family together.

Whinge · 05/08/2021 15:10

Only it doesnt does it because if they split up, then he will have no rights to access.

Exactly. Pretending he's the child's father doesn't benefit anyone. If the relationship ends, which is likely due to their ages. Then the poor child will have the double whammy of losing a step father figure, and learning that her biological father didn't want her.

AnneLovesGilbert · 05/08/2021 15:09

Yeah that makes him dad - you saying hes 'not the father' is useless as it nothing to do with 'biology' he is the father to this child and has been the childs whole life, its actions that make a father not blood.

Absolute load of crap. Say it as often as you like but it doesn’t make it true. The words mother and father have actual meanings, you can’t just make them mean what you want.

He hasn’t adopted her, has no parental responsibility, has no rights to ever see her again if the split up.

He’s the boyfriend of a woman who had a baby with another man. He can play dad but he won’t be a father unless he adopts her.

If his gf dumps him and meets someone else you can bet that blood suddenly matters. If she doesn’t want him to have further contact with her child she won’t have to.

mam0918 · 05/08/2021 15:09

Also the fact that he is 18 means sweet fuck all, I was 18 when I got with my DH and we have been together 14 years and thats without the baggage these kids already carried.

He has stood by this girl for THREE years already, while she carried another mans child, through the changes a child brings to friendship, love, relationships and life... there are fully grown men that arent that mature but just because of age your going to assume they cant be mature enough to handle the piffly ass problems that break up most teen relationships.

Hmm
ChloeCrocodile · 05/08/2021 15:07

I wouldn’t be impressed. There’s no need to use the name “dad” unless the child chooses to when she is old enough to decide for herself. Starting it off now is a recipe for disaster imo.

I don’t think there’s anything you can do about it though, OP.

x2boys · 05/08/2021 15:06

@mam0918

So hes been there in the main male role since before this child was even born and is in a relationship with the mother?

Yeah that makes him dad - you saying hes 'not the father' is useless as it nothing to do with 'biology' he is the father to this child and has been the childs whole life, its actions that make a father not blood.

Only it doesnt does it because if they split up, then he will have no rights to access.
Twoforthree · 05/08/2021 15:06

You can’t live his life for him, but I would feel sad about it too.

TakeMe2Insanity · 05/08/2021 15:05

I really do get that you don’t want this for your son, but you really should be proud of him.

bishbashbosh2020 · 05/08/2021 15:05

Your son sounds wonderful, you should be very proud of him. All things considered, it seems normal that the child would consider him her father. YABU, your son is an adult and this is between him and his partner.

Whinge · 05/08/2021 15:04

@YesDisney

Why are you all assuming she won’t know the truth and think he’s her biological father? Confused

You know you can call someone dad and still know they’re not your biological dad, right?

OP says the child's biological father didn't want anything to do with the mother or child, and that her DS appeared on the scene even before the child's birth. So it's not too crazy a leap to think they've not mentioned her biological father.
x2boys · 05/08/2021 15:04

@YesDisney

Why are you all assuming she won’t know the truth and think he’s her biological father? Confused

You know you can call someone dad and still know they’re not your biological dad, right?

Because shes two, two year olds dont tend to be deep thinkers 🙄
AnneLovesGilbert · 05/08/2021 15:03

I don’t see where OP said she was trying to stop him so the “nothing to do with you” comments are irrelevant. She’s airing her concerns, on here, where her son can’t see them, and asking what other people think.

This is the first thread in a while where the majority are hell bent on a 19 year old being an adult. Aren’t they usually seen as large children with unfinished brains who need to be fed, clothed, housed, prodded and cosseted? Yet when one wants to pretend to be the father of a baby whose mother he hasn’t been dating very long all of a sudden he’s mature and responsible and must be making a sensible decision.

The people who think he’s doing the right thing - would you say the same about a 19 year old girl becoming a full time step mum? Would you think she should be pretending to be the child’s mother? Would her boy friend be right to encourage it? To pretend the woman who gave birth to the baby didn’t exist? Would you say she was responsible, stepping up, doing the right thing?

funinthesun19 · 05/08/2021 15:02

Yanbu Sad I can understand why you’re so sad about it. I would be too.

Unfortunately he’s an adult and you can’t stop him. You just have to hope he won’t look back and regret it.

If he asks for your opinion though then give the honest one.

mam0918 · 05/08/2021 15:02

So hes been there in the main male role since before this child was even born and is in a relationship with the mother?

Yeah that makes him dad - you saying hes 'not the father' is useless as it nothing to do with 'biology' he is the father to this child and has been the childs whole life, its actions that make a father not blood.

YesDisney · 05/08/2021 15:01

Why are you all assuming she won’t know the truth and think he’s her biological father? Confused

You know you can call someone dad and still know they’re not your biological dad, right?

Ducksurprise · 05/08/2021 15:01

What a stand out young man

And what will you be saying about him when the relationship fails, because in all likelihood it will as they are teenagers?

nimbuscloud · 05/08/2021 15:00

Are they both working?

cookiecreampie · 05/08/2021 14:59

I understand your point, he's only 18 and probably won't be with her forever and things could get messy if there's a child involved who he is attached to. But it's his decision and you have to let him get on with it. He sounds like he's responsible and a good person. Maybe talk to him about your worries, but you have to just respect his wishes and let him get on with it, even if you don't like it.