Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want DS to be a ‘dad’

234 replies

fomentin · 05/08/2021 14:24

My eldest is 18, almost 19, his girlfriend is 19.

She found out she was pregnant when they were in year 11 with her then boyfriend, DS supported her as the actual father didn't want anything to do with her or the baby. DS also supported her when the baby was born and she is now almost 2.

DS and his girlfriend have been in a relationship for almost a year, and recently the little girl has been calling him daddy. Except, DS isn't her dad.

AIBU to not want him to be her ‘dad’ especially as he's so young!

OP posts:
Whinge · 05/08/2021 16:01

@Disfordarkchocolate

I had three children when I married my second husband. He was seven years younger than me.

The reason I love my MIL is because she never said a word and she opened her heart to my children. She must have been apprehensive but she raised a man with strong values and she was sensible enough to trust him to live them.

That's not really comparable to the OPs situation. OP shouldn't be afraid to voice her concerns, as the situation her son is in is likely to lead to heartbreak.
Disfordarkchocolate · 05/08/2021 15:58

I had three children when I married my second husband. He was seven years younger than me.

The reason I love my MIL is because she never said a word and she opened her heart to my children. She must have been apprehensive but she raised a man with strong values and she was sensible enough to trust him to live them.

phishy · 05/08/2021 15:57

Has it affected DS in terms of education, job prospects, etc? I can see why parents wouldn’t want this for their child.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 05/08/2021 15:55

@daisyjgrey

This couldn't be less of your business.
It is if she's expected to play the role of granny.

My sister had a baby girl aged 18 and a man who wasn't the father raised her. I remember his parents really pushing back on being called grandma and grandad, and my god the names they were called for not pretending to go along with the lie were ridiculous. This is how entitled people are

Whinge · 05/08/2021 15:54

It's easy to assume an 18 year old is clueless about their rights etc, but i don't think that's necessarily the case.

I think pointing out his rights would be beneficial, as it's likely he has no idea that he could easily be cut out of the child's life. Plenty of people don't get married and then find it a shock that they're not entitled to XYZ. So an 18 year old who knows about his rights in such a difficult situation would be unusual.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 05/08/2021 15:53

I love how on MN an 18yo becoming the default father to a toddler that isn’t his is the height of maturity. The 18yo is an adult and such a great role model.

It makes me wonder if the OP was posting about her 18yo daughter taking on the role of mummy to her boyfriend's child, would she get the same response and called mature and upstanding? I doubt it. The unanimous verdict would be 'tell her to run'.

I am a staunch feminist, have been since the age of about 4 when I noticed how differently my brother were treated and objected to it, and I'm usually in the Rad-Femish 'men are probably the problem here' camp. But the way MN speaks about teenage boys is absolutely abhorrent.

daisyjgrey · 05/08/2021 15:52

This couldn't be less of your business.

Onlinedilema · 05/08/2021 15:48

I think it's wrong.
What happens when the child eventually finds out he is not her father?
All children have the bright to know who their parents are and this trumps any feelings the parents have.I
Totally wrong.
I've known of several adults who have found out their 'father' is nothing of the sort and trust me the shit has hit the fan.
Not one of them has been forgiving of either the mother or the father figure.

Flomoon · 05/08/2021 15:46

@Iwonder08

There is plenty OP can do. Assuming they have good relationship, she can respectfully explain how irresponsible the situation, how even though he probably believes this young woman is a love of his life, he has no rights and therefore no responsibilities towards this little girl. How this young woman can decide at any moment of time to leave and he wont be able to do anything at all about being in the little girl's life. Also it is understandable why OP is unhappy with the situation. I wouldn't want my 18 yo raising someone else's child and trying hard to provide for them instead of travelling, going to uni, dating many people, socialising and meeting new people without a burden of such heave responsibilities. And no, I wouldn't be 'proud of him' either. It is a stupid thing to do at such a young age.
It's easy to assume an 18 year old is clueless about their rights etc, but i don't think that's necessarily the case. You might not want your 18 year old to do something, but it doesn't mean you have any real influence in their decision making beyond talking to them.
AcrossthePond55 · 05/08/2021 15:46

I understand why you feel the way you do, they are both very young. If this relationship ends (as many teenage relationships do) then it will be all the more difficult for the child.

BUT, it's really between your DS and the GF, so grit your teeth, MYOB, and say nothing. The only thing you have control over is whether or not you wish to take on the roll of grandparent and be called by a 'grandparent name'. That's something you need to think about now, but say nothing until/unless it happens.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 05/08/2021 15:44

I totally understand your concerns but it's not your place to try to tell him what to do. If he asks for your opinion then give it. Otherwise, try to stay neutral.

Iwonder08 · 05/08/2021 15:44

There is plenty OP can do. Assuming they have good relationship, she can respectfully explain how irresponsible the situation, how even though he probably believes this young woman is a love of his life, he has no rights and therefore no responsibilities towards this little girl. How this young woman can decide at any moment of time to leave and he wont be able to do anything at all about being in the little girl's life.
Also it is understandable why OP is unhappy with the situation. I wouldn't want my 18 yo raising someone else's child and trying hard to provide for them instead of travelling, going to uni, dating many people, socialising and meeting new people without a burden of such heave responsibilities. And no, I wouldn't be 'proud of him' either. It is a stupid thing to do at such a young age.

MyriadeOfThings · 05/08/2021 15:43

I love how on MN an 18yo becoming the default father to a toddler that isn’t his is the height of maturity. The 18yo is an adult and such a great role model.

And at the same time a 19~20yo is still a teenager. Don’t you know that brains aren’t fully developed until they are 25yo. Still a child so you need to leave them some leeway etc etc.

Personally, I think it’s crazy. Regardless of their age, they’ve been together for only a year or so. Letting the child calling him daddy is too much too soon. They are not even living together! (Arent they?).
I would actually say that letting that happen and/or encouraging it is a sign of a lack of maturity.

As for him becoming ‘a dad’, tbh he isn’t. At best he is a step father.
As it is always the case in that sort of situation, he will only become a dad much later on after actually spending a few years acting as a father. No way he has done that whilst not living together etc…
I think people have this feeling that an 18yo ready to step up like this is amazing so want to make it something it actually isn’t.

jimmyjammy001 · 05/08/2021 15:41

He is young and naive and no life experience, you are quite within your rights as parents to voice your concerns and tell him of what sort of lifestyle he is getting him self into, having to deal with someone else's children at that young age heavily restricts what you can and can not do, he won't be able to go travelling for a year, go on holidays as a couple without children, if he enjoys that sort of lifestyle then let him crack on but he has no experience of being free and single with no ties and responsibilities

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 05/08/2021 15:40

Well said @Kokeshi123 and @diddl

All this "ah isn't he lovely for doing that" - no!!! He's only just reached adulthood, he didn't impregnate anyone and therefore should not have to raise a child he doesn't have to raise. WHY would someone be a teen parent if they didn't absolutely have to be?! He will have no rights the moment it goes tits up.

Funny how everyone is all "they're grown adults" - yet last night there was a thread that eventually got deleted, where the OP said her 19yo son was drug dealing taking drugs and smashing things up, and he hated her partner (who's not the 19yo's dad) for objecting to the drug taking. OP was swiftly told to dump the OH and concentrate on her child, he's only a boy, being 19 doesn't make him an adult, and it's the OP's fault he is the way he is for bringing men into the house to abuse him Hmm it was a glorious display of ridiculousness and victim blaming, but those of us saying "he's old enough to move out" - well you'd think we were saying it about a 6yo. One person even said men don't mature properly til 35 so can't be treated as grown ups Confused

But an 18yo taking on someone else's kid - none of the OP's business, he's a grown man 🤣🤣

nocturnalcatfreetogoodhome · 05/08/2021 15:37

@Kokeshi123

Some of the responses here are just so Peak Mumsnet.

Look, he's 18. He's technically an adult, his right to do what he wants, blah blah. But yes, I'd be pretty horrified. It's not a lovely and upstanding thing to do, it's bloody stupid.

He needs to be focusing his time, energy and resources on getting himself set up. Is he providing financial support (either formally or informally?) in this setup? Unless he has inherited a lot of money from somewhere, it's pretty hard to imagine an 18yo having the resources to do this without shortchanging himself. If he's working, he won't have much money. If he's in full time education, where is the money coming from right now (Mum and Dad, I'm guessing).

Even in cultures where people marry younger than we consider usual, it's pretty out-there to be the "father" of a 2yo at age 18. This is way too young to be playing the father role to a toddler.

The odds of this relationship surviving long-term have to be close to zero. I don't think he should be playing daddy to this child and encouraging a parent-child type relationship when he is very unlikely to be in the child's life long-term; nor should he be deluding this young woman into folding believing that she's got a new partner and "father" to her child.

And a very young single mother of a two year old should be focusing on her child and on setting herself up to provide for a child, not on dating and forming new relationships right now. Stepfathers and mums-boyfriends are risk factors for children--the obvious risk being abuse, but also the more subtle risk of emotional involvements between the child and the guy, which can leave the child devastated when the relationship breaks up. I'm sure the OP's son isn't an abuser, but the risk of emotional entanglement is absolutely there. This is not good for children.

Is the biological father of this child at least paying financial support? I bloody well hope so. We have DNA tests for a reason.

I hope to hell that this couple are doubling up on birth control (hormonal BC AND condoms), because otherwise there could be another pregnancy in the near future and the OP's son will be well and truly stuck.

All very good points but he's still 18.

What's he going to do? Listen to Mummy and walk away?

They've obviously made their minds up, however questionable the decision. He's clearly been on the scene since she's born in one capacity or another and has no intention of walking away.

All nagging him about this will do is push him away, instead, step back and wait to see if it does fall out.

Are you positive he isn't the biological father, OP?

LaMagdalena · 05/08/2021 15:36

I'm genuinely surprised so many people think it's none of the OPs business. Technically she can't do anything about it, but of course she can be concerned.

I'm a single mother of a 2 year old who doesn't know her dad. I don't have a boyfriend, but I would be pretty concerned if I got one and she thought he was her dad, it could potentially cause all kinds of hurt for her later on.

diddl · 05/08/2021 15:36

Are they even living together as a family?

diddl · 05/08/2021 15:34

@Kokeshi123

Some of the responses here are just so Peak Mumsnet.

Look, he's 18. He's technically an adult, his right to do what he wants, blah blah. But yes, I'd be pretty horrified. It's not a lovely and upstanding thing to do, it's bloody stupid.

He needs to be focusing his time, energy and resources on getting himself set up. Is he providing financial support (either formally or informally?) in this setup? Unless he has inherited a lot of money from somewhere, it's pretty hard to imagine an 18yo having the resources to do this without shortchanging himself. If he's working, he won't have much money. If he's in full time education, where is the money coming from right now (Mum and Dad, I'm guessing).

Even in cultures where people marry younger than we consider usual, it's pretty out-there to be the "father" of a 2yo at age 18. This is way too young to be playing the father role to a toddler.

The odds of this relationship surviving long-term have to be close to zero. I don't think he should be playing daddy to this child and encouraging a parent-child type relationship when he is very unlikely to be in the child's life long-term; nor should he be deluding this young woman into folding believing that she's got a new partner and "father" to her child.

And a very young single mother of a two year old should be focusing on her child and on setting herself up to provide for a child, not on dating and forming new relationships right now. Stepfathers and mums-boyfriends are risk factors for children--the obvious risk being abuse, but also the more subtle risk of emotional involvements between the child and the guy, which can leave the child devastated when the relationship breaks up. I'm sure the OP's son isn't an abuser, but the risk of emotional entanglement is absolutely there. This is not good for children.

Is the biological father of this child at least paying financial support? I bloody well hope so. We have DNA tests for a reason.

I hope to hell that this couple are doubling up on birth control (hormonal BC AND condoms), because otherwise there could be another pregnancy in the near future and the OP's son will be well and truly stuck.

Yes!

I know he has been there for the girl before they were dating-but they haven't been dating a year yet & he is called Daddy?

It all sounds way too much!

BizzyIzzyfruitpie · 05/08/2021 15:34

I totally understand your concern. All you’ll get off of this forum though is that it’s none of your business, he’s an adult blah blah blah.

He’s really young and of course it’s not what you want for him. I find it hard to believe it what anyone would want for their 18 year old. It’s dangerous territory with her calling him dad, it’s not right and very confusing for her. I’m not sure what you can actually do though x

StrawberryPuff · 05/08/2021 15:31

It’d be appropriate to be proud of him.

RantyAunty · 05/08/2021 15:30

He sounds lovely and mature.
He's an adult so I would stay out of it.

If they're still together in another year or 2, maybe he can consider adopting her.

nocturnalcatfreetogoodhome · 05/08/2021 15:29

Difficult. I can see why you're disappointed, nineteen is very young to be a Father, even younger when it's not biologically his.

Unfortunately I think you need to get used to the idea, it'll only push him away if you try to dissuade him.

From a different perspective, what a man you have raised.

You never know, this might be forever, I was nineteen when I met my husband. Make an effort to get to know them. Do you know the girl?

nimbuscloud · 05/08/2021 15:27

@AlmostSummer21
It’s more to do with the comments telling the op to mind her own business.
If her son and his girlfriend are relying on parents for financial support then it’s very much her business.

PinkTonic · 05/08/2021 15:24

@Kokeshi123

Some of the responses here are just so Peak Mumsnet.

Look, he's 18. He's technically an adult, his right to do what he wants, blah blah. But yes, I'd be pretty horrified. It's not a lovely and upstanding thing to do, it's bloody stupid.

He needs to be focusing his time, energy and resources on getting himself set up. Is he providing financial support (either formally or informally?) in this setup? Unless he has inherited a lot of money from somewhere, it's pretty hard to imagine an 18yo having the resources to do this without shortchanging himself. If he's working, he won't have much money. If he's in full time education, where is the money coming from right now (Mum and Dad, I'm guessing).

Even in cultures where people marry younger than we consider usual, it's pretty out-there to be the "father" of a 2yo at age 18. This is way too young to be playing the father role to a toddler.

The odds of this relationship surviving long-term have to be close to zero. I don't think he should be playing daddy to this child and encouraging a parent-child type relationship when he is very unlikely to be in the child's life long-term; nor should he be deluding this young woman into folding believing that she's got a new partner and "father" to her child.

And a very young single mother of a two year old should be focusing on her child and on setting herself up to provide for a child, not on dating and forming new relationships right now. Stepfathers and mums-boyfriends are risk factors for children--the obvious risk being abuse, but also the more subtle risk of emotional involvements between the child and the guy, which can leave the child devastated when the relationship breaks up. I'm sure the OP's son isn't an abuser, but the risk of emotional entanglement is absolutely there. This is not good for children.

Is the biological father of this child at least paying financial support? I bloody well hope so. We have DNA tests for a reason.

I hope to hell that this couple are doubling up on birth control (hormonal BC AND condoms), because otherwise there could be another pregnancy in the near future and the OP's son will be well and truly stuck.

All of this will bells on!

YANBU OP, it’s gutting and I hope he’s being encouraged to put his own future best interests first and keep the relationship light. It’s completely inappropriate that the child is being allowed to think of him and refer to him as Dad.