Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Big age gap, should I have a 4th child?

91 replies

Julie010177 · 05/08/2021 14:23

Hi everyone, I have 2 older sons at 23 and near 21, then I tried for a 3rd one but kept having early miscarriages, I finally had a third son at 41 but he was born exactly 20 years after my first, now I keep thinking because of the huge years gap my third son might feel a bit like a lone child, especially that they are step brothers and one has already moved out and the other is going to uni accommodation, so I started thinking it might be nice for him to have a brother or sister close to his age, but it's so much work when they're young and also the money, I'm unsure plus I could have miscarriages again as I'm 44 now, I really could do with some friendly advice. Thank you

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HotHointheavo · 11/08/2021 16:53

My youngest 2 have 20 years between them. They are actually surprisingly close. However yes the youngest has many times said 'I am effectively an only child' That could be because she is 12 going on 27 of course!!!
She has a life of adults due in part to having 4 much older siblings (2 step from her dad). She is mature, outgoing, compassionate, intelligent and worldly. She has opinions and voices them. Being her own version of 'an only child' has brought nothing but benefits.

PurpleOkapi · 11/08/2021 15:26

But I just don't want to have any regret if i don't have anymore kids and my son tells me later he wished he had a brother or sister, because that would be too late!

Didn't see this before, but I want to address it now. I was an only child who said that exact thing a lot, and I suppose I meant it at the time. But I was a child with a child's understanding of the issue. I couldn't think beyond "live-in playmate," and I assumed this live-in playmate would never bother me, make any noise, or demand parental attention at inconvenient times, because that's just how children think. Now, as an adult, it's obvious to me that I was very, very wrong about that, and I'm glad my parents didn't listen to me. If they'd had another child, I'd have been miserable, and my mother would have been, too.

OP, you have other children, so you already know this, but it bears repeating: just because a young child thinks they want something doesn't mean that something is best for them, or even good for them to have. There's a reason children don't get to make these kinds of decisions for themselves.

Redarrow2017 · 11/08/2021 11:26

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Heliachi · 11/08/2021 11:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Polkadots2021 · 11/08/2021 09:26

@Julie010177

I definitely would want the 3 or 4 to all get along, but who knows. But I just don't want to have any regret if i don't have anymore kids and my son tells me later he wished he had a brother or sister, because that would be too late!
OP there's massive benefits for 'only' children, better academic outcomes, better relationship with parents. And massive benefits for ones with siblings (if they get along they always have a playmate). If you want another make sure it's not just to give your current child a playmate!
liveforsummer · 11/08/2021 09:07

@QueenBee52

Have your very much wanted 4th Baby OP... 🎉

Nowhere has OP said she very much wants a 4th child. The only reason she has given is that she'll feel bad if dc3 decides later he'd have liked a sibling and that she's worried dc3 will be lonely
PinkTonic · 11/08/2021 09:06

@Heliachi

The world is on fire largely due to human overpopulation.
This.

And you already have 3 children and you’re 44. It’s unconscionable.

liveforsummer · 11/08/2021 09:01

But I just don't want to have any regret if i don't have anymore kids and my son tells me later he wished he had a brother or sister, because that would be too late!

People wish for stuff they don't have all the time, often not realising the reality is different to the dream. It's definitely not a reason to have a child

Indoctro · 11/08/2021 09:00

No don't do it. No one needs that's many kids, take responsibility for what's going on in the world and don't add to the problems by having lots of kids.

liveforsummer · 11/08/2021 08:59

My dc have a 3 and a bit year age gap and they hate each other. I think the eldest especially would rather be an only child. I'd think carefully if I were you. The impacts of a sibling won't all be positive either (less money, tired mum, less attention)

Londonnight · 11/08/2021 06:51

I have a 20 yr age gap between child 3 and 4.[ half brothers ] I was 42 when youngest was born. I didn't consider having another child just to keep him company.

My youngest is now 20, and his siblings are in their 40's. He gets on well with all of them, and is especially close to sibling 3. They were all really great with him when he was young [ and still are ] and played a lot with him

I loved having a child later in life, and we are very close. But it was enough for my at the age I was to just have the one.

Tumbleweed101 · 11/08/2021 06:17

I’m 45 and work with young children - over the last year I’ve found my patience has decreased and I find it
more tiring than even a year or two back. I’m putting it down to my age and approaching menopause. I most certainly couldn’t contemplate having another of my own now. I guess what I’m saying is it might be far harder work far sooner than you expect if you decide to have another. The age gap isnt my favourite either. Four or more years isn’t ideal for siblings playing together through childhood. You’ll be mid sixties by the time they are independent.

HarebrightCedarmoon · 11/08/2021 05:35

I hope people on here making simplistic remarks about the environment are regularly donating to charities which promote girls' education around the world, as this is what is really reducing birth rates and can lead to population decline.

Marty13 · 11/08/2021 05:25

Wow, lots of people there deciding that "no one needs a fourth child". And you get to decide that for other people because...?

The environmental thing I don't find particularly convincing. The fertility rate in the UK is 1.5 so if you're concerned about overpopulation maybe you should worry about countries where the population renewal threshold is actually met.

That said, OP, it really doesn't sound like you're actually keen, more like you feel you "have to" for the sake of your youngest. If that's the case then I wouldn't, especially at your age with energy levels decreasing. Your youngest is just getting to an age when you can do a whole bunch of fun stuff with them.

But only you can know what you truly want to do.

PurpleOkapi · 11/08/2021 05:17

I know many people who enjoyed being an only child, or who benefited from it in other significant ways like parental availability and financial help. I know many people with siblings who made their childhoods (and sometimes their adulthoods) miserable. I know several people who decided they had to have another child to give their first child a sibling, and then that sibling ended up having severe health issues that will be a lifelong burden to the oldest child, long after the parents are gone. That's a particular risk at your age, OP. If you really want a second child for the right reasons, then by all means, have one. But don't have one just because you think your three-year-old "feeling like" an only child is the worst thing ever. That's not the worst possible outcome here - not by a long shot.

EccentricaGalumbits · 11/08/2021 04:39

You don't actually sound that keen OP. More that you feel it's your duty to your 3rd child to give them a sibling.

I have 2 close in age and now they're teens I can see that the eldest would have thrived as an only child, he just has that sort of personality. I'm sure he loves his sibling on some level but mostly has just been irritated by them since they were old enough to start snatching toys. Their bickering is hell to live with and has been more than I can cope with at various points over the years.

There's a good chance your DC3 won't get the best friend and companion you're hoping for.

Heliachi · 11/08/2021 03:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Birdkin · 11/08/2021 02:48

I would agree 5 years can be a very awkward age gap! Me and my brother get on now but didn’t for most of our childhood due to always being at very different life stages. My parents always particularly lament that just as as I stopped being a vile teenager it was my brother’s turn 😁

Chunkymenrock · 11/08/2021 02:00

@QueenBee52

Have your very much wanted 4th Baby OP... 🎉

'Very much wanted' wasn't what primarily came across as the reason. It was about her son having a sibling.
QueenBee52 · 09/08/2021 01:51

Have your very much wanted 4th Baby OP... 🎉

burritofan · 08/08/2021 14:41

As others have pointed out, the environmental impact is huge. And the climate change tipping point is here – life is going to be very different for this hypothetical baby than for us.

Plus: can you afford it? How’s your pension? How are your older two set for housing? What’s the plan for the current youngest in terms of university costs, and whatever housing costs once they’re grown-up (if half the country isn’t under water by then)? What if you have birth injuries this time or a high or special needs child, what will the effect be on your prior children? Count your blessings and stop.

Blueskyemily · 08/08/2021 14:33

I wouldn't let other people's experience of age gaps influence you too much to be honest. My dad has an 11 year age gap with his brother and they get on great. A friend has an 18 month age gap with her sister and they hate each other so much they don't talk. There's no way of knowing how it will go and there's no perfect formula.

Also my husband and my best friend were both only children and LOVED it so I don't think it's necessarily a bad experience for children.

Personally I wouldn't want another baby at 44, but if you want to have another child and don't mind that then go for it. But I wouldn't do it purely because of the age gap/"only child" thing.

SunscreenCentral · 08/08/2021 14:21

This. There's only 2.5 years between me and my brother (I'm the elder) and he was an absolute nightmare and ruined my childhood. I left home at 18 to get away from him. There's almost 10 years between me and my sister and tbh we couldn't be closer. I adore her, she's my best pal and greatest supporter in life.
Not sure how helpful this is to you OP but I think I'd only have a baby if I wanted one for itself and not for any imagined potential relationship between siblings.

KittenKong · 08/08/2021 13:46

Haha - the flip side is that this is the child that one day destroys us all!

theleafandnotthetree · 08/08/2021 13:23

@HeyDemonsItsYaGirl

#knowyouraudience

You'd think parents would be the "audience" most concerned about the future of our planet. Apparently not?

In my experience, they are the people most in denial, especially the 'every child is a gift/you'll only regret the children you don't have/every child that's born might be the one that 'saves' us brigade .
Swipe left for the next trending thread