Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What should I do about this money?

112 replies

cararri · 05/08/2021 12:59

I'll try and be brief, I'll have to fudge a couple of details too so forgive me if I get my wires crossed doing that.

I have had a very troubled relationship with both my parents. They have a troubled relationship with each other. They have no friends and have fallen out with every other relative. They both have narcissistic traits and my Dm is very codependent. I am late 30s, only child.

The emotional and psychological abuse, plus the sabotage and lying from my Ps have been truly awful. The levels of control they achieved over me were unbelievable. I look back now and I can't understand how I got so worn down as to accept it all. Financial control has been a huge thing.

The thing is, a few years ago, my DF really calmed down. He was still not great and his attitude towards me was still one of disinterest and demands but it was as good as it was ever going to be. Sadly at this point my DM escalated her behavior enormously. She became very manipulative, verbally abusive and cruel to me.

Very sadly she also confirmed a few enormous lies that have had huge consequences for me. These were not small lies either, they were prolonged campaigns of pretending to be interested and involved in good things I was trying to do and making sure they didn't happen. Very deliberate. A couple of these things were related to finances and education.

Anyway. My DPs are well off. Not like the Windsors or anything but comfortably off. They set up a few savings accounts for me and gifted me the money. We are talking in the 10s of 1000s. I was not allowed to touch these. Fair enough.

I do realise that this was very generous of them and that there are people out there who would love to be able to do this or receive this kind of help and can't. I also know that my Ps came from very poor backgrounds and to them this is like… why would I not just accept whatever their demands are in return for such a huge advantage.

At the start of 2019 I went through a few problems and was struggling. I did not tell my Ps this, I tell them as little as possible. They found out through opening post that I was in my overdraft and offered me some money. Let's say 1K. I stupidly accepted. I didn't live with them at the time but my Dm insisted my bank statements got sent to their house. I did say not to open them but she would say she did it by mistake..pause…and then say I would never know if it was a mistake or on purpose anyway.

After this my DM said she wanted to have access to all my bank statements and that in return for her putting money in my account which she would regularly do she would go through all the spending with me and discuss it and tell me what I was allowed to use the money for. I thanked her and said that was very generous but I felt it was not a good idea. So I basically said no thanks to a gift of money every month. This went down like a sack of the proverbial.

She also said that because I would inherit money and a house she wanted me to do nothing with my life except what she said. This would have meant becoming single, moving back in and asking permission to go anywhere or see anyone. I was very much Shock her response was "you'll have it all when I'm dead, can you not wait until then, you just want me dead now so you can have more money!" I left, very, very upset.

I have trouble clearly remembering this as it was so confusing but she was also insisting I stop working. She was saying I could go on benefits and give the money to her and she would pay for whatever I wanted that she approved of. Seriously though, I can't even really remember that part. When people behave this way it makes you feel crazy yourself and you shut down.

In 2019 I became very ill. I used one savings account to enable me to survive really. Me and my Ps were NC at the time. There is another account I have not touched.

I felt awful using the money, like I was stealing. However, I was very ill and the money was in an account in my name and I thought well, would my Ps really want me to languish and suffer when there is an account there with funds in it? It all feels very odd.

There are 3 other accounts with significant funds in them. These are online accounts and the login details and the old phone I used to verify etc are at my parents house.

As I am aware this is getting long let me just say there is NO WAY I can just go round and talk to them. It just does not work like that. My DM has all these rituals she needs me to do before she even let's me cross the threshold. She is incredibly mean and abusive from the first second of opening the door. She will literally corner me and then square off to me (she is tiny, I am not) kind of making it feel like I would have to physically mover her to get away. She lies in the extreme. She tells my DF one thing and me another. My DF is a self pitying bully who has no patience for anyone or anything and goes into meltdowns. She says disgusting things about people's appearance and I am not looking my best after being ill for so long. I don't really feel up to someone I actually care about taking the piss out of my thin hair, weight gain or things like that. She did that to a horrible extreme before I was ill, when I was quite well actually.

The thing is, they really need to take this money back, don't they?

There is no reason they can't login to these accounts themselves and technically they could take the money out again. That's fine with me, it's theirs. I suppose that's not technically legal though?

Also, say I did login..how do I send that much money back to them? I am guessing there is a limit on how much money I can gift to them in one year etc? This was all set up over the years with the cash as gifts to me basically.

I have come to understand that my DM will manipulate any chance she gets. She sees money as the golden chalice of manipulation. I can't see how this will ever be resolved because she won't ever want to drop that advantage. As I already said, she'll spin it one way to my DF and then spin it to me a different way. When she gets us together she gets very aggressive because she doesn't want to get caught out lying, which happens.

I can't really carry on having accounts in my name that I can't access, don't know what is in them and try and make my own financial plans on that basis. I can't resolve this is person.

The three accounts have approximately 3 Xs the amount in the account I have access to. I don't want to return the one I have access to. I don't know if that's a reasonable position to take or not.

I literally don't know what to do.

OP posts:
RadandMad · 05/08/2021 15:12

Child of deeply narcissistic parents here. Sending you massive hugs because I know what a horrible mess this makes of your psyche, and how hard it is to unravel it and find a solid sense of self.

I echo what others have said about going no contact, or very limited contact, until you're in a better place mentally. I think I would keep the money, though I completely understand why you might not want to - it does feel like bloody money. But if I were you I would spend it on finding a really good therapist and getting the help you need.

The most significant thing you need to work on is completely giving up the hope that they will change and become the parents you want/need this to be. This is very hard, and can take a very long time, but I promise you it's possible, and it's the only way you will ever be truly free. I can also promise you they will never change - narcissists see no reason to, as nothing is ever their fault. They project all their worst qualities on others, especially you. They almost never commit to therapy, because in their eyes they're already perfect.

Be as gentle and kind on yourself as you possibly can be. Do your best not to internalise the messages they've given you about your worth as a person. Read up on everything you can about parental narcissism and its impact - knowledge is power. Wishing you all the best. x

whatcangowrong · 05/08/2021 15:09

Transfer all the money to an account in your name that they do not have the details of. Maybe they’ll be less wacko when they don’t have the ability to hold that over you.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 05/08/2021 15:09

One more thing about getting away from them & healing yourself...

I didn't go NC at once. I avoided them as much as possible before the split actually happened, but I got guilted into seeing them now & then. I found that each time I saw my parents, their abnormality was more & more obvious, & I was less & less willing to put up with it, even face to face. It's a good sign of healing & getting used to the normal outside world!

Now sometimes I look back & shake my head at it all. How anybody can live that way is beyond me. And they did it their whole lives. Not my problem - except for the misfortune of growing up in that mess.

Twoforthree · 05/08/2021 15:03

I don’t think I’ve ever read about such a toxic relationship with parents - even on mumsnet.
It’s so dysfunctional, it made very hard reading. Please get more counselling then sort out the financials once and for all. Get everything to your address/email account then, either accept it’s yours or return it all in one go, via a bank cheque or bank transfer if you’ve got their details. You can’t keep being in limbo.

I think you should keep it all, then completely cut ties with them, but you can thrash that out with a counsellor. Remember that the counsellor you’ve got may not be the perfect one and you can change if you feel you might get better insight from someone else. I’m concerned that you aren’t even aware of how dysfunctional things are.

toocold54 · 05/08/2021 14:56

You are making this SO MUCH HARDER than it needs to be.

Call the bank and tell them you have moved house and give them YOUR address. Tell them you want online banking info resent. Then the statement's don't go to your parents any more 🤷🏼‍♀️. Keep the money. It's yours. It was given to you

Stay away from the parents.

I agree.

Anordinarymum · 05/08/2021 14:56

Have they gifted the money to you for tax purposes OP? Is this why they have this hold over you - that the money is not really yours to spend but theirs to hide from HMRC?

toocold54 · 05/08/2021 14:56

Honestly just stop speaking to them completely.
Change your number, move if possible but literally cut contact with them.
You say they are well off so there’s no need to pay the money back. It sounds like you’ve earns it anyway.

wonkylegs · 05/08/2021 14:55

If the bank accounts are in your name and they have gifted you the money - it's now your money
I know you have a complicated relationship but that's what it boils down to.
They can tell you there are strings attached but once they transferred it to you, as an adult it's yours full stop.
Contact the banks - change your address and contact details. You can go into a branch with ID to do this.
You can then decide if you give it back to them, leave it alone or use it.
If it sits in an account in your name it could have implications to your credit rating, taxes and if you ever need to claim benefits so you can't just ignore it really.

fantastaballs · 05/08/2021 14:53

You are making this SO MUCH HARDER than it needs to be.

Call the bank and tell them you have moved house and give them YOUR address. Tell them you want online banking info resent. Then the statement's don't go to your parents any more 🤷🏼‍♀️. Keep the money. It's yours. It was given to you .

Stay away from the parents.

LakieLady · 05/08/2021 14:51

Get control of those accounts, and go NC or VLC with them. Grey rock any attempts to discuss the money, inheritance or anything else. Your mother has behaved appallingly and abusively. I don't think I've ever heard of a worse example of manipulative behaviour.

That money wasn't a gift, it was a weapon. And, not for the first time, I'm reminded that "gift" in German means poison. Your mother and her "gifts" are utterly toxic.

Lovelydovey · 05/08/2021 14:51

Oh and think about setting up a mail redirection for your post (to a PO Box if you are worried about them getting your address). As I understand it a letter will be sent to your previous address confirming the redirection (which will no doubt cause the shit to hit the fan) but means that they cannot keep your post from you. This would include bank account statements (and if needed correspondence with the banks while changing address formally on the accounts).

AcrossthePond55 · 05/08/2021 14:51

I wouldn't feel a moment's hesitation nor one iota of guilt about keeping that money. I'd contact the banks, get access, and get it transferred to a different account, preferably at a completely different bank. But are you sure the money is even still there? If you have no access it's possible they could have drained those accounts (illegally) out of anger at you for not being 'an obedient child'.

I'd consider it repayment for the abuse I suffered and I'd use it to further my mental health in any way I needed to, be it therapy, a rainy day fund, or a home far far away.

Don't contact your parents. It's not going to go well for your mental health. Take charge and do what YOU want.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 05/08/2021 14:48

@Snog

I would suggest you get some counselling before you decide how to proceed. This will help you to feel confident and strong in whatever decision you make.

You need to think about what level of relationship you want and are able to have with your parents that is healthy for you. This might mean no relationship. Then consider your various options regarding the money and how this fits in with the kind of relationship you want going forward.

The current relationship sounds very unhealthy for you. I am concerned that if you return the money to your parents they will find out that you have spent some of it and will react badly to this.

My own mother is pretty high on narcissistic traits. I am very low contact with her having been no contact for two years prior to that.
I have accepted that she will be disinheriting me as a result. She is a wealthy woman in her 80s and a bumper inheritance would be great to have but my mental health and ability to live a peaceful life matter a whole lot more to me.

It is very sad OP when your mother was not the mother you needed her to be as a child or wanted her to be as an adult. I found counselling super helpful.

I sympathise. Following a link which appeared on MN at the weekend, I just got a copy of my father's will & saw for the first time what he did. I went NC about 30 years ago & he died a few years ago.

As expected, he left everything to his second wife (my mother died decades ago). But what he did in case she predeceased him took my breath away. He left everything to my only sibling. If said sibling was dead, it was to go to a more distant relative. If SHE was dead, it was to go to a charity. No mention whatsoever of me.

Reading it brought up all sorts of feelings from the past, & then I thought, no - actually I've won, I do have power. I don't want anything that belonged to him. I don't need his money (though if by some chance it had come my way, I would've taken it as the first decent thing he ever did). I have a nicer house in a better area than he did. I walked away & lived a far happier life than I ever would have done if I'd stayed in contact with him. I've had a good marriage, & I've spared my DH the pain of being involved with my father.

There is a life after growing up with narc's. There is a good life to be had. It wasn't always easy, but we (DH & I) got there in the end. Sending best wishes to anyone reading this who's dealing with the same issues.

Frenchfancy · 05/08/2021 14:46

The money in all accounts in your name is YOUR money. They have made you feel like it isnt, like you have no right to your own things or your own life, but they are wrong.

Please don't give them any money back. Contact the banks. Tell them you have lost your details (and lost your phone with them on) and they will help you.

Penistoe · 05/08/2021 14:45

I am confused they are your accounts? Go to the back and say you forgot the log in details. Change address etc. Move the money to a new account they don’t know about then use the money to move somewhere they don’t know. Block and NC

Waspsarearseholes · 05/08/2021 14:43

Take the money and run. See it as compensation for the shit show they've made your life.

MrsTerryPratchett · 05/08/2021 14:43

The money is theirs and they have gifted it to me. So the account has my name on etc. I don't view it as my money if that makes sense.

How have they managed to give you all the guilt and inconvenience of giving you money with none of the actual... money? All cost, no benefit.

MNers are telling you to access the money because you deserve it. But I think you believe it comes with too high a price. I'd talk to CAB or a lawyer and work out the best, simplest, legal course of action. Unemotional financial decisions based on expert advice. That way, it's not your 'fault'.

MyriadeOfThings · 05/08/2021 14:43

The money isn’t theirs.
It’s only theirs in as much that it’s a way to manipulate you and hold something over you. The reality is that they gave it to you, it’s yours and get how they fucked you up financially before, it’s only fair that to treat that money as yours (seeingbthat it’s yours, in an account with your name on etc etc)

I would open a new account plus saving account and transfer all the money there.
I think you also need carry on with the counselling to help you process their behaviour and start putting boundaries to protect yourself. They are awful.

Thebookswereherfriends · 05/08/2021 14:41

Why don’t you think of the money as compensation for crappy parenting? Get the account details changes so only you have access and then if you do t feel comfortable using the money right now just leave it for emergency use. Your parents gifted the money, maybe they did it with the intention of maintaining control over you, but if that’s the case then it’s still in your name and you are entitled to it.

QueeniesCroft · 05/08/2021 14:40

Whatever their reasons for setting up these accounts, they were not good- I'd bet it's either to avoid tax, or to control and manipulate you. Possibly both. Therefore, you have no need to feel guilt- this isn't you showing ingratitude for a generous gift, it's a dodgy scheme backfiring on them.

AS others have said, when you open a bank account there is usually an option to transfer funds from an existing one, and (optionally) to close the old one. Do this, followed by whatever is necessary to make sure that you never have to hear from them again.

If nothing else, remind yourself that it is legally sensible to know what is being done in your name, financially and otherwise.

NameChange2PostThis · 05/08/2021 14:38

@cararri I’m sorry your parents are abusers Flowers

I think it’s important for you to keep reminding yourself that their behaviour is toxic to you. Contact with them is literally dangerous to your health.

I’m sorry, but there is no way you can have a healthy relationship with people who behave this way. As I’m sure they will never seek therapy to change their behaviour, you need to accept they will never change. They will always be abusive. You could choose to build a relationship with them but it would have to be on their terms. You would be in their control, you would be treated badly.

Please stop all contact. They are terrible parents. You deserve so much more.

The money is clearly a parental obsession. It’s a control mechanism and a talisman. You don’t have to adopt this belief. I suggest you leave the money where it is - you do not need to do anything with it. Have therapy. Get yourself into a good place health-wise both physically and mentally. Then, take control of these accounts and do whatever feels right. If you need the money, keep it. If you don’t, please can I suggest you give it to a children’s charity that helps children escaping from abusive parents. They need it way more than your horrible parents do - also any contact with your parents, even returning money, is toxic. Perhaps knowing the money is helping to prevent other children going through a similarly nasty childhood will help your healing process too.

boireannach · 05/08/2021 14:37

Secure the money in your name with only you able to access it. View it as compensation for everything you’ve endured. Do with it what you want. Have a happy life.

Wjevtvha · 05/08/2021 14:34

Go to the banks amd ask for all the details to be reset so that only you have access to them. Then you can think about what you want to do with the money; personally I would keep it as it’s been given to you. You don’t need to do anything with it and it can be money you use in the future once they’ve passed if you then feel differently or you cooks give it to charity. Before spending it is consider getting some advice on whether they could then try and get it back from you and say it was just a loan.
If you really don’t want to have it then tell them you want to return it otherwise you’ll give it to charity as I suspect that would prompt action although it may spark more abuse.
In terms of a future relationship you need to accept that your mum is unlikely to change and is no contact better for your mental health?

TedImgoingmad · 05/08/2021 14:33

Don't feel guilty about keeping the money. Look at it in terms of compensation for the personal injuries they have inflicted on you. They may not have broken your bones, but it sounds like they have broken your spirit. Good parents do not do that to their children.

Lovelydovey · 05/08/2021 14:33

I think you have three options:

A) gain control of these accounts and ignore your DMs attempts to control these. They are in your name so presumably you can ring the banks they are held at and state that you have lost the paperwork and moved and ask to go through identity verification again. Your parents should be unable to stop this as the funds are in your name.

B) Ignore the accounts. By law they are yours as they are in your name and your parents should not be able to withdraw funds from them. When your DP pass away, you can gain access to them (without paying inheritance tax as they are in your name already). The only challenge in this is that you should be paying tax on any income / they would disqualify you from benefits claims but I’d claim ignorance of existence of the accounts if that ever came up - not least as you don’t have access to the accounts.

C) attempt to return funds to your parents. I don’t know how likely they are to accept this.