Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask your thoughts on the NHS

364 replies

Bumblecattabbybee · 05/08/2021 08:46

Don't get me wrong. I love and totally support the NHS. But the way it is right now just doesn't seem to be working as well as it should, and people are getting really sick, not getting treatment they need, often unable to even see a GP in good time when they have serious symptoms, and having to wait months for appointments for treatment. The whole thing seems to be falling apart.

Another issue is that a lot of the time, people don't really feel comfortable or free to use the NHS without judgement. The amount of times on here I've seen people listing some serious and scary symptoms that they or their child has and questioning whether it's okay to go to A&E/the GP. I've also regularly seen people criticising others who were in A&E/the GP for symptoms they didn't consider serious enough.

When I started working abroad, the difference really hit me. When I was sick or had a small injury or problem, I wouldn't go to the doctor because I was so worried about wasting their time, and I found that other British expats were the same. We have had it drilled into us that unless our sickness is of a certain severity or we seriously think we might have a serious, life threatening problem, or until a problem has got to the point where it's seriously affecting our wellbeing/mental health/quality of life and we can't cope anymore, we don't the go to the doctor because it's seen as a waste of NHS time, money and resources.

All my non-British friends here thought this was absolutely ridiculous - the way they see it is, when you're sick, you need to go to a doctor. You don't take risks. You don't put it off because you're afraid of wasting the doctor's time. This isn't how it should be with healthcare. You just go. The risk is NEVER worth it. Whereas I recently read an article about how this issue of people not wanting to waste doctor's time is a genuine issue in the UK - especially among older people, who end up really unwell because of their reluctance to see a GP when they first experienced symtoms.

A close relative of mine was recently diagnosed with cancer and luckily they're going to be okay, but the two issues above meant that they almost weren't. Firstly, the pressure to not waste NHS time meant that symptoms weren't investigated as soon as they appeared because relative felt the need to give it time, not make a fuss, see if things got better on their own. By the time they realised it was actually serious enough to warrant use of NHS time, it took SO long to get an appointment to see a GP. Weeks. So I've been thinking about this a lot recently - what a close call it was.

I used to be so proud of the NHS and in many ways I still am, but the above two issues really, really scare me. And from what I've seen, it's just getting worse and worse. I recently heard of someone who was given an appointment for a hospital procedure for a date at the beginning of 2023! I constantly hear of people waiting weeks for a GP appointment, and in some cases, a period of weeks can mean the difference between dealing with a small problem or a big one, dealing with mild symptoms or serious ones, and even be a case of life and death.

Here, I have to pay for heath insurance but I know that should I have any health issue, I can see a doctor that day, have tests that day, scans that day, if we can't get it all done that day then I'll come back tomorrow, and I never need to question whether it's serious enough to waste a doctor's time on because there's more a sense of, the doctor is providing me with a service which I am paying for, whereas the NHS always felt more like a privilege to use. But I can't help feeling this huge injustice over the idea of healthcare being a paid service in this way, and this scares me too.

Is there a solution? What do you think? I'm just curious about other people's experiences and thoughts.

OP posts:
Goodallsfolly · 05/08/2021 11:15

By the way, just because I praised the European health care model in my post below, does not mean that I have much faith in private hospitals in the UK either. My aunt had a hip replacement in a private UK hospital where no doctors were on site overnight. But that is down to the way the private and NHS systems have evolved together in the UK, as opposed to a privately funded national, state subsidised and regulated European model.

RosesAndHellebores · 05/08/2021 11:14

@Poppitt58 because the government provides the funds to CCGs and it's the CCGs who commission the services and are often told utter crap by the Trusts they commission. They are getting better at making them accountable but a great deal more needs to be done.

jessycake · 05/08/2021 11:14

It's massively underfunded , and we pay too little, and will only realise it when rationing really ramps up and have to pay for private insurance on top.

chopc · 05/08/2021 11:13

@Bumblecattabbybee and what if your insurance doesn't cover something? You are prepared to fork out on the balance most of the time healthcare is easily accessible and good?

Bluepiano · 05/08/2021 11:11

I’m sad to say but the dismantling by underfunding of the NHS is part of the Tories’ plan to privatise: either partially or completely. They want the NHS to fail or for people to believe it isn’t fit for purpose so that contracts can be handed to their friends or rich Tory donors.

Poppitt58 · 05/08/2021 11:10

Actually where I live the local MH Trust was given an extra £2.5m in 2016 for CAMHS. They pissed it away on an extra layer of bureaucracy which resulted in no or minimal additional support for young people.

Why are the government incapable of holding them to account?

Unfashionable · 05/08/2021 11:09

The NHS is crap.

The service it provides is hopelessly inadequate and its problems are not just caused by underfunding, although that is obviously a factor. The NHS is over-bureaucratised, over-politicised, inflexible and stuck in the past. Like all public sector organisations It is run for the benefit of its employees, not its customers. It still wastes tens of millions of pounds a year sending out letters to patients, decades after all other large organisations had moved on to modern methods of communication.

NHS apologists love to point to the US system which provides world class healthcare to the insured majority, but neglects the uninsured completely. What they fail to understand is that both systems ration care in different ways. The US system by ability to pay, the NHS by waitlist.

Britain needs to learn from other comparable developed countries which have far better healthcare systems that we do based on hybrid public / private models and universal insurance schemes. Germany & Israel might be good places to start.

summersolstice43 · 05/08/2021 11:08

As a worker for the NHS I have to agree with what a lot of people are saying here, the NHS is totally underfunded BUT it also wastes a lot of money too. There are so many restrictions where we are only allowed to order from certain areas and they know this so they bump the prices up, for example we can get a decent oximeter from amazon for £20 but the ones we have to order are £165! This is just a small example of the waste of money.

Also, it is massively understaffed. I've lost count of the amount of emails and memos that has been sent out asking staff to cancel or reduce their holidays so they can cover shifts etc. I've been onto wards where it looks calm and quiet and staff are standing around doing nothing THEN I found out the "staff" were actually student nurses and didnt have a clue what they were supposed to be doing, didnt have the correct log ins to systems etc

I agree, things need to change but also the general public need to stop abusing the service too

Becca19962014 · 05/08/2021 11:06

And that was fifteen years ago.
Much worse now.

RosesAndHellebores · 05/08/2021 11:05

Actually @Poppitt58 where I live the local MH Trust was given an extra £2.5m in 2016 for CAMHS. They pissed it away on an extra layer of bureaucracy which resulted in no or minimal additional support for young people.

The lack of access reached crisis levels and resulted in an independent review in 2018 which concluded the service wasn't fit for purpose and needed to be transformed. Just like the review said in 2009 and in 2014/15.

And meanwhile community CAMHS rumbles on with the same old incomepetents who tick boxes to cover their own backside and assess and assess to say the same young person who cuts and ods is safe without immediate therapy and after the next crisis (which could have been avoided) and overnight admission via A&E (that costs about £1000) the whole thing happens all over again.

frumpety · 05/08/2021 11:05

@SchrodingersImmigrant

Of course there are lots of systems other than the NHS or pay as you go, which is why I have asked the OP to tell us how much they personally pay and what it includes. It would be useful to know which country they live in as well, as some systems are still subsidised by the state or the employer.

Becca19962014 · 05/08/2021 11:03

Its not national either, each uk country has their own NHS with their own rules. You go outside of your uk country and get ill or need assessment you can find yourself being charged, and, worse refused treatment in your home country.

I live in Wales, worked for NHS Wales for years. My conditions cannot be treated in Wales only England. I was forced to pay for a private consultation as NHS Wales refused to fund it, and, my trust refused me time off to attend (I needed a day, they allowed ten minutes). The consultant put me on his NHS list but because I live in Wales I couldn't have the medication on NHS I was forced to pay. It cost £300 for three months. I was allergic to it. It took staff fighting in a&e for me to get treatment because it was "from England". I got referred to a specialist unit, again annual leave, but needed a week off which was denied last minute - I then got a nasty letter for being irresponsible, particularly as a NHS worker. When I eventually got admitted and tests done, treatment recommended it was denied because he was English. When I went back he refused to treat me anymore - he had no understanding that my NHS Wales trust or the, then, Welsh assembly could refuse gus recommendations along with a long diatribe about how he's Indian not English (of course he didn't understand what they meant the grammar being appalling).

I was taken ill in Warwickshire and refused NHS treatment as I was a foreign visitor and must pay. Couldn't pay, sent home to get treatment.

Experiences from working there were people that people just wasted money. Example I wasn't allowed to book hotels for courses online, only direct (waste of money) but the worst was the "essential" meeting I was told I must attend or lose my job. My manager had gone off on leave leaving me with his job and mine, I was up to my neck in it, zero time to spare. I went, a ten hour round trip by train for a "six hour meeting". Turned up, in a foul mood, then we went around the table to find out what was happening. Nothing was the reply from every single one of them. That was literally it. Then it was off to have our lovely four course lunch and chat (as a woman i was asked if I was married, if I wanted to see the bedrooms and that was the end of anyone speaking to me after they got short shrift) for the rest of the day. I was fuming, I'd a pile of work to do and couldn't bring it with me so it went undone. It was an utter waste of time and money, to make it worse my train back hit cancelled half way and I spent the night on a station. When my manager got back he informed me it wasn't appropriate for me to attend national managerial meetings anymore.

I needed a pen. Not allowed to buy one must buy 200 which worked out cheaper (per pen) and leaked. I ended up buying a bic myself for 50p. The box cost them £5 and none of them worked.

The sheer number of senior managers in NHS Wales slamming projects into walls, because it's not like it's their money (yep heard over and over again) just to move on to another. Not only projects but trusts/health boards too. Oh well never mind it's the NHS it's what people expect. Haha.

By the end of my post i was struggling with my disabilities (which I got bullied for, though not by my manager) and the sheer incompetence of people who saw the whole thing as a joke. Very very few saw it for what it was.

Despite working for years before in make dominated industry that was the first time I'd actually I seen 'the old boys network" in practice.

chalamet · 05/08/2021 11:03

It’s because the Tories have underfunded it for years.
I recently was diagnosed with a condition that has affected me my whole life but when I was trying to investigate it under the NHS I was constantly fobbed off and actually laughed at in one appointment. Eventually I asked for a blood test for the specific thing and my new surgery are great so they sorted it out but my referral for a biopsy would have taken over a year to come to anything on the NHS. My local NHS hospital has shut one of the wards that do those biopsies. Luckily a family member was able to help me so I could go private - I’ve never been able to even dream of paying for healthcare before. It’s just such a shame. Especially when so many doctors and nurses work so hard in a system that cannot work as well as it should.

Goodallsfolly · 05/08/2021 11:03

The NHS is chronically underfunded to ensure that we eventually go to a hellish American system

Well I don't know if that is the intention of the powers that be in the UK but there are so many better alternatives than the American system. We really ought to be looking to Europe not America.

I live in a European country where I can visit my GP within 24 hours or two days at most, for a very modest price of about Euros 23 for an ordinary 15 minute consultation, 75% off which is refunded by my obligatory health insurance (reimbursements are means tested eg the poorer you are the more you are reimbursed). There is not a shortage of doctors and the hospital facilities are superb. You can still call out a doctor to visit you at home. And ime, in towns, you never have to wait more then 10 minutes for an ambulance. And the health insurance in Europe is NOT at all the same as the American model, where insurers wield huge power. Insurance in my European country is mandatory, non-profit-making, and state regulated so no huge profits are made, it is fit for purpose.

The benefits of the system are that by paying a modest amount for treatment, people do not abuse the system. They turn up for appointments and there aren't as many fights in A & E. And they take more responsibility for their own health. And as the op says, you the patient have more power, autonomy and choice when it comes to your own health. You are not a passive recipient grateful for anything you can get.

Most of my European friends have the attitude that their health is a top priority and therefore they are happy (I would go as far as to say proud) that they pay towards it.

They do not understand the English mentality where some people seem happy to pay a couple of thousand to operate on their dog, but are not prepared to put a fiver towards their own health.

It has to be said that it is a massive cultural differences between Brits and Europeans though with Europeans in general being accustomed to having less disposable income than Brits because they are used to paying higher taxes for the public good.

There are some heroic staff and really excellent areas of competence in the NHS but it has been running on emergency measures and good will for quite a number of years now and the current model, with an ageing population and more complex treatments, is not sustainable.

MrsWorriedMother · 05/08/2021 10:58

I work for the NHS and the thing that is bringing the NHS to its knees is the attitude of some staff. There are so many shirkers who play the system by going off on long term sick leave and then returning for the required period of time and then going off again when the finance clock resets.
I have witnessed this for the past ten years.

My own mother was taken into hospital suddenly on Monday. Thankfully I am allowed to visit but I am not getting any information from anyone about her condition. I ring and they ask me to ring back. When I visit every day there is no one around and the nurses don't seem to have any information for me and I'm sorry none of them have a good bedside manner.

Poppitt58 · 05/08/2021 10:58

So the NHS is perfectly funded, and they just spend it on the wrong stuff? Children’s mental health providers just spend it on water coolers and choccy biscuits and the government have no way of holding them to account?

SchrodingersImmigrant · 05/08/2021 10:57

@frumpety

How much would you all be willing to pay for a visit to a GP ? £20 , £30 or more ? If you only need to go once in a blue moon this might not be an issue, if you have a chronic condition that needs more frequent visits, it will be a tax on ill health and most people I know with chronic conditions are still working so would be outside the threshold for free care. Do we decide that certain conditions mean you can get free or discounted care a bit like certain prescriptions are free regardless of means testing ? If private healthcare suddenly becomes the norm, what happens to people who already have chronic conditions or who have recently had an acute illness or have been diagnosed with a life limiting disease ? Will providers have to take them on at reduced rates and full cover or will people be left with no health cover for conditions they already had ? How much can people afford to pay for healthcare monthly out of their wage ? It is unlikely that taxes would go down if a private healthcare route is taken, so you will be paying an additional amount on top of tax and NI.
There isn't only NHS or pay per visit. There are sysyems all around the world which are working.

I would happily pay on top of NI for healthcare.

RosesAndHellebores · 05/08/2021 10:54

@Poppitt58 the problem is the extra funds have never been well-used and there is a lack of accountability.

Poppitt58 · 05/08/2021 10:52

I think it should be better funded. The underfunding is part of the governments plan to make it so crap, that we adopt a system that lines the pockets of the rich.

I don’t think the American system is something we should aspire to, many countries have a private element to their health system, however they don’t go bankrupt due to their diabetes or premature baby.

My experience outside the U.K. is Germany. Private top ups are common, but you don’t need to remortgage your property in order to have heart surgery and people don’t die because they can’t afford insulin.

RosesAndHellebores · 05/08/2021 10:51

I have experienced far better medical care in France and Austria.

RosesAndHellebores · 05/08/2021 10:50

@NotPersephone very well put and I entirely agree. I fully support a European system.

SusanBAnthony999 · 05/08/2021 10:49

I have lived in many countries over the years - mainly Northern Europe and North America.

The health care I have received in all of those countries has been miles better than anything I have experienced in UK. In all of those countries treatment has been free at the point of delivery. Costs are covered by (usually compulsory) insurance schemes.

I am constantly astonished at the way the NHS is lauded in UK. I can only assume that none of those people have ever received treatment in another G7 country.

RosesAndHellebores · 05/08/2021 10:48

Who made the decision about your ds @Musicaltheatremum?

Otherpeoplesteens · 05/08/2021 10:47

@NotPersephone

I find the NHS adoration tends to be amongst the young. Once they’ve actually used it for anything serious or seen it neglect/kill a relative through piss-poor care, they realize that a taxpayer-funded service has limitations.

Using the NHS is like walking into an East German supermarket in the 1970’s. Thanks to (willful, at times) ignorance and misplaced British exceptionalism, plenty don’t realize how much better the rest of the world have it. The state of UK hospitals is a national embarrassment.

I was talking to a friend from Belgium about the trans debate over single sex wards. She looked puzzled and horrified by the idea that single rooms are not the norm. That’s an example of the problem.

If the NHS was so good, someone (other than Venezuela/Cuba) would have copied it. We should adopt a European system - I’d be someone who paid a lot more, but I’m happy with that. No amount of tax money will fix the NHS. We saw under Brown that the massive budget increases didn’t get to the front line - it was trousered by hcp’s and often pissed away on vanity projects.

One of the finest posts I've ever read on Mumsnet about the NHS, from someone who gets it. Actually, I don't think anywhere else in the world has copied the NHS.

Some figures on Gordon's budgeting for the NHS: 40% increase in funding produced a 4% increase in output and no discernable change in quality. It went straight into the pockets of staff through the Agenda for Change pay review, which still gives in-band increment rises every year above inflation regardless of the "NHS pay rise" everyone talks about on the news. It is one of the reasons there is so little sympathy in government now for pay rises.

Musicaltheatremum · 05/08/2021 10:45

My son in law. Highly trained intensive care nurse, ran ITU during the pandemic moved to a job in Scotland and was told he couldn't take blood, or give injections or put in drips because the courses he did in England weren't valid in his new trust and they wouldn't put him on a course "because of COVID" so he was being paid quite high up his band for making tea and doing obs that the health care assistants can do. He has now left. It's an absolute disgrace. Imagine a surgeon moves from London to Newcastle and they say that they can't to the operation they've been doing for years because they trained in a different area, the place would grind to a halt!!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread