Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask your thoughts on the NHS

364 replies

Bumblecattabbybee · 05/08/2021 08:46

Don't get me wrong. I love and totally support the NHS. But the way it is right now just doesn't seem to be working as well as it should, and people are getting really sick, not getting treatment they need, often unable to even see a GP in good time when they have serious symptoms, and having to wait months for appointments for treatment. The whole thing seems to be falling apart.

Another issue is that a lot of the time, people don't really feel comfortable or free to use the NHS without judgement. The amount of times on here I've seen people listing some serious and scary symptoms that they or their child has and questioning whether it's okay to go to A&E/the GP. I've also regularly seen people criticising others who were in A&E/the GP for symptoms they didn't consider serious enough.

When I started working abroad, the difference really hit me. When I was sick or had a small injury or problem, I wouldn't go to the doctor because I was so worried about wasting their time, and I found that other British expats were the same. We have had it drilled into us that unless our sickness is of a certain severity or we seriously think we might have a serious, life threatening problem, or until a problem has got to the point where it's seriously affecting our wellbeing/mental health/quality of life and we can't cope anymore, we don't the go to the doctor because it's seen as a waste of NHS time, money and resources.

All my non-British friends here thought this was absolutely ridiculous - the way they see it is, when you're sick, you need to go to a doctor. You don't take risks. You don't put it off because you're afraid of wasting the doctor's time. This isn't how it should be with healthcare. You just go. The risk is NEVER worth it. Whereas I recently read an article about how this issue of people not wanting to waste doctor's time is a genuine issue in the UK - especially among older people, who end up really unwell because of their reluctance to see a GP when they first experienced symtoms.

A close relative of mine was recently diagnosed with cancer and luckily they're going to be okay, but the two issues above meant that they almost weren't. Firstly, the pressure to not waste NHS time meant that symptoms weren't investigated as soon as they appeared because relative felt the need to give it time, not make a fuss, see if things got better on their own. By the time they realised it was actually serious enough to warrant use of NHS time, it took SO long to get an appointment to see a GP. Weeks. So I've been thinking about this a lot recently - what a close call it was.

I used to be so proud of the NHS and in many ways I still am, but the above two issues really, really scare me. And from what I've seen, it's just getting worse and worse. I recently heard of someone who was given an appointment for a hospital procedure for a date at the beginning of 2023! I constantly hear of people waiting weeks for a GP appointment, and in some cases, a period of weeks can mean the difference between dealing with a small problem or a big one, dealing with mild symptoms or serious ones, and even be a case of life and death.

Here, I have to pay for heath insurance but I know that should I have any health issue, I can see a doctor that day, have tests that day, scans that day, if we can't get it all done that day then I'll come back tomorrow, and I never need to question whether it's serious enough to waste a doctor's time on because there's more a sense of, the doctor is providing me with a service which I am paying for, whereas the NHS always felt more like a privilege to use. But I can't help feeling this huge injustice over the idea of healthcare being a paid service in this way, and this scares me too.

Is there a solution? What do you think? I'm just curious about other people's experiences and thoughts.

OP posts:
onlychildhamster · 05/08/2021 13:26

@NotPersephone

The NHS had saved my life, my parents live and my brother's life.

The NHS didn't: modern healthcare did. We can all appreciate medical science without insisting it's only delivered via an obsolescent communist system.

@onlychildhamster we also pay six figures in tax every single year and pay for private treatment out of net income where we can. My DS is disabled and receives zero NHS support - no OT, no therapy, no help to manage his sensory issues, his anxiety, dyspraxia....that costs us about £700 a month all in. Middle rate DLA is about £250. WTF are people on low incomes meant to do?

Pretending the NHS will provide when it so frequently doesn't is utterly mendacious.

A means tested medical care system would help people in your bracket the most.. It would mean the NHS can afford to provide more services and you would still pay less than if you go private.. A strong public healthcare system is still good value for wealthier individuals even if they have to pay because the sky is the limit for private healthcare.

the problem with the NHS isn't just the waste due to privatization/abuse of the system. It gets more and more expensive every year due to aging population and advances in medical technology. In the past, the state only had to pay for the treatments for a few years before the person sadly passed on, now someone can live for 20-30 years in ill health. So we need to find a way to pay for it and usually the people who can afford to pay have to shoulder the burden (just like how taxes are likely to increase for higher rate taxpayers after the pandemic). No point imposing higher taxes on the average person

onlychildhamster · 05/08/2021 13:16

@SunShinesBrightly It may be a lot of money. but if it is between reducing services for NHS services and making richer people pay a bit more for the rare times they use the NHS. Even my DH who is merely a higher rate taxpayer uses private hospitals and has private medical insurance (as do I) so I can imagine they would rarely use the NHS. However if they do need to, I think they should pay. They have the option to go private or even go abroad.

NotPersephone · 05/08/2021 13:15

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

NotPersephone · 05/08/2021 13:12

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

SunShinesBrightly · 05/08/2021 13:08

[quote RosesAndHellebores]@onlychildhamster I think you have missed the point that £119k is paid every year.[/quote]
119K tax over 20 or 30 years is A LOT of money.

RosesAndHellebores · 05/08/2021 13:07

And for that we are supposed to be grateful and let the staff call us "love" and "dahlin".

RosesAndHellebores · 05/08/2021 13:04

When my mother was in hospital a few years ago she was in a filthy 6 bedded Bay, with filthy lavatories, staff discussing personal issues from behind a cotton curtain with a foul mouthed woman with a foul mouthed family visiting her in the next bed. The food was dire, tea was served in a plastic cup, her IV tube for AB's was not being changed as regularly as it should have been, evidently because the staff were too busy but it didn't stop them congregating and chatting shit very loudly at all hours. When I politely asked for it to be changed I got the NHS eyeroll.

She was there because two GPs visited her at home and said she just had bad flu and the pain in her hip was arthritis. When she was getting worse after the second visit my step carried her to the car and took her to A&E. She had sepsis.

It's like living in the third world. It is totally unacceptable and the standards in hospital are shockingly filthy imo.

SunShinesBrightly · 05/08/2021 13:03

onlychildhamster

@SunShinesBrightly £119k is nothing in the world of medical bills. My Singaporean grandfather's medical bills would have amounted to the equivalent of £250k (in a public hospital) if he wasn't on a civil service plan; and I highly doubt that it would have cost the NHS any less if he had it done in the UK (as London and Singapore are quite similar in terms of cost of living).

Indeed.
A person earning 300K (£170,161 net) isn’t in a position pay for the treatment themselves outright but their £119k tax contributes way more than the £3,486 tax contribution I pay on my salary.

onlychildhamster · 05/08/2021 13:02

@RosesAndHellebores oh i knew that. Also many people who earn at that level set up a limited company and get their wages paid through that so the tax rate is much lower. my point was that a person's lifetime medical bills can be well over a million (given that 1 year of my grandfather being in ill-health somehow managed to rack up £250k).

RosesAndHellebores · 05/08/2021 12:58

@onlychildhamster I think you have missed the point that £119k is paid every year.

onlychildhamster · 05/08/2021 12:54

@SunShinesBrightly £119k is nothing in the world of medical bills. My Singaporean grandfather's medical bills would have amounted to the equivalent of £250k (in a public hospital) if he wasn't on a civil service plan; and I highly doubt that it would have cost the NHS any less if he had it done in the UK (as London and Singapore are quite similar in terms of cost of living).

As every civilized country should have universal medical care, this should simply extend to ensuring that everyone has access to it. medical bills in a Western country would be unaffordable for the majority of the population so it makes sense that the government should subsidize it/make it free. But I don't see how this extends to making it free for multi-millionaires even if the multi-millionaires pay a lot of tax

HoboSexualOnslow · 05/08/2021 12:51

Patient expectations can be too high, it's a postcode lottery as to what services are available, i wish we had more staff and thr funding was properly managed

Peachee · 05/08/2021 12:48

My experience of the NHS this weekend has been awful. 30 weeks pregnant.. Left to manage severe pain with paracetamol only. No help or advice offered. Finally ended up in a covid riddled a&e as I was so desperate and no one would help.. people vomiting into bowls around me and people bent over in agony.
There was no issue with the staff as they did everything they could eventually it’s just the system that’s completely failing and some of the inexperienced staff, especially who man the 111 service.

I have just finished a job working as a call handler for part of the NHS (I won’t disclose what for) part of the job was to state I was calling on behalf of the NHS however I was employed by an agency for a statistics and research company which we’re working for a global private company called serco on behalf of the NHS. All taking their cut from our NHS budget.. and this is where the problem lies. It’s disgusting.

We will eventually lose the fabulous service to corrupt money making private companies.
It’s really sad and very worrying.

MephistophelesApprentice · 05/08/2021 12:46

The NHS had saved my life, my parents live and my brother's life. It is where it is because of a deliberate strangulation and mismanagement by the Tories to try and create pressure for the two tier systems that are being suggested in this thread. With sufficient funding and the complete removal of all business oriented organisational structures it could return to what it was truly meant to be.

Beware astroturfing.

Soberanne · 05/08/2021 12:42

I dont agree high earners should need to pay for health care as they already pay a huge amount in taxes. Everyone should be able to access free health care as and when they need it.

Soberanne · 05/08/2021 12:39

I think the NHS is a fantastic service and i hope we never have to face Britain without it but
I feel that we expect too much, it needs to be stripped back to provide medical care, People need to stop relying on it for every little thing, if you can afford to buy a bottle of calpol then do so. We need to put more value on the staff and the work they do.

Education is key, we need to reevaluate as a society what the nhs is actually for and educate people as when to place demand on it and when to not. We also need a better care system put in place.

BethTTC · 05/08/2021 12:38

On the other hand here in the US I have private insurance through work, that I pay $350/month for my husband and I, and we both also put off seeing a doctor because it's going to be too expensive even with the insurance. My recent miscarriage cost us about $1800, and my insurance refused to cover an ultrasound to check I'd passed everything because it wasn't 'medically necessary' despite my doctor saying it was and the consequences of retained products are sepsis, hysterectomy and death. At the time I was too upset to fight them and that could have cost me my life. I was lucky.

RosesAndHellebores · 05/08/2021 12:37

Quite right @SunShinesBrightly. Whilst everyone gets the same NHS service it isn't right that it's absolute crap for everybody.

aiwblam · 05/08/2021 12:37

There is no solution because the first step is to admit the massive, shocking and catastrophic failures in the NHS. That's not to insult the staff, most of whom are dedicated and skilled. But it's usually taken as an insult if anything negative is said about the NHS. Or taken that you are some kind of extreme right winger who hates free healthcare and thinks that anyone without money should die on the street. I have a friend who is a GP and she works double her paid hours under huge pressure in a completely broken system. We have to stop waving fucking flags and admit that it's broken beyond belief. If we can't admit the problem, we can't fix it.

SunShinesBrightly · 05/08/2021 12:34

Quote fail!

Absolutely. Looking at this the other way around, my bil who earns above 300,000 a year in the UK, still sees a gp free of charge and has been to A&E recently free of charge. He can afford to pay for his healthcare - or at least make some contribution towards it - why shouldn't he?
He paid for his cat to be operated on a couple of years ago and I know that cost about £300. It's a mad system if you think about it!

I’m sure he would argue that the yearly
£119,960Income tax
and
£9,879 National insurance
he pays on his 300K salary more than covers his contribution to the NHS.

SunShinesBrightly · 05/08/2021 12:33

Absolutely. Looking at this the other way around, my bil who earns above 300,000 a year in the UK, still sees a gp free of charge and has been to A&E recently free of charge. He can afford to pay for his healthcare - or at least make some contribution towards it - why shouldn't he? He
paid for his cat to be operated on a couple of years ago and I know that cost about £300. It's a mad system if you think about it!

I’m sure he would argue that the yearly
£119,960 Income tax
and
£9,879 National insurance
he pays on his 300K salary more than covers his contribution to the NHS.

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 05/08/2021 12:31

I have lived in 4 other countries and in my experience the UK has the worst healthcare system of all of them. The NHS is completely unfit for purpose.

RosesAndHellebores · 05/08/2021 12:29

I agree with @roarfeckingroarr and also think the system is heading that way so let's be a little more honest about it and deal with it.

DH and I both still work full-time. We simply do not have the time to spend endless hours phoning the GP surgery for routine things and attending appointments 20 miles away from our workplace at 2pm in the afternoon. Would be perfectly happy to pay an enhanced rate of NI or tax for a service that better and more conveniently meets our needs but if so, I would not expect the person behind reception to be chewing gum, generally not bovvered with a good morning, etc. And if I need a procedure I really don't want to hear about the nurses' private lives which a gaggle of three have time to discuss but are put out if they are asked to do their actual job.

MissyB1 · 05/08/2021 12:28

I think a mixed model of free for the poorest and insurance for the rest would be better

I think people who say this actually have no idea what that insurance would really cost, and who would be classed as “the poorest”.

Goodallsfolly · 05/08/2021 12:25

@ChunkySloth

They also need to stop supplying care to people that aren't entitled to it. In europe you don't get free care willy nilly.
Absolutely. Looking at this the other way around, my bil who earns above 300,000 a year in the UK, still sees a gp free of charge and has been to A&E recently free of charge. He can afford to pay for his healthcare - or at least make some contribution towards it - why shouldn't he? He paid for his cat to be operated on a couple of years ago and I know that cost about £300. It's a mad system if you think about it!
Swipe left for the next trending thread