Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask your thoughts on the NHS

364 replies

Bumblecattabbybee · 05/08/2021 08:46

Don't get me wrong. I love and totally support the NHS. But the way it is right now just doesn't seem to be working as well as it should, and people are getting really sick, not getting treatment they need, often unable to even see a GP in good time when they have serious symptoms, and having to wait months for appointments for treatment. The whole thing seems to be falling apart.

Another issue is that a lot of the time, people don't really feel comfortable or free to use the NHS without judgement. The amount of times on here I've seen people listing some serious and scary symptoms that they or their child has and questioning whether it's okay to go to A&E/the GP. I've also regularly seen people criticising others who were in A&E/the GP for symptoms they didn't consider serious enough.

When I started working abroad, the difference really hit me. When I was sick or had a small injury or problem, I wouldn't go to the doctor because I was so worried about wasting their time, and I found that other British expats were the same. We have had it drilled into us that unless our sickness is of a certain severity or we seriously think we might have a serious, life threatening problem, or until a problem has got to the point where it's seriously affecting our wellbeing/mental health/quality of life and we can't cope anymore, we don't the go to the doctor because it's seen as a waste of NHS time, money and resources.

All my non-British friends here thought this was absolutely ridiculous - the way they see it is, when you're sick, you need to go to a doctor. You don't take risks. You don't put it off because you're afraid of wasting the doctor's time. This isn't how it should be with healthcare. You just go. The risk is NEVER worth it. Whereas I recently read an article about how this issue of people not wanting to waste doctor's time is a genuine issue in the UK - especially among older people, who end up really unwell because of their reluctance to see a GP when they first experienced symtoms.

A close relative of mine was recently diagnosed with cancer and luckily they're going to be okay, but the two issues above meant that they almost weren't. Firstly, the pressure to not waste NHS time meant that symptoms weren't investigated as soon as they appeared because relative felt the need to give it time, not make a fuss, see if things got better on their own. By the time they realised it was actually serious enough to warrant use of NHS time, it took SO long to get an appointment to see a GP. Weeks. So I've been thinking about this a lot recently - what a close call it was.

I used to be so proud of the NHS and in many ways I still am, but the above two issues really, really scare me. And from what I've seen, it's just getting worse and worse. I recently heard of someone who was given an appointment for a hospital procedure for a date at the beginning of 2023! I constantly hear of people waiting weeks for a GP appointment, and in some cases, a period of weeks can mean the difference between dealing with a small problem or a big one, dealing with mild symptoms or serious ones, and even be a case of life and death.

Here, I have to pay for heath insurance but I know that should I have any health issue, I can see a doctor that day, have tests that day, scans that day, if we can't get it all done that day then I'll come back tomorrow, and I never need to question whether it's serious enough to waste a doctor's time on because there's more a sense of, the doctor is providing me with a service which I am paying for, whereas the NHS always felt more like a privilege to use. But I can't help feeling this huge injustice over the idea of healthcare being a paid service in this way, and this scares me too.

Is there a solution? What do you think? I'm just curious about other people's experiences and thoughts.

OP posts:
TheSkatesOfCoachBombay · 05/08/2021 14:26

Honest thoughts, it's not for for purpose and should be overhauled massively.

I believe a true full private healthcare system should be a second option to the NHS/run alongside. And they should offer everything including maternity services and it should be available nationwide.

This would allow those who can/want to pay and want better service to go private, and the NHS would benefit from less patients to see because some would have gone private. The NHS could then begin to improve its service and streamline operations.

Fact of the matter is the NHS was set up when the population was much smaller, the population is now huge and the NHS doesn't have the infrastructure to support the ballooned population.

They also need to scrap a lot of middle management who are soaking up eye watering wages for basically fuck all.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 05/08/2021 14:26

@vivainsomnia

These discussions always sadden me greatly. To see an amazing institution criticised when the main reason for its crisis is people own doing. I am always repeating myself, but the biggest cost to the NHS is diabetes. 90% of diabetes are so because of their poor lifestyle choices.

The NHS is overwhelmed because of US. WE are killing the NHS.

Yet I know that this post will be ignored because despite being a fact, it's one people hate to acknowledge. it's so much easier to blame the system, managers, politicians....

That's just not right. This is what I was talking about in my post above. While people should take care of themselves the "People are killlllliiing it" is exactly the pr spin the state needs to do "well what do you wnat us to do when you all fat🤷" instead of "weneed to fund things and education about self care better".

People ebing fat shouldn't exvuse lack of access like in my aforementioned example of gyno care.

Boarderingmadness · 05/08/2021 14:22

@NotPersephone

No point imposing higher taxes on the average person

But that’s exactly what needs to happen to raise any amount that’s going to move the dial - there simply aren’t enough HR taxpayers to go around and they already account for a huge proportion of the total tax take.

People are always keen to raise taxes - starting always with those who earn a little bit north of them…

The number of very wealthy people in the UK has shot up since the Pandemic, so perhaps rather than criticise the NHS, we need to look at how taxation works in this country.

But regardless, there is, currently enough money to have a european standard health service, its just that we want lower taxes, HS2 and Trident rather than better health.

Thats not at Government level, thats what we, the electorate, vote for every GE.

Germany has 3 x as many nurses per 100k than the UK, ditto GP's and beds.
Some Polish friends of mine, who went back home after Brexit (both were in NHS) say their health system is significantly better, even accounting for CV.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 05/08/2021 14:21

@NotPersephone

No point imposing higher taxes on the average person

But that’s exactly what needs to happen to raise any amount that’s going to move the dial - there simply aren’t enough HR taxpayers to go around and they already account for a huge proportion of the total tax take.

People are always keen to raise taxes - starting always with those who earn a little bit north of them…

Absolutely.
NotPersephone · 05/08/2021 14:12

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

RosesAndHellebores · 05/08/2021 14:11

@onlychildhamster I wouldn't have an issue with that because I believe we would use the NHS when needed. I would, however, have an issue if despite a very large balance I was told there were no services available as we were when DD developed MH problems and despite making huge contributions, we had to fund her MH health care personally. As indeed we had to do post botched birth for me - after the GP set smile "now dear, let's see how you feel about it in a year after some physio"? OK what's the waiting list - oh about 12 weeks for a consultation then more physio, then 12-16 weeks and the last lady was cancelled twice. "OK then make the referral now, and I'll do the physio while I'm waiting". And exactly the same when I crunched a vertebrae - "Well dear we wouldn't usually refer unless the pain hasn't resolved after 12 weeks" waiting list 10 weeks and the form slammed on the desk when I noted that could mean me not working for 22 weeks and if I lost my job the NHS would stop benefitting from my shed loads of tax. The attitude too often beggars belief and is not pragmatic.

I think it would be very helpful for every individual to have a health care account on their medical records so costs were more transparent.

Over the years the NHS has refused the following for my family:

Grommets x two children
DD'S MH care
DD's ingrowing toenail

Additionally I have had a pro-lapsed bladder, rectocele, and incompetent anal sphincter arising from DS1's botched birth during which he very nearly died. I also therefore do not feel the NHS provides wonderful care in childbirth all for free. It provides cheap care that often results in potentially life long problems which it sweeps under the carpet, does not account for and corrects too infrequently. It provides sub-optimal care with some very poor post natal provision. Shrewsbury, QEQM, etc, much of which is cultural rather than funding related.

Mommabear20 · 05/08/2021 14:10

Can only speak from personal experience, but I love it. Meant I didn't have any worries about care during my 2 pregnancies, and I know that it's there for me, my children and all my loved ones if needed, giving me peace of mind for their health.

roliepopsock21 · 05/08/2021 14:08

Staff retention is a major problem, which leads to people going off sick and staff shortages. Recruitment is significantly easier. On nursing courses they’re increasing the amount of students to a level where it’s going to be very difficult to an an adequate level of experience due to the shortages of placements and where to put the students! So that’s just going to create another problem in itself.

Longwayfromhome21 · 05/08/2021 14:06

I also live overseas, we have public healthcare so anyone can get free medical attention much like NHS. But it’s no frills and you might have to wait. Most people that can afford it also have private health insurance and the private service is fantastic. We use a bit of both.

AntiMaskersAreTwats · 05/08/2021 14:06

I’ve never had good care on the NHS. Bo the my births were horrendous, care of my children when ill was terrible. I would never be without private healthcare now. My dad has just recovered from bowel cancer. He went private. Faultless care from beginning to end. Now he has to see the stoma nurses on the NHS and they are rubbish. Uncaring and too busy to look after him properly. The bill for his cancer privately was over half a million pounds. Think of the number of people that have cancer and how much it must cost. The NHS isn’t sustainable anymore. There has to be an overhaul for a better system even if we have to pay more.

8dpwoah · 05/08/2021 14:06

I have concerns about the maternity care I've received this time compared with 2/3 years ago in the same trust, I've raised them and was meant to be having a dialogue with someone about it but I still haven't had that.

They've bought into an app for patient records that doesn't do what the paper notes did, doesn't talk to their own systems, so patients have massive holes in the records that they can see. They have had numerous complaints, and yet don't seem to be holding the developer accountable. If they are they aren't communicating it to the complainants who are experiencing a lack of information.

The have committed to a continuity of carer model which appears to be causing staff shortages and isn't actually happening anyway, I'm on it and have seen three midwives in four appointments (routine ones, not the after scan ones) so that's great continuity isn't it. They had a planned change of staff areas but never actually informed any patients despite having an app that in theory could do.

The admin side of things has deteriorated, I got called for one scan too early by their dates which meant it was impossible to carry out one of the main functions of that scan and I had to go again. But I had to go through PALs to get that as they just wanted to fob me off with a partial blood test instead. I had one appointment letter from them that was so confusing and basically wrong that I had to phone them up to check what was actually happening.

During covid I arrived for one appointment and there was not a soul to be seen, nobody doing check in etc. Some random staff member told me I was waiting in the wrong place (the reception) until I pointed out I was following the instructions to get checked in etc. The person waiting for me thought I was a no show but luckily saw me. I only got seen at all because I popped my head round into where I knew I needed to go.
I had to travel to a different hospital for a routine blood test because I simply couldn't get through on the phone, ringing out not engaged, to mine. They got rid of their walk in/ticket system AFTER covid so I can't believe it was down to that.

All of those problems seem to me to be down to bad management not anything the frontline medical staff are doing. Writing bad letters and getting dates wrong isn't covid. Changing structures and processes and letting them bowl along despite them quite obviously causing a deterioration in safety (as per CQC inspection too) isn't covid.

It's not fair on the people who have the patients in front of them as almost all of my concerns have absolutely nothing to do with the actual clinical staff looking after me who have been as God as ever. The only service that has been resolutely decent is my GP and from what I've read on here it's because they've gone off and done their own thing that they haven't dropped a beat this whole pandemic, for me.

Overdon · 05/08/2021 14:04

Agree with PP that NHS good in a crisis, but in my own experience as an employee and patient overall not fit for purpose.

There are legions of drs and nurses slogging their guts out, but I have also witnessed NHS managers working part time hours on full time inflated salaries.

I also know that the NHS is routinely abused by overseas citizens and some NHS trusts don’t even bother to bill them (as then they are responsible for chasing the debt).

I have had to go private for my son ( when we are already struggling) as CAMHS abandoned us, I also had a terrible time giving birth in a NHS hospital, which was like a production line and we were treated like cattle.

The healthcare system has been used as a political football for years, and as mentioned previously the language surrounding it is emotive. But it clearly needs a radical overhaul. I would be happy to pay more for the NHS but it needs to be managed better than it is now.

Hemingwaycat · 05/08/2021 14:02

DH is now partially sighted in one eye because his condition was misdiagnosed for over 2 months last year. He went to a specialist eye clinic pretty much every day in unbearable agony and they kept insisting it was just conjunctivitis and sent him away with useless treatments. He had a very rare parasite from swimming with contact lenses in which has now pretty much blinded him in one eye. If it had been diagnosed and treated correctly from the off he’d still have his vision.

Their mental health services aren’t fit for purpose either. I’ve been struggling with PND and anxiety for months and have been trying to get counselling. I’m automatically top of the waiting list because I have a baby so in theory I should have had an appointment quickly. What’s actually happened is the first counsellor wouldn’t speak to me because I had my baby with me. Rearranged to have evening appointments with a different counsellor so DH could sit with baby. Had one appointment with him, he then had annual leave the following week followed by 2 weeks sickness and when he returned he said he could speak to me that week but wouldn’t be able to do another 2 weeks after due to more annual leave. I just sacked it off, I’m back on the waiting list but Christ knows how long I’ll be waiting. Just getting progressively worse as time goes on.

So yeah, I’m bitter about NHS treatment as a whole. I’d rather pay a set amount for health insurance every month or have it covered through our employers.

BigWoollyJumpers · 05/08/2021 14:00

Talking of wastage, I have seen much in the last couple of years of my DM's life. My god, she got amazing service (pre-covid). She was always at the GP's, with her many issues. She was given time and medications. Boxes and boxes of them. She went into hospital, where she refused a stent, but went back in several times by ambulance, each time refusing treatment. Each time she was re-medicated, often with different medications, whilst the ones she took in were binned. She then went back to her GP to get her "normal" medications, and so binned the hospital ones. She had every test under the sun, blood tests, scans, physio, mental health. She was referred to age clinics, falls clinics, physciatry, most of them she refused to acknowledge, or to take any advice. Lots of the appointments she just didn't attend because she didn't want them. Meanwhile she spent £10k on getting her teeth fixed privately. She was 92 when she died of Covid this year, having refused the vaccine.

Goodallsfolly · 05/08/2021 14:00

@vivainsomnia

These discussions always sadden me greatly. To see an amazing institution criticised when the main reason for its crisis is people own doing. I am always repeating myself, but the biggest cost to the NHS is diabetes. 90% of diabetes are so because of their poor lifestyle choices.

The NHS is overwhelmed because of US. WE are killing the NHS.

Yet I know that this post will be ignored because despite being a fact, it's one people hate to acknowledge. it's so much easier to blame the system, managers, politicians....

But the point is that people do tend to take more responsibility for their own health when they have to pay a modest (state subsidised) amount for treatment.
vivainsomnia · 05/08/2021 13:55

These discussions always sadden me greatly. To see an amazing institution criticised when the main reason for its crisis is people own doing. I am always repeating myself, but the biggest cost to the NHS is diabetes. 90% of diabetes are so because of their poor lifestyle choices.

The NHS is overwhelmed because of US. WE are killing the NHS.

Yet I know that this post will be ignored because despite being a fact, it's one people hate to acknowledge. it's so much easier to blame the system, managers, politicians....

onlychildhamster · 05/08/2021 13:54

@RosesAndHellebores would you mind if instead of paying 40% taxes, a portion of your tax monies went to a medical fees bank account that is in your name- which is then used to pay your means- testing premiums. That is what we do in Singapore- we all have medical savings account which is used to pay medical insurance premiums/routine care; highest tax rate is 22%. This also cuts down on wastage- if its your money, you are not going to A & E willy nilly. But the money is there if you need it.

I think the European insurance system is good too, its just extremely expensive, but it depends if we as a nation are willing to pay it.

RosesAndHellebores · 05/08/2021 13:46

But if it's means tested the standard for everyone would have to increase because it wouldn't be a choice. And actually as a family with a regular tax bill of £250k per annum I think we pay more than enough already towards the NHS and I would not willingly pay more without an increase in standards across the board.

Lelliebellieboo · 05/08/2021 13:45

It's an interesting discussion, but not one that many people are willing to have mainly because as PP said, to criticise the NHS is to apparently criticise hardworking nurses.

My opinion is that the NHS is exceptional in times of crisis. Years ago, my relative had an organ transplant. She had to be airlifted from her rural village and taken to a big hospital in a large city and given exceptional treatment and obviously it didn't cost a penny. To me, that is absolutely what the NHS is for. The alternative for someone like her if she lived in a country like America and had no insurance would be heartbreaking.

I think the NHS is also marvelous to enable women to have babies without having to spend thousands of pounds. To know that if you're hit by a bus, an ambulance will be there to help you. To offer treatment for cancer/heart attacks/diabetes etc

However.

We are an aging society. I personally believe that's partly why the UK was so battered by covid deaths last year. Treatment is there for everyone which means that we are all living longer when historically we would have passed away years ago. That means that there's more pressure than ever before on the NHS because the population is living longer.

I recently damaged my back with a slipped disc. It took multiple visits to the doctor and the NHS physios to diagnose and treat me, and every single person I saw told me something different. Within two sessions of going to a private Osteopath, the issue was resolved, I was able to improve my movement and I was off all of the painkillers. My experience of the NHS in those circumstances were bloody awful, but no one dares say that because no one wants to criticise it.

Personally I would be happy to pay more taxes if it meant that the NHS would be improved but I genuinely don't think that any influx of money would improve things. Theres too much wastage and it's a system designed for 20th century healthcare, not 21st century. Without being looked at holistically, I can't see how it can get any better.

millymollymoomoo · 05/08/2021 13:45

I don’t think it’s under funded - it’s over consumed
People want quick fixes, and expect nhs to pay to solve everything
Eg rushing children to gp for mild high temp, people expecting antibiotics when actually the right answer is allow your body to fight it due 72 hours m instead, hate to say it but obesity - causing huge financial pressure on nhs re things like diabetes, strokes, blood pressure and people expecting nhs to fix the symptoms rather than they take responsibility and fix the cause, etc etc - these are just a few examples
Add to that the bureaucracy, the wastage, the terrible contracts that gave historically been negotiated - the nhs just isn’t fit to provide everything free of charge anymore against the expectations people have it it
We should be able have an honest debate about what the country needs and can afford - but unfortunately we don’t appear able to

BigWoollyJumpers · 05/08/2021 13:44

The underfunding message is a red herring. We are somewhere in the top of the table on OECD average, and that is with the mostly public funded service. Others above us have a higher proportion of private expenditure. Everyone always defaults to "funding" as it is the easy answer, it's not. The issues are historical and structural, and need refocusing on 21st century health problems.

onlychildhamster · 05/08/2021 13:42

@RosesAndHellebores

I'm not sure of the point you are making Hamster.

I would happily pay a means tested premium if it meant easier access to pre 9am appointments or post 7pm appointments, cutting edge pain relief when I have a procedure (I was told when I had a colonoscopy at a private hospital that the pain relief/sedation was better than it would have been on the NHS) and certainly for a private room if I had to stay in hospital and the option to pay for better food, enhanced cleaning and hot drinks to be served in a China mug rather than a plastic cup and for nurses who don't screech all night at the nurse station.

I don't care if the care is free at the point of delivery, I would like it to be civilised as well.

I am from a country which means test (Singapore). And yes there are different classes of ward so yes you can get a private room even in a public hospital. The standard of care offered across all wards are the same.

I have lived in 3 countries and I feel that the main problem with NHS care is that while it is great that it is free at the point of delivery and I never need to worry about payment when I use it (and its also there as a backup no matter how poor I become), it seems the current level of taxpayer revenue can't sustain it. At the same time, drastically increasing taxes to fund the NHS may not be a good solution, who knows what the government would actually use it for. Means- testing would funnel in more money to the NHS and not penalize the poor.

FinallyHere · 05/08/2021 13:39

There is plenty of money it's just in the wrong place.

This is no different to the truism that 80% marketing spend is wasted. If we knew in advance which that is, it would not be spent.

The US system of private insurance provides really top class service for those who can afford it, while inflating costs across the board and seemingly glorying in the absence of provision for those who cannot afford it. That is no way to have society run.

The European model of state underwritten health insurance appears to work well. It does cost more overall, nothing like the cots in the US and manages to both do away with the queues which are such a feature of the NHS and provide a good quality safety net for those without jobs such as pensioners and the unemployed.

The service provided is sufficiently good to provide very little appetite for private provision, only for people such as whose jobs with international corporates who include private health care provision where ever in the world they are posted or the very , very top end personal physician end of the market.

Not unlike the provision of education.

If the public provision is regarded as good, it dispenses with the desire for private provision for the vast majority producing a more cohesive society.

Worth consideration, depending on what kind of society we really want to build.

RosesAndHellebores · 05/08/2021 13:34

I'm not sure of the point you are making Hamster.

I would happily pay a means tested premium if it meant easier access to pre 9am appointments or post 7pm appointments, cutting edge pain relief when I have a procedure (I was told when I had a colonoscopy at a private hospital that the pain relief/sedation was better than it would have been on the NHS) and certainly for a private room if I had to stay in hospital and the option to pay for better food, enhanced cleaning and hot drinks to be served in a China mug rather than a plastic cup and for nurses who don't screech all night at the nurse station.

I don't care if the care is free at the point of delivery, I would like it to be civilised as well.

SunShinesBrightly · 05/08/2021 13:27

[quote onlychildhamster]@SunShinesBrightly It may be a lot of money. but if it is between reducing services for NHS services and making richer people pay a bit more for the rare times they use the NHS. Even my DH who is merely a higher rate taxpayer uses private hospitals and has private medical insurance (as do I) so I can imagine they would rarely use the NHS. However if they do need to, I think they should pay. They have the option to go private or even go abroad.[/quote]
As I said, I pay £3,486 tax on my salary each year. I think paying 119k a year is already contributing ‘a bit more’ than I do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread