Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DH to give up his career?

243 replies

Lonelylooloo · 05/08/2021 07:53

Please don’t flame me I know I am probably being VU and will accept that if you tell me.

I have a big house, nice car, cleaners and no money worries, I know I’m very very lucky. I also have a DH we rarely see who works long hours in a draining job.
We have two small DC the youngest is just a few weeks old and DH has been on SPL, it’s been so lovely having him around and I don’t mean to sound ungrateful but I’ve realised how lonely and unhappy I am when DH is working.

He goes back tomorrow and Im upset. I want to simplify our lives. We could sell up and purchase a small property cash, reduce our monthly outgoings to less than 1/4 of the current and DH (or I) could work PT to survive comfortably. There’s huge demand for DH’s skills and I have a decent PT job. He could actually spend time with our toddler who adores him and not be miserable and exhausted all the time. I could not feel like a single parent! We are so lucky to have the option to live like this as so many don’t.

I told him how I feel but he doesn’t feel the same. He likes his job and wants this expensive lifestyle. He just kept repeating ‘it’s gonna be ok’ but it’s just me watching him work himself raw and me doing everything with the house/kids alone. This isn’t how I want to live. What’s the point in a big house when he’s never here to enjoy it?

I wanna spend time together with our beautiful kids whilst they’re little.
I want DH to be around to see them grow up and not have had a heart attack before 40!

OP posts:
Hekatestorch · 05/08/2021 11:12

Women just have to suck it up

You think only men are career focused?

Rainbowqueeen · 05/08/2021 11:10

Well he’s showing he is not a team player. Your marriage should be about team work and meeting everyone’s needs.

What will happen if you go back to work? Will you be expected to organise all childcare and cover all sick days? He needs to pull his weight. He chose to have children too and he should be thinking about what they need as well as what he needs. And kids need a happy mum and a dad who is not grumpy and stressed the whole time.

I would not ask him to give up his career but I would be asking him some questions about how he sees family life and what he intends to do to meet the needs of the other members of his family. He couldn’t continue in his job if you were not doing what you are doing and he needs to recognise that and value that

GrandmaSteglitszch · 05/08/2021 11:09

I feel alone but I’m not.
In some ways that can be worse than actually being alone.

Instead of jumping to the solution of DH giving up his career, ask him to think about your situation and how things could be improved, which might be by alterations to his career.

Being presented with the possible solution, which he doesn't want, reduces the chance of him giving proper consideration to what's upsetting you.

BakewellGin1 · 05/08/2021 11:09

Firstly yes I feel YABU.

You need to give your head a shake, realise how lucky and privileged you are.

The idealism of all the family time sounds lovely I am sure, however when you have to give up the majority of what you have would you cope with that.

And please don't give the 'I feel like a single parent' - unless you have done it alone paid for everything alone, took sole responsibility no you do not feel like a single parent. For the record I am not a single parent either, DH works away, we have nowhere near your lifestyle or money, I have the DC myself the majority of the time and also work FT. But I am still not a single parent.

Build your social network, meet up with friends, take DC out, visit family and arrange to spend family/couple time together when he is not working.

Being so dependent on DH to make you not be lonely is unhealthy.

Applesonthelawn · 05/08/2021 11:09

Is he making you be a SAHM against your wishes? It doesn't sound like he is.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 05/08/2021 11:06

I'm very well aware that for a long long period of time that men have never been expected to be around for their children and that the vast vast majority of childcare and housework falls to the mother. It's what underpins the patriarchy isn't it.
I'm sure many kids are 'fine' only having quality time with their fathers 'most' weekends, doesn't mean it is in their best interests at all. And they are 'fine' because the mothers pick up the pieces and run themselves into the ground.
The OP may well not have realised what a difference actually having children makes to your family life and balance. I don't think it's unreasonable for her to be unhappy and to ask her DH to consider a change - it's what we do in partnerships isn't it.
Totally agree it is up to what works for each family, and I'm sure a lot of men will easily be able to brush away a mild regret that they missed their children's growing up and consigned their wives to decades of housebound drudgery and loneliness. Probably as they are consoling themselves with a daily round of golf in their early retirement as the children have gone off to uni with barely a backward glance.
Of course I'm exaggerating as it is not what we have chosen. But honestly I see many people working themselves into the ground, only seeing their children for a day or so a week, and then collapsing with a breakdown when they're in their forties and for what?

Applesonthelawn · 05/08/2021 11:06

Stop with the single parent analogy. I have been a single parent in a highly paid very demanding job. No help from family or the father. Not complaining, firstly because in a way I chose it, and secondly because it was short lived. But it's nothing like having someone else bring in the money.

user1471538283 · 05/08/2021 11:03

I don't mean to be harsh but you do not feel like a single parent. I am one and it is and was just me earning all the money, paying for everything, juggling everything, being responsible for everything.

I understand that you are lonely and want to see more of him but he does not want to give up his job and his lifestyle so you will have to choose between this and splitting up.

Justlife45 · 05/08/2021 11:02

I think lots of posters on here are missing the bigger picture.
Yes ops dp has a choice based on his lifestyle but he also CHOSE to have children. And that also warrants some responsibility from him.

If his lifestyle is so hectic he is basically vacant from their lives and missing out on quality time with them he has a responsibility to sort out that balance more. Having a workaholic parent is never healthy and usually results in alot of loneliness. OP shouldn't have to feel like she is parenting on her own. And I think covid has given lots of us a wake up call as to what is truly important, family. if there is way that her dp can cut down his work and they are still financially okay it's not right for him to ignore that for his own wants and needs when he has dependant children in the mix.

He needs to put them first too over his expensive lifestyle

YANBU OP.

IncludeWomenInThePrequel · 05/08/2021 11:01

I think how you feel when you have a very new baby is not necessarily how you feel 3/6/12 months later.

Just breathe! No decisions need to be made right now.

RadandMad · 05/08/2021 11:01

The other thing to consider is your DH is obviously very driven and career focussed. Take that away from him and he may well turn into a different person. Depressed, resentful etc

Meanwhile OP feels depressed and resentful. But so what, eh? Women just have to suck it up.

DillonPanthersTexas · 05/08/2021 11:00

@PurpleOkapi

I have seen the scenario you describe played out numerous times in my peer group. Can't say I am hugely sympathetic when these individuals who willingly reduced their independence by working part time or not at all, reduced the burden of childcare and running a household via cleaners, nannies, gardeners etc to later complain about the hours their DH is working to keep the while show financially on the road. Certainly from my observations these are the same people who would not have looked twice at a more time rich but lower paid man as a potential partner.

Hekatestorch · 05/08/2021 10:58

@RosesAndHellebores

No offence meant *@Hekatestorch*. I do appreciate all of that although I do recall life being very easy when DH was in NY pretty much for 18 months. It really was one less to look after and no worries about absolute tidiness (he likes everything in its place). But yes I do realise there were no money worries and if there had been an absolute crisis he'd have been on a flight home in a heartbeat. At this level though I do think there may be a different definition of crisis from family to family and if I had been admitted to hospital for, say appendicitis, ie, non life threatening alternative arrangements would have been made.
See you say its different. Then say that him being gone for 18 months made life easier. What does that actually mean? How does that compare to a single parent? Are you saying a single parent has it quite easy because there's one less person to clean up after?

Firstly, if your dh is hardly home anyway. It wouldn't have made a huge difference.

And you husband was on the end of a phone. Theres someone to make decisions with, even if its just to talk it through. And either you didn't work, which makes lives a lot easier (but not something most single parents can do) or you worked and had one decent or good or great wage and one great wage to help out. So, if you were in hospital, bills would still be paid.

You would be able to afford home help for recovery and look after your children if he didn't come home. You wouldn't have to be relying on friends and family to help if they could or face putting your kids in Foster care.

I don't, actually, take offence. But I think its patronising to explain how your life is like a single parent, to people who have been or are single parents. Then giving examples of how, you think your life is like a single parent, when the examples show, how your life isn't like a single parent at all.

If you haven't been in a position, you don't understand it. Which is fine, but don't pretend that you do know.

ThanksIGotItInMorrisons · 05/08/2021 10:51

Sounds normal to me. If one parent works they can’t be at home at the same time. Usually the sahp ends up feeling alone and dumped on. And guilty that the working partner is working so much. The difference is you can totally change this as you are in fortunate circumstances. But it’s not what dh wants. You need to figure out why it’s not what he wants. Then go from there ....

Maggiesfarm · 05/08/2021 10:48

You're not unreasonable to crave a simpler life but your husband obviously likes his job. What you do for a living is very important and it's unrealistic to expect someone to give up a challenging, albeit exhausting, career.

It's a bit extreme to think of your husband having a heart attack before 40. Yes it happens but most people don't. He will get fed up of the rat race one day, just not yet.

I'm sorry you feel as you do but that isn't unusual when you've not long had a baby.

When your baby is a bit older maybe you can find something that interests you outside of the home, or are you planning to return to work at some stage?

I'm so sorry about how you feel but think there is nothing any of us can suggest that will alleviate the feeling. It will just take its own time. I hope you at least have some people whom you see and with whom to have conversations, a laugh etc.

In the meantime you have my sympathy.

Flowers
PurpleOkapi · 05/08/2021 10:47

@C8H10N4O2

In my experience, the opposite is more likely to be true. This is the more common scenario: a woman marries an investment-banker type that she likes well enough, but would never have married had he been a plumber. She enjoys his company in small doses and his money in large doses, which works out well because he's usually at work anyway. She decides she wants children, and he agrees because he wants her to be happy and isn't opposed to the idea - since he'll still be at work most of the time, he has no reason to be. She decides she wants to quit her job to stay home with the children, and he's fine with it and happy to pay for it, but it does mean he's effectively trapped in his own job. Then she decides he needs to be home more, spend more time with the kids, do more of the chores, or whatever. That's often where he draws the line, because all those other things that she wanted and he gave her are the reason he can't reduce his hours. Or sometimes he does what she wants, loses his job for it, and then she gets mad because now they're not rich anymore.

I'm not saying OP is like that. But this is very often how these things work out. The husbands are usually far from perfect, but the wives' expectations are often unreasonable and sometimes impossible.

Annasgirl · 05/08/2021 10:45

Well I think lots of people on this thread need a bit of counselling - or perhaps a relook at life.

Our DC are young for such a small length of time - they need us, they adore us, they are extremely hard work. But it goes in the blink of an eye. No corporate representatives will be there at your death bed (your DC might not be either, but when you are on that death bed, will you regret the time you spent with your DC, or the time you spent in endless meetings, talking in circles (I know, I worked in many high pressure multinationals where the "avoid bed time" meeting was common place).

You are not wrong OP but your DH is not on the same page. Perhaps keep the lines of communication open and try alternatives - he could take his full parental leave for example (do you have parental leave in the UK?) - DSis and her DH work full time but will have every Summer off with a combination of parental and unpaid leave - could you aim for this? Or even a month off and no work on weekends?

I think you are correct to expect him to parent his children with you - no money makes up for the fact that a Dad is not interested in parenting his DC. And I know many very wealthy men who manage to be there every weekend to do all the parenting.

earlynightforme · 05/08/2021 10:44

I meant - go against the grain and SAY no you are not being unreasonable in part

earlynightforme · 05/08/2021 10:43

@Lonelylooloo

I fully retract my feeling like a single parent comment. I should have worded that better. Maybe ‘I could feel like I have an equal and present co parent’ I’ve not been a single parent so I don’t understand that but with DH working long hours and being difficult to get hold of I don’t generally have him to discuss decisions or parenting choices with. I feel alone but I’m not.
I will go against the grain here and so no you are not being unreasonable, in part. If you were without children, yes you'd be unreasonable. But a part of your posts indicate that you are wanting your dh to spend more time with your dc, with you all as a family, and that his time with his dc at the moment isn't really good enough for them. In relation to the dc, you are not being unreasonable, and you should give his head a wobble. I'd sit down and tell him how important father time is to children, and see if you can work out a compromise on that basis.
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 05/08/2021 10:42

This is a tricky one and you both seem to be coming at it from extremes. He wants to work incredibly hard and not do his share at all in the week. And you want to cut work right back. Surely there is some compromise to be had?

I think people saying you knew what he was like is harsh. Peoples priorities do need to change at least slightly when they have kids. No one knows exactly what it will be like or how hard or easy they will find it but most people go into it realising that they will need to spend at least some time with their kids and do some basic parenting duties in the week.

Unless this was the arrangement that you both discussed prior to having kids, that you would do 100% of stuff at home then he is being shit just expecting you to do his share. If he really can't be there to do it then he needs to sort alternative arrangements (eg nanny) but I dont think that's what you want either.

If he wants to keep the job and the lifestyle...surely he can commit to finishing on time twice a week so that you have overall half your evenings together where he is present and doing some of his share of parenting. If he is in demand for his skills at the moment I don't think it will be to the detriment of his career. No reasonable employer is going to have an issue with anyone leaving at 5 if that's their contracted hours, a couple of times a week, even if the culture is to do more.

carefreecameras · 05/08/2021 10:37

You can't make someone give up their career but you don't have to stay married to them if it isn't compatible with the life you want.

Surely you went into the marriage eyes open to the fact he was in an all consuming career?

It's worth noting that careers like that don't last beyond 50. Unless he is the entrepreneurial type who is going to leave and set up on his own you might find that he goes from being never there to never not. That's a big adjustment that most people don't have to face until 65 plus.

My advice, make your own social life away from him, pay for childcare so that you have a break, and don't make any rash decisions until you are through the toddler years. Once your dc reaches school age you will have a very different life.

The other thing to consider is your DH is obviously very driven and career focussed. Take that away from him and he may well turn into a different person. Depressed, resentful etc

Lonelylooloo · 05/08/2021 10:35

I fully retract my feeling like a single parent comment. I should have worded that better. Maybe ‘I could feel like I have an equal and present co parent’ I’ve not been a single parent so I don’t understand that but with DH working long hours and being difficult to get hold of I don’t generally have him to discuss decisions or parenting choices with. I feel alone but I’m not.

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 05/08/2021 10:34

I must say I'm very surprised at the number of posters who are happy for a Dad to be absent from his children's lives in return for money
Absent? Where did you get that he is absent. He works a lot. That doesn't mean he is never there for his kids. He sees them at least every weekends, like many kids.

I think this has been blown out of proportion. I am a very independent person and I found the transition from OH at home during his paternity leave to being on my own very tough and lonely for a few days/weeks. I then adjusted and quite often was happy when he went back to work on the monday to have the place for myself.

If OP wrote this when her kids older, and said she'd felt this way since the birth of the second, then maybe that would be concerning, but it isn't when baby is only a few weeks old, hormones are flying about and it's a big transition.

Also OP writes about concerns for his feelings and not being there so much, but he is happy, so it's not an issue for him, only for her, right now.

OP, it will get better, it really will and you'll be very grateful for a nice income when they kids are older. Saying that, your OH might decide one day that indeed, it is all too much for him and he wants to spend more time with you all. Let's hope if that happens you haven't changed your mind 😉

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/08/2021 10:34

Lots of people saying it's not what he wants and you can't make him. But the truth is he's only able to do this because your support is underpinning him. If it's not what you want, give him notice that you'll stop enabling him to carry on regardless of your wishes. You have the right to negotiate a lifestyle that works for both of you. Honestly, if he refuses to compromise, that would be a deal-breaker for me

This.

intothewoodss · 05/08/2021 10:34

@Ihaventgottimeforthis

I must say I'm very surprised at the number of posters who are happy for a Dad to be absent from his children's lives in return for money.
Some posters, ie me, knew that our husbands were in demanding careers when we married them. I knew exactly what I was getting into, eyes completely open. My DH adores his kids and has recently made some major lifestyle changes (not related to work) that have maximised his time with them. They certainly aren't missing out on anything.

I would just quite like a holiday at some point in the next 4-5 years.