Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DH to give up his career?

243 replies

Lonelylooloo · 05/08/2021 07:53

Please don’t flame me I know I am probably being VU and will accept that if you tell me.

I have a big house, nice car, cleaners and no money worries, I know I’m very very lucky. I also have a DH we rarely see who works long hours in a draining job.
We have two small DC the youngest is just a few weeks old and DH has been on SPL, it’s been so lovely having him around and I don’t mean to sound ungrateful but I’ve realised how lonely and unhappy I am when DH is working.

He goes back tomorrow and Im upset. I want to simplify our lives. We could sell up and purchase a small property cash, reduce our monthly outgoings to less than 1/4 of the current and DH (or I) could work PT to survive comfortably. There’s huge demand for DH’s skills and I have a decent PT job. He could actually spend time with our toddler who adores him and not be miserable and exhausted all the time. I could not feel like a single parent! We are so lucky to have the option to live like this as so many don’t.

I told him how I feel but he doesn’t feel the same. He likes his job and wants this expensive lifestyle. He just kept repeating ‘it’s gonna be ok’ but it’s just me watching him work himself raw and me doing everything with the house/kids alone. This isn’t how I want to live. What’s the point in a big house when he’s never here to enjoy it?

I wanna spend time together with our beautiful kids whilst they’re little.
I want DH to be around to see them grow up and not have had a heart attack before 40!

OP posts:
RoseGoldEagle · 05/08/2021 12:11

I have a similar situation to you OP, financially very secure (and very grateful for it), but a DH who works very very long hours, and three kids under 5. I did a similar job to him pre kids, and I think it’s harsh to say ‘you should have discussed this before having children’ - before we had children I honestly thought I’d be happy going back to work full time, and then after having DD it was like my whole world view shifted. I have felt the same as you in wanting a simpler life. Ultimately though you have to be on the same page with that.

One thing I would say is that having a toddler and newborn is incredibly tough, and the way you’re feeling now is normal, but may not be how you’re feeling in a few months time, so allow yourself and your newly expanded family some time and space to settle down and find your feet a bit before deciding what you really want.

TacoSunday · 05/08/2021 12:10

Your post reminded me of this quote.

To ask DH to give up his career?
ExpressDelivery · 05/08/2021 12:07

I think it's reasonable enough to want that, but it's not what he wants. Presumably this is the man you married, he hasn't become career driven and money orientated since DC arrived?

Bluntness100 · 05/08/2021 12:01

Op he can neve be an equal co parent when you only work part time ans him full time, that’s an unreasonable demand, if you’re working less so you can be home with the kids of course you will parent more.

And as much as it’s lovely that he’s your best friend, please make sure that doesn’t also mean only friend. Because that’s too much responsibility on one person and not fair on him.

It’s not ok to decide you want to be home to see th kids grow but you don’t quite like doing it alone so want him to quit and do it with you.

If being at home isn’t for you then get back into the work place, find something else to do. But you can’t force someone to live a life they don’t wish just so you can be happy.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/08/2021 11:56

Ooops that is this thread Grin

Getawaywithit · 05/08/2021 11:54

@Justlife45

Yes, I have seen that. Still doesn't mean that the balance is right for the OP's husband. Having been through a no-money period in life, I would rather over-work now to avoid being in that place again. I know which is worse, that's for sure.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/08/2021 11:53

The way I read this is that the dp wants to keep up this lavish expensive life even if it's at the expense of his children growing up to have less time with him. When they could live a comfortable life and sacrifice some expensive ways to be together more

Ironically, there is another active thread about just this and the OP (female) is being lambasted for not respecting her DH's right and need to work - and her expensive lifestyle is being thrown in her face...

dottiedodah · 05/08/2021 11:52

You say your DH is your Best Friend.This is lovely and how I feel about my DH too.However I do have other friends! Its not healthy to rely on one person so much .I really think it would make such a difference to you to have some female friends with DC a similar age .I was/am a SAHM and lived for the coffee mornings when DC were small. Your DH is like many men ,they are work driven and wont be happy at home fo long .

Phineyj · 05/08/2021 11:48

I thought spider's advice was good. Small steps, make sure annual leave is booked and taken. Reevaluate in a year.

Working hours are long in the UK and Covid hasn't helped as a lot of people have lost the natural boundary of the commute. So resisting the upward creep of hours is a good idea. That's what would help across the board - more dads with constraints such as reaching nursery/after school club by 6. More dadswho take on genuine responsibility for organising aspects of family life. It's being The Keeper of All Tickets, Arrangements and Resources that gets me down, more than the actual childcare. I thought a lot about being a mum. I should have given more thought to being a frigging quartermaster!!

OP, worth a conversation with DH in due course about timeliness. There are more and less expensive times to reduce working hours - I don't know what he does but shares, bonuses, partnerships, professional qualifications all have to be factored in. Plus if he works with people whose DC are privately educated, he may be thinking he's going to need £50k a year for that and once you're on that train it's hard to get off. Or maybe, like my BF's DH, he'll eventually admit he's no real interest in hands-on dadding...

Do you have career goals?

In summary, try to think about the next 10-15 years if you can, not the next 5.

Justlife45 · 05/08/2021 11:48

@Getawaywithit

Yes but the op said even if they did less hours they wouldnt be struggling. So effectively what they will be giving up on is nice cars, holidays, branded clothes ect. Not worrying about house payments and Bill's. She made it clear in her op they can afford to work less without putting themselves in a bad position

Getawaywithit · 05/08/2021 11:45

Spending time with the ones you love is way more important than material things like expensive cars and a luxury lifestyle

It's a fine line though. It's easy to say 'money can't buy happinness' but if you're a single parent with an average wage coming in, running yourself ragged with drop offs and pick ups and worrying about making the mortgage payment and paying for school, money sure as hell would make life a lot easier.

Justlife45 · 05/08/2021 11:43

@PurpleOkapi

No one forced her to have a child, much less two

That made me cringe internally whilst reading this. You keep trying to par everything off on the woman. Her parent ALSO choose this. This is why the op brings up feeling equal. It's clear even from the perspective of outsiders that this dynamic isnt equal. She didn't decide to impregnate herself both she and her husband sat down and decided to become parents. Together. So he should also pull his weight as a dad breadwinner or not. It's not like they will be slumming it if he cuts down his hours. OP said it is well in their means to cut down on expenses in return for quality family time, which should be priceless for parents.

The way I read this is that the dp wants to keep up this lavish expensive life even if it's at the expense of his children growing up to have less time with him. When they could live a comfortable life and sacrifice some expensive ways to be together more. Also just because they can afford a nanny doesnt mean they should. Maybe the op recognises what is more important is for her children to be raised with their parents around them instead of being chucked into full time care whilst both parents work like crazy when it's not necessary. Just a shame the dp doesnt think the same.

PurpleOkapi · 05/08/2021 11:34

@TedMullins

Why does no one say this about career-driven, high-earning women though? You see it all the time on here "I had a Big Job before kids and earned more than DH, then I went part time/became a SAHM and now he earns 85 times what I ever could". Why? Why does nobody look at women like that and say to her male partner "well, don't expect her to give up work and push a pram around, you know what she's like, you better prepare to be a SAHD!"

I've said that exact thing plenty of times. But it doesn't matter, really, because no matter what anyone claims, a husband can't force his wife to quit her Big Job for the same reasons this OP can't force her husband to quit his. If he chooses to quit it because that will make OP happy, fine - he has every right to make that decision, and he's going to have to live with the consequences. Likewise, when a woman chooses to quit her Big Job to make her husband happy, that's her decision that she has every right to make, and she's going to have to live with the consequences. If she later regrets that decision, that doesn't make the whole thing someone else's fault.

vivainsomnia · 05/08/2021 11:31

I had a Big Job before kids and earned more than DH, then I went part time/became a SAHM and now he earns 85 times what I ever could". Why? Why does nobody look at women like that and say to her male partner "well, don't expect her to give up work and push a pram around, you know what she's like, you better prepare to be a SAHD!
Because these women give up these jobs by choice, because THEY want to be there for their kids. I know many mums who decided to do both, continue with their career and be a good mum and managed both very well.

I don't know any woman in real life who has given up a very good established well paid career because their husband wanted them to. It just doesn't happen.

In OP's case, there would be no issues if he agreed, but he doesn't. Do you think it would be right for a man to insist that his career wife should go part time despite loving her job and the income that comes with it because he was feeling lonely? I very much doubt it!

PurpleOkapi · 05/08/2021 11:29

@TedMullins

Did she "decide" to change her lifestyle though or was it implicitly assumed? What if she'd carried on as her DH has done, gone back to work as soon as physically possible after giving birth, and carried on as if nothing had changed? Would the DH have cut down his hours and done the parenting without any discussion, as has seemingly happened here? It's hardly a free decision is it, when women so easily fall into this role without men even giving it a moment's consideration. What if SHE was the surgeon and has now dropped to another, part-time medical role, because she implicitly considered her kids? Why isn't the same expected of men?
Sounds like they can afford a nanny, so that's probably what they'd have done. If DH had objected to it, she'd have been within her rights to tell him to stay home himself if he was opposed to their child being raised by a nanny. No one forced her to have a child, much less two, and there's no indication that anyone forced her to quit her job to raise them. She's an adult who chose to do all of those things despite being fortunate enough to have a plethora of other options. That's the same regardless of the type of career she chose to give up. If a man chose to do the same thing in the same circumstances, that would also be his own free choice.
Shellfishblastard · 05/08/2021 11:28

Could your DH condense his hours and take a day off? My DH did this and works a 9 day fortnight. The day at home with our girls has been great for him and for the DC.

I do understand why you want to make these changes OP. I’ve had similar thoughts in the past. DH and I both work full time and it’s a slog. We are financially secure - not as comfortable as you describe but also have a nice home, 2 cars etc and in the past I have suggested selling up and buying an ex local authority property so that we have no mortgage and can go part time. I probably haven’t been very serious about it - or I probably was at the time but then the moment passed and life continued on.

But if your DH likes his job and likes his life then it’s not going to be possible - but your opinion matters in all of this so he shouldn’t just dismiss you.

PurpleOkapi · 05/08/2021 11:25

@Justlife45 If one spouse is the primary breadwinner while the other is the primary caregiver, the breadwinner's life doesn't change nearly as much as the caregiver's. It can't, because they still have to go to work every day and spend 8 hours or more doing exactly the same job as before. The bills still need to be paid, and now there are a lot more of them. Most people with SAH spouses don't reduce their hours after having children, not because they don't want to, but because they can't.

OP's proposed plan involves somehow reducing their living expenses to 1/4 of what they are currently. There are obviously going to be some huge negatives to that plan, for both themselves and their children, and her husband disagrees with her opinion that the pros outweigh the cons. Without more details, I don't see any reason to assume that she's right and he's wrong. Since it requires both of them to continue working part-time while doing all of the household work themselves instead of paying others to do it, I'm not convinced it would even give them significantly more time with the children.

FrownedUpon · 05/08/2021 11:21

I get it. So many people slog it out for a big house, nice car etc. forgetting about the important things-family, health. Your life sounds so miserable & there are other options. However your OP needs to be on board.

TedMullins · 05/08/2021 11:20

Did she "decide" to change her lifestyle though or was it implicitly assumed? What if she'd carried on as her DH has done, gone back to work as soon as physically possible after giving birth, and carried on as if nothing had changed? Would the DH have cut down his hours and done the parenting without any discussion, as has seemingly happened here? It's hardly a free decision is it, when women so easily fall into this role without men even giving it a moment's consideration. What if SHE was the surgeon and has now dropped to another, part-time medical role, because she implicitly considered her kids? Why isn't the same expected of men?

Gardenwalldilema · 05/08/2021 11:18

Ask him to give up his career by all means, but be fully prepared to go to work full time yourself to make up the difference.

Justlife45 · 05/08/2021 11:18

@PurpleOkapi but your lifestyle changes when you have children. Everyone knows that. You cant thing to bring another human into the world and selfishly keep to the same ways you have been doing before them. You have to adjust and accommodate. Having children is about sacrificing and comprising. It seems op has realised that but her husband doesnt.
This is meant to be a website based on women and mothers. I'm surprised so many still think that it's okay for the husband to have this none present role in their children's lives and choose work over them. We arent living in the olden days anymore.

As parents the have a responsibility to balance their work life with family if they can afford to, which op has made clear they can.

christinarossetti19 · 05/08/2021 11:17

I don't think that a few weeks after childbirth is the best time to be making life-changing decisions tbh.

But I do think it sounds like the right time for you and dh to open and maintain a dialogue about what the future holds for you all.

Is he as worried as you about his health? When are you planning to return to work, if you are? What happens at the weekends - is he working all the time then as well? Would wfh some of the time be an option for him, to reduce commuting time and let him spend more time with the children? Does he even want to spend more time with the children?

Only you and dh can sort this out, although you might find couples counselling helpful.

At the moment, you're poles apart but if your relationship is strong enough, you'll be able to find a workable middle ground.

TedMullins · 05/08/2021 11:16

@BuffySummersReportingforSanity

Life changes when you have kids and he should be more open to working around family life now that he's a parent - he decided to have kids as well, presumably!

There are plenty of women for whom this is basically the ideal scenario. They're funded enough to do whatever they like, they rule the house without having to have an annoying husband underfoot, and as long as the DH turns up occasionally for special occasions they're basically happy.

I'm not saying the OP has to accept this, she gets to set her own boundaries. But when you marry a man who has always been very driven and works long hours for a big salary... I think you probably know what you're getting, basically, and it's not someone who's going to quit to push the pram or go PT so he can take them to the beach a lot.

Why does no one say this about career-driven, high-earning women though? You see it all the time on here "I had a Big Job before kids and earned more than DH, then I went part time/became a SAHM and now he earns 85 times what I ever could". Why? Why does nobody look at women like that and say to her male partner "well, don't expect her to give up work and push a pram around, you know what she's like, you better prepare to be a SAHD!"

Expectations for men are so, so, so depressingly low. God forbid a man takes time to parent his own children. So what if it means a smaller house and fewer cars and holidays? Reading between the lines, I doubt a downsizing of lifestyle would put this family on the breadline. We really, as a society, need to shake up our expectations of parenting and family life and make it the default that men are expected to step up and do their fair share, rather than expecting that women will be the ones to take the majority, if not all, of the hit.

vivainsomnia · 05/08/2021 11:14

Our DC are young for such a small length of time - they need us, they adore us, they are extremely hard work. But it goes in the blink of an eye. No corporate representatives will be there at your death bed
Working FT and long hours doesn't mean you can't be a good parent though. Physical presence is only one part f parenting. Then you have the other parts. The devotion to give them things that will make their life and future better. Giving them emotional attention, educating them about life, even if it's only for a bit at weekend, or during holidays, and showing them another good role model that might be an inspiration to them. You don't need to witness every moment of their lives to value it.

Meanwhile OP feels depressed and resentful. But so what, eh? Women just have to suck it up

That's not what people are saying, why systematically fall into the victim mode. What we are saying is that there are other means to beat the feeling of loneliness than just having her partner at her side for half of the time.

We don't even know what his career is? What if he is a surgeon? Over 10 years of studying, and then what? It's difficult to be a surgeon PT. Hospitals need you to be available as much as possible, patients don't pick to have surgery when it suits the surgeon. There is then all the time to do research, train etc...

This is very different to say being a high earning accountant, when you could work for yourself and just pick to have a smaller portfolio, but even then, availability and reputation based on availability is often key to success.

PurpleOkapi · 05/08/2021 11:13

@RadandMad

The other thing to consider is your DH is obviously very driven and career focussed. Take that away from him and he may well turn into a different person. Depressed, resentful etc

Meanwhile OP feels depressed and resentful. But so what, eh? Women just have to suck it up.

I think the difference here is that the husband is doing everything the same way he's always done it, which is exactly what OP should have expected when she married him and had children with him. OP's the one who decided to change her lifestyle, which in turn changed her feelings about his lifestyle, and now expects him to change his lifestyle to accommodate her changed feelings. That doesn't mean it's fine for him to completely ignore her feelings, but he's not obligated to completely upend his entire life just because it took her a few years to many to realize she doesn't actually want the life that she knew being married to him would entail.