Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DH to give up his career?

243 replies

Lonelylooloo · 05/08/2021 07:53

Please don’t flame me I know I am probably being VU and will accept that if you tell me.

I have a big house, nice car, cleaners and no money worries, I know I’m very very lucky. I also have a DH we rarely see who works long hours in a draining job.
We have two small DC the youngest is just a few weeks old and DH has been on SPL, it’s been so lovely having him around and I don’t mean to sound ungrateful but I’ve realised how lonely and unhappy I am when DH is working.

He goes back tomorrow and Im upset. I want to simplify our lives. We could sell up and purchase a small property cash, reduce our monthly outgoings to less than 1/4 of the current and DH (or I) could work PT to survive comfortably. There’s huge demand for DH’s skills and I have a decent PT job. He could actually spend time with our toddler who adores him and not be miserable and exhausted all the time. I could not feel like a single parent! We are so lucky to have the option to live like this as so many don’t.

I told him how I feel but he doesn’t feel the same. He likes his job and wants this expensive lifestyle. He just kept repeating ‘it’s gonna be ok’ but it’s just me watching him work himself raw and me doing everything with the house/kids alone. This isn’t how I want to live. What’s the point in a big house when he’s never here to enjoy it?

I wanna spend time together with our beautiful kids whilst they’re little.
I want DH to be around to see them grow up and not have had a heart attack before 40!

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 05/08/2021 13:45

You are right to ask your partner to prioritise you and your children. Working all hours, being stressed, not contributing to the running of the family beyond providing money (which, let's face it, it's just as easy to do if you're separated/divorced) is not the way to be a good husband and father. It's just not
How self-visionary and controlling.

Firstly, OP hasn't said he was contributing at all. She said she missed him when he works and feels lonely but it didn't take long for posters to equal this to him being useless and doing nothing at all at home.

Secondly, many posters seem to have missed the point that he really enjoys his job.

The reverse would see such a different response. 'I'm a SAHM of two children. My OH works long hours and earn a very good income so that I can be home and we can enjoy a good lifestyle. We've always agreed that I would be a SAHM and it means a lot to me because I really love being with my kids. My second is now at school and my OH is insisting that I go back to work PT because he thinks that we don't earn enough and could do more fun things with my income. I don't want to go back to work, I enjoy being a SAHM and we are doing very well financially. He just wants more luxuries.

How many would say that her OH is entitled to change his mind, entitled to want a change in their life, entitled to demand that she changes her life because it would make him happier even if that's not what she wants. Yet, it's ok to expect OP's OH to change his life, what was the norm before, do something that he is not happy with just because she misses his company?

liveforsummer · 05/08/2021 13:42

Well YANBU to feel this was but he's certainly not BU to not want to do it. Maybe if he wanted to up hours and be away more , but to keep things the same as they've always been and you knew what that was, you can't expect to change it now. You need to decide if you can live with it or want to split

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 05/08/2021 13:37

YANBU to want more time with him, but YABU to ask him to give up what he clearly loves.
If he doesn't recognise the value in spending more time at home with you and the children over flogging himself, then you trying to make him see isn't going to work, and will only cause resentment.

You can point out the benefits of him cutting down his hours, you downsizing etc. - but until he wants to do it, it's not going to work.

Cocomarine · 05/08/2021 13:33

@SarahBop that’s exactly my point though. I wasn’t going to tell OP that she isn’t like a single parent because she isn’t “xyz”. Because we’re not a homogenous group. We’re all different. And of course, some of what we go through, we have in common with married people more than we do other single mothers.

But people who trot out that they’re like single parents when they are not single parents really need not to be tone death. Because they really really are not single parents at all.

As another poster said - yeah, some of us get more breaks - but that break can suck when it’s Xmas day 🤷🏻‍♀️.

People who think they’re like a single parent when they do it all, are missing that there are so many other elements to being a single parent. Not all of which are bad!

Bottom line… if you are not a single parent, just talk about your own experience, don’t trot out that you’re like a single parent.

This OP for example has never experienced knowing she’s the sole breadwinner for her child.

Fairyliz · 05/08/2021 13:31

You’ve just had a baby and we have all just gone through 18 months that I don’t think anyone could have imagined.
I don’t think now is the time to be making any changes/decisions more taxing than shall I have a tuna or cheese sandwich for lunch!
I would park it for now and just try and get through the next six months/ year of sleepless nights.
Then when you are more rested think about what if any changes you would like to make.

dannyrojas · 05/08/2021 13:30

Read this with interest as I am the one with the job and dh is the sahp to 2 kids.

My job is well paid and financially we are fine but not well off - no mortgage, savings are ok and we don't have to worry day to day but no way could we afford private school, our cars are always second hand and run into the ground, IKEA not John Lewis etc.

I work 50/60 hours per week standard. I love parts of my job and hate other bits. I struggle with boundaries but get a great deal of personal satisfaction and fulfilment from it. I feel a huge amount of pressure being the sole breadwinner and that need to provide keeps me saying yes to things ideally I'd say no to because I can't risk not being thought of as a good performer. I accept there are bits of my kids lives I will miss out on happy dh gets to be there with them.

We talk frequently about rebalancing. I think about going part time and that is the plan in a few years but I'm not ready to yet and dh likes the security of my extra salary. I try to be present when not working, ring fence weekends and annual leave etc. He had a heap of hobbies which keep him occupied and he has his own social circle.

The fact that he considered part time and tried to make it happen indicates to me that he's not checked out or expecting you just to get on with stuff but you have a new baby (congratulations:)) and that's tough. Keep talking to him and consider counselling to help you understand each other.

MyriadeOfThings · 05/08/2021 13:24

@GreenFingersWouldBeHandy

If you are lonely and unhappy, YOU need to make some changes in your life. It's not fair to ask your husband to give up his career.

Why don't you go back to work? It's sounds as though you can afford childcare.

Well, I dint think it’s as simple as that. It’s not as if the OP is lonely and expects her DH to fill up the gaps. Her issue is that she wants to have more family time and time with her DH. I think it’s a different issue and a big one tbh.

Because if one person in the couple ranks family life and time together very high up and the other ranks money/work/big house etc…. higher up it talks about a very different vision of what life is about.

It certainly not about needing to fill your time with doing some work/seeing friends for coffee.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 05/08/2021 13:19

If you are lonely and unhappy, YOU need to make some changes in your life. It's not fair to ask your husband to give up his career.

Why don't you go back to work? It's sounds as though you can afford childcare.

hudagee · 05/08/2021 13:11

but getting a break from relentless 24/7 demands of the home and kids, can make a huge difference.

The OP has options though because she has money. I'm not working this week but mine are at an activity camp.

Dacquoise · 05/08/2021 13:10

I am going to be the boring one here but have you considered the long term financial implications of this? Yes you can downsize and live a smaller life but have you put away enough for your retirement years at your ages? Also when your children go to university will you be able to support them financially? Also what about helping them get on the housing market?

SarahBop · 05/08/2021 13:08

@Cocomarine

Oh please, just sod off with the “feel like a single parent” crap.

Come back when you have no-one to bounce parenting decisions off and sole financial responsibility, then we’ll talk.

I earn a great salary and I get plenty of breaks. So no one stereotype of a single parent here.

But just - don’t even go there, when you’re not, OK?

His career is important to him and you knew that and were happy with it before. I expect the grass is greener and less money and husband underfoot, bored, wouldn’t actually be that great.

I earn a great salary and I get plenty of breaks.

So in some ways, maybe you have it mentally better than the OP?
Not wanting to start a debate...but getting a break from relentless 24/7 demands of the home and kids, can make a huge difference.

To me , the OP sounds desperately overwhelmed and lonely. She isn't a single parent, as in that she IS married and does have someone earning her money...but mentally, she IS alone..because it sounds like she is doing everything alone.

We all have different circumstances. Some single parents don't get a break AT ALL. Others have their kids 24/7, have zero support network/break/financial security....some people can be married and still feel this way, because of isoaltion, lack of support and financial abuse.

TheDailyCarbunkle · 05/08/2021 13:03

I'd love there to be a change away from the idea that it's acceptable for one parent to basically not be around/be too tired and stressed to do much practical parenting. If you're on the bones of your arse and need to work all hours just to survive, that's unfortunate and can't be helped. But choosing to live a stressed and miserable life is madness.

hudagee · 05/08/2021 12:59

Can he not take longer paternity leave? Most of our friends take at least 2 months as many companies are working on work/life balance. DH took 3 months & it was fab.
Long term you need to decide what you're happy with. Dh earns well but I would not tolerate a role long term that made his miserable & exhausted.

TheDailyCarbunkle · 05/08/2021 12:58

I think you're very sensible to recognise this now and not let it drift on until you're another 5 years down the road and far more resentful and detached from your DH. IMO a lot of responses you've had reflect the fact that earning money is seen as a legitimate reason to ignore what your family needs - if he was spending hours and hours on a hobby and you felt lonely and upset because of that, the responses you'd get would be very different. It's no uncommon for one partner (almost always the woman in heterosexual setups) to just accept that their partner is away most of the time and that they have to do most child related/household things on their own. Over time what often ends up happening is that there is essentially no partnership - each person is doing their own bit of keeping the family going and barely cooperating on anything. Fast forward a few years and the partner at home feels they have no one to depend on - they are the 'default parent' all the time and their partner knows little or no detail about the house or the children, while the working partner feels disconnected and left out and unable to make their way back into the family. The result is resentment, lack of communication, no teamwork and often leads to the death of the relationship.

You are right to ask your partner to prioritise you and your children. Working all hours, being stressed, not contributing to the running of the family beyond providing money (which, let's face it, it's just as easy to do if you're separated/divorced) is not the way to be a good husband and father. It's just not.

samG76 · 05/08/2021 12:49

I can see the dilemma. I'd love to go back to work, but DH makes many time what I would get even full-time, and I have been a SAHM for 5 years because the extra hassle of childcare etc affected my ability to do my job properly. With the youngest DC at school I hope to get back into the jobs market.

ddl1 · 05/08/2021 12:47

I don't think YABU to prefer a different way of life; but, assuming that this is the way your husband has always been, YABU to expect to change him.

Perhaps you could try to persuade him to be at home more during your baby's first few months. He might be more receptive to that if it's presented as adapting to a specific short-term situation, rather than a permanent change in his lifestyle. But I think ultimately you have to either accept him as he is, or break up.

TheGoogleMum · 05/08/2021 12:41

Yanbu but he's got to realise himself I think that lifes too short

rookiemere · 05/08/2021 12:35

Maybe now is an opportunity for him to revisit the reduced working hours option.
If you were both working and he was needed for pick ups and drop offs then he'd absolutely have to make reduced hours/unusual working pattern work.
Things have changed a lot over the past 16 months, no harm in seeing if he'd revisit the option. Even a 9 day fortnight would give him a bit more time with his DCs.

clueblues8 · 05/08/2021 12:34

I don't think either of YABU. Things do change when you have children. Money isn't everything, but you need to make sure you have enough to be comfortable. I think you both need to think ahead and think about you want in the future. Create a plan for the future and work from there, compromising to try and meet both of your needs. How much time you want to spend with the children? What type of house do you want? Could you downsize but still have plenty of space? Is private education something you want for your children? Expensive holidays? When do you want to retire? What is most important to you both? From the sounds of it, cutting back doesn't mean living in poverty for you? Our setup is a smaller house which is more than big enough but with a smaller mortgage, house hasn't got expensive new kitchens and decor but is more than adequete, we are living in a very nice area with good state schools but no option to go privately due to income, not having to worrying about money at all but a simpler lifestyle without expensive holidays, gym memberships, expensive cars and clothes. It is still a lovely lifestyle, but much simpler than our peers who have much bigger houses (bigger than you need) with amazing renovations, nicer cars, expensive holidays and all the trappings. We work less hours. This works for us, I'm not saying it for everyone. It depends on what is most important to you.

PP suggested starting with small changes like him taking all his annual leave etc, that sounds like a great start. Maybe there is a half way point where he works a bit less, you get more support in the shape of nanny/nursery etc and get more social support from friends?

If he is exhausted and stressed, that isn't great for his health and also runs the risk of him burning out and not being able to work at all for a while. He needs to treat it as a marathon, not a sprint. The same goes for you, you need to look after yourself else otherwise you will struggle with the children and work. Remember the "put your oxygen mask on first" analogy.

Sorry for the long post!

Bluntness100 · 05/08/2021 12:24

@TedMullins

I'm not advocating for anyone to be forced to give up their career against their will – ultimately no, she can't force him to do anything, but wanting/expecting him to take on more parenting duties is not unreasonable. This is more than an issue of 'everyone here has made their choices and has to live with them', while that is somewhat true, it's undeniable that on a societal level the expectations placed on women when it comes to parenting are not the same as those on men.
She has chosen to go part time. She has specially said she wants to be home to see her kids grow. She can go back full time and use child care like eighty percent of mothers.

Of course it’s unreasonable to then say he has to do it too as she doesn’t like it. He should equally parent when home, but it’s hugely unreasonable to say I want to stay home but it’s a bit shite so can you stay home too to help me.

ThePlantsitter · 05/08/2021 12:23

I totally understand where you're coming from and having been a SAHM / bits and pieces of part time work while my H pursued his career I'm coming out of it now the youngest is 10.

The difference for me was that DH was a bit of a slacker when I met him and got his 'big' job when I was pregnant with my second so I never signed up for the lifestyle. I'm not going to say that it was easy but I'm guessing it was a lot easier than being a single mum or skint, so I put up with it, tried to make my feelings plain wherever possible and now have gone back to work full time and am making DH do a lot of the parenting stuff too. You have to carve out things for yourself (hobbies, education, friendships) and it does feel a bit like leading separate lives for a while but it's coming together now -- and I've Covid to partly thank for that too.

Honestly, if I had my time again and knew how it would pan out I would not choose to have kids with someone who valued a big career over time with the family, but once it's done it's done isn't it? Leaving him wasn't going to make it easier, and I have loved him throughout even if I've hated him at times, so that helps.

TedMullins · 05/08/2021 12:17

I'm not advocating for anyone to be forced to give up their career against their will – ultimately no, she can't force him to do anything, but wanting/expecting him to take on more parenting duties is not unreasonable. This is more than an issue of 'everyone here has made their choices and has to live with them', while that is somewhat true, it's undeniable that on a societal level the expectations placed on women when it comes to parenting are not the same as those on men.

DrNo007 · 05/08/2021 12:12

Try to find a compromise and ask him if he'd consider doing one day per week less at work. It's a bit unfortunate that this has grown into an 'all or nothing' decision. And develop your own interests and social life that don't involve him.

MzHz · 05/08/2021 12:12

You’ve said how you feel, (well done! That took guts!)

Let him return to work.. who knows maybe he will see what you’re saying when he’s back dragging his weary carcass to and from work.

You’ve sown the seeds.. who knows he might work it out for himself

Angliski · 05/08/2021 12:11

It’s wonderful to have choices. Life is too short to waste it at work you can’t stand. Most don’t have that option, I coach people on careers and would absolutely recommend having the chat. What I woood say is that men often I’d ratify more strongly with their work identity - so doing something, less stressful but still something, usually works better than a full retirement or stay at home dad. I say this with a stay at home dh myself, but he’s a very beta person and in a later stage of life :)