Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DH to give up his career?

243 replies

Lonelylooloo · 05/08/2021 07:53

Please don’t flame me I know I am probably being VU and will accept that if you tell me.

I have a big house, nice car, cleaners and no money worries, I know I’m very very lucky. I also have a DH we rarely see who works long hours in a draining job.
We have two small DC the youngest is just a few weeks old and DH has been on SPL, it’s been so lovely having him around and I don’t mean to sound ungrateful but I’ve realised how lonely and unhappy I am when DH is working.

He goes back tomorrow and Im upset. I want to simplify our lives. We could sell up and purchase a small property cash, reduce our monthly outgoings to less than 1/4 of the current and DH (or I) could work PT to survive comfortably. There’s huge demand for DH’s skills and I have a decent PT job. He could actually spend time with our toddler who adores him and not be miserable and exhausted all the time. I could not feel like a single parent! We are so lucky to have the option to live like this as so many don’t.

I told him how I feel but he doesn’t feel the same. He likes his job and wants this expensive lifestyle. He just kept repeating ‘it’s gonna be ok’ but it’s just me watching him work himself raw and me doing everything with the house/kids alone. This isn’t how I want to live. What’s the point in a big house when he’s never here to enjoy it?

I wanna spend time together with our beautiful kids whilst they’re little.
I want DH to be around to see them grow up and not have had a heart attack before 40!

OP posts:
enoughforme · 05/08/2021 19:42

YANBU but neither is he. It's purely just life that you have grown to a stage where you both want different things and neither of you are wrong in those circumstances.

I also have some empathy OP as I'm in a similar situation, me and DH started as workaholics a business ten years ago so I was the same as Him working myself to the bone,

Now we have a similar lifestyle to the one you describe - everything I ever wanted and now I want to slow down. I've had enough, but DH wants to keep going so I keep following,

I feel trapped, like I'm going to pass my life by being a stressed workaholic and I'm even more worried about DH having aheart attack too.

I guess I don't really have much advice aside from saying I know exactly how you feel and you are not alone, what the solution is I don't know.

Justlife45 · 05/08/2021 18:23

I think your all missing the point here.

The dad has the luxury of cutting back his job, not quitting, and still living comfortably whilst he has more free time for his children.

He has willingly chose not to. So this whole someone needs to supply for the family argument isnt applicable in this circumstance. OP isnt even a stahp she works as well! However she doesnt want her children to be under the care of a nanny and never have both parents around so she has kept it part time. Her husband, who decided to have children WITH HER, should also try to be as present as possible for those poor children sake and of course for his wife.

It is selfish to not expect his life to change as soon as he became a dad

And it is selfish to choose money and luxuries over quality time with them

ThePlantsitter · 05/08/2021 17:00

It's not a situation where you can say 'if a man said... Blah blah' because it doesn't matter what the request is, nothing is off limits to talk about or request. It's how you deal with the decisions that are the point. It's interesting that women are told you can have both a sparkling career and a happy, involved family life but men are not expected to strive for that - but it's not really relevant. OP wants a life where both parents are very involved with the kids at the cost of less money for luxuries. OP's H doesn't. It's up to them to find a balance that works for both of them. Ultimately though the person who wants the other to change is onto a loser if the other doesn't want to and especially in the OP's position when there isn't anything that makes the situation how she wants apart from her H caring less about his high flying career, which he doesn't think is reasonable. I disagree, but I'm not him, and societal expectations are firmly on his side too.

dft6432 · 05/08/2021 16:57

I'm not sure I'd agree that a parent who only sees their kids for any length of time at weekends is a "shit" parent. Time with kids is very important but it's not really quality time with our kids during the week due to sports commitments, homework etc. My husband works long hours during the week but I'm around for the kids while he's working. He gives them 100% of his time at the weekend, and him working also provides a nice lifestyle for them.

I wouldn't judge parents for taking a job with less onerous hours, that has its merits. But those parents who work long hours make their contribution too, albeit in a different way. I wouldn't see either as good/bad.

TedMullins · 05/08/2021 16:46

@vivainsomnia

If he was spending hours and hours on a hobby and you felt lonely and upset because of that, the responses you'd get would be very different That might be your views but it is not the general consensus. There have been enough threads of women complaining that their partner wanted them to go back to work when they were doing fine financially and it was agreed before that they would be a SAHM long term and the response was in the very large majority that the guy is selfish and can't suddenly make demands when they had an agreed arrangement in place before.

OP doesn’t SAH though she said she works part time, so she’s already financially contributing and wants DH to do more of his share of the parenting. Not unreasonable
that's not what she says, again, the usual interpretation. She says she is lonely and wants more of his presence, very different.

Like i said I don't think men who want their SAH wives to go back to work are unreasonable so I would not respond to a thread involving that scenario in the way that you think.
Recessed · 05/08/2021 16:33

She said in her first post that he rarely sees them - rarely was the word used. That's what I'm talking about. A parent who "rarely" sees their DC when they have the option to change that is a shit parent IMO.

Bluntness100 · 05/08/2021 16:20

@Recessed

Not stay home permanently obviously but to see them occasionally during the week - yes I do think parents should see their children and be involved in their day to day lives. It's odd not to want to. The OP says they rarely see him. That's shit parenting in my book male or female and completely unnecessary in most cases.
What are you talking about? He does seem them regularly through the week. She’s not said he’s live out.
Recessed · 05/08/2021 16:18

Not stay home permanently obviously but to see them occasionally during the week - yes I do think parents should see their children and be involved in their day to day lives. It's odd not to want to. The OP says they rarely see him. That's shit parenting in my book male or female and completely unnecessary in most cases.

MyriadeOfThings · 05/08/2021 16:16

As a pp said if a man wants his wife to go back to work,he’s unreasonable.

On the other side, it’s pretty much expected that the mum is giving up her career as soon as she becomes a mum. So expected that it’s not even discussed. It just happens….

Amazing that when it’s the other way around and we are talking about a dad who gives up his career when becoming a dad is seen as awful…..

Bluntness100 · 05/08/2021 16:14

@Recessed

I must say I'm very surprised at the number of posters who are happy for a Dad to be absent from his children's lives in return for money.

Yes it's quite a shocking thread in that regard. As if it's unacceptable to ask the big important man to compromise after they decided to have children. As though he's entitled for his life to remain absolutely the same. It reads like "you made your bed woman, facilitate the life of the almighty penis at the expense of your own" Confused

Oh and piling on her for the single parent comment. Such bitterness. I've been both and it's incredibly lonely and stressful being in a marriage where the other parent leaves the entire load to you. Yes doing it all completely alone is a heavy load to bear and there are differences but it's comparable in many ways.

Bloody hell. Do you both also feel if a woman works she’s absent from her children’s lives in return for money? That everyone should quit and stay home?

Odd. Very odd.

Recessed · 05/08/2021 16:12

I must say I'm very surprised at the number of posters who are happy for a Dad to be absent from his children's lives in return for money.

Yes it's quite a shocking thread in that regard. As if it's unacceptable to ask the big important man to compromise after they decided to have children. As though he's entitled for his life to remain absolutely the same. It reads like "you made your bed woman, facilitate the life of the almighty penis at the expense of your own" Confused

Oh and piling on her for the single parent comment. Such bitterness. I've been both and it's incredibly lonely and stressful being in a marriage where the other parent leaves the entire load to you. Yes doing it all completely alone is a heavy load to bear and there are differences but it's comparable in many ways.

Bluntness100 · 05/08/2021 16:09

There’s always a gender bias on here, whatever a woman wants is deemed to be reasonable. Whereas any bloke who wants the same is not. It’s quite stark too

As a pp said if a man wants his wife to go back to work,he’s unreasonable.
But if a man said I want my wife to stop working, as I don’t want to work full time and I want to stay home with th kids, but fuck me it’s lonely and hard, so if she stopped work too then it would be easier for me to be a stay at home parent, he’d get his arse handed to him

But on here, oh you want to stay at home with your kids, that’s great, and yes of course it means you’re doing more of the parenting, that’s the job definition, but it is hard and lonely so get him to quit too and share the load. Totally reasonable.

The answer is if the op doesn’t like being a stay at home parent and finds it hard and lonely then get herself back into work and find childcare. Not everyone is cut out for it

But what you can’t do is decide you want to be a stay at hone parent, then decide it’s a bit shit so your partner should quit and make your new job easier.

Recessed · 05/08/2021 15:41

YANBU but obviously there's not much you can do if he refuses. I wouldn't frame it as an all or nothing but there can be compromises made. I felt similar when my DCs were babies/toddlers and in the same situation. I also asked that he take a job closer to home - it would have dramatically reduced his earnings but it would have given me more work options and would saved our marriage. He refused. We are now in the process of separating. It's not worth it unless both parties are happy with the arrangement. Finicaial security is important but excess money is unnecessary if it comes at such a high cost. When they were tiny there were many periods when my DC didn't see their dad from Monday to Friday due to the length of his commute, he'd often work Saturdays and he was so exhausted on Sundays that he'd spend hours sleeping on the couch - all for what? We didn't need it, we had no mortgage, we could have easily tightened our belts for those early years. I think he loved being Billy Big Balls "provider" with the wife and children at home. Our children have ultimately paid the price.

RantyAunty · 05/08/2021 15:13

You've stated how you feel about it but I think you'll have to accept many men just don't feel the same way.

Many see their families as a box to tick off. They like the idea of it and love that you make HIS life easier for him while he works all those hours. He can get the good parts of parenting and marriage without any of the down side or work involved.

He likes it. He likes the company of his coworkers.
Someone at his level can shift things around some.
He just doesn't want to.

vivainsomnia · 05/08/2021 15:09

If he was spending hours and hours on a hobby and you felt lonely and upset because of that, the responses you'd get would be very different
That might be your views but it is not the general consensus. There have been enough threads of women complaining that their partner wanted them to go back to work when they were doing fine financially and it was agreed before that they would be a SAHM long term and the response was in the very large majority that the guy is selfish and can't suddenly make demands when they had an agreed arrangement in place before.

OP doesn’t SAH though she said she works part time, so she’s already financially contributing and wants DH to do more of his share of the parenting. Not unreasonable
that's not what she says, again, the usual interpretation. She says she is lonely and wants more of his presence, very different.

TedMullins · 05/08/2021 14:59

Bold fail, I’m quoting a PP there between the asterisks

TedMullins · 05/08/2021 14:58

*The reverse would see such a different response. 'I'm a SAHM of two children. My OH works long hours and earn a very good income so that I can be home and we can enjoy a good lifestyle. We've always agreed that I would be a SAHM and it means a lot to me because I really love being with my kids. My second is now at school and my OH is insisting that I go back to work PT because he thinks that we don't earn enough and could do more fun things with my income. I don't want to go back to work, I enjoy being a SAHM and we are doing very well financially. He just wants more luxuries.

How many would say that her OH is entitled to change his mind, entitled to want a change in their life, entitled to demand that she changes her life because it would make him happier even if that's not what she wants. Yet, it's ok to expect OP's OH to change his life, what was the norm before, do something that he is not happy with just because she misses his company?*

I would say that would be a very reasonable expectation for someone to decide they don’t want to shoulder 100% of the financial burden and want a SAHP to go back to work. OP doesn’t SAH though she said she works part time, so she’s already financially contributing and wants DH to do more of his share of the parenting. Not unreasonable.

RadandMad · 05/08/2021 14:55

@TheDailyCarbunkle

I think you're very sensible to recognise this now and not let it drift on until you're another 5 years down the road and far more resentful and detached from your DH. IMO a lot of responses you've had reflect the fact that earning money is seen as a legitimate reason to ignore what your family needs - if he was spending hours and hours on a hobby and you felt lonely and upset because of that, the responses you'd get would be very different. It's no uncommon for one partner (almost always the woman in heterosexual setups) to just accept that their partner is away most of the time and that they have to do most child related/household things on their own. Over time what often ends up happening is that there is essentially no partnership - each person is doing their own bit of keeping the family going and barely cooperating on anything. Fast forward a few years and the partner at home feels they have no one to depend on - they are the 'default parent' all the time and their partner knows little or no detail about the house or the children, while the working partner feels disconnected and left out and unable to make their way back into the family. The result is resentment, lack of communication, no teamwork and often leads to the death of the relationship.

You are right to ask your partner to prioritise you and your children. Working all hours, being stressed, not contributing to the running of the family beyond providing money (which, let's face it, it's just as easy to do if you're separated/divorced) is not the way to be a good husband and father. It's just not.

Beautifully expressed!
BetsyBigNose · 05/08/2021 14:50

I understand how you feel OP. I think I would feel similar in your shoes, as I hugely value spending time with my DH and DC together over the financial rewards either of us working longer hours or in a more stressful role would bring.

Marriage to me is about being kind to your partner, compromising and finding a middle ground which makes the whole family as happy as they can be. I think you and your DH will both have to 'give a little', but I'm sure there has to be an agreement you can reach which means everyone feels that their concerns have been addressed and the balance of time vs money vs happiness is optimal for your family. I hope you manage to find it.

vivainsomnia · 05/08/2021 14:43

I don’t think you really get what children do to your day to day life till you have them. So don’t think people are being entirely fair on OP, I know I didn’t think about it nearly enough*
Indeed, you don't, but that's where choices come into it. My friend took to motherhood in a state of shock. She found it hard, lonely, and soul destroying, so even though she had imagined being a SAHM of 3 or 4, she instead decided to stop at 1 and go back to work.

If you don't enjoy your every day life, especially with the luxury of a good family income that allows you to do things and not just stay at home, then don't have more children. Many families do very well with just one child.

Roomonb · 05/08/2021 14:38

I don’t think you really get what children do to your day to day life till you have them. So don’t think people are being entirely fair on OP, I know I didn’t think about it nearly enough.

In theory taking a massive drop in income is great but I imagine the reality would be very different. Would you be able to outsource what you currently do? would both have to do more of the drudge work of life? The whole booking a ridiculously expensive holiday, or things in the shopping cart or just not worrying about money would probably not be exact the same. It sounds like even on reduced wages you could have a nice life, does that include private school helping kids through uni helping them buy property etc which is what I assume the current plan is.

I can’t imagine the level of wealth some of the posters here probably have but I also couldn’t imagine DH not being around as much as he is (bog standard 8-5 job some evenings and weekends). He had to work one day this weekend and I was at the end of my tether.

If he likes what he has he’s not going to change I would get a couple of nannies if I were you amd sort out some activities for yourself. Just outsource as much as you can. I know it can be lonely and it’s so different parenting with someone else there than it is by yourself for the majority of the day.

Velvian · 05/08/2021 14:25

YANBU at all. I used to think that it was OK for DH to 50% of stuff when he's here, but actually it's not if he just picks and chooses when to be here. (I work too).

We have to expect more of fathers.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 05/08/2021 14:12

Sorry only skimmed the thread so this may have been said.

I am the main earner and DH was a SAHD when the DC were young. I am a high earner and earlier in my career worked stupid hours because that was necessary to progress. I am now senior enough to have some flexibility (and can MN when I stop for lunch Wink).

As the main and at times sole breadwinner I felt huge pressure to provide for the family. It was my responsibility to pay the bills. I wanted to provide the best I could for my DC and give them the opportunities I missed out on. It may be very important to your DH to give your DC a certain standard of living and so your talk of scaling back may be clashing with his goals of supporting his family in a particular lifestyle.

He may feel that scaling back is too risky and may make it harder for him to guarantee that he can continue to support the family if it jeopardises his career. He may also feel that his goals for the family are not being considered.

Its not about who is right or wrong, its about agreeing an approach that meets both your needs.

XelaM · 05/08/2021 13:52

Wow just wow! I'm a single working parent and you're being insanely unreasonable and ungrateful! If your husband likes his job you can't tell him to give it up just because that's what you want

underneaththeash · 05/08/2021 13:47

He’ll always resent you if you ask him.
Just make the most of your weekends and get in paid help during the week if you need.
(I was in exactly the same situation - but DH retired, at 50, a few months ago) having financial stability for your children is great and we can afford for them not to have to pay uni fees and give them a start on the housing ladder.