Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How common is ASD

131 replies

glowyjuice · 04/08/2021 21:29

Hi I'm posting this as just to see what other peoples opinions are, I've read that about 1% of people have a diagnosis of ASD, I'm wondering do you think taking into account those who are undiagnosed would this figure be much higher? I do sometimes wonder how many undiagnosed adults or even children there are out there.

OP posts:
BlankTimes · 05/08/2021 18:19

threads about ASD and other forms of neurodivergence will automatically attract posters with experience of this, these posters are also more likely to post seeking or offering support referencing their experience

Absolutely agree Smile

As for all the armchair diagnosis that takes part on MN threads, it's very rarely done by parents of neurodiverse kids. They are more likely to suggest an assessment would be a good idea and leave it to the individual poster to do what they want to.

The armchair diagnostics are much more often voiced by people who don't have neurodiverse kids and are not qualified to diagnose. They also reinforce the ghastly stereotypes (no eye contact, no empathy, easy to get a dx, etc. etc.) which parents are then left to correct.

People rarely use the SN boards to discuss these things, despite them being populated by very knowledgeable parents, instead they post on AIBU or CHAT so by definition they are going to get a lot of input from people who think they know the answers, but are actually just muddying the waters. Sad

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 05/08/2021 18:16

I need to clarify I think.

  1. I am not 'insinuating people are making it up', rather, as I said, I think there's a recent fad, craze, call it what you will, for picking up on any single autistic-like trait and jumping to the conclusion that is evidence of ASD. It's not helped by the oft-repeated nonsense like 'we're all on the spectrum somewhere/everyone is a bit autistic lol', because that then feeds into a perception that any behaviours that autistic people might display being witnessed in an undiagnosed person, is therefore evidence of ASD. In some ways its a good thing that there's an increased awareness, but I genuinely think there's also a growing tendency to suspect ASD where there really is no reason to.
  1. I don't think there's anything awful about mentioning a diagnosis, my bemusement stems from the fact that is so preponderant on Mumsnet in particular that I can't help feeling a degree of scepticism. I fully accept all the points about online forums being a source of support, gravitation etc, but even considering this the sheer numbers of people claiming to have suspicions about family members being undiagnosed makes me think that there are surely one of two things going on. Either the accepted figures for preponderance in the general population are so wildly inaccurate that the people compiling them really ought to resign in disgrace, or that a significant number of mumsnetters are thinking they are seeing something that simply isn't there.

Again, I'm not accusing anyone or any specific individual of making things up, I just find the preponderance of alleged ASD on mumsnet difficult to reconcile with the wider world, and speaking as someone with a diagnosis, well aware of the stigma, with lived-experience of many of the co-morbid bells and whistles that are also stigmatised, and also having worked for years with vulnerable adults, it does irk me a little that armchair-diagnosing ASD seems to be all the rage right now.

Phineyj · 05/08/2021 18:14

The system is so crappy and under-resourced that you are looking at spending several grand to get your DC diagnosed and some help for them privately, either that or wait years and get thoroughly patronised by professionals who know less than you do. So it makes sense on a site like Mumsnet that posters (many educated and well off) have been able to seek diagnosis and help rather than just suffer.

As a teacher I concur with 1 in 30. About 1 in a class on average. Although some.private schools have higher numbers due to lack of support in state, see above.

There's a mainstream private school not far from me with 2/3s diagnosed SEN. That tells you something about lack of capacity.

ArianaDumbledore · 05/08/2021 18:00

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

Or it could be that people with children with ASD are more likely to seek out support on an online forum, as there isn’t all that much support in real life?

No doubt, but I can't shake the feeling that there's a recent craze for picking up on any autistic trait and armchair diagnosing ASD.

You see it in threads that are in absolutely no way relevant to ASD support. 'MIL is being a cow. Me, DH, DD5 (ASD), DS3 (ASD)...' etc when it's nothing more than a whine thread about a cantankerous MIL.

It's at the point whereby its a novelty to find a DC referenced on here that isn't described as ASD or suspected ASD. No, just because he won't eat orange food and is fascinated with blue crayons doesn't mean he's nailed-on ASD.

But "armchair" diagnosis isn't an actual diagnosis. And most diagnosis starts with someone, usually a parent but not always, suspecting possible ASD etc. So I'm not sure why people get so sensitive about it being thrown in as a consideration.

And as for mentioning a diagnosis when there's no need (!) 1 why is mentioning it so awful? And 2 it might become relevant as the thread develops at which point accusations of "wow that's quite a drip feed" will derail the thread.

I shall make a point to reference my DC dx so you can enjoy the novelty.
ds2 also had Chronic Fatigue Syndrome. Unfortunately DS4 is NT no health issues[sad

Clocktopus · 05/08/2021 17:51

There are more parents of autistic children and autistic adults online as there is very often a lack of RL support so people find their 'village' in online forums. It can also be a bit of confirmation bias - threads about ASD and other forms of neurodivergence will automatically attract posters with experience of this, these posters are also more likely to post seeking or offering support referencing their experiences.

Two pages into the thread and we're already having the doubting posts and the posts insinuating that people are making it up. In case you weren't aware, attitudes like this contribute to RL stigma around neurodivergence which is part of the reason RL support doesn't exist.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 05/08/2021 17:30

Or it could be that people with children with ASD are more likely to seek out support on an online forum, as there isn’t all that much support in real life?

No doubt, but I can't shake the feeling that there's a recent craze for picking up on any autistic trait and armchair diagnosing ASD.

You see it in threads that are in absolutely no way relevant to ASD support. 'MIL is being a cow. Me, DH, DD5 (ASD), DS3 (ASD)...' etc when it's nothing more than a whine thread about a cantankerous MIL.

It's at the point whereby its a novelty to find a DC referenced on here that isn't described as ASD or suspected ASD. No, just because he won't eat orange food and is fascinated with blue crayons doesn't mean he's nailed-on ASD.

BizzyIzzyfruitpie · 05/08/2021 17:11

@ArianaDumbledore

Hmm and when my son was diagnosed 13 years ago. it was 1 in 10. My son was 3 at the time the paediatrician also said he wouldn't have been diagnosed until 7 or later 10 years previously but the assessment process was able to pick up kids like him earlier. He's nearly 16 and no one doubts his diagnosis in real life
My son was diagnosed in 2000. He was just 3. He’s at the severe end of the spectrum but even then they weren’t sure it was actual autism so his original diagnosis is communication disorder/autism. He also has severe learning disabilities. We had a very thorough assessment , it was 2 hours a week for 11 weeks at an assessment centre. At the end a multi disciplinary meeting where all HCP’s involved agreed on the diagnosis. I’ve no idea what the assessment process is like now but school wanted my youngest assessed when he was 6. I said no. He’s a perfectly typical teenager now. He has quirks but definitely nothing that would suggest he’s autistic.
daisycottage · 05/08/2021 17:09

It's around one in 30 by my estimation and observations.

I was diagnosed autistic at 45 and adhd at 50 after a lifetime of struggling and depression.

Ds1 has adhd and ds2 has autism. I tried to access help for ds1 for donkeys years, but just got fobbed off because he's very intelligent. He's only got help as an adult. We couldn't face asking for help for ds2 because the process is so humiliating and difficult.

There are a lot of ND people out there who are struggling terribly, but who try hard to hide it because it's shameful being different. We have a high incidence of mental illness and suicide. Many people in the prison system have adhd and are being failed. Lots of lives wasted.

We don't seek diagnosis to show off or something. It helps us to understand ourselves and perhaps access a few adjustments in school or work.

Nowmum43 · 05/08/2021 16:51

Oh and to the outside world my dd I'm sure comes across as and incredible kind caring girls, has lots of friends, is sociable, empathetic you know all the things that someone who is autistic can't be! So I'm sure people thinking I'm talking bullshit when I tell them! But they don't have to deal with the daily meltdowns when she comes home as she finds the social interactions so hard. She wants to be that girl and is but is exhausted after. I wish people could stop judging what they can't see and presume people would make something like this up about their own child. I mean what benefits are there for your child being autistic? You don't get freebies and stuff Angry

Nowmum43 · 05/08/2021 16:45

We suspect our DD11 is autistic, we are on the beginning of a very long road to getting a diagnosis. I think it's less of a stigma to have an ASD diagnosis and parents and schools are more likely to spot it and get the help needed so it seems 'more' people have it. It's more thats it's been accepted.
My dd has masked incredibly well and I think it's only started slipping now due to lockdown and the uncertainty of the world. I'm glad we know now though and however hard it is she doesn't have to feel like she has to hide who she is anymore.

stayathomer · 05/08/2021 16:37

I think it's probably too late for me.If I was secondary school age it would be absolutely beneficial for friendships, understating my social anxiety and why I feel so alien
Never ever ever too late, I've met tons of people in 50s and 60s diagnosed only in the last 5 or 10 years

kittykarate · 05/08/2021 16:36

My GP decided that I couldn't possibly be on the autism spectrum as I can maintain eye contact. I couldn't face going back again with my AQ test results (41). Luckily I work in a field where being an odd duck isn't too unusual though if I'm put in some situations I can crack.

stayathomer · 05/08/2021 16:33

My brother has as and most of our family share so many defining traits but don't acknowledge them. From meeting other families with as this is so common and people get so offended if you mention a genetic link. I don't know about percentage of the population but I'd say those actually diagnosed- that number isn't even close which is a pity

ArianaDumbledore · 05/08/2021 16:29

I actually have 2 children with ASD dx Shock. And one of those also has an ADHD dx Shock Shock

Neverrains · 05/08/2021 16:26

Exactly this. When my son was diagnosed nearly 20 years ago the figure we were given was 1 in 10,000 . It sees every other kid on her has asd

So you think posters are making it up? Why would they do that?

Vanishun · 05/08/2021 16:24

I mean, fuck me, what kudos which people are supposedly claiming here when they talk about it? It's a disability.

Neverrains · 05/08/2021 16:19

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

If you believe mumsnet, almost everyone

This.

Between 1 in 60 and 1 in 70 of the general population, which is why I've always found the apparent 98% incidence in Mumsnet DC's a bit Hmm

Or it could be that people with children with ASD are more likely to seek out support on an online forum, as there isn’t all that much support in real life?
Vanishun · 05/08/2021 16:18

So what's the consensus from old timers then?

Anyone newly diagnosed doesn't count?

Or anyone newly diagnosed is just doing it to be cool?

becca3210 · 05/08/2021 16:16

@sheiselectric

I'm a teacher and every class I have ever taught has had at least one child diagnosed with autism. There is usually another 2 children in each class that I would highly suspect are autistic and have communicated this to the parents but they have chosen not to pursue a diagnosis.
I was about to post the exact same thing. The 1% figure really does not fit with my experiences in the classroom
ArianaDumbledore · 05/08/2021 16:09

Hmm and when my son was diagnosed 13 years ago. it was 1 in 10. My son was 3 at the time the paediatrician also said he wouldn't have been diagnosed until 7 or later 10 years previously but the assessment process was able to pick up kids like him earlier.
He's nearly 16 and no one doubts his diagnosis in real life

BizzyIzzyfruitpie · 05/08/2021 15:49

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

If you believe mumsnet, almost everyone

This.

Between 1 in 60 and 1 in 70 of the general population, which is why I've always found the apparent 98% incidence in Mumsnet DC's a bit Hmm

Exactly this. When my son was diagnosed nearly 20 years ago the figure we were given was 1 in 10,000 . It sees every other kid on her has asd.
whistlers · 05/08/2021 14:00

[quote BlankTimes]whistlers

It all depends to what extent it affects your daily life. If you're happy as you are at home and at work, then do nothing. If you're affected and need reasonable adjustments, then seek an assessment, preferably by someone who understands female presentation.

Don't forget, many of us have traits, but it's the traits since childhood and the intensity of their presentation in each individual which determines whether they have a diagnosis.

This is one of the best threads I've read regarding living with neurodiversity in adulthood.
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/a4309176-To-ask-what-its-like-to-be-neurodiverse?msgid=109547930[/quote]
I think it's probably too late for me.

If I was secondary school age it would be absolutely beneficial for friendships, understating my social anxiety and why I feel so alien

ArianaDumbledore · 05/08/2021 13:31

I think it's quite probable DH and I are ND but I'd never pursue an assessment. As I think it would just be used against us by certain professionals, particularly as I believe the SEND reforms is going to be detrimental for our DC.

ArianaDumbledore · 05/08/2021 13:25

@Popsicle438

If you believe mumsnet, almost everyone This 100%. I so often wonder why every other poster has a child with ASD and/ or SEN. Is it that these posters are more likely to ask for advice?
I originally joined MN on 2008 for the SN support board as my eldest was on the waiting list for an ASD assessment. I then recommended it to others on the parenting forum I was on (now Dunnington iVillage) as it was crap for SEND support.
3scape · 05/08/2021 13:20

Having ASD I find I don't have in depth conversations with a lot of people in RL so I rely on online environments for understanding certain situations better. Generally I also like reading the variety of views that there are over different situations. I can sometimes fall into lazy thinking that there's always a "right" answer. I have 2 children also with asd. I had an adult dx as I know there's a lot of the population that will conclude I shouldn't have had children knowing my problems Hmm always fun to get told that