Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How common is ASD

131 replies

glowyjuice · 04/08/2021 21:29

Hi I'm posting this as just to see what other peoples opinions are, I've read that about 1% of people have a diagnosis of ASD, I'm wondering do you think taking into account those who are undiagnosed would this figure be much higher? I do sometimes wonder how many undiagnosed adults or even children there are out there.

OP posts:
Sleepyblueocean · 06/08/2021 11:46

Ds has severe autism and a severe learning disability. The severity of the autism was obvious very early on. The extent of his learning disability came later.

Vanishun · 06/08/2021 11:45

I personally agree that we could do with more delineation. After all, we like categorising things, and it feels like we could come up with a series of autism profiles if we all clubbed together and really thought it through.

I guess the problem is that there'd be some rules that came out of it, like "only autism categories 1-3 warrantee levels of support". People would quarrel over faulty labels or which one they belonged to ("I'm a level 3 at this and level 12 at that.")...

Huge can of worms I suppose.

Justrealised · 06/08/2021 11:29

@budgun

Well for some people you can my eleven year old has severe autism and learning disabilities he is non verbal he wont be going to university as he, s still working at pre school levels he has always been at a special school, there are an awful lot of children at special school, s with a diagnosis of autism.

It's the learning disabilities that are key here though, the discussions re separating the autism diagnoses again are for autism only. Any additional conditions obviously change things.

I'm not saying all autistic people are the same, I'm just saying that a over the course of a lifetime they are affected in different ways so placing someone into box A/B/C as a child isn't particularly helpful.

The point that I made though is that previously if you told someone that somebody had autism it was generally understood to be more profound as that is what the dx was, classical autism. Now the dx has been opened to the "full spectrum" so the autism dx is meaningless to those with the most profound needs.

The widening of the spectrum has created more diagnoses, as it includes those whose autism has less impact. This is in response to the op's question.

My son has recently had an independent EP assessment (AR for transition) he has categorically ruled out learning disability although acknowledges some learning difficulties, however my son will never live alone or go to university etc. He has severe autism.

Autism is a disability and is very profound in some cases. Having your son and my described by the same dx isnt helpful to either but probably more so to my son as he isn't able to advocate for himself or campaign for the change whereas high functioning (for want of a better term) are.

As an aside lack of communication ability all the time is also very different to periodically being unable to speak. The two aren't comparable. (In response to your previous post).

budgun · 06/08/2021 10:45

Well for some people you can my eleven year old has severe autism and learning disabilities he is non verbal he wont be going to university as he, s still working at pre school levels he has always been at a special school, there are an awful lot of children at special school, s with a diagnosis of autism.

It's the learning disabilities that are key here though, the discussions re separating the autism diagnoses again are for autism only. Any additional conditions obviously change things.

I'm not saying all autistic people are the same, I'm just saying that a over the course of a lifetime they are affected in different ways so placing someone into box A/B/C as a child isn't particularly helpful.

x2boys · 06/08/2021 10:37

@budgun

There is a big difference between an adult with an autism dx who is able to marry, work, contemplate how their autism impacts them to someone who has little communication, can't live alone, no sense of danger etc. Recognising this difference helps with identity and with communicating needs and disability.

I don't think you can know how substantial any differences will be when the autistic child becomes and adult though.

My DS was all of the things you describe as a child, up until about age 12 where he started to develop into the 18 year old he is today. About to go to uni (albeit living at home). So putting him into the box as a child would have been damaging to him as an adult.

I'm in my 40s and still have moments where I can't talk. Sometimes I need to process what is happening and how to respond and it leaves me unable to talk. Usually when I am out and my day is thrown into chaos (think cancelled train/error at appointments etc)

Well for some people you can my eleven year old has severe autism and learning disabilities he is non verbal he wont be going to university as he, s still working at pre school levels he has always been at a special school, there are an awful lot of children at special school, s with a diagnosis of autism.
Ladyrattles · 06/08/2021 10:35

If a MN posts mention ND I will reply and often mention our conditions but I won't actively seek out ND posts. It is nice when they pop up though, as it makes me feel less alone dealing with ND things.

My eldest daughter got a dyspraxia diagnosis at 7. It wasn't until she was 22 that she got her autism diagnosis. Her university disability team suspected it and suggested further testing, but it took 2.5 years on the nhs waiting list to confirm. The ASD diagnosis team were shocked it hadn't been picked up in childhood but they said that is often the case for girls. Our other children have ND diagnosed conditions too.

randomlyLostInWales · 06/08/2021 10:24

Older fathers may be making it slightly more common:

www.newscientist.com/article/dn9998-older-dads-boost-risk-of-autistic-children/

2019 average age of father was 33.6 years old - a figure that has increased for 10 consecutive years.

Though I also suspect daisycottage - the world is more busy and stressful place.

I've been back and forth to GP with DD1 as loud noises cause her ear pain and all my children complain about noise levels at their secondary - I have dsylexia and dyspriaxia but schools will only say my children show traits - GP aren't interested leaving us with private diagnosis which is out our price range. I persume their tolerance levels are higher than children with ASD but they can find schools and other busy situations overwelming at times.

I've no idea how common ASD is - but I can well belive it's been under reported in the past.

budgun · 06/08/2021 10:16

There is a big difference between an adult with an autism dx who is able to marry, work, contemplate how their autism impacts them to someone who has little communication, can't live alone, no sense of danger etc. Recognising this difference helps with identity and with communicating needs and disability.

I don't think you can know how substantial any differences will be when the autistic child becomes and adult though.

My DS was all of the things you describe as a child, up until about age 12 where he started to develop into the 18 year old he is today. About to go to uni (albeit living at home). So putting him into the box as a child would have been damaging to him as an adult.

I'm in my 40s and still have moments where I can't talk. Sometimes I need to process what is happening and how to respond and it leaves me unable to talk. Usually when I am out and my day is thrown into chaos (think cancelled train/error at appointments etc)

Justrealised · 06/08/2021 10:09

@toconclude it doesn't tell you everything but it does tell you that the child was so affected that their autism was apparent from an early age where as in some people it can be questionable or not apparent for a long time. Yes education and therapies help but the base line is different. I'm pleased your son has made progress but some people won't. My son was diagnosed at 2 however this was a long time ago.

There is a big difference between an adult with an autism dx who is able to marry, work, contemplate how their autism impacts them to someone who has little communication, can't live alone, no sense of danger etc. Recognising this difference helps with identity and with communicating needs and disability.

ObviousNameChage · 06/08/2021 09:54

As for the "oh could it be autism" reflex response in adult threads , a lot of the time it comes from posters thinking they are being inclusive and considerate, that don't actually have any understanding or experience of autism. Hence always correlating bad behaviour with autism. It's misguided at best and harmful at worst.

ObviousNameChage · 06/08/2021 09:47

[quote toconclude]@RocketPanda

In what way is the diagnostic male-based? Have you links to studies? Not arguing, would genuinely be interested.[/quote]
The diagnosis assessment is based on how autism presents in males. It is widely acknowledged and recognised now that autism presents significantly differently in females, but still the same questions/assessment are used. That's if it even gets noticed and recommended for referrals, because once again , the typical red flags are male presentation based.

vickibee · 06/08/2021 09:29

My son was diagnosed aged nine after years of seeking help, we were told he was spirited by the health visitor and school saw that he coped academically so didn’t pursue anything. It is so hard to get a dx so anyone who has one will have had to endure many hoops
I also feel I may be asd too but am too long in the tooth to bother, I have researched it in depth and match many of the traits. I think amongst my age group there will be many undiagnosed people ou there. Is there any point getting one later in life ?

toconclude · 06/08/2021 09:15

@Justrealised

The problem with that option is that a diagnosis at an early age doesn't necessarily tell you everything. DS2 was much, much more disabled by his autism at 3 than he is now at 30. Autistic people still grow up and develop and take advantage of education.

Nowmum43 · 06/08/2021 09:14

[quote StupidNC]@Nowmum43 everyone is different but generic things that have helped me massively are:

changing my clothes to natural fabrics and loose shapes (bamboo, linen and cotton). This was perhaps the most £££ thing and made easier by not being a teenager / swayed by fashion any more. Bamboo socks are pretty reasonable though and don't have the hard seams that other socks have.

Noise cancelling headphones

Taking loads of quiet time, and by loads sometimes I just sit quietly in a corner for two days until I feel better. I prioritise my job above my home life, so in practice I spend a lot of time being quiet at home. As she gets older you may need to teach her coping skills for independent living - I struggled to feed myself properly and keep a house (I hated being in a houseshare). So having simple healthy meals in, or minimal prep recipes and I also have a cleaner (which is affordable because I prioritise my job over home life).

Advance notice of as much stuff as possible, including plan changes. I look up menus, Google street view, find out who will be at places, etc. The other day DH decided to stay at his sister's for takeaway at the last minute and although I was polite when he called to tell me, I had a full scale mardy meltdown. I don't care, objectively, if he stays for takeaway- we didn't have anything planned- but the last minute change really freaked me out. It took me six hours to calm down and it was really hard to convince him that I wasn't cross with him. It was also really hard to lie to him on the phone - like picking up a weight I could barely lift. I knew if I told him how I really felt he'd come straight home but that's not fair on him - my ASD shouldn't rule his life.

The way I see it is that you can't get rid of everything, so it's about smoothing the stuff you can control so that the other stuff has less of an impact (hopefully).[/quote]
Thank you so much.
At the moment we encourage quiet time if we have been out, she doesn't always want it but we get her do it it as we know it will later on in the evening her being unable to cope and she'll start hitting out at the smallest thing.
She loves to bake and I'll get her to cook more now she's starting high school. She's most looking forward to home economics which is good and will hopefully help her look after herself as she's get older.
She struggles in the car so we have got a holder so she can watch her iPad with her headphones on, not sure if that's a good idea or not.
She is also doing hypnosis to try and help her with some of her anxieties like needing the toilet when she's anxious and getting worked up in the car.
I just want her to be happy and she seems so anxious all the time that it's heartbreaking. I think the worry or starting high school isn't helping her either.

Willwebebuyingnumber11 · 06/08/2021 09:13

@OffCycling did they at least start referral to paediatrics?

StupidNC · 06/08/2021 09:10

@Justrealised I completely agree - to me they are two very different kettles of fish and our needs are so different.

toconclude · 06/08/2021 09:08

@RocketPanda

In what way is the diagnostic male-based? Have you links to studies? Not arguing, would genuinely be interested.

Allthenumbers · 06/08/2021 09:06

@Popsicle438 please educate yourself. I’m a teacher. My knowledge of autism was negligible before I became a parent of an autistic child. What you are saying is incorrect, insensitive and if you are still teaching you need to better understand autism.

Letsgetquizzy · 06/08/2021 09:05

@Popsicle438 this attitude is what makes it so hard for children to be diagnosed.

My DD (13 yo) was diagnosed last week by NHS paediatrics after a 4-year merry go round which caused enormous stress to her and our whole family. I first sought help in 2015 but due to always seeing locums (including one who said she couldn't be on the spectrum as she has no speech disorder), no one ever put all the information together.

The relief she has at finally receiving a diagnosis is immense. I pursued it as she is so like my mum it's untrue, and I think mum would have had a far happier life with similar insight.

I should point out that it has taken this long with 2 fully supportive schools, a supportive GP and our being able to fund private reports and support. Hate to think how we'd have managed otherwise.

StupidNC · 06/08/2021 09:03

@Nowmum43 everyone is different but generic things that have helped me massively are:

changing my clothes to natural fabrics and loose shapes (bamboo, linen and cotton). This was perhaps the most £££ thing and made easier by not being a teenager / swayed by fashion any more. Bamboo socks are pretty reasonable though and don't have the hard seams that other socks have.

Noise cancelling headphones

Taking loads of quiet time, and by loads sometimes I just sit quietly in a corner for two days until I feel better. I prioritise my job above my home life, so in practice I spend a lot of time being quiet at home. As she gets older you may need to teach her coping skills for independent living - I struggled to feed myself properly and keep a house (I hated being in a houseshare). So having simple healthy meals in, or minimal prep recipes and I also have a cleaner (which is affordable because I prioritise my job over home life).

Advance notice of as much stuff as possible, including plan changes. I look up menus, Google street view, find out who will be at places, etc. The other day DH decided to stay at his sister's for takeaway at the last minute and although I was polite when he called to tell me, I had a full scale mardy meltdown. I don't care, objectively, if he stays for takeaway- we didn't have anything planned- but the last minute change really freaked me out. It took me six hours to calm down and it was really hard to convince him that I wasn't cross with him. It was also really hard to lie to him on the phone - like picking up a weight I could barely lift. I knew if I told him how I really felt he'd come straight home but that's not fair on him - my ASD shouldn't rule his life.

The way I see it is that you can't get rid of everything, so it's about smoothing the stuff you can control so that the other stuff has less of an impact (hopefully).

BlueLobelia · 06/08/2021 08:58

edited by MNHQ at OP's request - repeats deleted post
It is incredibly well known and well documented that ASD children can abide by the rules when at school (which takes up all their mental energy) and then collapse at home. Because home is their safe space.

I find it shocking that someone who claims to be a teacher can be so ignorant of something that is fundamentally understood.

(Mind you, talking of ignorant teachers, when my DS was diagnosed and the ed psych was talking to us and his form teacher she commented brightly 'Oh, there is a boy in the news today who is atusti!!' (That boy in question was in the news because he had muredered a school friend. I froze. The ed psych froze and DH just looked confused. I find it almost funny now. )

DoingItMyself · 06/08/2021 08:58

It's not 'common'. It's exclusive. We have it. If you don't have it, you can't join.

@Popsicle438, that's called 'masking'. We do it all day so people like you can feel comfortable. Then, when we go home, we're mentally, emotionally and physically exhausted, so we might rant, scream, throw things, kick, become mute, bite our arms, hide in bed or take to a book or computer game to dull the pain. That's what adapting to a neurotypical world does to us.

budgun · 06/08/2021 08:58

[quote BlankTimes]assessment would be really hard to access

It really isn't.

Do the AQ test online, aspergerstest.net/aq-test/ take the results to your GP if you score within the parameters for the possibility of ASD, ask for a referral. Your GP will explain how long the NHS waiting lists in your area are, be prepared for a good 2 years. He will also be able to give you a referral for a private assessment, or look for a diagnostic service in your area via the NAS www.autism.org.uk/directory[/quote]

My GP wouldn't refer me as my health board doesn't have any provision for adult assessment.

Clocktopus · 06/08/2021 08:58

You'd think a supposed teacher would know better.

BlueLobelia · 06/08/2021 08:55

@Elephantsparade

As a parent of a child with ASD, I was told 1 in 52 but with missing girls i think its 1 in 30. As for why we are on mumsnet in high proportions. I find a lot of parents like me get quite cut off and isolated as our childs SEN takes up a lot of time and limits chances to go out so its fills a gap. I also spend a lot of time in my car waiting whilst appointments happen or my child attends their school on part time hours and its something to do.
I think this is why we are on MN in high proportions also. I first came to MN when my DC1 was diagnosed. I was goolging support services for families and came across some threads. Stayed for the rest of MN.

I agree also that parents with SEN kids are often quite isolated. I freely admit that probbaly 90% of my social interaction with other adults is on MN.