Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How common is ASD

131 replies

glowyjuice · 04/08/2021 21:29

Hi I'm posting this as just to see what other peoples opinions are, I've read that about 1% of people have a diagnosis of ASD, I'm wondering do you think taking into account those who are undiagnosed would this figure be much higher? I do sometimes wonder how many undiagnosed adults or even children there are out there.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Justrealised · 06/08/2021 17:28

@ObviousNameChange I mistook your intentions. Please don't leave the discussion.

These discussions make me very defensive as due to the nature of my sons disability and those like him they cannot advocate for themselves but there are many people who can advocate for those with autism that isn't as profound so it always feels a battle.

Justrealised · 06/08/2021 17:25

@SwimmyG

Carly Fleischmann is non-verbal but has a much better understanding of pragmatic language and social awareness than I do. In this interview with Channing Tatum she is flirting, joking, is able to take turns etc etc. I struggle with those things a lot.

Being non-verbal doesn’t always mean you’ll never do anything with your life and being verbal doesn’t always mean the world is all rainbows and sparkles and you can do anything. Yes, in some cases the person is significantly affected in all areas of the spectrum and will need level 3 support for everything. In other cases they may only need level 1 support in some areas but level 2 in others.

I have been assessed as needing level 1 support so would be labelled “high functioning“, which is fine but also irritating because then I’m labelled as not being ‘that bad’, just a ‘bit quirky‘, only have it ‘mildly’, which is not the case at all. I’m not going to detail my issues/struggles here as I don’t believe there’s much point and it would turn into a race to the bottom with some people.

I can’t understand what it’s like to be Carly or someone else who is significantly affected in all areas but I wish people wouldn’t presume they understand what it’s like to be me either and that I can’t possibly have it as bad just because I can talk. Advocating for someone doesn’t have to be at the expense of others, which is sometimes how it seems on here.

I don’t like the linear or gradient spectrum that people refer to because it pigeon holes everybody on the spectrum into one box that they’re not allowed to get out of. It’s not a gradient at all. It’s not less autistic to most autistic. It’s not mild to severe. Carly is no more disabled than I am and vice versa but people would presume very different things about us.

I am also another professionally diagnosed person that is irritated by the whole self-identification/self diagnosis nonsense. You cannot call yourself autistic unless you have a formal diagnosis. It’s akin to going around telling people you have cancer when you don’t. It’s a lie.

I watched the videos of Carly, I was amazed but I also watched the interviews around it. The majority of her AAC use was pre programmed so it is a wholey true representation of her abilities. She is amazing, but I am talking about functioning communication by any means not just verbal.

I completely support the use of AAC and think it should be used more widely but I cannot agree that someone who is able to articulate as well as you do is just as disabled as someone who can only very limited communicate whether that's by objects of ref, pecs, other symbol systems, makaton etc by nature of you being on here being able to type and Express your feelings you are already a more able communicator than someone with severe autism.

I'm completely with you on self I D. An autism dx isn't something you can opt into. I imagine for those who geta dx as an adult it's an extremely emotional and bearing experience.

I cannot agree that autism is autism, I'm not saying that those who don't have severe autism don't need support or a form of dx, I'd just like it to revert back to how the dx was originally given or for those with severe needs to be separated in some way.

ambereeree · 06/08/2021 15:37

Before my son was diagnosed I would have said 1%. Now I think its much higher and also many people undiagnosed.

LizzieAnt · 06/08/2021 15:03

Just replying to those that think the incidence of asd on mumsnet is quite high -
It should be remembered that the number of people (indirectly) affected by autism is quite a bit higher than the number of people who have autism. Many teachers here have mentioned that, in their experience, there is at least 1 child with asd per class. So in a small school of 90 pupils (about 45 families, say) there would be about 3-4 with autism. So maybe about 1 in 15 families who are dealing with asd on a daily basis? (I haven't checked actual figures, just illustrating a point here.) I'm not including grandparents, cousins, friends etc. Many of those who post don't have asd themselves but are affected by it nonetheless. The incidence of this group of people is always going to be higher.
And also yes, to those who say you are more likely to post if looking for help and support, or to reply if you have experience that may be helpful.

LotLessBovver · 06/08/2021 14:41

ObviousNameChage - I hope you're okay. Flowers

When mine were dx'ed as preschoolers 15+ years ago, we felt very much alone. I only knew of one other parent with a child with an ASD diagnosis. Online websites like MN were the main way of finding useful information and other parents in my situation.

As my DC got older and progressed through primary and secondary school, they each had classmates who they'd known since early primary who later went on to be diagnosed with ASD. So anyone looking at the rate of diagnosis in their class in the mid-2000s would have said it was 1 in 30. If they'd checked those same children 10 years later they would have seen that it was actually 3 or 4 in 30 - and that still doesn't take into account the ones who might not get a diagnosis until much later in life.

In the primary school where I work, most classes now have at least one child with an ASD diagnosis. I also see other children who have definite traits which become increasingly obvious as they get older.

In the general population I would say that there are a lot of undiagnosed people out there. As others have mentioned, a lot of parents realise during their own child's assessments that they themselves (and other older family members) almost certainly would meet the diagnostic criteria too.

BlankTimes · 06/08/2021 14:25

I've always thought this explanation of the spectrum described more peoples' experiences than most do.
neuroclastic.com/2019/05/04/its-a-spectrum-doesnt-mean-what-you-think/

As for classifying one person's autism as compared to another person's autism in terms of their abilities, I wouldn't know where to start. I don't even know if that's a good thing to do in terms of describing how it affects different people.

All I have is my own experience of my now adult DD and my observations of her challenges which can vary a lot day-to-day. Sometimes I could not definitively say a reaction of hers was definitely due to her autism, because it could also be attributable to one of the co-morbids. Much of the time her CFS limits her achievements far more than her autism.

How common is ASD
ObviousNameChage · 06/08/2021 13:41

[quote Justrealised]@ObviousNameChange, I'm going to take that last comment as an accidental faux pas rather than jab or even a threat. Biscuit[/quote]
Once again I apologise and I'll bow out of this thread since what I'm trying to say and how it actually reads is miles apart and upsetting.

x2boys · 06/08/2021 13:34

@SwimmyG

Carly Fleischmann is non-verbal but has a much better understanding of pragmatic language and social awareness than I do. In this interview with Channing Tatum she is flirting, joking, is able to take turns etc etc. I struggle with those things a lot.

Being non-verbal doesn’t always mean you’ll never do anything with your life and being verbal doesn’t always mean the world is all rainbows and sparkles and you can do anything. Yes, in some cases the person is significantly affected in all areas of the spectrum and will need level 3 support for everything. In other cases they may only need level 1 support in some areas but level 2 in others.

I have been assessed as needing level 1 support so would be labelled “high functioning“, which is fine but also irritating because then I’m labelled as not being ‘that bad’, just a ‘bit quirky‘, only have it ‘mildly’, which is not the case at all. I’m not going to detail my issues/struggles here as I don’t believe there’s much point and it would turn into a race to the bottom with some people.

I can’t understand what it’s like to be Carly or someone else who is significantly affected in all areas but I wish people wouldn’t presume they understand what it’s like to be me either and that I can’t possibly have it as bad just because I can talk. Advocating for someone doesn’t have to be at the expense of others, which is sometimes how it seems on here.

I don’t like the linear or gradient spectrum that people refer to because it pigeon holes everybody on the spectrum into one box that they’re not allowed to get out of. It’s not a gradient at all. It’s not less autistic to most autistic. It’s not mild to severe. Carly is no more disabled than I am and vice versa but people would presume very different things about us.

I am also another professionally diagnosed person that is irritated by the whole self-identification/self diagnosis nonsense. You cannot call yourself autistic unless you have a formal diagnosis. It’s akin to going around telling people you have cancer when you don’t. It’s a lie.

Yep i totally agree with you on the self diagnosis, comment if you have autism you have autism, but to say you have when you havent had a diagnosis and then try and shout down struggling parents (seen this on many facebook groups is so wrong)
budgun · 06/08/2021 13:29

I am also another professionally diagnosed person that is irritated by the whole self-identification/self diagnosis nonsense. You cannot call yourself autistic unless you have a formal diagnosis.

Urgh. These Facebook groups are full of it. Self IDing as autistic Angry

Literally fuck off.

SwimmyG · 06/08/2021 13:23

Carly Fleischmann is non-verbal but has a much better understanding of pragmatic language and social awareness than I do. In this interview with Channing Tatum she is flirting, joking, is able to take turns etc etc. I struggle with those things a lot.

Being non-verbal doesn’t always mean you’ll never do anything with your life and being verbal doesn’t always mean the world is all rainbows and sparkles and you can do anything. Yes, in some cases the person is significantly affected in all areas of the spectrum and will need level 3 support for everything. In other cases they may only need level 1 support in some areas but level 2 in others.

I have been assessed as needing level 1 support so would be labelled “high functioning“, which is fine but also irritating because then I’m labelled as not being ‘that bad’, just a ‘bit quirky‘, only have it ‘mildly’, which is not the case at all. I’m not going to detail my issues/struggles here as I don’t believe there’s much point and it would turn into a race to the bottom with some people.

I can’t understand what it’s like to be Carly or someone else who is significantly affected in all areas but I wish people wouldn’t presume they understand what it’s like to be me either and that I can’t possibly have it as bad just because I can talk. Advocating for someone doesn’t have to be at the expense of others, which is sometimes how it seems on here.

I don’t like the linear or gradient spectrum that people refer to because it pigeon holes everybody on the spectrum into one box that they’re not allowed to get out of. It’s not a gradient at all. It’s not less autistic to most autistic. It’s not mild to severe. Carly is no more disabled than I am and vice versa but people would presume very different things about us.

I am also another professionally diagnosed person that is irritated by the whole self-identification/self diagnosis nonsense. You cannot call yourself autistic unless you have a formal diagnosis. It’s akin to going around telling people you have cancer when you don’t. It’s a lie.

Justrealised · 06/08/2021 13:00

@ObviousNameChange, I'm going to take that last comment as an accidental faux pas rather than jab or even a threat. Biscuit

budgun · 06/08/2021 12:58

[quote Neverrains]@budgun can I ask what the signs were at his 2 year check? I have a child I suspect may be on the spectrum but the HV here is still refusing to see people face to face and his 2 year check was done over the phone. It’s difficult to describe the issues over the phone.[/quote]

I wasn't tuned in at all to it being potential autism and she never said outright. I had very little knowledge of autism, I had seen a documentary in the 90s and that was about it. I didn't suspect it and I didn't realise his behaviours were not quite 'standard' so I had no input at all. HV just observed him - it was home visits they did back then here and she asked the questions on her form. She was surprised at his ability to use a mechanical toy which was beyond his years. I only brought it out to try and keep him still because he never actually played with toys, but this was something new I had thought I could use to get through the visit. Turned out it added to the questions raised. I cant even remember how we got from HV to paeds, I guess she must have told me then she was going to recommend referral?

x2boys · 06/08/2021 12:58

@ObviousNameChage

I think the main issue is that people see the autistic spectrum as linear with "low functioning " at one end and "high functioning " at the other.

In reality it's a wheel and there are difficulties (and sometimes strengths) in every area to various degrees.

The way I try to explain to some children I work with (apologies if it's dumb or trivial, but it seems to work) is to think of autism as a pizza cut into slices. Each slice is different, some slices (or even the whole pizza) might have more ingredients (so much so that it crumbles and falls under the weight) some might have less. It's still a pizza. It's still autism.Some slices might have their favourite topping which is great(strengths) some might have no nice toppings or even things they actually dislike(difficulties). It's still a pizza. It's still autism. Most pizzas will look entirely different to each other . It's still pizza. It's still autism.some people might say it's not even a pizza because it doesn't have tomato sauce or cheese. But it's still a pizza. It's still autism.

I hope I don't offend or upset anyone with this.

You see thst would mean nothing to my son, he has no clue he is autistic, hes eleven non verbal etc he, s not a clue, he communicates on a very basic level using PECs and objects of reference
QueenofBrickdon · 06/08/2021 12:53

Well in my sons class of 30, I know of 3 that have an Autism diagnosis including my DS. Just finished Y5 in a state school.

I work at the same school and I would say there is 1-2 children with ASD in every class, although not all have a diagnosis.

x2boys · 06/08/2021 12:53

@budgun

If your son is at uni now would he not have got an autism dx initially? Was aspergers still diagnosed when he was assessed? If so the autism dx will still stand it's just the meaning of the dx has now changed to include hf /aspergers etc so your son is covered by the dx.

He starts this year, he is 18 now.

His diagnosis was ASD, they had just changed a few months beforehand and told me he previously would have received a diagnosis of 'classic autism' - initially he had been referred by a paediatric to CAMHS for 'query aspergers'

It's tricky. I would not want to minimise anyone's diagnosis, but as I have always said when asked how 'severe' my DCs autism is 'it depends what you are asking them to do'

Separately diagnosing I feel could be harmful for those like DS, who is very different to the child who was diagnosed. No matter what anyone says there would always be an extra hurdle to jump if the diagnosis were split. I find people talk to me as if I'm stupid sometimes if I disclose my autism on first meeting - imagine having a diagnosis as a child that didn't quite for as an adult, and having to convince people that you are capable. I do agree though it is arguable more harmful for those who are much more severely affected to lump everyone together.

I'm sure there is an answer somewhere.

i realise that some people with autism they can have spikey profiles and do badly in some areas and well in others, But for many people who are severley impacted by autism they are impacted in all area, s I think in America they have different levels of autism to differentiate how impacted people are
ObviousNameChage · 06/08/2021 12:51

@Justrealised

I'm also going to guess the children you're explaining it too aren't severe. Given that you are explaining it, using metaphors etc
I apologise, yes you're right.

And I completely understand that the main focus for you is your child and advocating for his needs , making sure they are recognised,acknowledged and hopefully catered to and supported, especially once you won't be able to anymore.

Thanks
Neverrains · 06/08/2021 12:50

@budgun can I ask what the signs were at his 2 year check? I have a child I suspect may be on the spectrum but the HV here is still refusing to see people face to face and his 2 year check was done over the phone. It’s difficult to describe the issues over the phone.

budgun · 06/08/2021 12:45

Children diagnosed early especially those with regression usually (not in your case) are profound. My son was picked up at his 1 year hv check, which was slightly delayed by a couple of months. He was just over two when he got his dx. There was no question. These are the people who need that separate dx. While it may not help your child, I can only advocate for mine and this would help him. Your son and mine are different. I can't help but want his dx to reflect this.

The HV clocked it at his 2 year check. He was referred to community paeds and eventually went through CAMHS -

budgun · 06/08/2021 12:42

If your son is at uni now would he not have got an autism dx initially? Was aspergers still diagnosed when he was assessed? If so the autism dx will still stand it's just the meaning of the dx has now changed to include hf /aspergers etc so your son is covered by the dx.

He starts this year, he is 18 now.

His diagnosis was ASD, they had just changed a few months beforehand and told me he previously would have received a diagnosis of 'classic autism' - initially he had been referred by a paediatric to CAMHS for 'query aspergers'

It's tricky. I would not want to minimise anyone's diagnosis, but as I have always said when asked how 'severe' my DCs autism is 'it depends what you are asking them to do'

Separately diagnosing I feel could be harmful for those like DS, who is very different to the child who was diagnosed. No matter what anyone says there would always be an extra hurdle to jump if the diagnosis were split. I find people talk to me as if I'm stupid sometimes if I disclose my autism on first meeting - imagine having a diagnosis as a child that didn't quite for as an adult, and having to convince people that you are capable. I do agree though it is arguable more harmful for those who are much more severely affected to lump everyone together.

I'm sure there is an answer somewhere.

Justrealised · 06/08/2021 12:41

I'm also going to guess the children you're explaining it too aren't severe. Given that you are explaining it, using metaphors etc

RampantIvy · 06/08/2021 12:38

Thank you for the link @BlankTimes. I did the test and scored 14. I will ask DH to do the test. I suspect that his score will be muvh higher.

Justrealised · 06/08/2021 12:36

@obviousNameChange

The point with severe autism is that some people (not just children) have severe needs in every aspect. Hence severe. Their strengths aren't things that you would expect and are relative to their other also serve needs.

I dont see autism as linear but I do acknowledge that autism isn't autism some people are more affected.

Justrealised · 06/08/2021 12:30

@budgun

Autism is a disability and is very profound in some cases. Having your son and my described by the same dx isnt helpful to either but probably more so to my son as he isn't able to advocate for himself or campaign for the change whereas high functioning (for want of a better term) are.

But my son would have been diagnosed the same as yours. We had no idea that university was a possibility for DS when he was younger. We thought we were looking at a very bleak future for him if I'm perfectly honest. I still think it's unlikely that he will ever live alone, he still needs an awful lot of support, but he is a different person to the boy who was diagnosed.

As an aside lack of communication ability all the time is also very different to periodically being unable to speak. The two aren't comparable. (In response to your previous post).

I wasn't trying to compare these 2 things. I was (badly) trying to demonstrate that despite being a functioning adult, sometimes I can't function. Sometimes I am affected differently.

Sorry I can get very defensive, as you'll be aware it's a never ending battle.

I agree completely about different functioning and people who can function sometimes not at others. I think this needs recognising also and where needed (not saying in your case, you haven't implied, just for some others) support given.

I think it's amazing that your son is at university, I'm sure you've all put alot into getting there and had a fair few battles along the way.

I would imagine tho that your case is the exception rather than the norm and if your son doesn't fall into the severe "box" you'd be able to change it as it seems quite obvious he isn't (even with all the support). If your son is at uni now would he not have got an autism dx initially? Was aspergers still diagnosed when he was assessed? If so the autism dx will still stand it's just the meaning of the dx has now changed to include hf /aspergers etc so your son is covered by the dx.

Children diagnosed early especially those with regression usually (not in your case) are profound. My son was picked up at his 1 year hv check, which was slightly delayed by a couple of months. He was just over two when he got his dx. There was no question. These are the people who need that separate dx. While it may not help your child, I can only advocate for mine and this would help him. Your son and mine are different. I can't help but want his dx to reflect this.

ObviousNameChage · 06/08/2021 12:22

I think the main issue is that people see the autistic spectrum as linear with "low functioning " at one end and "high functioning " at the other.

In reality it's a wheel and there are difficulties (and sometimes strengths) in every area to various degrees.

The way I try to explain to some children I work with (apologies if it's dumb or trivial, but it seems to work) is to think of autism as a pizza cut into slices. Each slice is different, some slices (or even the whole pizza) might have more ingredients (so much so that it crumbles and falls under the weight) some might have less. It's still a pizza. It's still autism.Some slices might have their favourite topping which is great(strengths) some might have no nice toppings or even things they actually dislike(difficulties). It's still a pizza. It's still autism. Most pizzas will look entirely different to each other . It's still pizza. It's still autism.some people might say it's not even a pizza because it doesn't have tomato sauce or cheese. But it's still a pizza. It's still autism.

I hope I don't offend or upset anyone with this.

budgun · 06/08/2021 11:46

Autism is a disability and is very profound in some cases. Having your son and my described by the same dx isnt helpful to either but probably more so to my son as he isn't able to advocate for himself or campaign for the change whereas high functioning (for want of a better term) are.

But my son would have been diagnosed the same as yours. We had no idea that university was a possibility for DS when he was younger. We thought we were looking at a very bleak future for him if I'm perfectly honest. I still think it's unlikely that he will ever live alone, he still needs an awful lot of support, but he is a different person to the boy who was diagnosed.

As an aside lack of communication ability all the time is also very different to periodically being unable to speak. The two aren't comparable. (In response to your previous post).

I wasn't trying to compare these 2 things. I was (badly) trying to demonstrate that despite being a functioning adult, sometimes I can't function. Sometimes I am affected differently.