Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this a bit annoying at EVERY meal?

339 replies

mockingbirdi · 04/08/2021 18:08

A good friend of mine has invited a new friend into our friendship group. There was originally about 4/5 of us going for lunch or dinner whenever so now there's 5/6. Absolutely fine

Except this friend of hers is nice enough but insists on eating chicken nuggets and chips! At every place we go

She was invited out with us to an Italian on Saturday. She has posted in the grouch at that she won't come as 'There isn't anything on the menu for me 😔'

So now, my friend that was originally her friend before she came into the group is saying we should change where we eat! So no Italian because they don't actually sell chicken nuggets and chips. And no Chinese that we like, or Japanese, as again nothing she wants there

AIBU to think this is ridiculous now?

OP posts:
Waspsarearseholes · 05/08/2021 08:55

Do you think she, in some way, sees this as a 'cute' quirk of hers that she expects people to think is sweet/endearing? I mean, she's totally wrong, but what you've said about her reminds me of a friend of a friend, which I know is a rather tenuous link, but she often did similar. Everybody found it so overwhelmingly annoying. I think everybody (or those who aren't dicks) are sympathetic and accommodating of people with allergies/intolerances/ARFID and will usually try to find an acceptable compromise but this doesn't sound like the case here. She sounds extremely inflexible and completely unaware that she is expecting an established dinner group to spend their money eating in shit places, rather than discreetly trying to find something she can eat from the menu of the chosen restaurant or making an effort to call ahead to check they can accommodate her. It sounds as though she's quite open about just preferring nuggets and chips and she needs to be aware that her preferences don't trump everybody else's.

threestars · 05/08/2021 08:54

She can still join you, but just order herself a dessert or drinks instead. Nothing to stop her eating/filling up at home first.

Toomanyradishes · 05/08/2021 08:48

@coaltit there are archeological remains of hens from the iron age in britain and evidence they were eaten from roman times onwards, although admittedly in medieval times poor people tended to keep them for eggs rather than eating but chicken was definitely available, although to be fair I was just teasing the person who questioned what medieval people would have eaten

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 05/08/2021 08:41

If you have disordered eating for any reason, you don't join a group centred around food. Just like I wouldn't join a walking group and then demand we change to a sitting group because of my disability.

JesusIsAnyNameFree · 05/08/2021 08:36

@TheDevils

She can't be that fussy as she likes a roast dinner, but says she just loves chicken nuggets above most stuff

I suffer from ARFID and will happily eat a roast dinner. It's not up to you to decide what constitutes a selective eater.

No, but it is up to her whether or not she puts up with it and she really shouldn't.

I would not be spending my girls nights out in the sort of places serving nuggets and milkshakes. Once, fine, I'll suffer through it but I'm not putting up with bad food just because one person, who's completely new to the group no less, can't eat more than a couple of dishes.

CoalTit · 05/08/2021 08:26

@Toomanyradishes

Pretty sure medieval people ate chicken....

Chickens, also known as jungle fowl, are native to South East Asia, so most mediaeval Britons probably didn't get to eat them.

TheDevils · 05/08/2021 08:25

@Justilou1

Surely the point of going out “with the girls” is choosing somewhere you don’t have to cater for toddlers.
I really wish people would stop referring to selective eating as toddler behaviour. People who do this are the reason I suffer from panic attacks and sleepless nights before having to eat with people I don't know very well.

I know my eating habits aren't normal but, on the whole, I'm fine with it. It's people judging me and referring to me as a toddler that causes the issues.

I suspect this woman doesn't have an eating disorder because generally those who do go to great lengths to hide it and don't draw attention to it by dictating to a group.

However, people's attitudes towards this particular type of eating disorder sucks.

MarleneDietrichsSmile · 05/08/2021 08:14

We have all diagnosed this womb with ASD and arfid now, and possibly an eating disorder

To me that still does not mean she gets to dictate the places to eat, esp as she only joined the group recently

She is changing the whole dynamic and is making people feel bad…. Takes the fun out of it. And to me that is selfish of her. She puts her wishes before the group’s wishes

BarbaraofSeville · 05/08/2021 08:06

@DeRigueurMortis

Sorry posted in error...

It's not clear at all that this is an eating disorder.

Yes it might be.

Irrespective of that, it's hers to own and manage.

I've deliberately not allowed my DS's food sensory issues deprive everyone else in the family from eating a variety of foods in restaurants.

Enabling him doesn't help.

Of course he's not deliberately being a PITA. But that doesn't mean he gets to dictate what everyone else can eat/enjoy.

He needs to develop coping mechanisms- which he has done - to socialise with people in restaurants that don't necessarily serve his safe foods.

Be that checking menus, calling restaurants to check if they will accommodate certain requests, eating before hand and just having a side dish/pudding or even a drink etc.

The point of the exercise is spending time with friends. You value that or not and if you do, then you don't get to curtail their enjoyment of food to address your lack thereof.

Exactly this. Pre-covid I was in a group who went out for meals, which reminds me, we need to start doing that again, it's sort of fallen by the wayside sadly, but yes, one of the group was a very 'plain food, chicken and chips only please' but in just about every restaurant she was able to find something to eat, or the restaurant could accommodate this without fuss, so you barely noticed that she rarely had anything other than some variation on plain chicken and chips.

The problem comes when you have someone with food requirements so rigid that they won't eat chips if they're the wrong thickness, or breaded/battered chicken because it's been made fresh and is home made rather than the processed/shaped factory type.

I'm sympathetic to that if it's due to ARFID etc, but still, its unfair to a group to restrict food choices to accommodate that, except occasionally, eg if there's five people eating out in the group, everyone gets to take a turn choosing a restaurant, but they can't expect to dictate the choice every single time.

Sally872 · 05/08/2021 08:04

The fussy woman is being very entitled by expecting a group of friends to always choose a meal to suit her. She could have dinner before and only have dessert and drinks. Or meet after. Every few meet ups it would be nice to actively choose somewhere she can eat, but not every time.
Once she becomes a good friend to all then maybe more allowances would be made IF it comes to light there is some sort of food issue. By more allowance I mean coffees, drinks meet ups as well as dinners in nice places that don't serve chicken nuggets.

I would say to your friend who introduced her "I am happy for your friend to join us whenever she wants. I am happy to go to harvester etc sometimes to accommodate her. But I do want to go to other places too. I think it is unfair for any one person to rule so much out."

HollowTalk · 05/08/2021 07:50

But the thing is that she has joined a group of women who enjoy going out for different types of meals and now she is saying she wants them to only go for one kind of meal. That isn't the point of the group so if she doesn't like it then why does she think that she should change the whole group's dynamic?

RookieRoo · 05/08/2021 07:47

This would annoy me, trying to guilt you to changing?! What's the bet she ends up going anyway and "just has a garlic bread" or something. Not like spaghetti bolognaise is particularly adventurous.

Stick to your guns, you can go somewhere else next time, this time was agreed Italian.

Hydrate · 05/08/2021 07:19

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

I'd just say "sorry your friend doesnt like the restaurants we sometimes go to - why doesnt she join us afterwards for drinks at X? Understand if you would rather wait and meet when she comes too, but if not, table at Italians is booked at 7"
^ this.
RedHelenB · 05/08/2021 06:56

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

I'd just say "sorry your friend doesnt like the restaurants we sometimes go to - why doesnt she join us afterwards for drinks at X? Understand if you would rather wait and meet when she comes too, but if not, table at Italians is booked at 7"
I'd do this
Justilou1 · 05/08/2021 06:54

Surely the point of going out “with the girls” is choosing somewhere you don’t have to cater for toddlers.

PerciphonePuma · 05/08/2021 02:31

@ShitPoetryClub

We have a little group of 4 who meet up to dine out at least monthly. A while back I suggested inviting someone else along and the other 3 were aghast and said, what we have now works and they didn't want to spoil the dynamic. Fair enough. Now I understand why.
Are you some sort of kids club?!?! 🤣 Come on, you're grown women! What you describe is infantile at best
DeRigueurMortis · 05/08/2021 02:11

Sorry posted in error...

It's not clear at all that this is an eating disorder.

Yes it might be.

Irrespective of that, it's hers to own and manage.

I've deliberately not allowed my DS's food sensory issues deprive everyone else in the family from eating a variety of foods in restaurants.

Enabling him doesn't help.

Of course he's not deliberately being a PITA. But that doesn't mean he gets to dictate what everyone else can eat/enjoy.

He needs to develop coping mechanisms- which he has done - to socialise with people in restaurants that don't necessarily serve his safe foods.

Be that checking menus, calling restaurants to check if they will accommodate certain requests, eating before hand and just having a side dish/pudding or even a drink etc.

The point of the exercise is spending time with friends. You value that or not and if you do, then you don't get to curtail their enjoyment of food to address your lack thereof.

DeRigueurMortis · 05/08/2021 02:01

*This seems quite clearly a long way from picky eating though. As someone with sensory issues with food (improving a lot, but much worse when I was younger) I was mortified to be the one poring over the menu to check safe food was on there before I agreed to go anywhere. Having friends who understood is the only thing that stopped me from feeling like a freak of nature (and got me socialising).

Picky eaters might always order the plainest dish or ask for everything removed etc - they don't generally restrict to one meal only. I very much doubt this woman only eats chicken nuggets and chips in every restaurant out of pure pickiness - that's quite an extreme and specific food rule she seems to have which suggests a food related MH condition and as such she's probably very embarrassed (and thankful for friends who are generally accommodating).

OP you don't always have to go where your friend is accommodated but if - as I suspect - there's a bigger issue behind her food restrictions, expect her to be hurt and embarrassed and ashamed.*

I disagree that "is clearly"

Germolenequeen · 05/08/2021 01:02

@therocinante

Agree 100% 🌼

MyrrAgain · 05/08/2021 00:17

But surely almost everywhere does chips on the menu? Even some Italians! Isn't there something on the menu she can have?

Ask what she can have then... She's set it up so it's possible to ask - then ask her to find an Italian with an option along the lines of her list of foods.

therocinante · 05/08/2021 00:09

@FrownedUpon

YANBU. I hate adult picky eaters & it’s really unfair when it affects where everyone else can eat. Don’t change where you’re eating.
This seems quite clearly a long way from picky eating though. As someone with sensory issues with food (improving a lot, but much worse when I was younger) I was mortified to be the one poring over the menu to check safe food was on there before I agreed to go anywhere. Having friends who understood is the only thing that stopped me from feeling like a freak of nature (and got me socialising).

Picky eaters might always order the plainest dish or ask for everything removed etc - they don't generally restrict to one meal only. I very much doubt this woman only eats chicken nuggets and chips in every restaurant out of pure pickiness - that's quite an extreme and specific food rule she seems to have which suggests a food related MH condition and as such she's probably very embarrassed (and thankful for friends who are generally accommodating).

OP you don't always have to go where your friend is accommodated but if - as I suspect - there's a bigger issue behind her food restrictions, expect her to be hurt and embarrassed and ashamed.

ivfbabymomma1 · 04/08/2021 23:46

@CovidDoesNotExistDuh proper fine dining there 😂😂

BorderlineHappy · 04/08/2021 23:45

Just go to the Italian restaurant by yourself @mockingbirdi .
Enjoy the peace and quiet.

Also had someone join our group and tried to change times etc.
She was just told to meet us there later.
Wend down like a lead balloon.
But she never asked again.

PhoenixReincarnated · 04/08/2021 23:44

You can't all be expected to eat at Harvesters (or equivalent) indefinitely. Don't know what sort of 2 years this woman has had but, due to covid, none of us have had a brilliant time. This is going to sound harsh but I don't think she should be able to use the last 2 years to get her own way all the time.

Futureself · 04/08/2021 23:24

nuggetry GrinGrin