Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to Feel judged about size of son!

261 replies

Angliski · 04/08/2021 15:26

Ftm here. Conceived after five years of struggle, my gorgeous dS is 18 months old. Thing is he is very tall and strong. Off the charts of red book. He looks about 3- weighs 17kg nearly 90cm tall. He’s not fat, he has a six pack almost and likes lifting bricks. He has all his teeth and is just a big and advanced boy for his age.

Thing is, he was conceived by egg and sperm donation so he isn’t genetically linked to either of us. People always comment on how astonishingly big he is for a 1.5yr old, then they ask if DH is/was big. Don’t know how to reply to this. Will never know what his donors looked like as kids.

I feel so ashamed because I couldn’t use our own genetic material and I don’t know how to answer.

We are in Italy atm and today someone walked past and said he was ‘brutto’ which means ugly.he is actually a very handsome child who looks like a surfer but he is a weirdly big toddler. I was so upset. Also I am fat and very ashamed of it and think people think he is fat like me and/or doesn’t look like me ( he isn’t my colouring).

Aibu to get upset? Any advice?

OP posts:
Imcatmum · 05/08/2021 16:16

People comment, the issue here is that you have an unusual scenario that people would never guess or even think to be sensitive to.

Fuck the genetic material aspect. He's your son and no more or less of an individual than anyone's genetic child. My 4 kids are incredibly different from each other.

I'd just answer no, his daddy isn't remarkably tall but he (ds) is just himself! Who knows where any of them get their particular genes from!

BookFiend4Life · 05/08/2021 16:13

Ooh Joyce Carol Oates can be quite scary! It has to be very sunny outside for me to read her stuff usually. My husband loves her but even he has to set her down sometimes!

Yes she wrote "Expecting better" which was also really good! I like her practicality. My beb is at the other end of the spectrum in terms of size and I get SO tired of people telling me how little she is, so I really appreciate the straight talk about how development and growth have a wide distribution and "normal" is a much bigger tent than we think!

Winemewhynot · 05/08/2021 16:08

Hmm I smell bullshit with this post. That child is neither fat nor looks like a three year old. Most likely OP has made up being insulted to create a stealth braggy post about her surfer looking six pack having brick lifting free spirited child Grin

Was partially believable until the photos and her rude responses to posters sensible advice regarding putting the brick throwing kid some shoes on 🙄

Angliski · 05/08/2021 15:53

@BookFiend4Life emily oater wrote that science book on pregnancy right? She was really good. I will definitely take a look.

Ooooo I like Natalie Portman and have actually never heard of that film so will add to Netflix list thank you!

Yes I do have backpack reins. He goes mad when I put them on but as long as he doesn’t ‘feel the tug’ it’s ok. Like a PP said about her son, he is quite sensible, he knows when I say no and explain that there is a reason for it, but still, life is exciting at that age isn’t it and I get very anxious about roads. That’s my high squawk zone as I’m sure it is for many, many parents. He likes the trike and we also cycle him on DH’s bike with helmet to safe places but eventually Everyone has to walk down roads don’t they? He also hate holding hands unless he needs your help to get somehweee tricky.

I’m reading hazards of time travel by Joyce carol oates and happiest toddler on the block - which I really recommend.

OP posts:
BookFiend4Life · 05/08/2021 15:35

Omg the self-righteous concern trolling of some people on the internet, I honestly don't know what they get out of it!

@Angliski I actually just finished cribsheet by Emily Oster, she's very level headed about milestones and baby stats! I really like her work! For fiction I just finished reading the southern reach trilogy, that movie Annihilation with Natalie Portman that came out a few years ago is a pretty faithful adaptation of the first book... though scarier!

If you're worried about him when on walks near roadways I wouldn't be shy about using a child "leash" I know they're super controversial, but I was a nanny of a "spirited" child for several years and I absolutely would not have been able to keep him out of the street without one. Some kids just wiggle out of your grasp! I'd rather take a judgemental look than an accident with a car or bike any day.

XelaM · 05/08/2021 15:32

My mum is also very petite but my brother and I take after my dad Grin

XelaM · 05/08/2021 15:26

My dad's mum was tiny(!!!!) and both her biological sons are way over 6 foot and my dad is a basketball player

Angliski · 05/08/2021 15:24

@Moonbabysmum

He. Has. Plenty. Of. Shoes. that He Does.Wear.

Sometimes a child does something before you have the right kit on it. I take it your children have never had a wild wee because you are ALWAYS on top of nappies. Well done you.

I won’t be following up again. Hopefully like the majority of people you will understand that I don’t normally let him pick up rocks of that size at all and without shoes. That’s why there is a photo because it was a remarkable and weird event.

OP posts:
Angliski · 05/08/2021 15:18

@VeryLongBeeeep oh yes exactly right. Of course he is sitting on the drill as we speak and has a chisel in his ear. Don’t be daft.

I was going to try to explain what I mean but I see this is a hiding to nothing!

You do you and I’ll do me.

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 05/08/2021 14:37

Aw OP, the chunky toddlers are THE BEST, I used to love my DC's chubby little thighs and cheeks

I'm pretty sure everyone thinks their own toddlers are the best be that chunky or slim, tall or small, blonde or brunette. It's only the best to you though, not fact 😆

Foldinthecheese · 05/08/2021 14:13

I have three children, and they all run big. When my twins were little I found it hugely stressful because we got so many comments, and manhandling two very solid toddlers was bloody hard work. They are now 5.5 and very tall and lean. Their ribs are visible and they are definitely a healthy weight, but certainly bigger than their peers. The thing is, when they are alongside their friends, you can just tell that they are built bigger. They all have skinny legs and knobbly knees, but mine just seem to have bigger bones. It’s taken a lot of the stress away with my 2yo. She is similarly tall and solidly built, but I know she’s likely to slim down as she gets older, just as her brothers have. They are all extremely active and healthy, so I know they’re fine.

For what it’s worth, I tend to pre-empt comments now. So, when people ask how old they are, I tell them and then cheerfully say, “We produce big kids!” That seems to move the conversation on pretty quickly.

VeryLongBeeeep · 05/08/2021 13:52

his dad is a sculptor so he is around unusual materials not just highly sanitised plastic tat

So if his dad was a tattooist or worked for Rentokil it would be equally fine for him to play with needles or rat poison?

Adult work materials are not always appropriate for small children to play with, especially in bare feet.

FenceSplinters · 05/08/2021 13:46

‘Highly sanistised plastic tat’

Like baby toys?

Moonbabysmum · 05/08/2021 13:42

By working alongside family, you mean child labour...

Peachy.

And no, not everything is better. But there are less fatal accidents and more kids make it through childhood. You can't use 1920s health and safety principles to argue that a young toddler carrying a brick with bare feet is sensible 😂

What do you have against shoes. This is really really weird.

gunnersgold · 05/08/2021 13:39

He doesn't look that tall or big tbh ..

Angliski · 05/08/2021 13:39

@Moonbabysmum some others things From the ‘dark past’

  • breastfed by default and breast milk shared when problems arose
  • kids working alongside family rather than being dropped off at nursery for 40 hours a week with the mostly costly fees in the world for childcare crippling families
  • village collective social responsibility for kids.

Not everything that was is worse than it is now.

OP posts:
Moonbabysmum · 05/08/2021 13:38

You do what you want love.

And if (when) your toddler who 'frequently' plays with bricks drops one on his bare toes, it won't be me explaining that to the hospital. I can't imagine then you'll go in about sanitised plastic etc.

Lots of people have mentioned him wearing shoes, I assume by you either ignoring them or writing sarky replies that you disagree?

NewlyGranny · 05/08/2021 13:38

I voted YABU because you are letting strangers' rude comments upset you.

Randoms or even friends have no right to pry into your medical history! Your best bet is to say something like, "Oh, there's big bones on both sides of the family. We're amazed at how big and strong he is for his age, but clearly we're doing everything right!"

No lies told, no claims made, no confidential stuff disclosed.

Well done, btw, he sounds wonderful and you are clearly a top mum.

Angliski · 05/08/2021 13:32

Righteous much @Moonbabysmum. Thanks for the lecture.

OP posts:
speakout · 05/08/2021 12:43

, the chunky toddlers are THE BEST,

Slim toddlers are equally adorable.

FrangipaniDeLaSqueegeeMop · 05/08/2021 12:35

Aw OP, the chunky toddlers are THE BEST, I used to love my DC's chubby little thighs and cheeks.

If people ask if your DH was big just say "Yes he was/not really" depending on the truth - you don't have to go into detail about your conception journey with anybody except eventually your child

EmmalineC · 05/08/2021 12:32

He looks like a gorgeous, healthy, happy little boy and I don't think you have anything to worry about. I'm Italian and brutto can also mean healthy, strong, definitely not ugly when referring to a child!

Moonbabysmum · 05/08/2021 12:14

His dad is a sculptor so he is around unusual materials not just highly sanitised plastic tat. I think people forget that it was only 100 years ago that kids would be out learning outside all day.

I think you forget that 100 years ago child mortality was huge (around 15% would die before the age of 5) it was common to beat children, and experts reccomended that children should not be hugged or kissed.

I'm not for wrapping them in cotton wool, but health and safety wise it's a good thing that we've moved on since the 1920s.

Put some shoes on him around building materials for goodness sake.

vivainsomnia · 05/08/2021 11:41

OP, My DS was this size at the same age. His dad is very tall but we were divorced by then and so rarely together. I am very petite, so people commented a lot, and all the way through. He doesn't even look like me at all, different colour of eyes and hair! He is now in his 20s, 6'4'' and I still look at him and can't imagine he came out of me.

All this to say that whether genetically yours or not, it doesn't make a difference. Your DS is who he is and that's that. If people are stupid enough to make rude and inappropriate comments, the issue is with them. Just to add that my DS has always been a big gentle. Such a king heart and caring for others. His PE teacher actually had to say to him in secondary school that he should use his size in his favour because he always felt self-conscious about hurting others.

liveforsummer · 05/08/2021 11:12

This made me laugh uncontrollably

Seems pretty sensible advice to me!