Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH not paying rent or contributing financially

133 replies

Alwaysthebeach · 04/08/2021 10:46

So DH moved out. We have two children who are mainly with me, but also staying with him.

He has moved out due to issues I wont go into. But his hope and mine is that he moves back soon.

In the meantime, he is basically giving his rent on his property priority over paying for the family home. He gives me something sone months and nothing some months. Last month was £700,this month nothing.

The lease is in his name.

I cant afford to pay it all. I also cant have the stress of never knowing where i stand. Then he turns it on me blaming me for the cost of it.

He acts surprised every month of all his expenses.

His money mangement is horrendous.

he is giving me nothing for child maintenence.

What can I do legally etc? See a fin advisor? solicitor.

He just thinks it is ok. Please help i feel helpless.

I dont know what to do.

OP posts:
Goldbar · 05/08/2021 10:43

The only thing her husband should be paying her is child support. Plenty of us manage to organise childcare and work as single parents.

Child maintenance rarely covers 50% of the costs of bringing up children. If the OP is going to be left destitute, she should drop the kids off with her ex and then she'll have plenty of time to work and study. He has a legal obligation to care for them too.

KurtWilde · 05/08/2021 10:41

@Goldbar

The one who has the children for the least amount of time should live with their parents/in a bedsit.
And pay for his ex to live in the family home?? Don't be ridiculous. When you separate, you pay your own living expenses. The only thing her husband should be paying her is child support. Plenty of us manage to organise childcare and work as single parents.
Goldbar · 05/08/2021 10:36

The one who has the children for the least amount of time should live with their parents/in a bedsit.

UDontDans2Tekno · 05/08/2021 10:25

@Goldbar

Genuine question - if he can’t afford two households, what is he meant to do? If he gives OP enough money for rent and children, sounds like he’d be homeless.

It's amazing that some men think it's ok to prioritize themselves over their dependent children. A single adult can get a bedsit, house-share or move back to their parents' house until they get themselves sorted. Children need stability. If there's not enough to go around, the children should come first.

Sorry, just to be clear you think the ex should live with his parents (rent free?) Or live in a bedsit or houseshare and continue to pay OPs living expenses, rent etc??

And why should he do this? He is not in a relationship with OP. Of course he should provide for his dc, but not for OP

Goldbar · 05/08/2021 09:21

Well she can't just get small room and contribute cms amount. Going by this thread she should pay exh rent and stuff too though... Or is that just for men?

Well, it seems it's fine for men to walk out and just pay the CMS amount. So it should be fine for women as well. And we can all pretend that CM mythically covers 50% of the costs of raising children even if it's £20 per week.

In reality, they need to have a conversation about it. If the OP's course will lead to well-paid employment, it's not in the children's interests for her to abandon it after she's already done 2/3 of it. Even if they're no longer together, they should both want what's best for the children and work together to achieve that since it's for such a short period of time. It's not going to be the best thing for the children to have a primary parent who is trapped in low-paid work.

Yes, the OP needs to get paid employment to meet her share of her children's expenses but she can't do both that, her course work and childcare. Something has to give. Hence the suggestion that she leaves her children with her ex as primary carer for most of the time and focuses on work and study. It's perfectly possible to work full-time and study in the evenings, but not if you're caring for children as well.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 05/08/2021 09:11

Yes, she could. But she should drop the kids off at their dad's first. With him responsible for childcare and paying for the kids' expenses, she could then get an evening job to fund her expenses, finish her degree and pay a tiny amount in child maintenance per month to their dad.

The person who should be living in a single room is not the one who has the kids for most of the time.

Well she can't just get small room and contribute cms amount. Going by this thread she should pay exh rent and stuff too though... Or is that just for men?

Freddiefox · 05/08/2021 08:58

@Goldbar

The op could do the same though. She could move back in with her parents and finish her degree or get a single room.

Yes, she could. But she should drop the kids off at their dad's first. With him responsible for childcare and paying for the kids' expenses, she could then get an evening job to fund her expenses, finish her degree and pay a tiny amount in child maintenance per month to their dad.

The person who should be living in a single room is not the one who has the kids for most of the time.

Yes she could and maybe that would work for both of them. Then he can claim cm’s from the op as well.

Neither should be living in a single room as parents they should both be responsible enough to provide for their children. But the op
Is completely unreasonable to expect her ex to pay the rent on her home and forgo his rent so she can continue her studies.

Both of them need to be financially independent of each other and the one who has the children less provide cms payments.

Goldbar · 05/08/2021 08:51

The op could do the same though. She could move back in with her parents and finish her degree or get a single room.

Yes, she could. But she should drop the kids off at their dad's first. With him responsible for childcare and paying for the kids' expenses, she could then get an evening job to fund her expenses, finish her degree and pay a tiny amount in child maintenance per month to their dad.

The person who should be living in a single room is not the one who has the kids for most of the time.

Freddiefox · 05/08/2021 08:44

@Goldbar

Genuine question - if he can’t afford two households, what is he meant to do? If he gives OP enough money for rent and children, sounds like he’d be homeless.

It's amazing that some men think it's ok to prioritize themselves over their dependent children. A single adult can get a bedsit, house-share or move back to their parents' house until they get themselves sorted. Children need stability. If there's not enough to go around, the children should come first.

The op could do the same though. She could move back in with her parents and finish her degree or get a single room.

You could argue that the op needs to put her children first and get a job. The children should come first.

The father will need to have a home that his children can visit. Somewhere they feel
Comfortable.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 05/08/2021 07:51

@Goldbar

You either join him in abdicating all responsibility or do what many single parents do, sacrifice whatever it takes to pay the bills.

Well, she can't really. Unless she drops the kids off on his doorstep and refuses to have them back. The reality is that only one parent can decide effectively to abandon their child.

Yeah! That was my point.
choli · 05/08/2021 02:47

@Seesawmummadaw

I couldn’t support two households either! How much does he earn?
And how much does the OP earn/contribute?
Seesawmummadaw · 05/08/2021 01:55

I couldn’t support two households either!
How much does he earn?

Hont1986 · 05/08/2021 00:52

I'd rather be homeless than see my children evicted, wouldn't you?

I bloody wouldn't!

MichelleScarn · 04/08/2021 21:42

I agree @SchrodingersImmigrant. The unrealistic thoughts of some posters here that have this attitude are bonkers. Such as he should have his entire pay directed to the op, he should go homeless and give everything to op rather than op have a break in studying.... Confused so how can he work if he is homeless?!

DroopyClematis · 04/08/2021 21:21

Please talk to the students union. They will be able to direct you to support for you and your children.
You cannot , now, just rely on your 'ex.'

SchrodingersImmigrant · 04/08/2021 21:15

@Goldbar

You either join him in abdicating all responsibility or do what many single parents do, sacrifice whatever it takes to pay the bills.

Well, she can't really. Unless she drops the kids off on his doorstep and refuses to have them back. The reality is that only one parent can decide effectively to abandon their child.

They are still with him though as well so I wouldn't call that abandonment.

He is doomed if he does and doomed if he doesn't.
If he gets a sharedroom somewhere, he will be a bastard because he can never had kids and abandoned them and doesn't spend enough time with them so mum can also have a break.
If he gets big enough space so they can also be with him, he is a bastard because he can't afford to finance two households.

Goldbar · 04/08/2021 21:03

You either join him in abdicating all responsibility or do what many single parents do, sacrifice whatever it takes to pay the bills.

Well, she can't really. Unless she drops the kids off on his doorstep and refuses to have them back. The reality is that only one parent can decide effectively to abandon their child.

DroopyClematis · 04/08/2021 21:01

I understand that you won't go into details but it looks like you are living in the family home. He's moved out. He can't afford to support two homes . You are also a student, so , presumably not working.

What more do you expect from him?

Talk to the Students Union . They may have suggestions.
Your ex needs a home.
Maybe sell the home/ move into a cheaper rented home.

Do you have support nearby?

You cannot expect your partner to subsidise two homes if you are not earning either.

That you won't give details speaks like there is a backstory that might alter posters' opinions.

Neverrains · 04/08/2021 20:32

If he can’t afford to maintain 2 households then I’m not sure what you expect him to do… he needs somewhere to live. This is a genuine question, but how do you expect him to pay his rent and give you money too if he can’t afford it, by your own admission?
He either needs to move back in or you both need to downsize so that between you you can afford to maintain 2 households.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 04/08/2021 20:27

Sounds like he's doing you a favour letting you stay tbh.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 04/08/2021 20:26

He shouldn't pay 2 lots of rent and bills. Why did he leave if the home is only in his name? Can you not rent somewhere?

omgthepain · 04/08/2021 18:05

@Alwaysthebeach

He sounds like a nightmare
Leave him where he is - contact your landlords and tell them he's moved out and your doing a universal credit application and be upfront with them and they'll thank you for this

Go on www.entitledto.co.uk

And do a calculation then start your application ASAP

Why you'd consider having him back and "your hope is he'll move back soon" is beyond me you already have 2 kids why entertain a manchild as a third

You will be better off financially and mentally yourself I promise you

SchrodingersImmigrant · 04/08/2021 16:22

Unies are ofter very helpful so they could provid3 extra time or let student deffer partially. There are extra funds, hardship funds etc. It's doable if it's just few months lwft. If it's a year, deferral is better option

CuriousaboutSamphire · 04/08/2021 16:17

@Alwaysthebeach

Curious - you are wrong. I am not going to go into it all as i just want to sort out the financials for now.
If you mean about your relationship then there is little point looking to the CMS etc.

You will have to concentrate on getting a job that will pay your bills... which means accepting that his decision has screwed your degree, temproarily or completely only you can work out.

There are no other financials. He can't or won't pay. You either join him in abdicating all responsibility or do what many single parents do, sacrifice whatever it takes to pay the bills.

Your choice.

Like it or not, he has made his!

MadeOfStarStuff · 04/08/2021 13:44

YABU

The two of you clearly can’t afford two households so need to either decide to end the temporary split and move back in together or make it permanent and potentially downsize into a smaller more affordable property.

Housing the children is your responsibility just as much as his, it’s not reasonable to expect him to pay the costs of two households unless he’s a very high earner. He should pay child support but that won’t cover all your costs and it’s not expected to.

is your studying genuinely going to lead to a job that will enable you to support you and your kids in 6 months time? If so then it’s worth the short term pain, but if not then you should take a break until you get the finances sorted out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread