Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask your advice on my pcp car

56 replies

Fedupmum13 · 04/08/2021 08:50

Hope this is OK to post here, just thought I'd be more likely to get a response.
Have a pcp car coming to the end of the 4 years and a 6000 balloon payment due in November.
My options are to pay my balloon payment and keep the car (its got 60k miles - giving back isn't an option). Or take out another pcp for £250 a month (currently pay 290 a month). Dealer says I have a little positive equity in the car at the moment. Needs a service and mot this month, hence why I'm thinking of the options now.
I could, pay it off and it's mine, but I'm worried about the ever increasing mileage and things going wrong. Or take out a new pcp on a brand new car with 3 years servicing /warranty but means I start the cycle again.
I have a Renault captur at the moment and it's always been a great car for me. I could trade in for a new dacia duster.
Would be interested in thoughts, really don't know which to choose!
Thank you.
Voting:
YABU: Pay the balloon payment
YANBU: Take out another pcp

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
itsasin77 · 05/08/2021 12:58

Sorry about all the typos, didn’t check it over before posting! But you get my gist.

itsasin77 · 05/08/2021 12:56

We used to always do pcp but our two cars this time we have done on leasehite as dealers won’t budge on their prices abs we got cheaper monthlies leasing instead.
My bmw had 20k excess mileage and was due to go back July.
We sold it to an online company instead who gave us £2500 more than a dealer part Ex. So we cleared the balloon payment and used the equity money as deposit is on our lease cars.
If we just handed it back, we wouod HVe incurred £2k escsss mileage charge!
So it maybe worth considering.
I always go to pistonheads forums for good advice on things such as this.
For tour info, we used wizzle.co.uk to put our vehicle specs and pics on and a company called the car buying group purchased our car, came out cleared the finance abs paid us within 30mins and drove it away.
Hassle free.
Used car prices are extortionate at the moment due to lack of parts for nee cars and delays with these, so you may want to consider this as a selling option like we did whilst you can. The high mileage on our car was not a deterrent.
WhTever you do, don’t hand it back, they will sting you and make money when you could be doing this for you.

bp300 · 05/08/2021 12:48

@bloodywhitecat

Definitely look at second hand and pre-registered cars. We have bought I one year old car with 1100 miles on the clock, we got it for a fair whack less than it would've cost us new and we still have the remainder of the manufacturers warranty with free breakdown cover for that time.
Interest rates are much higher on used cars than new so this may not work out cheaper if going down the PCP route again.
bloodywhitecat · 05/08/2021 12:23

Definitely look at second hand and pre-registered cars. We have bought I one year old car with 1100 miles on the clock, we got it for a fair whack less than it would've cost us new and we still have the remainder of the manufacturers warranty with free breakdown cover for that time.

BashfulClam · 05/08/2021 10:44

You have positive equity and the car market is booming right now (6 months for a new factory car) I’d trade it in and start again . My DH had understated his mileage and we had £2k of charged. Don’t go for a Dacia though we just got rid of ours after a year for a better car.

anniegun · 05/08/2021 10:31

If you are happy with it and it is worth more than the balance pay the balloon. You can buy an extended warranty from someone like Warranty Direct (usually cheaper than the manufacturer). You should arrange the warranty before the existing warranty expires. Used cars are overpriced at the moment so keeping yours is likely to be the best deal you will get

Fedupmum13 · 05/08/2021 10:24

Thanks everyone
Interesting points, may pay for a 2nd hand car next time. Definitely hate the pcp cycle and not keen to continue.

OP posts:
Shurl · 05/08/2021 09:27

If you do decide to take out another pcp, then make sure you increase your milage to something realistic, otherwise you'll be in the same situation with the next car. In the meantime, I'd be working out whether I could save enough to buy a seco d hand car outright next time, particularly as you say you have savings.

I just got a used top spec mazda 2 for 12k. 2yr old, 10000 miles, ex pcp. Retail value about 20k due to added optional extras the original owner paid for. Current finance deals suggest the previous owner may have paid around £11000 over two years (monthly payment + deposit) for the car.

BIoodyStupidJohnson · 05/08/2021 09:13

@Fedupmum13

Thanks everyone. Genuinely have really helped and I've decided to get it serviced etc. Wait til around a month before balloon payment is due and potentially do wbac :)
Worth mentioning that WBAC isn't the only 'money-for-your-car' trade-in company out there. You could also look at Motorway and Wizzle. (Arnold Clark do it too, but I haven't had good dealings with them as a company so I can't recommend.) The prices/offers can vary so you could do worse than get a quote from several and see which works best when the time comes.
WitsEnd9 · 04/08/2021 20:28

A bit of track but my car is an 05 plate. I bought it 5 years ago and all I’ve had to get done to it is a new clutch and brake pads. It’s still under 100,000 miles though. I probably do about 3000 a year.

UrAWizHarry · 04/08/2021 20:21

Well, this is the risk/ problem with PCP really, if you aren't prepared to stay on the treadmill it will cost more than buying outright.

Personally I would keep the car and run it for a few more years.

Fedupmum13 · 04/08/2021 20:18

Thanks everyone. Genuinely have really helped and I've decided to get it serviced etc. Wait til around a month before balloon payment is due and potentially do wbac :)

OP posts:
Propercrimbo2020 · 04/08/2021 16:54

I had a Range Rover on PCP, wanted to hand it back but couldn’t until 50% was paid off.
I did a WBAC valuation online and it came out £2k less than the outstanding finance so left it. A couple of months later they emailed offering more than the outstanding finance, so I took it down and got £600 more than the outstanding finance!
They paid the finance company, I got my money, and it was done in less than a week!
They say the only time it gets down valued is if people aren’t honest about scratched, bumps etc. I would highly recommend.

Treaclepie19 · 04/08/2021 11:09

We were in the same predicament. We decided to keep the car and I'm glad we did because just as we were about to finish payments it got written off (not my fault, it was parked on our drive and nobody was inside)
So the money we got from the insurance company has paid the small amount left and we've had the rest.
A situation you don't expect but just my thought.

mayblossominapril · 04/08/2021 11:06

I usually buy a second hand car thats 3 years old and keep them trouble free for about 4 years and then sell them on for a good price.
I bought my last second hand cad, with less mileage than your for 10k, a friend bought an older one with more mileage for 13k.
Look at the prices of second hand cars and see how much yours would be on the open market. I would pay the £6k and keep it a further 3 years. If you save £300 per month you will then have almost £11k to spend on a new car and you will get very good finance with that deposit. You will also probably get a minimum of £3k for you existing car which can be put towards a new car.

DynamoKev · 04/08/2021 11:01

I've rarely had a car that I got with less than 100K on it.
My record is one I bought with 260k and did a further 20K before selling it on. They can vary so much - not just between makes but individual examples of the same make/model.

Georgeatemyhat · 04/08/2021 10:57

No idea about PCP, but we've only ever owned older second hand cars, our experience is they have lasted ok until mileage reached about 120-140K, or until they get to about 12/13 years old. Then they start costing so much in maintenance it's cheaper to scrap and start again.

poorbuthappy · 04/08/2021 10:41

WBAC obviously Hmm

poorbuthappy · 04/08/2021 10:40

And even if you're upfront with things with EBAC - like we had no spare key and no service history and told them upfront they still took more money off the offer when we went to them!

DynamoKev · 04/08/2021 10:20

Just a word of caution on WBAC - I actually got a good deal on one of my cars as the previous owner was going to sell to WBAC - when she arrived they found numerous faults that knocked their offer price right down - you need to be sure you have been upfront about the condition and they knock things off for not having all spare keys, ect.

DynamoKev · 04/08/2021 10:17

I don't know how long cars tend to last, online says 200,000 miles?! (obviously not every car will!)
It may seem like an obvious point - but it depends what you mean by "last". Most modern engines will last well over 200k with proper maintenance but there are a few "stinker" designs where there are know issues (BMW swirl flaps, cam chains, Land Rover cranks) - even then not every car suffers.
Also a car is much more than just the engine and almost everything wears out eventually - also as they get older it's not just mechanicals, they rust too.

OP Is the new PCP for a new car?

Fedupmum13 · 04/08/2021 10:16

I've looked and they'll offer me 8000 now, but that's as long as it's 6 months left on mot and full service history. I need to get it serviced and mot and then maybe in September will see that they'll still offer a similar amount and go from there.

OP posts:
Shade17 · 04/08/2021 10:07

Pay for the balloon payment, then see how much you’ll get with we buy any car?

Not necessary, just go straight to WBAC. They’ll settle the finance

Fedupmum13 · 04/08/2021 10:02

Thanks for the responses, I'll try we buy any car definitely. Didn't mean to drip feed, I do have the money in savings so could pay my car off and then it'll be mine without any further monthly payments etc. I suppose I'm worried about paying 6000 out for it to have problems. I don't know how long cars tend to last, online says 200,000 miles?! (obviously not every car will!)
The new deal (pcp) would give me 400 for my car (it's worth more than the balance out standing) if I took out another pcp. The new pcp would be 12k miles, 250 a month, over 4 years with a £6000 payment at the end. Obviously a new car would be great for peace of mind, reliability and then I wouldn't need to pay £6000. Obviously I'd be paying more than that over time. This is my 3rd pcp car, and I'm keen to get out of the cycle at the same time! Sorry, I just can't seem to make a decision!

OP posts:
Longdistance · 04/08/2021 09:52

Pay for the balloon payment, then see how much you’ll get with we buy any car? I looked up your car and one had 32k mileage, 2017 plate selling at a dealership for just over £9k.
One thing my friends father did was buy a car off a friend of his. The guys pcp was coming to an end, so her father paid the balloon payment rather than give it back to the dealership to make more money out of the car. His friend was happy with this arrangement.

Swipe left for the next trending thread