Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step daughter's boyfriend wants to move in

240 replies

GiftOfGob · 04/08/2021 08:37

I am new to this so please bear with me!

My SD has asked whether her boyfriend can stay in our home from Mon to Fri while he's working an hour away (and away from the flat they share). He is already living away in the week in a shared house supplied by his boss. This is about the same distance as the crow flies as our home.

Although they've been living together for years, we barely know the man as relations with SD have always been strained since we got together and have never improved even though she is long an adult now.

We have young children under 12 and my OH works long hours.

On the one occasion we asked him to help us out as we were struggling, he let us down at short notice even though we had offered to pay him.

He has never helped out when he has visited or put his hand in his pocket and offer as much as a drink to my OH yet quite happy to accept meals, going for the most expensive meal on the menu. He has been outspoken about our house and my OH's relationship with his daughter. We only ever seem to hear from them when there's a problem or they want something, be it a loan, help with a mortgage, request for money, etc. BTW these are not young people starting out in life. She is 27 and he is 35 and earning a good wage.

We live in a high octane house and would not want anyone living here full time in the week, least of all someone I've only met a handful of times and barely know and it isn't like he doesn't have another option. I have suggested he can come stay a night once in a while to break up the house sharing which I think is a fair compromise.

SD is now getting abusive and insulting towards me which is her usual MO when she doesn't get her way. She is throwing that my OH stayed with them 3 times over a course of months into the mix, hardly 4 nights a week for months. He would at least buy dinner and food for them too.

Standing firm on this, just wanted to put out the feelers to see if there are any points I'm missing...

Hope this is clear. Thank you.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 05/08/2021 16:31

No points missed that i can see, it is definately a no no. Stand your ground! Good luck x

Dollyparton3 · 05/08/2021 15:50

@GiftOfGob

DollyParton3,

Thank you so much for sharing your story. I am so sorry you have both had to go through this. Unless you have been through this yourself, it is difficult to both explain and understand.

Assumptions are often made, usually that some cheating was at play or the parent hasn't parented or absent out of choice because they have gone on to have children with someone else, that the parent or their spouse is somehow to blame for the situation.

Very rarely do people understand these behaviours are fuelled and modelled by the ex then adopted by the child.

I know right? The irony is that whenever DH tried to discipline SD she always withheld contact from him and exw sat back and enjoyed it. So she's been taught to manipulate in order to get what she wants.

Ironically we also have a MIL who is on the Narc spectrum and she's always undermined DH's parenting. So he really can't win. Eveyr narc has an enabler right? in this case there's an enabling triangle and they're all now left with it. It's so sad because we're from a very different "type", and as DSD is at an age now where the world really should be her oyster I can see her behaviour evolving the way your DSD's has. We can't influence that now but we will be ready for the future events that you've described.

DSD has told me in the past that she expects to own a 4 bedroom detatched home as her first house yet she has no career plan at 20. she screamed at DH when he part exchanged his car a few years back because "You should be giving that to me". (we'd already bought her a car but his was £10k more). I keep joking to DH that as soon as he becomes a grandad we'll really feel it. I joke but it's not funny.

I say we're a different type because DH and I have worked our socks off since we both left school at 18, we're fortunate in our circumstances and we value everything that we have. We'd hope that some of this would rub off on DSD but having not spoken to her for 6 months now she's been left with her mother as life coach and career advisor. The life advice she could give would be find a man, surprise him with a pregnancy 3 months into your relationship and jobs a goodun . If he leaves make him pay forever. And while he's paying keep telling the kids that they can't have nice things because "daddy doesnt give us enough money". Work 3 days a week until your kids hit 18 and keep going with that narrative.

GiftOfGob · 05/08/2021 15:25

DollyParton3,

Thank you so much for sharing your story. I am so sorry you have both had to go through this. Unless you have been through this yourself, it is difficult to both explain and understand.

Assumptions are often made, usually that some cheating was at play or the parent hasn't parented or absent out of choice because they have gone on to have children with someone else, that the parent or their spouse is somehow to blame for the situation.

Very rarely do people understand these behaviours are fuelled and modelled by the ex then adopted by the child.

OP posts:
GiftOfGob · 05/08/2021 15:03

MzHz,

Thanks for the tipsSmile.

Over the years, OH has had to stand back for his own sanity so no stranger to this uncomfortable situation.

Even though SD is practising double standards as shown in her response about me going to stay with them, and her demeanour far from the conciliatory you might expect from someone asking a favour, today she continues to shame him and call him out. Neither accepting his decision nor letting go.

He is not feeding it and ignoring. As you say ignore attention seeking and bad behaviour, reward good behaviour, as you would a toddler.

OP posts:
GiftOfGob · 05/08/2021 14:45

DoubleTweenQueen,

Just wanted to rewind a bit and thank you for your input from a SD point of view. I too was a SD once upon a time, albeit at a much younger age. After the typical 'he's/she's not my parent, they can't tell me what to do' phase (which incidentally was deftly nipped in the bud), I grew to love and respect both of my step parents, seeing our relationship as another dimension to my life. I still call my Mum's ex-partner every year on his birthday. To this day, I remain grateful to him for the love, kindness and generosity he brought to my Mum and our family♥️

Life really is too short. I lost my own Father at 25. Thankfully our relationship was straightforward. That doesn't mean it was completely without its differences, however they were few and far between, no regrets. My brother and Father were chalk and cheese and sadly did not have much of a relationship to speak of. When my Father was taken ill, he was there by his side and they got to make their peace, however his regrets have never left him.

OP posts:
MzHz · 05/08/2021 14:05

Standing up to narcs gives them fuel

Gives them the weapons to throw back. “Look at this, how terrible is my dad/ex that he said/texted this…”

Only way to win the game against people like this is not to play the game.

Grey rock all the way, till they realise that you’re not going to feed them

Dollyparton3 · 05/08/2021 14:03

@GiftOfGob and @MzHz I know exactly what you're talking about. We have one too. DH's ex spent years poisoning the children against my DH and he was only ever any use to her as a walking cash point. The children were even critical of his right to spend money on his own time when I met him nearly 10 years ago.

DSD has now become the most dilusional narcisisst young adult that it's ever been my misfortune to meet and she holds everyone to ransom in order to be part of her life.

These people are real unfortunately and I sympathise. And it's not even as if you're working with a stepchild any more, they're just a full blown adult bully and emotional terrorist. We discovered that last year when adult DSD went all out to send viral online terror to our home over something that we'd quite reasonably requested.

Stand your ground OP, then both step back and try to move on. It's horrible for you but even more awful for your DP. I know my DP was heartbroken when DSD showed her true fully blown colours to us. The worst part is the silence inbetween little glimmers of contact and then the "Ok, yep that again" feeling when you see it for what it is.

MzHz · 05/08/2021 14:03

@GiftOfGob

Lara Decouvrie,

I learnt my lesson in step parenting that my intervention would never work, it has to come from OH who comes from a nice family where everyone is kind to each other. Even though he is a fully grown man, nothing prepared him for this.

Please understand however it is very testing to stand back when your OH is at the receiving end of criticism, demands, abuse and swearing in your own home, when you are someone who doesn't suffer fools or bullies!!!

I taught mine to disengage, to ignore all bad/drama completely, no response

Only reply/respond to good

Classic toddler handling

But we were dealing with a teen, not some woman knocking on the door of 30!

Your h is doing the right thing

LaraDecouvrie · 05/08/2021 13:31

I imagine it is!!! But it’s adding fuel to the fire. And definately makes things worse.

I think your DH needs to learn to stand up to the women in his life!!!

GiftOfGob · 05/08/2021 13:24

Lara Decouvrie,

I learnt my lesson in step parenting that my intervention would never work, it has to come from OH who comes from a nice family where everyone is kind to each other. Even though he is a fully grown man, nothing prepared him for this.

Please understand however it is very testing to stand back when your OH is at the receiving end of criticism, demands, abuse and swearing in your own home, when you are someone who doesn't suffer fools or bullies!!!

OP posts:
GiftOfGob · 05/08/2021 13:11

Pemba,

I am not sneering at all (seems you are), just stating a fact that at 27, SD does not consider it her responsibility to make her own way in this life. She expects her Father who she has always kept at arm's length, to foot the bill for it all. This is the latest in a long line of financial requests. Her partner has a good job, more income and perks than most families I know live off...this is not about money though Pemba, it is about punishment and control.

When you've found the back story, please share how you would've dealt with this impossible situation rather than stereotyping me as the archetypal step mother!

OP posts:
GiftOfGob · 05/08/2021 12:54

MzHz,

Again you nail it!

Emotional terrorist is a good descriptive. Then you have a similar shared experience by sounds of it.

I was not young when I met OH and had had other relationships, most of which had ended amicably. Steering clear of toxic relationships, romantically or otherwise. Unwittingly I had entered a whole new ball game. You are right, you cannot reason or rationalise with these people. They thrive on chaos and disharmony and simply cannot live peacefully.

OH is taking some time out of the relationship as he has over the years. He cannot win:(

OP posts:
LaraDecouvrie · 05/08/2021 12:50

A bit late to the party, but Yanbu to say “no”! It would be a disaster for all!

Not sure why “high octane” is upsetting so many people. It’s not a phrase I would use as such, but not difficult to work out what it means.

But, if I were you, I’d take a step back and let DH manage the relationship with his own DD. You texting from his phone and getting involved years ago does not paint you in a good light!

Pemba · 05/08/2021 12:43

I don't know the whole backstory of course (since you didn't write it out - were there previous threads?). Sounds like your SD's ex has been difficult.

You do however come across as very sneering at your SD and her lack of career success etc. I just think it's all quite sad really.

GiftOfGob · 05/08/2021 12:36

MaggiesFarm, thank youSmilesaved me a post lol

OP posts:
GiftOfGob · 05/08/2021 12:30

Pemba,

Are you familiar with the term parental alienation? I wasn't before I met OH but sure as hell am now! Sadly not odd, more common than you realise. I have 3 adult friends all raised by their mothers whose contact with the father was either lost altogether or only resumed after leaving home.

SD's mother is second generation single parent, only child family whose mantra is 'all men are b***ds and will pay, financially and emotionally.'
From the day the girl was born she was used as a pawn. Daddy and his family always kept at arm's length with limited visits which would be thwarted, short lived or stopped altogether, covetous as SD's Mother was of her, only wanting to share a child she considered her sole possession with the Nan. As a result SD has missed out on a wider loving family and view of the world as has OH and family. No winners in this sorry situation I'm afraid.

Might I ask how you would've dealt with this situation since you are so quick to judge? Were you confronted with this level of 'punishment' and abuse, how would you respond?

To clarify the phone hijacking element, in her refusal to accept No for an answer, SD delusionally thinks it is me sending the messages from her father's phone! I had done this in our earlier days, however stopped when it only made bad matters worse.

And being happy with my own family and in my own skin does not make me smug or self-satisfied, it makes me grateful.

OP posts:
DoubleTweenQueen · 05/08/2021 12:24

@GiftOfGob I do understand - have been the SD. Not beloved if my SM at all, but I had respect for her & my DF.
It's sad for your SD too as she is very much an adult who has, and is, ruining the opportunity of a decent relationship with her family. She really needs to grow up and realise life is very short. If she feels anything for her dad, she needs to build bridges.

MzHz · 05/08/2021 12:09

My oh has this too. We have managed contact and refuse to be manipulated

It’s been really hard, and I just wish everyone here could realise that there really are some people who make it a mission to cause upset and drama in the lives of others and sometimes they’re related to other people.

My oh ex is - or was - a complete emotional terrorist

We’ve totally cut her out of the equation now and she’s realised she has absolutely no power and no matter what she tries to manipulate oh to get more money or whatever (trust me, she’s not short!) because she sees extortion as a sport. Always has done. Their DD has tried the same, or has been instructed to try it, oh just ignores, says a flat no or insists that her dm goes half.

@GiftOfGob your h has to take a step back I think, and being consistent in saying no is the easiest way to do this. No point in confronting, not point in engaging or trying to get them to see things from a normal person’s perspective. That’s never going to happen, (a) because that doesn’t result in them getting what they want and (b) they aren’t normal people, they’re narcissists.

We need to surround ourselves with those who love us, those who add to our lives and those who share our values.

GiftOfGob · 05/08/2021 12:00

Double Tween Queen

Thank you for your kind words. Lovely of you to think of my OH and familySmile

He has been quiet and laying low today. The extremes of radio silence or vitriol, with little else in between, are difficult to manage. I prefer the radio silence then it is never far away from his thoughts, his face etched with the sadness of it all.

OP posts:
ShallWeStartTheMeeting · 05/08/2021 11:54

Another one who's never heard high octane as a house description... Grin

GiftOfGob · 05/08/2021 11:50

MzHz, thanks for your ongoing kind words of supportSmile

OP posts:
Maggiesfarm · 05/08/2021 11:15

[quote DoubleTweenQueen]Being unfamiliar with words or phrasing used does not make the writer either pretentious or patronising.though??[/quote]
I agree, how horrible to suggest the op is either; she certainly didn't give me that impression. 'High octane' is a good description. Apart from that, homing in on a perfectly reasonable word is diverting the topic of conversation.

Surely if we don't understand a word or phrase, we can google? I'm forever googling unfamiliar words, it's good to learn new things.

Pemba · 05/08/2021 11:03

I agree that the SD's boyfriend should not be allowed to stay, as it's a damn cheek considering his attitude to the OP and her partner, and lack of a cordial relationship with them. He obviously only wants to do it to save money, he is most definitely an adult who can take care of himself, he's not in need at all. And it is very wrong of the SD to verbally attack the OP as she hasn't got her own way.

However, am I the only one to find it sad that the relationship between the SD and her father is so poor? Yes the SD is an adult now, but when OP and her partner met she was a young teenager who was probably distressed about losing her father. That goes some way to explaining her hostile attitude. Yes she's 27 now, and is behaving badly, but.... The OP is nothing but critical towards the SD and her mother, and what is all that about hijacking her partner's phone to send messages to SD as if from her father? All very odd, and the OP seems quite self-satisfied about her family and everything. A bit smug.

I also find it odd the way some of you are insinuating that the boyfriend has dodgy motivations for wanting to stay in a home with 'young children - OMG!' Get real people. Many households have children living there and he is clearly just a freeloading cheapskate, a bit much to insinuate he is also some kind of paedo!

DoubleTweenQueen · 05/08/2021 10:42

@GiftOfGob I hope your DH is ok - he must suffer a great deal from the continuing attitude from his daughter, and I imagine a source of tension and sadness for all of you Flowers

DoubleTweenQueen · 05/08/2021 10:40

Being unfamiliar with words or phrasing used does not make the writer either pretentious or patronising.though??

Swipe left for the next trending thread