Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the difficulty in seeing a GP is a plan to erode NHS treatment by stealth

138 replies

DuckyMcDuck · 03/08/2021 18:06

It is still impossible to get an appointment at our GPs so over the last couple of weeks we have had to pay for appointment to a) check my ears for ear wax and b) to pay a podiatrist to sort out of DS's ingrowing toenail (as he was in a lot of pain and they said it would be at least a months wait for a referral)

Both cost us over £100, now we are lucky we can pay for it but AIBU to think these are treatments that should have been sorted by a GPs visit.

OP posts:
Glitterblue · 03/08/2021 22:55

I've been trying to see a GP because I'm in utter agony with my hips. It's been getting progressively worse over the lockdowns, but despite trying several times, I've been unable to get past the receptionists. They flat out refuse to give me a GP appointment and say it has to be a self referral to physio, not a GP. I personally think it's connected to the perimenopause which I really wanted to discuss with a GP but I just can't get near them.

Kirstymonkey3 · 03/08/2021 22:54

My GP has been amazing. I was diagnosed with bipolar January 2020 and the support I’ve had from the 2 GPs I’ve spoken to about this has been amazing. They’ve seen me face to face when I developed a tremor due to medications. I’ve also been in for an examination when I found a lump.

In my job I send tasks for prescriptions for patients and GPs are actioning these as early as 6am and as late as 11pm. Just because you can’t see them working theres a lot going on behind the scenes!

nukeitfromorbit · 03/08/2021 22:53

If it's a conspiracy it's due to chronic under funding of the NHS. GPs have run themselves ragged this year trying to maintain business as usual and deliver the vaccination program. They were already desperately understaffed. No-one studies medicine for 10+ years in the UK with the intention of making money rather than helping people. There are much easier ways for these very intellectually gifted people to make money. Most GPs are doing their level best to meet their their registered patients health needs but there is just not enough hours in the day to do it with the current staff available.

Davros · 03/08/2021 22:51

No problem seeing my GP, ditto DH

OverByYer · 03/08/2021 22:46

I hope they do do something I can’t get an appointment at my GPS for love or money. Unless I book time off to sit on the phone all day redialling. Bloody shambles

FizziWater · 03/08/2021 22:43

I think expectations of the NHS are unrealistic and the sooner everyone accepts that completely free health care is unviable the better.
I have had crap health for two years starting with breast cancer so I've had my share from the NHS.
No way would I bother the GP / NHS for ear wax or podiatry as long as I could afford to pay.

tocas · 03/08/2021 22:32

Yabu, ear wax is not a medical issue and gp wouldn't be cutting out a toenail anyway.

Lentil63 · 03/08/2021 22:29

@Upamountain43

No but there is definite plan to change the GP system. Not sure how yet but it is unlikely GP's will exist in the same way in 10 - 20 years time. They are seen as unsustainable and expensive for what they actually do - which is predominantly gatekeep secondary care.

Some countries do not have anything like a GP system so it is perfectly possible to run without them.

By whom are GP’s seen as expensive and unsustainable? In reality GP’s see about 90% of NHS patients but cost a tiny proportion of the NHS budget. I do think there are plans afoot to change our primary health care and this will be aimed at reducing its cost. This will not be a positive thing for patients in my opinion. We do not attract enough doctors to train as GP’s and many practices are struggling to fill vacancies, you may care to ponder on why that might be; it is clearly not an easy option and many GP’s have taken early retirement due to stress and burnout. The rate of suicide among doctors is highest amongst GP’s.
wheresmymojo · 03/08/2021 22:26

@SimonJT

The majority of GPs do not work for the NHS, they are mainly private business that bill the NHS for their time.

This.

Almost all GPs are private businesses.

Large swathes of what we think of as the NHS are already private businesses - for example Virgin Care provide minor injury units, district nursing, sexual health clinics...

NiceGerbil · 03/08/2021 22:18

And the fact that some people are only noticing after years and years of this when they can't get a GP to look at their ear wax...

Shows why it's been going on for so long.

It's been in the news for years and years.

Loads of doctors going on about it.
Concern.
Outsourcing to private.
Carving out the easy stuff to private.
Putting various clinics under tight profit driven control, which means consultants can't do their full job and patients need more spots
And on and on.
Politicians etc banging on about it for years.

But...

I can't get a GP to look at my ear wax! Omg GPs (self employed) are conspiring to bring down the NHS!

Hopeless.

mrsbyers · 03/08/2021 22:15

I’ve seen a GP when I’ve needed to for serious issues , I wouldn’t have even attempted to try and see a GP for earwax without trying the over the counter remedies and even then it would be a practice nurse

NiceGerbil · 03/08/2021 22:12

That's been happening for decades though.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 03/08/2021 22:10

@Justanotherlurker

We’re sleepwalking into a US style system in which the fortunate get the best care — albeit with hefty premiums and co-pays — and the unfortunate are bankrupted or can’t afford their insulin.

The tories threatening to privatise the NHS has been a meme since the 70's, those still using it needs to use their apparent critical thinking skills that they like to openly profess.

Apart from getting into the lockdown narrative, whats needed is maybe actually following up what the 'online left' have been trying to promote for years and we follow the nordic model of healthcare which does require some privatisation/insurance and paying for GP visits etc, as in we need a proper discussion instead of flogging a dead horse that assumes any kind of reform of the NHS is automitically assumed to be going down the US route, and no bring up a certain book doesn't prove that you are right.

That’s my point. A discussion needs to be had, but it won’t happen. All that will happen is that the NHS will continue to be underfunded and more and more people will turn to private provision, and we will have a US system by stealth. It’s already happening.
NiceGerbil · 03/08/2021 21:35

The NHS is massive. I think it's - s couple of years ago was- the 3rd biggest employer in the world.

I mean it's a massive complicated thing.

The actual or accused attacks on the NHS have been going on for decades.

I think that oh the GPs are not seeing patients because of wanting to fuck up the NHS is... Random and superficial.

Apart from anything else.

GPs are self employed Grin

Justanotherlurker · 03/08/2021 21:28

We’re sleepwalking into a US style system in which the fortunate get the best care — albeit with hefty premiums and co-pays — and the unfortunate are bankrupted or can’t afford their insulin.

The tories threatening to privatise the NHS has been a meme since the 70's, those still using it needs to use their apparent critical thinking skills that they like to openly profess.

Apart from getting into the lockdown narrative, whats needed is maybe actually following up what the 'online left' have been trying to promote for years and we follow the nordic model of healthcare which does require some privatisation/insurance and paying for GP visits etc, as in we need a proper discussion instead of flogging a dead horse that assumes any kind of reform of the NHS is automitically assumed to be going down the US route, and no bring up a certain book doesn't prove that you are right.

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 03/08/2021 21:15

Well, yeah, I don't for a second believe someone charged £100 to look in their ear

Why not? Private dr is about that much

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 03/08/2021 21:14

I have to ring my dr at 8am to book a same day appointment for a medical review

Together with everyone else who may actually need a same day appointment

Its a shite system as far as i can see…and i know when i finally manage to get a telephone appointment they are going to tell me to ring back and book a blood test and a blood pressure test, and then ring at 8am for a few days to get another same day appointment to discuss the results

Its taking an ave

HmmmmmmInteresting · 03/08/2021 21:10

@gamerchick

Why is everyone acting all shocked at this? Lots of people with blocked ears go to the GP to have their ears checked every day (well, pre-covid). How do you know if it's wax, eustachian tube dysfunction or a foreign body without someone examining you?

If I get a blocked ear, a GP isn't my first thought.

Personally I think the OP is yanking our puddings here with those reasons tbh. Hand grenade and watch it roll.

Well, yeah, I don't for a second believe someone charged £100 to look in their ear, and the podiatrist scenario was nothing to do with not being able to see a GP and everything to do with the waiting list for podiatry.

A lot of NHS threads lately Wink

Artus · 03/08/2021 21:08

Much of this is down to a shortage of GPs. The NHS has been aware for years that this would happen as the current GPs retire and fewer doctors are attracted to general practice. There have been recruitment issues for many years, the workload is unsustainable, and the public perception of GPS has become worse, as can be seen by the many threads running them down. No wonder people don't choose this as a career.

I think the current general practice model will disappear and be replaced with a salaried gatekeeping service.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 03/08/2021 21:08

@OhWhyNot

No I don’t think it is

But we will be seeing more fees and insurance being involved

We could have a much better service and I think we shall go more of the way of other European countries

We won’t change to an American system. It won’t have the support we have very different attitudes towards health care to how many American (even liberal Americans) have

Do you really think we’ll be asked?
Kendodd · 03/08/2021 21:05

Anyone popped up to blame immigrants yet?

Kendodd · 03/08/2021 21:03

The state of our health service is 100% our own fault.
We get what we vote for.
If we (as a nation, not individuals posters) wanted a better funded health service we wouldn't repeatedly vote in politicians that allow it to wither.

gamerchick · 03/08/2021 20:55

Why is everyone acting all shocked at this? Lots of people with blocked ears go to the GP to have their ears checked every day (well, pre-covid). How do you know if it's wax, eustachian tube dysfunction or a foreign body without someone examining you?

If I get a blocked ear, a GP isn't my first thought.

Personally I think the OP is yanking our puddings here with those reasons tbh. Hand grenade and watch it roll.

Marcee · 03/08/2021 20:52

Its unlikely it's just due to the pandemic.

Where I work. We are down 2 GP's .

We have been unable to recruit after one retired, then then one left.

So weare ri
Running on locums- this makes the practice less attractive for anyone looking for a GP job.

Even with locums we aren't able to get enough doctors in to cover the vacancies. There aren't any locums either.

So low on appointments everyday.

There is a GP shortage. Any GP who gets a chance is leaving the country. The job prospects are getting worse and worse every day. Any GP that can is planning for early retirement. And any that aren't are looking into cutting down their hours and finding different roles.
Because the actual job has become impossible.

ActonSquirrel · 03/08/2021 20:47

My GP still isn't doing reviews let alone appointments. I'm T2 diabetic, take BP medication and haven't had a blood test or appointment for 2 years. So where do I go? I'm getting seriously pissed off with this Covid only healthcare.

That is outrageous. Diabetes can have serious complications and it needs monitoring.

The others can go and pay £1.50 for iron tablets or £4.29 for ear wax drops and they just don't want to

Swipe left for the next trending thread