Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the difficulty in seeing a GP is a plan to erode NHS treatment by stealth

138 replies

DuckyMcDuck · 03/08/2021 18:06

It is still impossible to get an appointment at our GPs so over the last couple of weeks we have had to pay for appointment to a) check my ears for ear wax and b) to pay a podiatrist to sort out of DS's ingrowing toenail (as he was in a lot of pain and they said it would be at least a months wait for a referral)

Both cost us over £100, now we are lucky we can pay for it but AIBU to think these are treatments that should have been sorted by a GPs visit.

OP posts:
DerAlteMann · 04/08/2021 16:24

No, I don't think there's a plan to "erode" the NHS by "stealth". Given that the NHS has been under the control of a Conservative Government for far longer over the years than it has been controlled by a Labour one, why have they waited until now? Actually, if anything, our GP service has improved, insofar as waiting times are concerned, over the last couple of years,

Nightlystroll · 04/08/2021 16:23

You wouldn't go the the Gp surgery with a broken leg anyway 🤔

Er, yes, you might. My neighbours son hurt his leg playing football. Ee was,still walking around though. She told him to stop moaning. Eventually she took him to the doctors. He had broken a bone in his leg. So it does happen.

HmmmmmmInteresting · 04/08/2021 16:22

[quote justasking111]We use Specsavers around here

www.specsavers.co.uk/hearing/earwax/earwax-removal?gclsrc=aw.ds&ds_rl=1293573&gclid=CjwKCAjw9aiIBhA1EiwAJ_GTSjgdWhvKfAVXxxwkHwW8U40-Q1QScGQHUSvcFe77eieGBjatXZJRMBoCY9AQAvD_BwE[/quote]
Exactly. So no idea why PPs are paying £100-200 just for someone to look in their ear. More money than sense.

unsure111 · 04/08/2021 16:20

@Nightlystroll

Triage at our surgery works like this. You ring and have to tell all your symptoms to the receptionist. (Had to do this before covid too.) They write everything down. They then make an appointment for someone to ring you and triage you. Usually in a week's time and it could be any time of day. Don't be fooled in thinking that because they say they'll ring between 2 and 6, that they won't ring you at 9.30. And if they do ring at 9.30 and you don't answer twice, you're off their list and you have to ring to make an appointment to be triaged again in another week. So then a nurse rings you, gets you to state all your symptoms that you have already told to the receptionist. They then make an appointment for you to speak to a doctor or nurse practitioner...in about 3 weeks. If you're unlucky, you have to ring the receptionist to make the appointment yourself. You then get a call from the doctor (again, any time, can be knocked off list). You then go through your symptoms again. Then you get an appointment to come in or they give a prescription even if they think it won't work (but it keeps you quiet. - actually had a doctor all but say that.)

A friends surgery put a notice on the locked surgery door saying that contacting the surgery is not always the best action to take. That's right, just nip into the builders merchants and get them to slop some plaster on your broken leg. British people - no imagination. 🤔

You wouldn't go the the Gp surgery with a broken leg anyway 🤔
justasking111 · 04/08/2021 16:18

@Intercity225

In addition, GPs are now catching up with serious illness such as cancer...but you want your ears checked for earwax so I just can't understand why the GP didn't prioritise you over possible cancer cases???

Apparently, I have a tiny canal in my left ear, and it is now getting completely blocked by ear wax every 3 months. When it is blocked, I suffer tinnitus, hearing loss and a feeling of pressure in my ear - it drives me bonkers, and really affects the quality of my life! It may not be as serious as cancer, but GPs don't just deal with cancer all day; and I believe I should be able to get treatment for my blocked ear on the NHS, rather than having to pay for 2 sessions of micro suctioning every 3 months.

If not, we would like a rebate on the tax DH pays (and DH has been a higher rate tax payer for over 30 years), so we can pay for private health care.

Rebate that's just unrealistic. Everyone pays for state education whether or not they have children, or privately educate. Public health care benefits society, as does education.

You say you have the money so pay. It's cheaper than the hairdresser.

unsure111 · 04/08/2021 16:12

@Paquerette who do you think sees the E-consult first? Not the Gp. The reception staff see them and put them on screen for the doctor. Urgent to less urgent order. The doctor doesn't tell them when the appointment will be. It's just on their screen and the E-consult is saved in your records for the Gp to view.

unsure111 · 04/08/2021 16:04

@8dpwoah

I don't know how my GP surgery manages it then as it was always possible to get a phone appointment same day, face to face if required the following day, no change as far as I know during covid. I rang up a few weeks ago with something non-urgent and said as much, but the receptionist insisted I go on the afternoon call list rather than waiting. Prescription at pharmacy an hour after the call. How is it possible for my GP surgery to consistently deliver a great service (including the nurse practitioners too, I and DD have both had plenty of jabs during the pandemic) when others have been so poor? Is it because they were pioneering phone triage way before covid and the patients are all used to it? It's a genuine question- I'd love to know how their model is so successful and if it could be rolled out to others?
I think it's down to different areas and CCGs who make all the decisions and then tell the surgeries in the area what they have to do. A surgery I work in has been open throughout. Same day appointments if people ring or next day appointments. Phone consultions, e consult answered the day after. We can book F2f a few days later. But I know a different surgery in a other area who has told patients that their next appointments available to see a Gp is October.
HmmmmmmInteresting · 04/08/2021 15:33

@LemonRoses

HmmmmmmInteresting and yet, experts like teh Kings fund would suggest that the NHS is one of he most efficient healthcare systems in the world. What are you meaning by efficient and what is your evidence base?
Oh gosh.. .how long have you got?!
Bagamoyo1 · 04/08/2021 15:33

OP most GPs don’t do ear syringing any more, so private or DIY is the only option. This has been the case for some time.
Podiatry is generally self-referral - you can get a form from the surgery or do it online. It’s free, it’s an NHS service. No need to see a GP.

Loubiemoo · 04/08/2021 15:32

Wasn’t there a thread like this recently?

HmmmmmmInteresting · 04/08/2021 15:32

@Intercity225

Well, yeah, I don't for a second believe someone charged £100 to look in their ear,

Why not? The first appointment with my local audiology practice is £150, and as they can never get the wax, next to the ear drum out first time, I have to go back again 2 weeks later, when its apparently moved further away - cost £50.

No, ear drops from the pharmacy don't work. All that happens is that I suffer even more hearing loss. The wax certainly does not come out.

Ah ok, I guess it's reasonable to pay that. It's not like you can do it yourself so you've got no choice!
Intercity225 · 04/08/2021 15:29

Well, yeah, I don't for a second believe someone charged £100 to look in their ear,

Why not? The first appointment with my local audiology practice is £150, and as they can never get the wax, next to the ear drum out first time, I have to go back again 2 weeks later, when its apparently moved further away - cost £50.

No, ear drops from the pharmacy don't work. All that happens is that I suffer even more hearing loss. The wax certainly does not come out.

Intercity225 · 04/08/2021 15:23

In addition, GPs are now catching up with serious illness such as cancer...but you want your ears checked for earwax so I just can't understand why the GP didn't prioritise you over possible cancer cases???

Apparently, I have a tiny canal in my left ear, and it is now getting completely blocked by ear wax every 3 months. When it is blocked, I suffer tinnitus, hearing loss and a feeling of pressure in my ear - it drives me bonkers, and really affects the quality of my life! It may not be as serious as cancer, but GPs don't just deal with cancer all day; and I believe I should be able to get treatment for my blocked ear on the NHS, rather than having to pay for 2 sessions of micro suctioning every 3 months.

If not, we would like a rebate on the tax DH pays (and DH has been a higher rate tax payer for over 30 years), so we can pay for private health care.

Anonawoman · 04/08/2021 15:04

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at OP's request.

BigWoollyJumpers · 04/08/2021 14:43

Sorry forgot the link:
www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/health-and-social-care-explained/nhs-reform-timeline/

BigWoollyJumpers · 04/08/2021 14:43

This is interesting - In 1950 we were spending 3.5% of GDP on healthcare, and has been rising pretty much every year, bar a couple of 0.1% points ever since.

The main problem is that many people expect too much, pp's an example, and healthcare has moved on, without the realignment of peoples expectation.

In 1950 many ailments were untreatable, people died younger, and babies born with issues were not routinely treated.

Now we have surgeries and treatments costing millions, we try to save everyone, we extend life in all scenarios. But we still want paracetamol and vitamins "on the NHS". NICE go a good job in looking into cost/benefit analyses for drugs, but still there is always a furore when a new drug is not approved. I think we really need to have a grown up discussion on self help and self reliance for non-complex day to day issues.

Nightlystroll · 04/08/2021 14:31

Triage at our surgery works like this. You ring and have to tell all your symptoms to the receptionist. (Had to do this before covid too.) They write everything down. They then make an appointment for someone to ring you and triage you. Usually in a week's time and it could be any time of day. Don't be fooled in thinking that because they say they'll ring between 2 and 6, that they won't ring you at 9.30. And if they do ring at 9.30 and you don't answer twice, you're off their list and you have to ring to make an appointment to be triaged again in another week. So then a nurse rings you, gets you to state all your symptoms that you have already told to the receptionist. They then make an appointment for you to speak to a doctor or nurse practitioner...in about 3 weeks. If you're unlucky, you have to ring the receptionist to make the appointment yourself. You then get a call from the doctor (again, any time, can be knocked off list). You then go through your symptoms again. Then you get an appointment to come in or they give a prescription even if they think it won't work (but it keeps you quiet. - actually had a doctor all but say that.)

A friends surgery put a notice on the locked surgery door saying that contacting the surgery is not always the best action to take. That's right, just nip into the builders merchants and get them to slop some plaster on your broken leg. British people - no imagination. 🤔

8dpwoah · 04/08/2021 14:26

It does seem a very badly structured and organised beast. While my GP surgery has gone 'rogue' if you like and instigated telephone triage off its own back well before covid, the same trust has a maternity service that has bought into an app (Badger maternity notes) that literally doesn't work. It doesn't talk to all of their systems but has been rolled out anyway. How on earth has that happened? Can't be blamed on covid, or underfunding, surely, so how have they ended up in that situation. They've shut the birth unit due to staffing but are persisting with a continuity of carer model that triggered a lot of the staffing issues (from what I can gather) in the first place. Again, how?

I imagine this is the same chain of thought and command as how lots of posters have ended up finding GP services a nightmare. Sticky ears and pointy toes aside, of course.

Scarlettpixie · 04/08/2021 14:23

Yabu to expect to be seen urgently for either of those things mentioned.

My GP surgery has been fab. I have had same day telephone appointments with GPs when requested and in person ones where they felt it necessary. I have had routine telephone follow ups too instigated by the GP. I have also been seen at minor injuries and A&E when needed so no complaints from me, it is a shame others have not had the same experience.

bunnybuggs · 04/08/2021 14:14

the thing is - all of you advocating the use of e-consult and how wonderful it is do not realise it is not available in all GPs surgery - it is very much a postcode lottery like a lot of NHS care/treatment

Talking of levelling up - which I hesitate to do - if something is developed that is better than constantly trying to get through to the surgery about a serious matter (let alone ear wax) and it operates a triage in a more efficient way - surely it should be available to all NHS patients. Angry

Westchesterarms · 04/08/2021 13:21

@LemonRoses. In 2019 health care was at 10.2% of GDP compared to 9.8% in 2010. Its stayed pretty static overall. Sorry, I don't know how to make the link clicky. You'll have to copy and paste.

www.statista.com/statistics/317708/healthcare-expenditure-as-a-share-of-gdp-in-the-united-kingdom/

The problem is no matter how much any govt spends, it will never be enough.

jimmyhill · 04/08/2021 13:11

For real urgent appointments (i.e. not pedicures or bring curious about how much ear wax I have), have always been able to get same day GP appointment.

Wheresmybiscuit3 · 04/08/2021 13:03

I don’t think so

LemonRoses · 04/08/2021 12:54

HmmmmmmInteresting and yet, experts like teh Kings fund would suggest that the NHS is one of he most efficient healthcare systems in the world.
What are you meaning by efficient and what is your evidence base?

Swipe left for the next trending thread