Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the difficulty in seeing a GP is a plan to erode NHS treatment by stealth

138 replies

DuckyMcDuck · 03/08/2021 18:06

It is still impossible to get an appointment at our GPs so over the last couple of weeks we have had to pay for appointment to a) check my ears for ear wax and b) to pay a podiatrist to sort out of DS's ingrowing toenail (as he was in a lot of pain and they said it would be at least a months wait for a referral)

Both cost us over £100, now we are lucky we can pay for it but AIBU to think these are treatments that should have been sorted by a GPs visit.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HmmmmmmInteresting · 05/08/2021 16:53

@Katefoster

No wonder people can't get doctors appointments if they're being taken up by people wanting the dr to check their ears for ear wax...
This is a really stupid statement. Impacted ear wax can be miserable. What do you suggest people do if they've tried drops and are still struggling to hear? 🤔
BigWoollyJumpers · 05/08/2021 10:30

My GP already operates what is effectively a two tier system. For those whom he knows are well off, and/or with private medical, everything is done by phone and on line, and specific medical issues are advised to book privately including: ears, eyes, moles, physio, mental health, etc etc. And of course we pay full prescription price on any prescription medication.

Essentially I don't have a problem with this. We can afford to pay, we should, it frees NHS up for others who can't.

We have on occasion also gone to private GP's for chronic issues, which NHS GP's just don't have the time for, specifically mental health and Lyme.

PostMenWithACat · 05/08/2021 08:09

@bakedbeans at my surgery, while they still did ear syringing, you weren't allowed to book the appointment with the nurse unless the Dr had looked at your ears and said it was necessary.

PostMenWithACat · 05/08/2021 08:07

Re the ingrowing toenail. DD had one. It really kicked off when she was about 13/14. Dr prescribed AB's. I took dd to a podiatrist/chiropodist privately - NHS referral was not possible. Podiatrist did a bit of snipping but the nail bed was very wide and splayed and it wasn't enough and she referred DD for minor surgery with a general surgeon with an interest in children. A specialist paediatric nurse had to be brought into the hospital for it. It needed doing but it wouldn't have been done on the NHS and that was 10 years ago.

If we hadn't paid privately dd would have been left to let it flare up once a year or more and then treated for the flare up rather than the problem.

Spanielstail · 05/08/2021 07:19

The bigger issue is lack of accountability for our own health. How many people exercise regularly, eat 7 lots of fruit and veg, only drink alcohol on occasion and have a healthy BMI? So many issues are preventable.

Kendodd · 05/08/2021 06:32

What is wrong with the OP wanting treatment for her ears? I agree, see in nurse would have been fine but beyond than don't see the problem. Likewise her feet. Neither of these problems might have needed a doctor but I have absolutely no problem with NHS treatment for them.

Katefoster · 04/08/2021 22:23

No wonder people can't get doctors appointments if they're being taken up by people wanting the dr to check their ears for ear wax...

bakebeans · 04/08/2021 22:14

Gps are still seeing patients if necessary. My 20 year old child had abdominal pain and was seen promptly the same day and advised to attend a&e.

Both your concerns did not have to be done with the Gp. Some areas have self referral for things like podiatry appointments and for checking for ear wax. In most practices it’s the nurses who do this. If the wax needs syringing it’s would be the treatment room nurse.
This can also be done via self referral in many a few areas now or buying over the counter olive oil ear drops from the chemist. These are neither things that the GP needs to urgently see you for

NiceGerbil · 04/08/2021 22:06

USA system no fucking way thanks.

Harvard-

'The study confirmed that the U.S. has substantially higher spending, worse population health outcomes, and worse access to care than other wealthy countries. For example, in 2016, the U.S. spent 17.8 percent of its gross domestic product on health care, while other countries ranged from 9.6 percent (Australia) to 12.4 percent (Switzerland). Life expectancy in the U.S. was the lowest of all 11 countries in the study, at 78.8 years; the range for other countries was 80.7 to 83.9 years. The proportion of the U.S. population with health insurance was 90 percent, lower than all the other countries, which ranged from 99 to 100 percent coverage.'

NiceGerbil · 04/08/2021 22:03

Sorry g7 maybe.

NiceGerbil · 04/08/2021 22:03

Some data from ONS. Us v Europe

Note the level of tax in some countries known to have good accessible healthcare.

'Main points
In 2017, the UK spent £2,989 per person on healthcare, which was around the median for members of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development: OECD (£2,913 per person).

However, of the G7 group of large, developed economies, UK healthcare spending per person was the second-lowest, with the highest spenders being France (£3,737), Germany (£4,432) and the United States (£7,736).

As a percentage of GDP, UK healthcare spending fell from 9.8% in 2013 to 9.6% in 2017, while healthcare spending as a percentage of GDP rose for four of the remaining six G7 countries.

The UK’s publicly funded NHS-based health system contributes to the UK having one of the highest shares of publicly funded healthcare (79%) in the OECD.

In 2017, the UK spent the equivalent of £560 per person on health-related long-term care, which was less than most other northern or western European countries, but a similar amount to France (£569) and Canada (£556).'

NiceGerbil · 04/08/2021 21:49

And you want all of this done because of your ear, just for that reason. For you. And DH. As you WANT the whole system completely overhauled at vast expense.

You really see that as totally reasonable?!

NiceGerbil · 04/08/2021 21:47

@Intercity225

In addition, GPs are now catching up with serious illness such as cancer...but you want your ears checked for earwax so I just can't understand why the GP didn't prioritise you over possible cancer cases???

Apparently, I have a tiny canal in my left ear, and it is now getting completely blocked by ear wax every 3 months. When it is blocked, I suffer tinnitus, hearing loss and a feeling of pressure in my ear - it drives me bonkers, and really affects the quality of my life! It may not be as serious as cancer, but GPs don't just deal with cancer all day; and I believe I should be able to get treatment for my blocked ear on the NHS, rather than having to pay for 2 sessions of micro suctioning every 3 months.

If not, we would like a rebate on the tax DH pays (and DH has been a higher rate tax payer for over 30 years), so we can pay for private health care.

Oooh a higher rate tax payer!

So am I and yet I have zero issues paying my taxes Hmm

IF all the... Just higher rate taxpayers? Rebates on the whole amount that goes to NHS? Or just for the cost of the ear thing?

Some people don't use NHS services much at all. Should they all get rebates?

That's mainly younger people- so maybe only older people and those who have chronic conditions/ have had babies etc should pay?

That's massively less funding. And setting up and running the rebate system you propose would take a good chunk of it, very complex.

Your DH is self employed? He could get private healthcare for the family. Shame doesn't work for a decent company- loads have it as a standard benefit now.

roarfeckingroarr · 04/08/2021 21:06

@Wintercoffee you think the govt shouldn't pay for your vitamins ???!!

Paquerette · 04/08/2021 20:44

@Anonawoman

I think some are assuming the Dr triages the e consult they don’t! And the reply in 48 hours can simply be “your e consult will be seen by the GP next Wednesday” it doesn’t have to be a resolution or answer often the gp won’t see the e consult until the week after it was sent /whenever a slot is available and sometimes the reply will be “please call the surgery to book a face to face appt” so they aren’t the short cut that some people seem to think. They still count as an appt and take up the GP time so are pencilled in as a slot. However yes they are very useful if you don’t want to wait on the phone! A good time to ring if you don’t need an urgent appt is in the afternoon it’s not as manic.
I don’t think that the eConsult is as crap as you think. You get a feedback form a couple of days after your eConsult which asks quite a lot of detail about whether you heard from the GP within the 48 hours, whether you got a GP appointment/referral/whether your problem has been resolved.
Zotter · 04/08/2021 19:46

BMA concerned. www.bma.org.uk/news-and-opinion/health-and-care-bill-bma-demands-greater-protection-for-patients-and-nhs

Sorry too ill to write more today.

LemonRoses · 04/08/2021 19:41

HmmmmmmInteresting. I’m patient. A few key evidence sources to start, perhaps. Not anecdotes, not scaremongering stories but good solid evidence. Say, five sources?

Zotter · 04/08/2021 19:37
  • to clarify that is only moves to creeping privatisation for profit model. Not non profit insurance models.
Zotter · 04/08/2021 19:35

@OhWhyNot

Zotter you would have to have public backing to move on to a system like they have in the US

You absolutely would not have it here. There needs to be decisions on what the NHS will fund and eBay can be funded through insurance

People in the US have a very different attitude towards healthcare than we do here. Any party that moved took away the NHS will be in opposition for a long time

The NHS really isn’t fantastic we should have a better service but we need to pay more what it was set up for is not what the NHS now provides as medical science has expanded and we are living a lot longer

Ridiculous amounts of money is wasted in the NHS but the money has to be spent to be accumulated foe next year it’s needs a change it can not cover every healthcare aspect we expect the NHS to

Such discussions aren’t happening. Only moves to creeping privatisation. Agree we need to pay more. Other European countries pay higher % of GDP on healthcare.

It’s true tories threatening to privatise the NHS has been said since the 70's but unlike justanotherlurker (with their tiresome accusation in so many threads that people lack critical thinking skills) I believe Tories are managing to inch us closer than ever.

Now the government is planning NHS legislation in England that will allow for more American-style privatisation. In July Conservative MPs voted for the Health and Care Bill through its second reading in Parliament.

“Campaigners warn that the Bill will increase the private sector’s involvement in the NHS and have called for Health Secretary Sajid Javid to withdraw it. Among their concerns are proposed changes to the rules for contracting NHS services. Current legislation requires a process of compulsory competitive tendering for NHS services, but the Bill would end this requirement.

Campaigners say that this would make it much easier for services to be contracted to the private sector without the appropriate checks and balances.

Concerns have also been raised about the introduction of integrated care system boards, which will bring together bodies working within the NHS — including private firms — to work on public health strategy.”

Anonawoman · 04/08/2021 18:51

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at OP's request.

Paquerette · 04/08/2021 18:22

Does it matter who sees the eConsult first? All eConsult submissions have to be seen by a Dr, and a reply sent or appointment booked within 48 hours. If you’re struggling to get through on the phone to book an appointment or the receptionist is refusing to book you in, the eConsult guarantees that a Dr has triaged your medical problem.

Westchesterarms · 04/08/2021 16:53

@IvyM. Ooo, thank you. It's always interesting to hear from someone in the know. I read GPs had been told to get back to face to face appointments if patients requested it, but GPs were complaining about that and wanted to keep triage and phone consults. But from what you say it sounds that that has been reported wrong and the govt is actually trying to stop face to face consults by introducing awkward protocols. Have I got that right? It's so hard to know what to believe these days.

Anonawoman · 04/08/2021 16:45

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at OP's request.

Intercity225 · 04/08/2021 16:43

You say you have the money so pay. It's cheaper than the hairdresser.

I may do now. DH could drop dead tomorrow, seeing as he has not been able to get a face to face appointment with the cardiology department since March 2020. Would someone, just living on the state pension be able to afford £200 every 3 months? I don't think so, nor would they be able to afford a hairdresser for £200 a time!

Is tinnitus, hearing loss and pressure in the ear medical problems or not? There shouldn't be this creeping privatisation of NHS services, like dentistry, now ear syringing, etc - because the point of the NHS was to maintain the health of the work force, by giving equal access to it for all. If I say, this tinnitus and hearing loss are driving me bonkers, I can't cope with caring for DDs, I will look to Social Services and the CCG to fund that extra care, the country won't be saving any money!

IvyM · 04/08/2021 16:34

My partner works within the NHS (senior consultant), he says the government is issuing protocols that when followed will bit by bit bring it's downfall. The pandemic was used as an excuse to bring this about sooner. Practices who used to still function and see patients now need to jump through hoops and devise new local protocols to combat those issued by the government. This means more work for the same pay, of course the majority would rather not go down that lane.

Swipe left for the next trending thread