Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's rude to juat assume I'll supply a reference?

138 replies

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 16:54

I'm a teacher in FE. I've been off on leave - returning next week so thought I'd log in and clear the crap put of my inbox today.

There are 5 reference requests from ex (adult) students. Only 1 has asked me first before putting my name forward.

I only teach a gcse re-sit subjects do I'm not the "go to" professional reference person

One company has emailed 3x asking for the reference despite my Out of Office stating I'm off until the 12th

When I go back I'm straight back into new student interviews, assessments and training so will struggle to find spare time.

One of the 5 I definitely won't be doing - the student was work why, demanding and always late!

OP posts:
Ivy48 · 03/08/2021 18:04

If they’re ex students are they able to even contact you? I know when I left uni and lost access to my email account I lost a lot of contact details and jobs have contacted the uni directly and references must have been directed to the correct person. Perhaps they are unsure
How to contact you first? Maybe you should let people you teach know you’re happy to give one but please ask first from now on and take it as a learning curve? Plus if you e applied for a new job and need to give a reference and it’s been 2+ years since leaving FE you’re hardly likely to still be in touch and may feel awkward contacting you directly but have no other references to give

pippistrelle · 03/08/2021 18:03

It is rude, but they probably don't mean to be.

I know of a student who provided a lecturer's name as a referee. The lecturer gave the reference and mentioned to the student, very nicely, that if she had passed on staff details, she should let them know. The student submitted a complaint.

ClaudiaWankleman · 03/08/2021 17:59

So that must take what, half an hour of your time?

Do you type with a singular goose feather instead of your fingers?

@anonforamo has pretty much written the email, you just have to reformat it. The longest amount of time it could have taken is the 8 minutes between the OP and this post.

BridgeOfLies · 03/08/2021 17:58

@anonforamo

I get these all the time! The way I see it, it's part of the job. I also use it as a learning opportunity. Typically I email the student if I have their details and tell them how excited I am they are pursuing whatever opportunity this is. I ask them a bit about role/course and then also suggest perhaps reaching our directly to ask if someone would mind being a reference, and tell them that helps me plan what to say and deal with it in a timely manner. This is an impressionable age and a bit of care and encouragement can go a long way.
Can I just say you sound absolutely lovely. Lucky students Flowers
Workyticket · 03/08/2021 17:57

@MarcusRashford

You sound like one of life’s terminally offended.
For not wanting to do work during the holidays that I've not been asked politely to do?
OP posts:
HollowTalk · 03/08/2021 17:53

@anonforamo

I get these all the time! The way I see it, it's part of the job. I also use it as a learning opportunity. Typically I email the student if I have their details and tell them how excited I am they are pursuing whatever opportunity this is. I ask them a bit about role/course and then also suggest perhaps reaching our directly to ask if someone would mind being a reference, and tell them that helps me plan what to say and deal with it in a timely manner. This is an impressionable age and a bit of care and encouragement can go a long way.
So that must take what, half an hour of your time? Just how many students do you teach?
MarcusRashford · 03/08/2021 17:52

You sound like one of life’s terminally offended.

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 17:51

@memberofthewedding

Its rude of the students but this is probably how their parents have brought them up to be so entitled. It seems that expressions like "please" "excuse me" and "sorry" are now dirty works, not only with the kids but also with parents who never taught their offspring these simple basic skills.

I can think of one business owning colleague who had to choose between two equally well qualified job applicants but selected one because the other was rude to his secretary!

I would make up a basic standard reference and send that off for all the students who failed to ask permission and save your efforts for those who contacted you first.

eh? They are adults

And they've not spent a year in my class without using please and thank you. Not a chance

OP posts:
Workyticket · 03/08/2021 17:50

I'm not at work. I won't be until the 12th. My laptop is at the repair place and they're not easy to do on my phone

These aren't students who've emailed asking me to write a few words - they're employers etc who have sent me reference forms so they're all different

They are adults - youngest is 27.

I've not said I'm not writing them - so I'm not 'mean'

I asked if it was rude for people to put me forward without asking

As I said - I'm not always suitable as some are 'employer specific'

OP posts:
lioncitygirl · 03/08/2021 17:49

I would find it rude - but I am over polite. 😂

ThePlantsitter · 03/08/2021 17:48

@memberofthewedding

Its rude of the students but this is probably how their parents have brought them up to be so entitled. It seems that expressions like "please" "excuse me" and "sorry" are now dirty works, not only with the kids but also with parents who never taught their offspring these simple basic skills.

I can think of one business owning colleague who had to choose between two equally well qualified job applicants but selected one because the other was rude to his secretary!

I would make up a basic standard reference and send that off for all the students who failed to ask permission and save your efforts for those who contacted you first.

Utter nonsense. Most young people I know are very polite. Additionally they have just basically given up a year of their youth to protect the generations above them from a disease that doesn't really affect them, so they are deserving of our respect and thanks actually.
TheDevils · 03/08/2021 17:46

I get that it's frustrating but it is part of the job.
I'm a uni academic and currently have 6 requests sitting in my inbox.

They don't take that long but could obviously make a difference.

I find it more annoying when the companies asking for the reference are rude - one I received today pretty much demanded a reference by close of play tomorrow!

Mistlewoeandwhine · 03/08/2021 17:43

Just do it. Help people. That’s what teaching is all about. (I’m a secondary school teacher). You can also email the people who have used you as a referee with a heads up on the proprieties of asking for references. A lot of people just don’t know these things and a lot of people come from deprived backgrounds which don’t supply that sort of information.

memberofthewedding · 03/08/2021 17:42

Its rude of the students but this is probably how their parents have brought them up to be so entitled. It seems that expressions like "please" "excuse me" and "sorry" are now dirty works, not only with the kids but also with parents who never taught their offspring these simple basic skills.

I can think of one business owning colleague who had to choose between two equally well qualified job applicants but selected one because the other was rude to his secretary!

I would make up a basic standard reference and send that off for all the students who failed to ask permission and save your efforts for those who contacted you first.

TableFlowerss · 03/08/2021 17:40

Part of the job surely? Perhaps a bit rude to not ask you first, fair enough, but they probably assume that it’s ok, as they won’t have a long list of suitable referees.

Most places do ask for an academic reference so if you’re a teacher, it stands to reason that this will be included in any teaching role?

ClaudiaWankleman · 03/08/2021 17:39

It is rude if they know that it is rude. If they simply don't know they are supposed to ask first, then they are ignorant of convention, not intentionally rude.

I agree. Presumably these are adults who have taken your class in order to move on in their professional lives, and in all likelihood it's the first time they've been asked to supply a reference - not all jobs would require it and especially not if they don't require GCSE subjects.

It's annoying, and it wouldn't be unreasonable to send emails to your students reminding them they should ask you before putting your name down, but it seems quite petty to just refuse to do it.

As for writing 5 references, you can probably copy paste the structure of the first one and change names and adjectives. They're all going to be asking the same kinds of things (how you know them, how long you knew them, whether you directly supervised them etc).

NumberTheory · 03/08/2021 17:33

Given they are adults redoing GCSEs you may be a bit unreasonable about them not asking you in advance. I think this depends on what sorts of students you are teaching.

If your students are redoing GCSEs because they didn’t do well in school and haven’t really managed to establish themselves as working adults yet, then I think their actions are down to ignorance and inexperience, not rudeness. And it ought to be part of the FE experience to instill knowledge about how to go about applying for jobs and getting references which would include you being more understanding and letting them know the right way to do stuff.

But if your students are generally already successful in work and are likely doing this GCSE out of personal interest or to further their already established working lives then they really ought to know better and yes, it’s rude.

My teaching friends and family have always talked about writing references as part of the job and specifically talked about the ethical challenges in writing references for students who were not exactly models of diligence or academic excellence. So I think YABU on that front too if you’re talking about a student who is not already established in a career.

Demelza82 · 03/08/2021 17:26

@SuperSange

In the time it took you to type out your post, you could have got it done.
This!
Elleherd · 03/08/2021 17:25

It is rude if they know that it is rude. If they simply don't know they are supposed to ask first, then they are ignorant of convention, not intentionally rude.

Neapolitanicecream · 03/08/2021 17:15

anonforamo - very supportive. Great to know people like you are looking out for the kids. They need all the help they can get this year, presume it’s not Daddy’s friends company as it is round our parts so other kids don’t even get a look in.

ThePlantsitter · 03/08/2021 17:12

I think you could make it clear they need to talk to you before putting you as a referee at some point during the course if this is a regular occurrence.

Obviously the ??? guy is a twat but you could write him a really enjoyably passive aggressive response about what the accepted method of getting someone to write you a reference is.

Mpsister · 03/08/2021 17:11

They're not kids, the OP said they're adult students. I think it's rude. I sometimes get emails from ex students telling me that they've given my name as referee. Not asking me, telling me. I think that's even worse

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 17:10

@DoodleBelle

It’s rude, of course it is, but they are just kids and I agree it’s part of the job really. Perhaps email them to say in future it’s good practice to ask people before using them as a reference so they know for next time. They are still learning how to function as adults. I think it would be very mean spirited to deny any of them a reference and you can use this as a teaching moment.
they're adult students
OP posts:
Hemingwaycat · 03/08/2021 17:10

Part of the job isn’t it? I do this without thinking now!

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 17:09

@Hont1986

I think it's a bit mean not to, really. If you aren't the go-to person, then if people had anyone better to put down, my guess is they would have.
I've not said I'm not going to. I've written lots over the years
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread