Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's rude to juat assume I'll supply a reference?

138 replies

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 16:54

I'm a teacher in FE. I've been off on leave - returning next week so thought I'd log in and clear the crap put of my inbox today.

There are 5 reference requests from ex (adult) students. Only 1 has asked me first before putting my name forward.

I only teach a gcse re-sit subjects do I'm not the "go to" professional reference person

One company has emailed 3x asking for the reference despite my Out of Office stating I'm off until the 12th

When I go back I'm straight back into new student interviews, assessments and training so will struggle to find spare time.

One of the 5 I definitely won't be doing - the student was work why, demanding and always late!

OP posts:
Thatsjustwhatithink · 03/08/2021 19:40

As a teacher surely it's a measure of success that your students are asking you to be their reference, especially adults who have come back to learn?

This is them trying to get on in life, by getting a job...and you think it's a big inconvenience? Are you sure teaching is for you?

fourminutestosavetheworld · 03/08/2021 19:34

OP, would you consider the possibility that they weren't trying to be rude but just didn't know?

If you were face-to-face teaching, perhaps they would have mentioned it but doing everything online has changed the dynamic a bit.

Perhaps they also feel let down by their educational experience this year.

Perhaps they thought it was part of your role.

I think YANBU to be irritated about it, and within your rights to leave it until convenient to respond. But do at least try to think the best instead of the worst of them.

Planttrees · 03/08/2021 19:34

I regularly give references in the course of my work and never expect to be asked first. I thought it was just part of the job and would always be happy to provide a student with a reference. You don't sound very supportive of your students.

GCAcademic · 03/08/2021 19:29

Most people would be capable of doing these five references inside of 30 minutes. Shocking to think the OP is a teacher in Further Education (College level,) when she seemingly isn't capable - or isn't arsed - to do five small references for ex pupils

I don’t know what kind of references you write, but my experience of writing them is that they take considerably longer than that. I spend about half an hour on a reference, unless it’s one of those tick box or scoring exercises. For certain purposes, it can take even longer than that.

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 19:29

@NumberTheory

Given what you say about your students YANBU at all. I wouldn’t put too much thought into it now, though. You have out-of-office switched on so the requesting companies will know not to expect anything until after the 12th (something the students themselves would have been aware of had they asked). When you get back to work write one message to send to all of them saying you are sorry you were away when the requests came in and if the references are still wanted could they please re-request and you will get around to them on [whatever date you are likely to have the time for them]. Send a copy to each student with a note saying it is the done thing to contact someone before using them as a reference and pointing out that issues like this is one of the reasons why as it doesn’t reflect brilliantly well on them.

Hope your students do well on results day!

thank you - i can't wait for results day.

Most know ish how they've done. A few didn't want scores from the assessments we did as they didn't want to worry over the summer.

ALL those who worried and chose not to get scores have ACED them. One in particular is a fabulous, kind woman with no self confidence. She smashed it and will be a bloody fantastic SEN teacher once she finishes the course she can now enrol on Smile

OP posts:
Skysblue · 03/08/2021 19:29

My old employer references just say that Name was employed between X date and Y date in Z role. No waffle or personal stuff. I think that’s pretty standard? Can’t you just reply I confirm that I taught the student between these dates and they obtained X grade in their exam.

Or just apologise and say that you have a policy of not doing references for your students. That does seem VERY weird tho I have never heard of a teacher being that unsupportive before. I thought this kind of thing was part of your job and your students obviously think that too.

burnoutbabe · 03/08/2021 19:26

I think all these request should be directed at a central admin person. Not just sent to whichever teacher you fancy (and therefore may well be an unfair distribution of who does then)

I had to have one to apply for a masters. We are told to ask academic advisor (allocated at start of course) . He is on sabbatical for 6 months. Luckily the next Chap I emailed said yes. But I was a bit lost ad to who to ask, what the etiquette was, how much to follow up, it's holidays etc. And I am also a qualified accountant of 25 years. I asked the under grad office and they just said "oh maybe person x".

But really it could all be simpler, like at work, hr do all references, they have the data. I assumed all tutors wrote an end of term report for each g student that anyone could crib.

Hopefully mine is one and done but a few students have had to email around loads before finding someone to agree.

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 19:25

You're well over invested in this @AngryWhompingWillow
You can roll-out your "I shall ask again" ahite as much as you want. I couldn't give a flying fuck.

I have 5 students making demands of me - I don't need you doing it too ;)

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 03/08/2021 19:23

Given what you say about your students YANBU at all. I wouldn’t put too much thought into it now, though. You have out-of-office switched on so the requesting companies will know not to expect anything until after the 12th (something the students themselves would have been aware of had they asked). When you get back to work write one message to send to all of them saying you are sorry you were away when the requests came in and if the references are still wanted could they please re-request and you will get around to them on [whatever date you are likely to have the time for them]. Send a copy to each student with a note saying it is the done thing to contact someone before using them as a reference and pointing out that issues like this is one of the reasons why as it doesn’t reflect brilliantly well on them.

Hope your students do well on results day!

Pastrydame · 03/08/2021 19:23

It is really, really hard to write a reference for someone who wasn't very good. Much easier if they were a great student/employee, the words just flow.

GCAcademic · 03/08/2021 19:22

I don’t write references unless I’ve been told by the student that a request is coming my way. How do you know, otherwise, that you have their consent to provide the third party with information about them?

AngryWhompingWillow · 03/08/2021 19:22

Last paragraph should read...

"And I shall ask again, what was the point of posting this thread, asking 'Am I Being Unreasonable?' when you are just telling everyone who disagrees with you, that they are 'wrong' and you are NOT being unreasonable?! ...."

onelittlefrog · 03/08/2021 19:22

@Workyticket

we've been online for half of this year - I've not really encountered this before - where people juat stick me down without asking/ giving me a heads up

A couple in the past have asked and I've happily said yes, assuming it was a character reference or an academic one - one big employer in our region insists on a previous employer one though so I know that I can't be a referee for those applications. A heads up saves them giving my email to the company, me saying I can't give an employer reference and them having to go back to HR, retract my name and give another.

I get why you're frustrated but it's the sort of thing that young people learn from experience, or from being directly told what to do. They don't just know this stuff.

Maybe when they are face to face in college they have careers advisors/ tutors spell this stuff out for them, but they haven't had that input whilst they've been online? And not everyone has parents who will guide them with this stuff so how are they meant to know?

Chances are they just don't know the etiquette. I think you should give them a break.

AngryWhompingWillow · 03/08/2021 19:20

@Astella

In the time it took you to type out your post, you could have got it done.

@SuperSange

I agree with this!

I agree. The OP has posted not one, but SEVENTEEN lengthy, and/or waffly posts on here, so far; defending herself, saying how wonderful and super helpful she is, and how wrong everyone is, who disagrees with her!

Yet she claims 'I just don't have TIME to do references for just FIVE of my ex pupils!' Confused

Most people would be capable of doing these five references inside of 30 minutes. Shocking to think the OP is a teacher in Further Education (College level,) when she seemingly isn't capable - or isn't arsed - to do five small references for ex pupils. Hmm

So which is it ??? @Workyticket

You can't be arsed?

Or you are incapable of doing it?

Because it's definitely one of the above.

And I shall ask again, what was the point of posting this thread, asking 'Am I Being Unreasonable?' when you are just telling everyone who disagrees with you, that they are 'wrong' and you and NOT being unreasonable?! Confused

sonjadog · 03/08/2021 19:18

I work in education and I would find it rude. I would still do it, but I at my own convenience and not in the middle of my summer holidays.

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 19:17

we've been online for half of this year - I've not really encountered this before - where people juat stick me down without asking/ giving me a heads up

A couple in the past have asked and I've happily said yes, assuming it was a character reference or an academic one - one big employer in our region insists on a previous employer one though so I know that I can't be a referee for those applications. A heads up saves them giving my email to the company, me saying I can't give an employer reference and them having to go back to HR, retract my name and give another.

OP posts:
Hercisback · 03/08/2021 19:16

Not everyone who didn't get their GCSE at 16 needs allowances for other things.

More than aware of this, however you have to accept a fair few of them may not realise asking for a reference is a social expectation. I get why you feel annoyed. I'm a teacher too and get requests like this, some direct from college/employers. I email the student a standard "yes I'll do it, it's polite to ask first so you know for next time".

Reply after 12th as your out of office says.

onelittlefrog · 03/08/2021 19:16

@Workyticket

They're not kids.
Well I work with young people and anyone up to 25 I will generally call a kid. On the whole, they've still got a lot of growing up to do and as the adult in this situation I wouldn't be getting offended by the fact that they are behaving like kids/ being a bit rude not asking you in advance. That's just how they are.

If it really bothers you, tell them in advance whilst you are teaching them that you don't give references unless they submit a polite email asking you directly for one.

A lot of young people just don't know the etiquette for these things. It's a bit of a silly thing for you to get offended by tbh.

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 19:12

They're not kids.

OP posts:
onelittlefrog · 03/08/2021 19:12

It's part of your job.

If it really bothers you then you should probably just say to the students in your class that you don't provide references when they leave and they need to ask someone else, but it's a bit off to be honest.

They're just kids, just fill in the form for them. It only takes a few minutes.

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 19:09

@Hercisback

Doesn't mean I can't expect a quick message to say "would you mind if I put your name down..."

The people you are expecting an email from may not be aware it is something you expect. Make that clear to them, and future students, then you can absolutely feel aggrieved.

They're mainly people hoping to re-train as nurses, midwives, teachers, pharmacists... or be promoted at work.

Not everyone who didn't get their GCSE at 16 needs allowances for other things.

I bloody love my students - for the vast majority I will write a glowing reference and cross everything that they get the job / promotion / place on the course

OP posts:
LauraFlashley · 03/08/2021 19:06

Yes, you are being a jobsworth.

Either you write references or you don't. When it comes to the end of the year or whenever the requests start to come in tell your students that you don't write them or you do but would appreciate a heads up that they would like to put you down as a reference. It's highly likely that some of them need to know this.

What exactly do you need to cover? Punctuality, teamwork, how they interact, their approach to study, etc. etc. For each area, have a few sentences then copy and paste for each student. Considering the fact that you barely know some of them, I would literally keep it to a paragraph for each student.

If you feel that strongly about it then tell them that you don't do references. Job done.

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 19:05

@EleanorOlephantisjustfine

It’s routine rather than rude. To refuse would be petty and unprofessional.
Who said I was refusing?
OP posts:
EleanorOlephantisjustfine · 03/08/2021 19:05

It’s routine rather than rude. To refuse would be petty and unprofessional.

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 19:03

I logged in to do a quick spam delete. Literally a 2 minute job. I wanted to check bank details for a retirement collection i want to donate to too.

I'm back in on the 12th. Safeguarding meeting at 8.30. It's results day so it'll be manic. Interviewing new students all afternoon blah blah

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread