Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's rude to juat assume I'll supply a reference?

138 replies

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 16:54

I'm a teacher in FE. I've been off on leave - returning next week so thought I'd log in and clear the crap put of my inbox today.

There are 5 reference requests from ex (adult) students. Only 1 has asked me first before putting my name forward.

I only teach a gcse re-sit subjects do I'm not the "go to" professional reference person

One company has emailed 3x asking for the reference despite my Out of Office stating I'm off until the 12th

When I go back I'm straight back into new student interviews, assessments and training so will struggle to find spare time.

One of the 5 I definitely won't be doing - the student was work why, demanding and always late!

OP posts:
Workyticket · 03/08/2021 22:04

@Senoritarita

Thank you. I think I've wound myself up because I can't do them without the laptop as much as I'm annoyed that they've not offered the courtesy of asking.

I like 4 of them and want them to well and the teacher guilt kicked in that I've not spotted them sooner because I've been off

OP posts:
senoritarita · 03/08/2021 20:50

You're not unreasonable. Manners cost nothing and these people are rude.

I work in a job where I get reference requests all the time. I also send them out a lot and often don't get replies back.

Here's what you can do to.

Ignore them all whilst you're on leave

Reply back asking for proof that the candidate has given them permission to contact you. This buys you more time. Why not copy the candidate so they know you haven't been asked

Write up very basic refs which you can copy and paste. Unless you want to go out of your way to help people

TheBestPlansAlwaysFail · 03/08/2021 20:45

@Workyticket I'm in HE rather than FE but I have adopted a strict "not checking emails on AL policy" (I do but they don't need to know - I am in Scotland, so "I'll be up a hill somewhere" works well!). Anyone who can reasonably ask for a reference knows they won't get a repy becaue I told them.

I do think a lot has to do with people not being taught how to ask for a reference (which is why I tell mine) but that still doesn't make it your issue. I recommend telling them, though, saves a lot of work!

MrsSchadenfreude · 03/08/2021 20:41

I am brutally honest if I give a phone reference. Grin I told one woman who rang up for a reference for one of our bright young things, that she was outstanding at her job, when she did it. She also brought a lot of drama and unreliability to the party, and on balance I felt I would rather have someone less good, whom we could train, but more reliable, and who didn’t have screaming hysterics if things didn’t go her way.

I also hate people not asking first. I have two friends that I haven’t really seen for about 8 years, who always put me down as a referee without asking, largely because I have an impressive job title. It’s an utter pain in the arse to do, particularly if it’s one of those pesky forms that goes through minutiae of previous jobs, their strengths and weaknesses etc.

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 20:28

@ThinWomansBrain

it's rude not to ask - I always ask current and present employers, let alone an academic referee. I would let the employers know when you expect to complete it by, email the students to confirm that you have done it - and that it expected practice/polite to notify the person they are asking to provide a reference in advance of the request.

and the work shy twat - either be brutally honest, or just confirm the dates he was a student.

Not allowed to be brutally honest these days unfortunately. I'll definitely reply with his attendance dates - will involve logging in though so he'll have to wait!

I've genuinely never put someone forward as a reference without asking!

OP posts:
ThinWomansBrain · 03/08/2021 20:19

it's rude not to ask - I always ask current and present employers, let alone an academic referee.
I would let the employers know when you expect to complete it by, email the students to confirm that you have done it - and that it expected practice/polite to notify the person they are asking to provide a reference in advance of the request.

and the work shy twat - either be brutally honest, or just confirm the dates he was a student.

AngryWhompingWillow · 03/08/2021 20:16

@jacks11

YANBU

Too many excuses made. Young adults or older, it is rude. I don’t think it’s too much to expect that someone wishing you to do something for them will ask whether you are willing to do so (preferably nicely), rather than just expecting you to do it as and when demanded.

Being young does not mean it is reasonable to expect to click your fingers and someone meets your demands. In any case, these are adults!

If someone did not ask me first, regardless of age or background, I would not be doing the reference. And if they sent me a line of ????? as a way to try and prompt me to meet their demands, then I might be tempted to do an extremely honest reference, stating exactly what I thought of them. I suspect they would not appreciate that though.

However, the responses have been illuminating. It explains a lot about how we have got to the current state of affairs where the levels of entitlement across all age groups are quite often astounding and expectations are frequently unrealistic. Basic manners is all that is required.

I mean- do you really need to be told that you should ask someone for a favour? As opposed to demanding they do something just because you’ve decided you need them to?

If you read the full thread; MOST people agree that it's a bit rude for these ex students to assume someone will do a reference. What is getting people backs up is that the whole demeanour and attitude of the OP just stinks! ... Wink
Hercisback · 03/08/2021 20:14

@jacks11

That's a scathing post. Until I had to write a reference for someone I had no idea what a task it was. It didn't really register as asking someone a favour Blush. I suppose I kind of assumed it was my uni tutor/sixth form teachers job. On reflection this attitude is awful but no one told me otherwise. They all said "if you need a reference, put me down".

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 20:14

@jacks11

YANBU

Too many excuses made. Young adults or older, it is rude. I don’t think it’s too much to expect that someone wishing you to do something for them will ask whether you are willing to do so (preferably nicely), rather than just expecting you to do it as and when demanded.

Being young does not mean it is reasonable to expect to click your fingers and someone meets your demands. In any case, these are adults!

If someone did not ask me first, regardless of age or background, I would not be doing the reference. And if they sent me a line of ????? as a way to try and prompt me to meet their demands, then I might be tempted to do an extremely honest reference, stating exactly what I thought of them. I suspect they would not appreciate that though.

However, the responses have been illuminating. It explains a lot about how we have got to the current state of affairs where the levels of entitlement across all age groups are quite often astounding and expectations are frequently unrealistic. Basic manners is all that is required.

I mean- do you really need to be told that you should ask someone for a favour? As opposed to demanding they do something just because you’ve decided you need them to?

Thank you. I really thought I was going mad.

I love my job - my students seem to like me. I have lovely relationships with the vast majority. Posters here have made me out to be worse than shit for wishing for a common courtesy :(

OP posts:
Workyticket · 03/08/2021 20:12

@PuppyMonkey

OP you said in your first post that you’re going to be mad busy with interviews etc when you get back to work so it did sound like you were saying you won’t be doing the references. And the ??? person you said you’d definitely not be doing.

But if you are doing them now, hooray. And just email the students to say “please ask first next time.”

No, I was always going to do them. As I say I've done hundreds - almost always had a heads up though which is what I'm complaining about not getting.

I'll be mad busy and it'll be hard to fit them in but of course I'll do them (except the one i mentioned)

I've got daft nails on hence the weird typos etc so really don't want to do them on my phone.

It's the one from an employer who has emailed askimg 3 times despite my Out Of Office bei.ng on. That person has a job and was doing an Access course so would definitely have others to ask.

OP posts:
jacks11 · 03/08/2021 20:09

YANBU

Too many excuses made. Young adults or older, it is rude. I don’t think it’s too much to expect that someone wishing you to do something for them will ask whether you are willing to do so (preferably nicely), rather than just expecting you to do it as and when demanded.

Being young does not mean it is reasonable to expect to click your fingers and someone meets your demands. In any case, these are adults!

If someone did not ask me first, regardless of age or background, I would not be doing the reference. And if they sent me a line of ????? as a way to try and prompt me to meet their demands, then I might be tempted to do an extremely honest reference, stating exactly what I thought of them. I suspect they would not appreciate that though.

However, the responses have been illuminating. It explains a lot about how we have got to the current state of affairs where the levels of entitlement across all age groups are quite often astounding and expectations are frequently unrealistic. Basic manners is all that is required.

I mean- do you really need to be told that you should ask someone for a favour? As opposed to demanding they do something just because you’ve decided you need them to?

PuppyMonkey · 03/08/2021 20:07

OP you said in your first post that you’re going to be mad busy with interviews etc when you get back to work so it did sound like you were saying you won’t be doing the references. And the ??? person you said you’d definitely not be doing.

But if you are doing them now, hooray. And just email the students to say “please ask first next time.”

AngryWhompingWillow · 03/08/2021 20:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

AngryWhompingWillow · 03/08/2021 20:05

[quote Thatsjustwhatithink]@Workyticket

Yeh and it would be lovely if everyone was perfect. But these are adult learners who have come back into education for GCSE level education. They are already putting themselves out there and you are making it just that but harder for these people to go on and be successful in their lives.

Like nearly all managers I write Appraisals for my staff. It's part of my job and helps them go where they want to in the career. I've had people who have left and put me down as a reference. It's good, I take it as a compliment.

Honest opinion....you sound really jack.[/quote]
Great post!

PaperMonster · 03/08/2021 20:05

I hear you @Workyticket. Thankfully I’ve only had one in the recent past who just assumed I would provide a reference. And that was a bloomin huge set of questions to answer! And he was a rare one who drove me up the wall. More recent ones have contacted me by text to double check so I don’t mind that.

newnortherner111 · 03/08/2021 19:58

If you decide to provide a reference, for those who did not ask first, make it clear in your response that you were not approached.

It would not have taken five minutes for them to have contacted you, even at the time they applied for the job.

Hercisback · 03/08/2021 19:56

Surely they know that it's asking a favour and therefore a quick heads up over Teams

They probably don't know.

I genuinely didn't know until it was pointed out on my university course.

Thatsjustwhatithink · 03/08/2021 19:56

@Workyticket

Yeh and it would be lovely if everyone was perfect. But these are adult learners who have come back into education for GCSE level education. They are already putting themselves out there and you are making it just that but harder for these people to go on and be successful in their lives.

Like nearly all managers I write Appraisals for my staff. It's part of my job and helps them go where they want to in the career. I've had people who have left and put me down as a reference. It's good, I take it as a compliment.

Honest opinion....you sound really jack.

Pastrydame · 03/08/2021 19:49

It's not part of her job while she's on leave

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 19:49

@Thatsjustwhatithink

As a teacher surely it's a measure of success that your students are asking you to be their reference, especially adults who have come back to learn?

This is them trying to get on in life, by getting a job...and you think it's a big inconvenience? Are you sure teaching is for you?

Absolutely. I love my job, I meet people every year that, if I met them outside of work, I'd like to be friends with

They often come to me for advice etc over their Access course leaders.

However surely if they like me enough that they trust me as a referee they can drop me a line "Hi Worky, remember me? I'm going for a band 4 job. Would you be my referee please? If you could mention xyz you oraises me for that would be great as it's a big part of the role I want" would be lovely!

OP posts:
ThreeWitches · 03/08/2021 19:48

@Workyticket

I'm not at work. I won't be until the 12th. My laptop is at the repair place and they're not easy to do on my phone

These aren't students who've emailed asking me to write a few words - they're employers etc who have sent me reference forms so they're all different

They are adults - youngest is 27.

I've not said I'm not writing them - so I'm not 'mean'

I asked if it was rude for people to put me forward without asking

As I said - I'm not always suitable as some are 'employer specific'

One of the 5 I definitely won't be doing
AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 03/08/2021 19:46

YABU
It’s part of the job

Magpiecomplex · 03/08/2021 19:46

@Workyticket I'm FE too - after several of these unexpected reference requests this summer, I did raise an eyebrow at them. I'm going to make sure I keep reminding my tutor groups this coming year about reference etiquette!

GintyMcGinty · 03/08/2021 19:43

This is part of your job.

YABU

Workyticket · 03/08/2021 19:43

@fourminutestosavetheworld

OP, would you consider the possibility that they weren't trying to be rude but just didn't know?

If you were face-to-face teaching, perhaps they would have mentioned it but doing everything online has changed the dynamic a bit.

Perhaps they also feel let down by their educational experience this year.

Perhaps they thought it was part of your role.

I think YANBU to be irritated about it, and within your rights to leave it until convenient to respond. But do at least try to think the best instead of the worst of them.

I can see where you're coming from and if they were school leavers then absolutely

But these are adukta applying for professional courses and promotions. Surely they know that it's asking a favour and therefore a quick heads up over Teams (their usual method of communication and something I do reply to when I'm off if it's a quick question that will put their mind at rest

Lots of them are on Access courses too so without the heads up I've no idea whether they've asked those teachers too.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread