Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'Life empty without children'

410 replies

ncncncncncncncnc12 · 03/08/2021 14:32

I am married and really want a family. Two of my close are single - I think one would like children if she met the right person and one is very vocal about not wanting them and they ruin lives / relationships etc.

We are TTC and have had some set backs this year, which they know about.

Over the weekend we were talking and they said that even if it doesn't happen for us, I will still have a great life with my husband, having nice holidays and more money etc and it's nothing to be sad about. But actually, I would be very sad if it doesn't work out, I yearn to have a family. I said that of course I love my husband but we both really want to be parents and to me (not everyone) my life would feel a bit pointless without children.

It's caused huge offence and taken that I think their life is pointless. I dont think that, but yes for me, holidays and cars are not going to fill the strong urge I have to be a mother.

Who is BU?

OP posts:
Marmitemarinaded · 06/08/2021 11:17

I think the op was deeply insensitive btw
I would never say this in real life

But on an anonymous chat forum…. I have no problem with saying this

I don’t see others having pointless lives because of no children

Actually when I think about it - I don’t give a hoot what they do and no thought to how they value their life or not!

Marmitemarinaded · 06/08/2021 11:15

I give no thought to what I would have done
I just enjoy my life. And despite wonderful friends, family, hobbies, good job - my children lie at the very centre. And I bloomin love that fact

CounsellorTroi · 06/08/2021 11:13

So if you’d have been unable to have children, you’d have done what?

People say, oh well we'd have had IVF or adopted, but none of those is a guarantee of a child....

LawnFever · 06/08/2021 10:56

@Marmitemarinaded

I have children

I have a good job, friends, a wonderful family, love running and sport and socialising. Go on spectacular holidays!

But yep…. If I didn’t have children, I honestly think my life would be, well… yes, a bit pointless!

So if you’d have been unable to have children, you’d have done what?

Given up on all the other parts of your life you enjoy? Stayed in bed all day?

Lots of people, me included haven’t had that choice, so it’s incredibly offensive to suggest my life, or anyone else’s is pointless on the basis of having children or not.

And you can say you’re talking about yourself all you like, but it’s a judgement on life in general without children.

You also have no idea whatsoever what your life would be right now without children, and you’re making the patronising judgement that having children puts you in a superior position to not having them.

Mazblue86 · 06/08/2021 10:33

I don't think OP was being unreasonable or especially insensitive. She was clearly expressing sadness/frustration/anxiety that she wouldn't achieve a deeply held desire and her friend belittled it. Maybe the OP es being a bit insensitive using the word 'pointless' but it isn't very psychologically healthy to assume that a comment on ones own life is a comment on everyone's.

I've got a friend who always stresses that she goes over 8 stone. I'm about 12 stone on a good day abs I don't sit around thinking she's calling me fat. I mean I am a bit fat but it's not up to my friend how I feel about that.

I think with genuinely close friends you should be able to be honest. Among my close friends we've all met partners and started having children at different times and had frank conversations about baby loss, marriage, children and one persons experience and feelings isn't a comment on someone else's life.

I mean this seriously, abs I'm not just being a dick, in order to be happy people need to take responsibility for their happiness, not assume that everyone else is responsible for it.

LibbyL92 · 06/08/2021 10:32

Everyone has their opinion.

I’m almost 30 and been with my partner for 7 years.

He desperately wants children and I do, well I think I do.
But on the flip side I’m so scared to give up my life and settling down. I’m really not sure if I want to do it or not. I feel like I’m losing part of me. And that scares me!

But at the same time I love children and feel like it’s the ‘right’ thing to do…

Clydesider · 06/08/2021 09:47

I find it quite sad that you think your life would be pointless without children. It's quite insulting to those who love you; you're saying they aren't enough.

You can say your 'pointless life' view applies to just you but it clearly doesn't. It's what you think about people who don't have kids. I'm childfree and I know my life isn't pointless. Probably best to keep that kind of opinion to yourself in future.

Youseethethingis · 06/08/2021 09:46

My child free best friend wasn’t offended because se knew my heart was broken and that was how I genuinely felt
Exactly as a good friend should!
When my baby was stillborn by childfree best friend sobbed along with me, didn't Witter on about how only having DS1 meant we could go on better holidays.
She's childfree, not an utter knob Hmm

CanICelebrate · 06/08/2021 09:42

@ncncncncncncncnc12

I think there are some unpleasant people on this thread deliberately not reading what you actually said.

Of course it’s ok to feel your life would be pointless without children, especially in light of a pregnancy loss. If you articulate this to good friends then I’d hope they’d understand.

When I was in hospital with severe complications in early pregnancy, I felt life had no purpose. My child free best friend wasn’t offended because se knew my heart was broken and that was how I genuinely felt.

We are TTC and have had some set backs this year, which they know about

I don’t think the miscarriage was a drip feed at all if people actually read what OP wrote.

Youseethethingis · 06/08/2021 09:29

Which is why I specifically asked
"Why must anyone feel sad for anyone who is happy?"
Obviously if someone's lifelong dreams of becoming a mother or owning their own home or moving to Australia or whatever it may be don't come true then that is said.
But a PP said she's happy and the next poster said "I find that sad"

Porcupineintherough · 06/08/2021 09:28

@CounsellorTroi you have a very altruistic view of volunteering. Most people - men and women- volunteer because they get something from it, just not money. It's not some great saintly act.

userxx · 06/08/2021 09:26

I find it sad that someone would think their life is pointless just because they didn't have children. Not hard to understand is it?

CounsellorTroi · 06/08/2021 09:26

@Youseethethingis

Why is it sad that what gives one individual the most joy in purpose is different than what another person might find? Why must anyone feel sad for anyone that is happy? Confused
Well not everyone can have children. So if someone feels that the one thing that would give them the most joy in life is the one thing they can’t have, and they feel unable to take any joy from anything else life has to offer, then that is sad.
Youseethethingis · 06/08/2021 09:18

Why is it sad that what gives one individual the most joy in purpose is different than what another person might find?
Why must anyone feel sad for anyone that is happy? Confused

userxx · 06/08/2021 09:09

@Marmitemarinaded

I have children

I have a good job, friends, a wonderful family, love running and sport and socialising. Go on spectacular holidays!

But yep…. If I didn’t have children, I honestly think my life would be, well… yes, a bit pointless!

I find that quite sad really. I suppose it depends how strong the desire to reproduce is, whether or not that is the point of your existence.

Marmitemarinaded · 06/08/2021 08:51

@EastWestWhosBest

** But don’t you see how even you saying your life would be pointless without children is offensive to childless/free people?
By saying that you are saying that without children life is pointless.**

Absolutely.
I would never say it in RL

On an anonymous chat forum? Sure

CounsellorTroi · 06/08/2021 08:47

*Why does not having children mean women need to volunteer? Ffs it’s such a sexist position.

Why is volunteering the only way to ‘leave a positive mark’ and give life purpose?

Why can’t women just live their lives fulfilled for themselves, through friends, work, art, fun, enjoying their lives putting themselves at the centre of their world?

It’s all part of the bizarre concept that not having children is ‘selfish’, which it isn’t, it’s a perfectly valid choice or for some people (like me) not a choice I made myself but one I’ve had to come to terms with.

But why do women’s lives need to be dictated by what they can do for other people/society, and be judged if they just put themselves first - it’s not ‘selfish’ when men do that.

I don’t need to validate my existence by volunteering to give my life purpose, women don’t need to apologise for their existence by paying penance through volunteering.

Why does this concept prevail that women are only here on this planet to give something to other people, that they can’t just ‘be’ and they have to be giving something/their time/their energy to some kind of greater good?

There a million ways life can have purpose and point without children and without the pressure of society feeling as women if we don’t have children we should put our own selves on the back burner because it’s somehow more important to give give give.

Nobody ever has this expectation of childless men, they can just live their lives as they please.*

Bravo. It’s this view of women as primarily nurturers and caregivers. The view that even if a woman doesn’t have children she must be a frustrated mother.

EastWestWhosBest · 06/08/2021 08:39

@Marmitemarinaded

I have children

I have a good job, friends, a wonderful family, love running and sport and socialising. Go on spectacular holidays!

But yep…. If I didn’t have children, I honestly think my life would be, well… yes, a bit pointless!

But don’t you see how even you saying your life would be pointless without children is offensive to childless/free people? By saying that you are saying that without children life is pointless.
Marmitemarinaded · 06/08/2021 08:31

I have children

I have a good job, friends, a wonderful family, love running and sport and socialising. Go on spectacular holidays!

But yep…. If I didn’t have children, I honestly think my life would be, well… yes, a bit pointless!

LawnFever · 06/08/2021 08:28

@CandidaAlbicans2

If you think your life would be pointless without children you're seriously lacking in imagination or think that life is only about passing your genes on. There's a huge amount we can do for the benefit of others and society which doesn't depend on whether we have kids or not.
Why is it, that if women don’t have children then immediately they should be benefiting others or giving something back, why is a woman only of value to society if she’s putting herself second?
LawnFever · 06/08/2021 08:20

@CandidaAlbicans2

I expressed myself clumsily and can see why my post didn't come over quite as I hoped. What I meant was if we go right back to our basic animal side, then the point of life is to mate and pass the genes on. Oh, and to be food for other animals. Just like the whole purpose of viruses is to mutate and survive. Of course we've evolved to think a little more deeply about life since then, to be far more emotional, but that's the bottom line.

Also, that if someone feels their life is pointless if they don't have children I disagree. I'd hope that the aim of parenting is to raise well adjusted and pleasant adults, which is the "benefit to society" I was thinking of. But if someone can't/won't have children they can still leave a positive mark on society in other ways, eg volunteer work, mentoring, etc. which can give their life some purpose and a point.

Why does not having children mean women need to volunteer? Ffs it’s such a sexist position.

Why is volunteering the only way to ‘leave a positive mark’ and give life purpose?

Why can’t women just live their lives fulfilled for themselves, through friends, work, art, fun, enjoying their lives putting themselves at the centre of their world?

It’s all part of the bizarre concept that not having children is ‘selfish’, which it isn’t, it’s a perfectly valid choice or for some people (like me) not a choice I made myself but one I’ve had to come to terms with.

But why do women’s lives need to be dictated by what they can do for other people/society, and be judged if they just put themselves first - it’s not ‘selfish’ when men do that.

I don’t need to validate my existence by volunteering to give my life purpose, women don’t need to apologise for their existence by paying penance through volunteering.

Why does this concept prevail that women are only here on this planet to give something to other people, that they can’t just ‘be’ and they have to be giving something/their time/their energy to some kind of greater good?

There a million ways life can have purpose and point without children and without the pressure of society feeling as women if we don’t have children we should put our own selves on the back burner because it’s somehow more important to give give give.

Nobody ever has this expectation of childless men, they can just live their lives as they please.

Porcupineintherough · 04/08/2021 20:41

I live my kids but I take umbrage at the idea that my life would be pointless without them. That's a pretty offensive choice of words tbh. Maybe keep those thoughts private.

EastWestWhosBest · 04/08/2021 20:37

What is this obsession with women without children bloody volunteering?

I shall ask my male child free friends if anyone has ever suggested to them that they should volunteer.

CandidaAlbicans2 · 04/08/2021 20:06

I expressed myself clumsily and can see why my post didn't come over quite as I hoped. What I meant was if we go right back to our basic animal side, then the point of life is to mate and pass the genes on. Oh, and to be food for other animals. Just like the whole purpose of viruses is to mutate and survive. Of course we've evolved to think a little more deeply about life since then, to be far more emotional, but that's the bottom line.

Also, that if someone feels their life is pointless if they don't have children I disagree. I'd hope that the aim of parenting is to raise well adjusted and pleasant adults, which is the "benefit to society" I was thinking of. But if someone can't/won't have children they can still leave a positive mark on society in other ways, eg volunteer work, mentoring, etc. which can give their life some purpose and a point.

BlithePilgrim · 04/08/2021 16:40

There are tonnes of us in between, unsure, uncertain, afraid of what will happen if we do, afraid of what will happen if we don't. It is rarely based upon cars, holidays abroad, having a lie or who will join us for Sunday lunch when we are old.

Yes, I think that's the key point that gets too often overlooked. Some people have utterly wanted children for as long as they can remember. Some people have known for as long as they can remember that they don't want children with a similar clarity and conviction. But for quite a lot of other people, it's a difficult and fraught decision, something to be pondered and worried about for quite some time, and not a straightforward yes/no.

And not often the kind of patronising bollocks women without children still too often get 'Oh, you'll change your mind when you're older!' as if broodiness hits all thirtysomething women alike like a tidal wave but a genuinely major life decision about what you want that life to be like, where you have to weigh up pros and cons about something that, by its nature, you can't experience until or unless you do it.

And I also get cross with the frequent riposte on here to posts about trying to decide whether or not to have a child that if you're ambivalent, you shouldn't bother, with the implication that if you have to give it any thought, parenthood is not for you.

It's a huge life decision -- it's hardly surprising that it's not a straightforward yes or no for many people, and it's certainly not any indication that if you haven't had ovaries screaming out for babies since puberty you shouldn't have a child.

What I tend to say on threads from people trying to make up their minds is that I don't recognise anything from a lot of the threads about motherhood on here, because I'm an individual who is mother to her own individual child in her own individual circumstances. There's no standard experience of parenthood. You will do it your own way, and if remaining at the top of your field in work/continuing to run marathons/going to festivals/needing time alone/travelling/living a life not exclusively defined by motherhood in whatever way is important to you, you will find a way to make it work. It is in most cases very possible to combine ordinary parenthood with other stuff.