Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'Life empty without children'

410 replies

ncncncncncncncnc12 · 03/08/2021 14:32

I am married and really want a family. Two of my close are single - I think one would like children if she met the right person and one is very vocal about not wanting them and they ruin lives / relationships etc.

We are TTC and have had some set backs this year, which they know about.

Over the weekend we were talking and they said that even if it doesn't happen for us, I will still have a great life with my husband, having nice holidays and more money etc and it's nothing to be sad about. But actually, I would be very sad if it doesn't work out, I yearn to have a family. I said that of course I love my husband but we both really want to be parents and to me (not everyone) my life would feel a bit pointless without children.

It's caused huge offence and taken that I think their life is pointless. I dont think that, but yes for me, holidays and cars are not going to fill the strong urge I have to be a mother.

Who is BU?

OP posts:
Mazblue86 · 06/08/2021 21:26

@Bizawit Again, I know that. The first thing I said when I told her was 'sorry, I know it's unfair...' Which it is. She's a bit sad, but also happy for me. I'm sad for her but not patronising enough to think she can't cope with my pregnancy. But (again) the point is that good relationships aren't so sensitive.

I certainly don't think my life is pointless without children and so wouldn't say so, but I still don't think an individual's feelings infer anything else about someone else's life.

Bizawit · 06/08/2021 21:20

[quote Mazblue86]@PurpleDaisies I know that. But she's also faking it until she makes it. It's the decision she's made at the moment and it would be a bit patronising for me to say 'I don't think you mean that...' But she knows I know she's putting a brave face on it. The point is, she's not offended by my desire to have children. [/quote]
Of course she’s not offended by your desire to have children , but I’m pretty sure if you said to her “I think my
life would be pointless if I didnt have children”, she’d be extremely offended and upset.

Agree with others that your friend is putting on a brave face, and you should tread lightly in the circumstances.

Mazblue86 · 06/08/2021 21:17

@notanothertakeaway Please believe me, I know that. We've talked about all the different feelings you can possibly imagine.I know that she is devastated but I also knows she means it when she says she's got a positive way through.

My point is that good friends can talk about difficult things and mature people can hold two feelings in their heads and separate their feelings from someone else's.

notanothertakeaway · 06/08/2021 21:12

@Mazblue86

Agreed, I don't think they're very good friends if they're going to be so easily offended. With my close friends we can talk about anything. It's complicated and hard all the marriage and babies stuff but we're all entitled to our views and feelings. One of my best friends is coming to terms with the fact that she can't have children and I am excited to be pregnant. It's hard for her that I got pregnant easily, but she also knows I lost one. She's happy for me and a little jealous (her words not mine!) and also says that she's happy to live a child free life getting richer (her words!!) while I get poorer. We just talk about the mixtures of emotions.
I think your friend is putting on a brave face and very supportive. Please be tactful and sensitive
Mazblue86 · 06/08/2021 21:10

@PurpleDaisies I know that. But she's also faking it until she makes it. It's the decision she's made at the moment and it would be a bit patronising for me to say 'I don't think you mean that...' But she knows I know she's putting a brave face on it. The point is, she's not offended by my desire to have children.

notanothertakeaway · 06/08/2021 21:05

I think YABU to suggest to anyone that their life is pointless and expect them not to be offended

PurpleDaisies · 06/08/2021 21:01

She's happy for me and a little jealous (her words not mine!) and also says that she's happy to live a child free life getting richer (her words!!) while I get poorer.

I can almost guarantee that she doesn’t actually mean that and she’s putting a brave face on it for the benefit of your friendship.

Mazblue86 · 06/08/2021 20:57

Agreed, I don't think they're very good friends if they're going to be so easily offended. With my close friends we can talk about anything. It's complicated and hard all the marriage and babies stuff but we're all entitled to our views and feelings. One of my best friends is coming to terms with the fact that she can't have children and I am excited to be pregnant. It's hard for her that I got pregnant easily, but she also knows I lost one. She's happy for me and a little jealous (her words not mine!) and also says that she's happy to live a child free life getting richer (her words!!) while I get poorer. We just talk about the mixtures of emotions.

penguinwithasuitcase · 06/08/2021 20:24

But what if your friend said “I think my life would be so pointless if I didn’t have a talent like playing the piano” ? Some people who lack a comparable talent might find that arrogant and rude for example

And others would understand that she's talking about herself, not them, and be able to have a sensitive and understanding discussion about different experiences of life.

I know which I'd prefer to be friends with.

Bizawit · 06/08/2021 19:59

@penguinwithasuitcase

Erm no not at all. Totally fine to say it’s something she really wants for her life. But to say her life would be pointless without children- the inference is rude. No need to say that at all to single, childless friends; especially since one might not be childless entirely by choice. But either way it’s insensitive. Each to their own of course. People are free to be unkind and rude to others, but they shouldn’t be surprised when offence is taken!

There is no inference at all, except what you're choosing to infer.

My friend is an incredible pianist and fully feels that's what she's made to do –she'd quite confidently say her life would feel pointless without being able to play.

And I can quite happily hear that without thinking she's saying MY life is pointless because I can just about manage Chopsticks on the piano, nor do I have any inclination to learn more.

And yes, before the outrage brigade jumps on the analogy, I am fully aware that a baby is not a piano.

I’m not “choosing” to infer anything. In my opinion saying “my life would feel pointless without children” is an insensitive thing to say to a single / childless friend. I felt the same way before I had my baby , but I wouldn’t put it like that to others who don’t have children , as I’d worry it would come across as rude/ hurt their feelings.. on the other hand I do agree that it was the OP’s grief talking and she’s been through a lot so deserves some grace.

I don’t think your analogy about your friend and her piano is comparable for a number of reasons. But what if your friend said “I think my life would be so pointless if I didn’t have a talent like playing the piano” ? Some people who lack a comparable talent might find that arrogant and rude for example..

LolaSmiles · 06/08/2021 19:57

It’s like someone saying “I hate package holidays, so boring!” in front of friends who love package holidays and go every year

Yes you are giving your opinion.
But it’s just thoughtless isn’t it
Not really. Somehow me and my friends manage to discuss the fact our holidays look very different and about the fact we'd not enjoy some things that each other do.
I couldn't imagine taking offence that someone said they'd not enjoy my type of holiday or would find it boring because they're not me and should be able to discuss the topic without having to think "oh crap, talking holidays with Lola, I better watch what I say in case she decides my holiday preferences are a slight on her as a person".

LolaSmiles · 06/08/2021 19:54

Erm no not at all. Totally fine to say it’s something she really wants for her life. But to say her life would be pointless without children- the inference is rude. No need to say that at all to single, childless friends; especially since one might not be childless entirely by choice. But either way it’s insensitive. Each to their own of course. People are free to be unkind and rude to others, but they shouldn’t be surprised when offence is taken!

There is no inference unless you're someone who actively seeks to find offence though. Nobody is being rude or unkind.

Person A makes a statement about how THEY feel about an element of THEIR life based on THEIR experiences and THEIR aspirations and THEIR feelings
If Person B hears Person A talking about A's feelings and does mental gymnastics to decide that obviously A is rude, incentive, has been offensive then they're probably a self-obsessed drama llama.

Marmitemarinaded · 06/08/2021 19:41

It’s like someone saying “I hate package holidays, so boring!” in front of friends who love package holidays and go every year

Yes you are giving your opinion.
But it’s just thoughtless isn’t it

penguinwithasuitcase · 06/08/2021 19:36

Erm no not at all. Totally fine to say it’s something she really wants for her life. But to say her life would be pointless without children- the inference is rude. No need to say that at all to single, childless friends; especially since one might not be childless entirely by choice. But either way it’s insensitive. Each to their own of course. People are free to be unkind and rude to others, but they shouldn’t be surprised when offence is taken!

There is no inference at all, except what you're choosing to infer.

My friend is an incredible pianist and fully feels that's what she's made to do –she'd quite confidently say her life would feel pointless without being able to play.

And I can quite happily hear that without thinking she's saying MY life is pointless because I can just about manage Chopsticks on the piano, nor do I have any inclination to learn more.

And yes, before the outrage brigade jumps on the analogy, I am fully aware that a baby is not a piano.

Bizawit · 06/08/2021 19:13

@LizzieW1969

But I don’t see it as rude at all. Rather, it was clearly her grief talking, as she’d had a miscarriage very recently. Surely, a true friend would be able to make allowances at a time like that?

Ordinarily, yes, it would be an insensitive thing to say.

Yes I agree that it sounds like grief talking and allowances should be made. Also it sounds like the friends comments were pretty insensitive too. Maybe they were trying to be helpful , but clearly what they said was misplaced/ badly judged.
Earlydancing · 06/08/2021 18:55

I think it depends on the timing of what was said.

If you'd just lost a parent and someone said now you've got you're inheritance to go on holiday. Very insensitive.

If you'd lost your parent 6 months previously and were still upset and someone suggested spending some of your inheritance to improve your life because that's what your parent would want. Then that would not be insensitive, it would be someone trying to be helpful.

Of course their comment might still feel insensitive but sometimes you've got to make allowances for intent.

MarshaBradyo · 06/08/2021 18:38

But it goes both ways surely. Saying it not happening is nothing to be sad about isn’t very sensitive. Especially after a mc at 12 weeks after you’ve announced pregnancy.

It’s a difficult time, the op doesn’t know what will happen for sure and feeling like she does is understandable

SnackQueen · 06/08/2021 18:33

Apologise and admit that you’ve become so self absorbed with your own life and so obsessed with having a baby that you clearly failed to recognise how thoughtless and hurtful your words were. Which they were.

LizzieW1969 · 06/08/2021 18:26

But I don’t see it as rude at all. Rather, it was clearly her grief talking, as she’d had a miscarriage very recently. Surely, a true friend would be able to make allowances at a time like that?

Ordinarily, yes, it would be an insensitive thing to say.

Bizawit · 06/08/2021 18:15

@LolaSmiles

Bizawit But on that logic, nobody should say anything about their their life in case their friends are incapable of comprehending that someone might talk about their OWN life using words that reflect their OWN feelings.

Why should people have to change the language that best reflects their feelings about their life circumstances because others look for offence?

Erm no not at all. Totally fine to say it’s something she really wants for her life. But to say her life would be pointless without children- the inference is rude. No need to say that at all to single, childless friends; especially since one might not be childless entirely by choice. But either way it’s insensitive. Each to their own of course. People are free to be unkind and rude to others, but they shouldn’t be surprised when offence is taken!
penguinwithasuitcase · 06/08/2021 17:55

@LolaSmiles

Bizawit But on that logic, nobody should say anything about their their life in case their friends are incapable of comprehending that someone might talk about their OWN life using words that reflect their OWN feelings.

Why should people have to change the language that best reflects their feelings about their life circumstances because others look for offence?

Amen.
LolaSmiles · 06/08/2021 17:53

Bizawit
But on that logic, nobody should say anything about their their life in case their friends are incapable of comprehending that someone might talk about their OWN life using words that reflect their OWN feelings.

Why should people have to change the language that best reflects their feelings about their life circumstances because others look for offence?

Bizawit · 06/08/2021 17:21

Your comment was pretty rude and insensitive tbh. YANBU for feeling this way, but you shouldn’t say that to single/ childless friends, as it does imply that you think their lives are pointless. I know you said you were speaking for yourself but it still sounds insensitive and rude. If you had said you would personally feel “unfulfilled” that would have been better.

cansu · 06/08/2021 17:17

I think you were a bit insensitive saying this to your friends.

PhotoGift · 06/08/2021 17:15

YUBU and I feel quite sorry for you that you’ve have such an unfulfilling life. It’s very sad.