Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'Life empty without children'

410 replies

ncncncncncncncnc12 · 03/08/2021 14:32

I am married and really want a family. Two of my close are single - I think one would like children if she met the right person and one is very vocal about not wanting them and they ruin lives / relationships etc.

We are TTC and have had some set backs this year, which they know about.

Over the weekend we were talking and they said that even if it doesn't happen for us, I will still have a great life with my husband, having nice holidays and more money etc and it's nothing to be sad about. But actually, I would be very sad if it doesn't work out, I yearn to have a family. I said that of course I love my husband but we both really want to be parents and to me (not everyone) my life would feel a bit pointless without children.

It's caused huge offence and taken that I think their life is pointless. I dont think that, but yes for me, holidays and cars are not going to fill the strong urge I have to be a mother.

Who is BU?

OP posts:
PhilippaBlake · 03/08/2021 16:05

This is one of my pet hates - when somebody says 'for me... (insert opinion/choice/preference here)' and other people then take offence and if you are commenting on their choices. It's so self-absorbed (of them, not you).

Of course you are not being unreasonable to feel as you feel and if you can't share that with your friends without them taking offence then what's the point of having them as friends?

habibibibi · 03/08/2021 16:04

I was with you until the cars and holidays comment.

My childfree friends (some by choice, some by circumstance) lead fulfilling lives and it's not all about cars and holidays. Many are involved with children in other capacities through families, friends or voluntary work even if they don't have their own. Some have very fulfilling and demanding jobs and are doing very well or they do voluntary work or do hobbies. They have other relationships with spouse, family and friends which they can devote more time to.

Of course, you're entitled to speak about YOUR life and how you feel about it. But I suspect form your comment that it was actually qiute judgemental.

FadoFado · 03/08/2021 16:03

As for childless people being able to have more, cars, holidays etc, they really do need to do something fulfilling either in their career or on a voluntary basis. I have friends who couldn't have children and they have had a wonderful life, giving of themselves to others (unostentatiously), and been extremely happy.

Maybe that's more true of people who wanted but were unable to have kids? Plenty of people who just chose not to have kids just pootle about having a happy life without feeling the need to 'give of themselves'. As laudable as that is.

sammylady37 · 03/08/2021 16:02

*Lottapianos
'Tbh as a childless woman I’m still trying to process the holidays and cars remark….'

Same here. It's incredibly tiresome and lacking in imagination to think that a childfree life is endlessly materialistic. None of this is helped by the stereotypes that parents are sensitive, empathetic saints and childfree women are all Carrie Bradshaw clones
Oh this.

All the childfree women who have careers, or travel, or have amazing hobbies.
Nope. Some of us just sit around eating biscuits*

Ah now. You forgot the designer handbags and other frivolities that we selfishly splurge on in an attempt to make our meaningless empty lives a bit better.

PostMenWithACat · 03/08/2021 16:01

Neither were in the wrong but both or all of you should possibly have kept your thoughts to yourselves and been mindful of the fact that very often what comes out of people's mouths is not what they actually have in their heads.

I wanted to be a mummy for as long as I can remember. My dolls were my world, a bit of net over my head and a friend carrying it behind me was my dream.

I had a very successful career before having my first child at 35 and frankly struggling to produce two. Oh how often I smiled and said bright things congratulating other people whilst feeling broken inside. How much harder it would have been if I'd ever worn my heart on my sleeve.

I adore my children. Grown up now. I loved their babyhood and childhoods and had the most glorious time: playing, painting, learning letters, numbers and colours, sometimes just being, stacking their opportunities for Oxbridge, etc.

Sometimes one might whisper ones dreams on MNet and get slapped down a bit. But in RL op, shhhhhhhhhhhhhh.

therocinante · 03/08/2021 16:01

@gannett

Child-free women hear variants on "life is pointless without kids" all the fucking time and often it is directed at them (even if sometimes wrapped up in more general wording, it's still intended as a dig). So I'm not surprised she took offence.

YANBU to feel how you feel - though personally I think it's quite sad if you really can't see a point to your life without children - but that word is particularly insensitive to use to child-free people, because it DOES sound like you're judging them.

This is it, I think. We hear that, or a variation of it, a LOT. From people who genuinely believe our lives are pointless without children.

So even if you 100% definitely, absolutely clarified in conversation you meant your life ONLY, there's still the unspoken "...because life is pointless without kids" that we hear a really quite weird amount. It feels like an implied judgement, because it so often is. And maybe that's her problem - I don't feel a single bit of doubt about my choice but I am still annoyed when I get this because it's so frequent, and that's my issue to get over.

But then you doubled down with the holidays and cars comment, which crosses the line from "this is a personal choice to me" into "things that may bring you joy won't bring me joy because I am fulfilling my higher purpose and I am not fulfilled by frivolous things". Which has judgemental overtones. I'd have been annoyed too, tbh.

As an aside, when an ex-friend made a comment about how they were having a third child because life was SO FULFILLING now and she was so glad she wasn't still "just selfishly thinking about myself all the time. I just look at my life now and think, well done me, I actually did something with my life" (yes, really)... I just replied "God yeah, like, for me, I'm so glad I made the right choice to not have to ask a man to do basic parenting tasks every day and just focusing on my career, so glad I did something with my life." She had the cheek to be annoyed.

EmoIsntDead · 03/08/2021 16:01

@gannett

Child-free women hear variants on "life is pointless without kids" all the fucking time and often it is directed at them (even if sometimes wrapped up in more general wording, it's still intended as a dig). So I'm not surprised she took offence.

YANBU to feel how you feel - though personally I think it's quite sad if you really can't see a point to your life without children - but that word is particularly insensitive to use to child-free people, because it DOES sound like you're judging them.

Absolutely.
leonpride · 03/08/2021 16:00

@Taliskerskye

You actually said life would be pointless without children and you wonder why they took offence.
"Life is pointless without kids"

Vs

"My life feels pointless without kids"

Not the same, and I agree with OP. If I could never have kids I wouldn't ever get over it, personally. In the same way some people say "kids ruin your life"- I wouldn't take offence as I'm secure in my decision.

TheAverageUser · 03/08/2021 16:00

I don't think either of you are BU, you just have different values.

I think you've walked into a conversation that is quite delicate to your friend because I think women who don't want children do sometimes feel judged. I'm not getting the impression that was your intention or feeling but could be worth backing down anyway.

ncncncncncncncnc12 · 03/08/2021 16:00

@EastWestWhosBest @Lottapianos apologies, I added the cars bit but it was her who said about more money and holidays

OP posts:
NeedNewKnees · 03/08/2021 15:57

Not necessarily unreasonable but very tactless! I'm not surprised your friend pulled you up on it.

Shellfishblastard · 03/08/2021 15:57

@LittleFroggie

Life would not be pointless. But where you are at in your life at the moment is making you feel this way…

So it’s rude to tell child free women that they may change their mind… but telling someone who desperately wants children doesn’t know how she’s feels is fine. Hmm

I don’t think I said that?

I don’t think it’s ok to tell anyone how they feel - although if I had a friend who was desperate to have children and couldn’t I would try and support them to see that life isn’t pointless…not minimising how they feel one bit by saying this.

Lovelybottom · 03/08/2021 15:56

Just to add though - the suggestion that single people only have cars and holidays is massively judgemental.

Lovelybottom · 03/08/2021 15:55

The problem is you said your life but they took it as a personal attack on their life choices. It's an emotive topic. I don't think you should have to justify why you want what you want but perhaps in this instance apologise, explain you were not referring to anyone but yourself. In future avoid the topic with these two.

Maggiesfarm · 03/08/2021 15:55

ncncnc, have you been trying to conceive for long? You said you have had setbacks this year but not if you have been trying for one or a couple of years or more.

If it is just this year, which let's face it has been a weird one for everybody, you may well become pregnant in the next few months.

As for childless people being able to have more, cars, holidays etc, they really do need to do something fulfilling either in their career or on a voluntary basis. I have friends who couldn't have children and they have had a wonderful life, giving of themselves to others (unostentatiously), and been extremely happy.

However you don't have to think about that sort of thing at the moment. I really hope your dream comes true before long and don't worry about your friends, you said nothing wrong.

Zelvinka · 03/08/2021 15:54

I used to feel my life would be pointless without children and think I would actually kill my self if I couldn't have children (serious MH illness) but I've gradually come to a kind of acceptance with being childfree...

You realise that your life is just as valid without children.
You still choke up at the sight of a newborn but it slowly doesn't hurt so much.
Coming to terms with being childless is like grieving.... you don't get over it as such but you slowly come to accept it.

@ncncncncncncncnc12 I hope that you will be able to conceive, and that even if you don't that friends' ill thought out words hurt a little less.

I unfollowed a relative on Facebook who kept posting shit about how a mothers love is the greatest... well it's not and I didn't need to keep reading that.
Sometimes you need to step back from hurtful people.

Sillawithans · 03/08/2021 15:53

I might also add, that it's actually a bit selfish to even have children. Once they're here they have to get on with it and live and for what really, so that their parent could live a fulfilled life.

Rosieandjim04 · 03/08/2021 15:51

I think what a child free life would be like, going travelling on a whim anywhere I wanted , nobody else to think about but me and my needs. I only have 1 child (that was unplanned) as I don't find motherhood completely fulfilling. I like having someone I love and she loves me but I'm sometimes not keen on the responsibility and how my life is an endless routine.
They both have positives and negatives.

Sillawithans · 03/08/2021 15:51

I have 3 children, never had the urge to have them, I got married and then had kids.

I can tell you that life with children is a long hard slog and I can see the benefits of having none.

I think your comment was a bit rude to be honest.

EastWestWhosBest · 03/08/2021 15:51

@Lottapianos

'Tbh as a childless woman I’m still trying to process the holidays and cars remark….'

Same here. It's incredibly tiresome and lacking in imagination to think that a childfree life is endlessly materialistic. None of this is helped by the stereotypes that parents are sensitive, empathetic saints and childfree women are all Carrie Bradshaw clones

Oh this.

All the childfree women who have careers, or travel, or have amazing hobbies.
Nope. Some of us just sit around eating biscuits.

TableFlowerss · 03/08/2021 15:49

have not gif!

foodanfagsjokiing · 03/08/2021 15:49

I definitely understand how you are feeling..my children really are my life but I 100% also understand why having children is not everyone's choice. My cousin chose not to have children and would not be remotely bothered by your comment.Good luck OP💐

TableFlowerss · 03/08/2021 15:49

Neither of you are BU as such, however I can see how you’ve both offended each other, though I’ve gif more sympathy with you OP

For someone that has no desire that have children, it’s so easy to assume life is great without kids, because that’s how they feel.

For someone that really wants them, of course the idea of a life without having any, is going to be far far worse, Than for someone that doesn’t want them.

InTheNightWeWillWish · 03/08/2021 15:49

I think you’ve both said something in the wrong way but neither of you meant any ill-will.

She thought that saying you can have a full life without children would help given your current setbacks. You found that insensitive. You then responded with an equally insensitive comment about life not being full without children. I can see what both of you were trying to say but you’ve both used the wrong words.

It’s hard to find the right words to someone who is struggling with setbacks for TTC, miscarriage and infertility. It also varies according to each couple, so I think there needs to be a bit of guidance from the couple as to what helps them. For some people it might help to focus on the benefits of a child free lifestyle and come to terms with it. For others, they don’t need ‘advice’ but someone just to unload to. It sounds like you’re the latter and so you probably need to say to your friends that you don’t want advice, you want them to be there to rant to and complain that it’s unfair.

MrsTerryPratchett · 03/08/2021 15:48

Interesting that the OP hasn't bothered coming back. Hmm