Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lunchbox contents fine for school but not holiday club

268 replies

TheLunchIsServed · 03/08/2021 12:44

DD is 7, about to go into year 3 at school.

She doesn’t always have a school hot dinner so takes a packed lunch. Usually she has

  • Ham Sandwich
  • Cheese string or babybel
  • Penguin bar or similar small type biscuit
  • Cucumber and carrot sticks
  • Apple orange or banana
  • Water

Sometimes I swap the cucumber and carrots for a homemade yogurt (fruit and greek yogurt combined). School have never commented negatively on the contents of her lunchbox, only comment I’ve ever had about it was from the headteacher the first time she took a lunchbox and I asked if it was (she’d gone in late for a reason and was taken to class by the HT) who said it sounded fine.

DD is at holiday club while I work and is taking the same packed lunch with her. She’s been before to this holiday club but I had a call to say policy has changed and she’s not allowed the cheese, yogurt (even a homemade one) or the chocolate and that lunch has to contain two portions of vegetables. They’d rather I didn’t send sugary fruit – even though DD tends to eat that at morning snack time rather than with lunch.

They’ve suggested I leave in the sandwich, cucumber and carrots, swap the cheese for another portion of vegetables – they suggested some cooked and cooled sweetcorn or tomatos (which are fruit) neither of which DD likes. They said to leave the chocolate out completely.

It’s nothing to do with hot weather as the lunchbox goes into a coolbag thing when she gets to holiday club and DD says it’s still cold when she eats it (at school I put those iceblocks in when it’s hot to keep it cool and DD says it’s nice there too).

I can’t understand why her lunchbox is fine at school but not holiday club who I was expecting to be more lenient.

So AIBU to think as I’m paying £35 a day for the service they can ignore a bit of cheese and a small chocolate bar? Or AIBU?

And if so can you make suggestions that a 7 year old will actually eat?

Rules are:

  • Two Portions of Veg
  • No nuts or seeds
  • No kiwi
  • No tahini/hummus
OP posts:
BreastedBoobilyToTheStairs · 03/08/2021 15:01

Have they actually said 'no dairy' or just no to the cheese/yogurt? Sorry, might have missed it. No dairy would suggest an allergy but if they're just picking on specific items rather than giving a blanket ban it might be to do with 'promoting health'.

It isn't unheard of for lunchbox police to crack down on high fat foods, completely ignoring the fact that children need fats for energy and instead applying an adult low-fat diet approach as a 'healthy' one. We've definitely had threads about it before.

AudHvamm · 03/08/2021 14:58

Definitely ask if there’s a dairy allergy.

I used to run a holiday club & we had one regular attendee who had severe allergies. We did ask parents not to send food with the most serious allergens, but not all paid attention. So we put other control measures in place - everyone ate lunch together, staff and kids so good supervision. We told the kids they couldn’t share food with each other (unless from same household or previously discussed with parents) and as soon as they’d finished eating they had to thoroughly wash and dry hands before going back to touch equipment. All done with the agreement of parents and kids so everyone on board. Much safer than just sending a list of banned foods.

As for the nutrition advice, it is absurd as many PP have pointed out, and there’s no way I would be following that for my own child.

Motherofalittledragon · 03/08/2021 14:56

They sound bonkers, I really can't stand the lunchbox police.

edwinbear · 03/08/2021 14:50

Personally, I can't see anything wrong with what you put in her lunchbox, she's growing, active at holiday club all day, so it looks fine to me - dairy is an important food group for children. BUT from their perspective, I'll bet it's the cheese string they have a problem with because they are so processed. I bet if it was a few crackers/breadsticks and cubes/slices of cheddar they wouldn't be concerned.

JustLyra · 03/08/2021 14:50

Do they sell lunches by any chance?

One of the holiday club providers here have got more and more ridiculous with their lunch rules that people generally find it easier to just buy their lunches… almost like that’s why they got stupid with their rules.

Demelza82 · 03/08/2021 14:49

Their service their rules. Get a grip rather than starting an argument. On a side note what you've provided for your child is trash food by any measure

Maggiesfarm · 03/08/2021 14:45

They are seriously over the top. There's nothing wrong with the lunch you usually prepare, don't give in to it.

I'm appalled that they look in the lunch box, never happened when my children were young.

purplesequins · 03/08/2021 14:38

I would ask about the no dairy request but other than that it seems fine to me (your lunchbox that is).
some settings are strict about sweets/biscuits/cake.

rantymcrantface66 · 03/08/2021 14:33

My DD's love raw veg. Dd2 will sit and eat a whole packet of mini cucumbers and a pepper like it's an apple however she doesn't seem to eat it at school so it comes back limp and unappetising. I imagine it's because some of her good friends are fussy and not eating any veg. For that reason she often has some at breakfast and for after school snack and I send things she will actually eat at lunch. I'd be pretty annoyed at a paid for holiday club dictating what could be in it. It's bad enough when schools do it (thankfully ours doesn't)

starfishmummy · 03/08/2021 14:33

@MrsFionaCharming

I’d be tempted to tell them some rubbish about how you’d been advised by a dietician she needs a high fat / calorie dense diet, then just continue to send in what you have been.
My son actually has been. The advice from her is to buy full fat everything and to add cream and butter to whatever we can. Fortunately throughout school (hes left now) my lunchboxes were never challenged!!
1WayOrAnother2 · 03/08/2021 14:32

Their plan doesn't sound healthier than yours.
I imagine that there are allergies and overweight children in the cohort?

lljkk · 03/08/2021 14:26

2 portions of veg would have been thrown away daily if in DS lunchbox....hell would freeze over before he ate raw veg. I suppose I could have sent some raw courgette & carrot chopped up, then put them in our cooking pot for evening meal, then repeat next time.

I am quite diffident but could imagine having a big paddy in OP's situation.

MagicSummer · 03/08/2021 14:25

Surely it is up to you as a parent what you feed your child? Why do the school/holiday club have a say?

godmum56 · 03/08/2021 14:24

@fruitpastille

Put the cucumber and carrot sticks in 2 small boxes so it counts as 2 veg. They have not got a leg to stand on with yogurt/cheese and I would keep putting it in. You could swap the penguin for a plain biscuit/flapjack/malt loaf if it's a chocolate issue. Excluding allergies, as long as you're not sending a Mars bar and a can of coke for lunch, it's none of their business.
nah, coke is for wimps, the hard kids get Red Bull
fruitpastille · 03/08/2021 14:22

Put the cucumber and carrot sticks in 2 small boxes so it counts as 2 veg. They have not got a leg to stand on with yogurt/cheese and I would keep putting it in. You could swap the penguin for a plain biscuit/flapjack/malt loaf if it's a chocolate issue. Excluding allergies, as long as you're not sending a Mars bar and a can of coke for lunch, it's none of their business.

Wolframhart · 03/08/2021 14:20

Unless there is a child with a dairy allergy I would tell them I will not be altering my child’s lunch. Though i would agree to remove the chocolate if they really insisted.

I’ve got an ASD kid who really struggles to eat. My goal for a packed lunch is to just get some calories into her to keep her going. We worry about nutrition on the balance of a week not at any one meal. The only veggies she consumes are blended into smoothies, I’m not wasting money and resources by putting them in her lunch.

godmum56 · 03/08/2021 14:19

I always wonder what parents do about these "healthy lunches" who have kids like I was. My whole life I haven't been able to tolerate "normal" amounts of fruit and veg or much in the way of fibre generally. If i had gone to that HC as a kid, they would NOT have liked the outcome of two portions of veg for lunch!

Ghosttile · 03/08/2021 14:18

If it isn’t a case of dairy allergy I would be Very Annoyed.

GoWalkabout · 03/08/2021 14:18

Which I believe suggests children should be having three dairy portions a day.

GoWalkabout · 03/08/2021 14:17

Can you ask them what UK government backed or nhs health advice excludes these food groups and maybe show them the eatwell plate.

Twixxed · 03/08/2021 14:16

Ridiculous. Leaving out the allergens like kiwi, tahini etc I can understand but everything else is way overboard.

Ghosttile · 03/08/2021 14:14

It has to be a dairy allergy to say no cheese or yoghurt. As to the sugar request? For £35/day they can fuck right off.

TheLunchIsServed · 03/08/2021 14:14

@MrsCrosbyNRTB

My DS (8) is at holiday club today from 8.30-4.30. He’s swimming and having football coaching. He’s SO energetic and slightly underweight as a result. He has a wholegrain cheese and pickle and tomato sandwich, a dairylea dunker thing, red peppers, cucumber and grapes, an apple, a penguin and an packet of crisps.

I really can’t get excited over a penguin. He is a great eater and very very active. He’s having mackerel with new potatoes and salad for tea. It’s all about balance, @jessycake puts it well.

We have oven baked salmon, potatoes and peas for tea (DDs choice) so the balance is there for us too.

I've just checked the website for the company and it states the lunchbox rules at the beginning of the OP but says that the rules are subject to change at any time so I may not have a leg to stand on.

OP posts:
MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 03/08/2021 14:13

Utterly rubbish. Mine would always have a healthy lunch for school but holiday club and school trips were always treat lunches. So a packet a crisps and a treat plus usual sandwiches etc.

You're paying for it so they can do one.

Lockdownbear · 03/08/2021 14:13

@AryaStarkWolf

I don't understand why Cheese is banned or yogurt (other than I guess it can be messy or something?)
Not sure about cheese but yogurt can turn if left in the heat on hot days, giving kids who might not notice a dodgy tummy.

Chocolate just makes a mess. But won't do actual harm.

My out of school ask parents not to put those in lunch boxes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread