Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lunchbox contents fine for school but not holiday club

268 replies

TheLunchIsServed · 03/08/2021 12:44

DD is 7, about to go into year 3 at school.

She doesn’t always have a school hot dinner so takes a packed lunch. Usually she has

  • Ham Sandwich
  • Cheese string or babybel
  • Penguin bar or similar small type biscuit
  • Cucumber and carrot sticks
  • Apple orange or banana
  • Water

Sometimes I swap the cucumber and carrots for a homemade yogurt (fruit and greek yogurt combined). School have never commented negatively on the contents of her lunchbox, only comment I’ve ever had about it was from the headteacher the first time she took a lunchbox and I asked if it was (she’d gone in late for a reason and was taken to class by the HT) who said it sounded fine.

DD is at holiday club while I work and is taking the same packed lunch with her. She’s been before to this holiday club but I had a call to say policy has changed and she’s not allowed the cheese, yogurt (even a homemade one) or the chocolate and that lunch has to contain two portions of vegetables. They’d rather I didn’t send sugary fruit – even though DD tends to eat that at morning snack time rather than with lunch.

They’ve suggested I leave in the sandwich, cucumber and carrots, swap the cheese for another portion of vegetables – they suggested some cooked and cooled sweetcorn or tomatos (which are fruit) neither of which DD likes. They said to leave the chocolate out completely.

It’s nothing to do with hot weather as the lunchbox goes into a coolbag thing when she gets to holiday club and DD says it’s still cold when she eats it (at school I put those iceblocks in when it’s hot to keep it cool and DD says it’s nice there too).

I can’t understand why her lunchbox is fine at school but not holiday club who I was expecting to be more lenient.

So AIBU to think as I’m paying £35 a day for the service they can ignore a bit of cheese and a small chocolate bar? Or AIBU?

And if so can you make suggestions that a 7 year old will actually eat?

Rules are:

  • Two Portions of Veg
  • No nuts or seeds
  • No kiwi
  • No tahini/hummus
OP posts:
TheCupboardOfChaos · 04/08/2021 21:00

As for allergies (disclaimer: I have a child with a severe nut allergy): where did they come from? When I was at school in the 70s and 80s, nobody had an allergy which meant entire classrooms had to be nut-free spaces. Why are they so prevalent now? It would be interesting to know.

TheCupboardOfChaos · 04/08/2021 20:58

God, it's miserable to be a 7 yo now.

A Penguin biscuit is fine. The problem is with a) people who feed their children nothing but Penguin biscuits; and b) people who impose blanket rules on people who feed their children a healthy diet which includes - shock, horror - a bit of chocolate.

I despair.

Myothercarisalsoshit · 04/08/2021 20:53

My son has a severe nut and sesame allergy. Whole nuts being banned I can understand as they do give off fumes (wrong expression but you get the gist) and can cause an allergic reaction across a room. Hummous is fine as long as the affected person doesn't eat it.
My cousin had quite a severe dairy / egg allergy and apart from not eating any of these things, no general mitigations for the other children were ever needed. In school we do have some children who react to kiwi and strawberries but we just don't give them any! This holiday club are going completely overboard here. For me, it's just arse covering to a massive extent and would also make me think that they're not really supervising the children properly whilst they're eating. As a teacher, I would, very respectfully, tell them to fuck right off.

DwangelaForever · 04/08/2021 20:41

The dairy thing is bizarre! My dad is starting school in September and in her welcome pack we got a leaflet about the importance of giving your kids dairy in their lunch box

PattyPan · 04/08/2021 20:40

@cookie4640 a vegan would never say fruit has too much sugar!

Frazzled2207 · 04/08/2021 20:38

Totally ridiculous to charge £35 then tell you ridiculous lunch rules.
I think actual school can make their own rules but this is a holiday club ffs.
My kids went today to a £15 holiday club and fairly sure there were no comments at all about the contents of the lunchboxes.

seven201 · 04/08/2021 20:27

Surely the cheese is a good source of protein! I get the penguin, but yoghurt and cheese. What has the world come to! Send the a picture of the eatwell guide inside the lunchbox.

cookie4640 · 04/08/2021 20:27

I wonder if it’s owned by a vegan?

TheJade · 04/08/2021 20:25

Unless there is a child there with some severe dairy allergy I think they’re being cheeky bastards. There is nothing wrong with the lunch you are sending x

amispeakingenglish · 04/08/2021 20:08

re safeguarding children with allergies. The world is not like that, they need to learn to safeguard themselves, why should one child go without something they want to eat because a child who is not going to eat that lunch is allergic? The allergic child's lunchbox is the one which needs to comply not everyone else. The one child is not more important than all the others. The suggested lunch box sounds like someone who wants them all to be vegan. You can choke on a nut!!!

amispeakingenglish · 04/08/2021 20:04

WTF???

Did they say why. Your child, your money, your choice for lunch box. No other child is going to eat it so why the are they laying the law down like this. Overstepping

Why no dairy? That is your choice. When children grow up they can chose, I have a vegan, a veggie one who is in between veggie and some meat and a meat eater. When small they all ate some meat as I do. Not a lot and getting less esp after the pig expose & the salmon (i know its not meat)

ForeverSausages · 04/08/2021 20:03

They should specify if a child has an allergy. It's unusual to only be allergic to cheese and chocolate rather than dairy as a whole surely?

Firstwelive · 04/08/2021 20:02

Is this holiday club run by a monastery or nunnery? Even then they'd have less rules. Is this real?

Island35 · 04/08/2021 20:00

@Secretroses

And what on earth is wrong with kiwi fruit?? Confused
My daughter is allergic to kiwi. It's quite scary.
MorganKitten · 04/08/2021 19:56

Do they have children funded by the Fuel project there? If so the lunches for every child are strict.

Lunaduckdrop · 04/08/2021 19:53

It could be some child has a dairy allergy. The problem is that with their rules, parents will struggle to get enough calories into lunchboxes. Children need enough calories!

mamabear715 · 04/08/2021 19:48

One of the happiest days of my life when the youngest of my seven left school & associated clubs etc. - the end of rules & regs!!

OH HAPPY DAY!! :-)

ForeverSausages · 04/08/2021 19:38

I literally don't know what my son would have on a sandwich if he couldn't have cheese (ASD). I put a variety of stuff in his lunchbox knowing full well he'll eat the sandwich and that's it. I was going to say, are they going to turn down your money if you ignore their crazy rules, but guessing not Wink.

me4real · 04/08/2021 19:33

Safeguarding people with allergies wouldn't explain the fruit thing at all either. That's just based on faulty science that actually discourages good nutrition, as fruit is a good thing to include in the diet, as well as having antioxidants etc.

TedImgoingmad · 04/08/2021 19:27

Ask them where in their contractual relationship with you they have stated they can police her lunch boxes.

SpeakingFranglais · 04/08/2021 19:26

Gosh the stress over bloody school lunches, hence why mine had school dinners but my healthy breakfast and balanced dinner.

Leave the dynamics to School and let them get on with it. As for out of school clubs, tell them to do one.

ConfusedCarrie · 04/08/2021 19:24

Even if it was to cater for someone with allergies, you cannot expect everyone to go without because of one child. My nephew is severely allergic to:
Dairy
Eggs
All seeds and nuts
Coconut
Seafood (except tuna)

My DB sends food in for school parties etc for all to share but never expects anyone to go with because DN cannot have it.

My own DD has a disorder which means she has trouble absorbing calcium so has to have a high calcium diet, so no cheese and no yogurt could seriously affect her calcium absorption.

lljkk · 04/08/2021 19:13

Thanks for update, OP. Carry on as you are, then. :)

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 04/08/2021 19:10

Not allowing chocolate is pretty standard.its unnecessary.

However I would take issue with blocking dairy. It's a nutritious source of fat, protein, calcium & vitamin D and while there are other sources of calcium etc, it's a palatable and widely available and provides calories some kids need.

Many schools & childcare settings have children with dairy allergies (my niece...) and do not restrict these products from other childrens lunches. You cannot force such a broad restriction on children's diets.

wildchild554 · 04/08/2021 18:58

it wont be anything to do with dairy allergy as the bread and butter or spread may still contain it otherwise they would have to ban them to and even some ham can contain it. I now this as we suffer with dairy allergy.