Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is Aunt tighter than 2 coats of paint?

64 replies

Twelveisthebestnumber · 03/08/2021 06:39

My Aunt is having a garden party at the weekend. No occasion. She just fancied one. Everyone is contributing in some way towards it with food and drink. My mum, her best friend and I are going up for 4 days to spend time with the family and help.
My Aunt is notorious for being fond of money, and as such has plenty. She also got bored in her 70's and so bought some property and now runs 2 properties as Air BnBs. The 3 of us are staying in one of these. I jokingly said to my mum we will probably get a bill at the end. Mum said it will cost us £90 for a deep clean.
AIBU to think she is being a bit cheeky?! I know it's not a lot of money for staying there but I almost feel I'd rather cut off my nose to spite my face and actually pay to stay in a different one. We will only be sleeping there and I'm quite capable of cleaning the property to a high standard and changing the bedding before we leave.
The list is way too long to provide examples of how she is so tight with money, often at her families expense, but the latest is I am doing some cosmetic work for her whilst there and it was really hard work to convince her she was getting it at cost price. I even sent her through the invoice!
AIBU Yes: pay up and be grateful
No: she's a cheeky mare

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TopTabby · 03/08/2021 14:06

Great thread title though!Grin

Persephoned · 03/08/2021 12:59

Fair enough OP! Enjoy the party and seeing your folks.

Twelveisthebestnumber · 03/08/2021 11:30

In reply to a pp she has asked us up to help her but it will still be nice to see her. It has halved the amount of time I will be at my mum's and able to visit friends and other family but that's my choice. Like I said. I will happily accept I was being unreasonable. I think in the future I will suggest we both pay the going price for our services. I will pay for the Air BnB and she will pay for her procedures. That way everything is a bit easier. I'm not going to drip feed all the things she has done in the past as it would take forever but I can assure you I'm not tight and she has benefited from my generosity considerably in the past!! It was always more the principle than money and now I can see that I was wrong. Which was why I asked!

OP posts:
CitrusIceCream · 03/08/2021 11:12

The £90 won’t just be for cleaning...it’s the cost of laundry & replacing consumables as well.

I agree with the others....you’re doing work for her “at cost price” and she’s letting you stay in her AirBnB “at cost price”.

Seems perfectly fair to me.

Yaya26 · 03/08/2021 11:04

Wow just wow 🤦

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/08/2021 10:59

Credit to you, OP, for taking on board what people have been saying.

It does sound annoying her turning up at your place, and it may well be that her sense of frugality does sometimes get stretched somewhat.

Then again, I think it's different when it's a business and not a family home. I get the hassle of having to spend time and effort to accommodate her visits to you, but you aren't actually losing money that you otherwise would have made by renting out the part of your house that she occupies, nor risking your business and sizeable investment by leaving yourself potentially open to devastating reviews.

Maybe she is unreasonable in some respects, we don't know. A lot of people can take money to extremes - whether guarding it obsessively or spending like there's never going to be a tomorrow - and a perfect middle-ground isn't always achieved. Tell us more about some of the other things she does in this vein, if you like, and we'll consider the whole case and present our judgment Grin

Bellend101 · 03/08/2021 10:59

You're the tight one. If you feel like you should stay somewhere else to make a point then do it and let your aunt earn her full rate.

M4J4 · 03/08/2021 10:58

@Twelveisthebestnumber

Well it seems that the overall opinion is I'm the tight one so I'm glad I asked. I will stay and be grateful for the accommodation. I am in no way jealous of her life and have a comparative one myself. We live abroad and she regularly invites herself despite being told it's not convenient. She says family does for family. This then involves half a day emptying and sorting out the spare room to make it a nice space for her. I am charging her £180 for work I would normally charge £500 for. She is just paying for the product. But as a pp said. It's an invitation, not a summons and I'm sure I will have a good time. I'll happily pay based on what everyone has said.
That does change things a bit, if she regularly foists herself on you then she shouldn't have charged you for the cleaning.

Do you ever just tell her, no she can't visit?

mafted · 03/08/2021 10:57

@Intherightplace

The kind of party where everyone brings something to eat and drink is completely standard in my life, although I know MN abhors it.
It depends on the party and the hosts.

Some of people in my experience love idea of playing hosts but then want everyone else to do all the work, not attending is awkward. It's not always enjoyable.

A casual meet up where everyone asks if they can bring someone is completely different IMO.

ShowMeHow · 03/08/2021 10:56

Meh. Sounds like she is doing it at (less than) cost price.

Also sounds like you and she are cut from the same cloth lol

Ps Yes Air bnb have a Covid cleaning standard.

Bluntness100 · 03/08/2021 10:53

@mafted

It sounds like she's throwing a party but everyone else is doing the work and then paying for the privilege. If that's the case then yes, she's being stingy.
Really? It’s totally normal in my world.
DelphiniumBlue · 03/08/2021 10:52

Are you going at her request to help prepare for the party? In which case you could reasonably expect her to put you up. Or are you going as a guest, and having a bit of a holiday while you're there?
Either way, it's pretty academic really, as it's £30 pp, so hardly a big deal.

Tattybyes · 03/08/2021 10:50

@mafted

It sounds like she's throwing a party but everyone else is doing the work and then paying for the privilege. If that's the case then yes, she's being stingy.
I agree with this. The aunt is having people over for a garden party but they have to pay for the privilege- they are going to visit the aunt for this reason not taking advantage of the holiday home.
Workyticket · 03/08/2021 10:46

She's charging you cost price, juat like you're charging her cost price

Bluntness100 · 03/08/2021 10:44

I am charging her £180 for work I would normally charge £500 for

Wow. So. It’s ok for you to charge cost but not her? You’d rather clean it yourself than pay 13 pounds a night? And you don’t care she’s loosing income by letting you stay for free?

That’s the tightest thing I’ve heard in a long time. Actually cringing for you.

Twelveisthebestnumber · 03/08/2021 10:38

Well it seems that the overall opinion is I'm the tight one so I'm glad I asked. I will stay and be grateful for the accommodation.
I am in no way jealous of her life and have a comparative one myself. We live abroad and she regularly invites herself despite being told it's not convenient. She says family does for family. This then involves half a day emptying and sorting out the spare room to make it a nice space for her.
I am charging her £180 for work I would normally charge £500 for. She is just paying for the product. But as a pp said. It's an invitation, not a summons and I'm sure I will have a good time. I'll happily pay based on what everyone has said.

OP posts:
TopTabby · 03/08/2021 10:10

When I was younger I remember getting outraged when my PIL asked for a contribution to staying in their caravan for a few days.
Now I'm much older & hopefully wiser I can see all the hidden costs & that we were getting an absolute bargain.
So £90 seems fair, you'll see it one day perhaps!

Persephoned · 03/08/2021 10:07

People aren’t daft, and I’m sure she is aware that you sneer and poke fun at her behind her back, which makes her generosity even more impressive.

Persephoned · 03/08/2021 10:05

Your aunt sounds quite impressive and it’s lovely that she’s hosting a garden party and providing you with free accommodation in one of her properties. You sound as if you don’t like her much and don’t want to go, so I wouldn’t go if I were you. If you do go - try and look at those good things she’s doing rather than hunt for any potential negative to criticise her for.

Winemewhynot · 03/08/2021 10:02

You sound the tight one not your aunt!

RealBecca · 03/08/2021 10:00

If she has contracted a cleaner then they will be there regardless so it still costs her £90 whether you clean or not.

I think youre being tight not wanting to pay £90 between 4 of you.

The next guests will want assurance it has been deep cleansed professionally, not by the owners niece.

Cuddlyrottweiler · 03/08/2021 09:58

You're giving her a service at cost price, she's giving you a service at cost price. Probably less actually as she's not charging you for the gas, electricity and water you'll use.

MaMaD1990 · 03/08/2021 09:51

You sound as tight as a badgers arsehole to be honest. £90 is not a lot split between 4 people when you're otherwise staying there for free. A deep clean is necessary due to COVID. YABU.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/08/2021 09:45

I also agree that it's horribly dismissive to describe her business as her 'getting bored' and basically suggesting that she bought some houses, sees regular rent money appear in her bank account and then does nothing else - especially as she's still working hard at it long after many people would have retired.

You haven't mentioned all of the other ways in which you suggest she's tight, but bear in mind that you are now hugely benefitting from her financial astuteness and careful ways with money - if she hadn't planned and been wise, there would be no holiday home for you to stay in virtually free right now. She might be 'tight' in some ways, but 'tightness' usually implies people who don't pay their way, never give anything away and expect others to subsidise their lives - from what you've said, she appears to be the exact opposite of this.

ApolloandDaphne · 03/08/2021 09:44

I used to have a holiday rental. When I had friends and family staying I asked them for money towards the cleaning rather than rent. It would say be £100 rather than £500. No matter who stayed I still had to get it cleaned by the professional cleaners so it would be at the right standard for paying guests. Your aunt is being generous letting you stay there for only £90! That is only £30 split three ways.

Swipe left for the next trending thread