Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About MILs holiday home

442 replies

strengthinnumber · 02/08/2021 20:35

MIL has a holiday home in a nice part of the UK. We usually stay there with her for one week a year and DHs siblings and their families do likewise. She rents it the rest of the time.

This year due to Corona we didn't want to do our usual foreign holiday so MIL offered (we didn't ask!) an extra week this summer for us to go. Now I had reservations. She's a well meaning woman but we're very different. We also live 10 mins from her so see her at least once a week for dinner or Sunday lunch. She also pops round a lot which is wearing when I work from home. Weirdly she "doesn't want to disturb DH" but is fine sitting at the kitchen table waiting for me to make her a cuppa. (Yes I have spoken to DH about this. Yes he's in agreement it's not on. Yes he did speak to her. She's paid no attention. That is a thread for a different time.)

Basically I see a lot of her.

So I asked DH to tactfully find out if she expected to come as well and if she did then to make an excuse because I can't face a whole week with her in summer on top of the week we will be having with her next half term. He chatted with her, mentioned that we really needed some family time to do water sports (which she hates) and surprisingly she told us to go ahead without her.

Dd is 16 and DS 14. They each asked if they could bring a friend and the place has room so I checked with MIL "We might ask a couple of the children's friends to come. Would that be ok?" She said fine.

So. We got here Saturday. It's very nice. I'm thinking happy thoughts about how generous this is of her. We came back from the beach 3 hours ago and SHE'S HERE. Apparently she had a boring, lonely weekend, felt sad so decided to surprise us. Thing is there's no room. It's a 3 bed place. Dd and friend, Ds and friend and DH and I. She really put out by this despite us asking about the friends and despite her not telling us she was coming.

DH found her getting DS and his friend to move their things into the living room to sleep on the sofas and he got really cross with her. They sat in her car on the drive while he told her she should have checked and she then stormed in grabbed her stuff and announced she was leaving as she hadn't realised she'd be so unwanted.

We let her go.

She came back 20 mins later saying she was too upset to do the drive and is now sitting sniffling in the lounge.

So onto the AIBU. It's her house. Its generous of her to lend it us for free. She's always come with us before so probably didn't think to check. The thing is I'm just so unreasonably mad with her. I've seen her at least 3 times a week for the past 18 months and I'm done. I'm about to tell DH that she leave or I do which will put him in an awful position. Do I have the right to be this cross? I'm currently in the car in a pub car park with the kids eating chicken and chips (no seating because we hadn't prebooked) but I will have to go home soon.

OP posts:
lastcall · 04/08/2021 17:54

She’s of a generation who don’t understand the unwritten rules of working from home

bollocks. she absolutely does, as OP has says she wouldn't dream of interrupting her son's work and has said as much. But it's ok to decamp to the house when OP is working and to expect tea and conversation during hours. She does understand; she just doesn't respect OP.

TriciaA1991 · 04/08/2021 16:42

Golly, some people are SO unsympathetic (that's to the responses, not to the OP)

Hope you are okay OP and that you get some sort of proper holiday.

Cyberattack · 04/08/2021 14:57

@lcl

Sorry but she sounds lonely and you sound unreasonable and pretty selfish. It’s her home after all. I make a big effort with my in laws for my husbands sake and my children. They can be very difficult but no one is here forever. Family is very important and that can require humility.
Totally agree with you icl:
Alwayscalminacrisis · 04/08/2021 09:51

A couple of posters have noted that some people don’t get better with age - so true.
My first MiL was a strong character, had a great sense of humour, was interested in her GC and only overstepped once or twice. I genuinely liked her. She died several years ago, a long time after ExDH and I divorced, and I was very sad at her loss. My current MiL is selfish, manipulative, rude, demanding and ignorant and DH just about tolerates her. He is very good at managing her as he is aware of how difficult she is. It’s nothing to do with her age - she has always been difficult. I’m afraid I don’t make much of an effort and can’t see a time when I will. You reap what you sow in the way you treat others.

S0upertrooper · 04/08/2021 09:35

My late MIL had a holiday house and occasionally (out of season) would let us use it. It was many years ago when we were young and skint. They'd turn up at the door, just to make a cup of tea or use the toilet so we couldn't relax and enjoy the place. If we went with her she'd invite other people because she couldn't say no and wanted lots of people around her. On one occasion there was someone sleeping on a blow up bed on the floor. I hated it so we stopped going with her and stopped using the holiday house 'alone'. Then I was accused of being anti social an unwelcoming.

I now have my own (very small, inexpensive) holiday house which I occasionally allow selective friends and family to use. I'm also a (sort of) MIL to my DS's partner. I wouldn't dream of dropping in on them when they were there because I understand that holidays are a time for catching your breath and recharging and the last thing you need is an additional responsibility. So I think your MIL was very unreasonable and your response was understandable.

Great that you were able to resolve it amicably, enjoy the rest of your holiday!

I understand she's lonely, mine was too, but we can't be there for other people all the time

SpindleWhorl · 04/08/2021 09:10

Decamp the kids into one room …. Make a big fuss of making this happen…

Two 16 year old girls. Two 14 year old boys. Sharing what, a set of bunk beds?

I think we have a new contender for 'insane pieces of advice'.

Crystalgirl90 · 04/08/2021 08:51

@burritofan

Borrow a tent and have a couple of nights away cheaply with DH later in the year let her bunk in with you for the night. Please combine these two frankly insane pieces of advice and have a night in a tent with just you and MIL.
Crying with laughter at this 🤣
Blossomtoes · 04/08/2021 08:37

@Yorkshiretolondon

You can’t send her home as annoying as it is as your DH will never be able to forgive himself. It’s less then a week now. Decamp the kids into one room …. Make a big fuss of making this happen… give mil the other room and then go about your water sports as you were before ….. spend ALL day out doing the sports! Retire to bed early so you can be up early doing water sports…. Be lovely be polite be caring It will be worth it in the long run for you DH and the kids …. They’re watching all this play out and will see mil not perfect but you managing very well x
RTFT
Yorkshiretolondon · 04/08/2021 08:35

You can’t send her home as annoying as it is as your DH will never be able to forgive himself. It’s less then a week now. Decamp the kids into one room …. Make a big fuss of making this happen… give mil the other room and then go about your water sports as you were before ….. spend ALL day out doing the sports! Retire to bed early so you can be up early doing water sports…. Be lovely be polite be caring
It will be worth it in the long run for you DH and the kids …. They’re watching all this play out and will see mil not perfect but you managing very well x

rookiemere · 04/08/2021 07:44

The OP has ALREADY resolved the problem over 24 hours ago.
People may be too busy and important to read all the posts, but do at least read the OP updates using the funnel button before ploughing into a long running thread.

Mima1 · 04/08/2021 07:41

:Buffs

Leave your children and their friends in the bedrooms and you and your husband go to a nearby hotel. Then you’ll all get a break.

Please do this....politely, helpfully...under the guise of resolving the problem. Also not too disrupting for DC and friends, who will probably barely notice the change of responsibIe adult.
I think you'll find you get a one night mini-break before she heads home and you can return. Likely she'll never do this again.

Odisia · 04/08/2021 07:29

MeanMrMustardSeed I agree. A balanced, real life response by the OP, her DH and family.

If people can't be bothered to read the whole thread before responding why not at least read the OP's posts?

Maggiejardine · 04/08/2021 07:17

It’s a bit like doing business with friends, the boundaries can be messy because of the relationship. She does have the balance of power because it’s her house and she is using that power, maybe because she’s lonely or doesn’t get that you would like a hol without her. If she doesn’t leave of her own accord or let DH take her home I would remind her that the room arrangements can’t be changed, she must sleep on the sofa, put up with her on that basis but resolve to never holiday there again, make independent plans. That may cost more but what price some MIL free time?

Whitedeer · 04/08/2021 05:06

Buffs.
That is pure gold! The perfect solution for the problem.

Buffs · 04/08/2021 03:07

Leave your children and their friends in the bedrooms and you and your husband go to a nearby hotel. Then you’ll all get a break.

MrsTerryPratchett · 04/08/2021 01:32

Call me Mystic Meg but here goes:

Dh's father was at least a bit of a shit, if not abusive. His way was the only way for a few years. MIL learned not to ask for what she wants and to subsume her needs and wants. This became such a habit that the only way to get her needs met was to be passive aggressive, she couldn't be aggressive or even assertive because it would have resulted in abuse or nastiness.

Their father being nasty and their mother being passive aggressive meant the children bonded AND live with fear, obligation and guilt. They can't challenge it because Mum is the sainted holy mother who was good all through the bad times. She still can't just out and ask for things and lives through her children but hasn't allowed them good boundaries so she can have an overly close relationship into their adulthood.

Am I close? It's a very very well documented psychology.

You can limp through this but YOU need boundaries if DH doesn't have any. And avoid opportunities for her to foist herself because you actually love her so if you can keep boundaries you will have nicer times when you see her.

MakeMathsFun · 04/08/2021 01:19

In the UK I knew someone years ago whose MIL bought the house next door. As the MIL couldn't take their hints to visit less often, they moved house as her excessive presence was unreasonable. Suddenly the MIL moved house again too, to the same street. After this happened 3 times, they just moved to Canada! 100% TRUE.

SpindleWhorl · 04/08/2021 01:18

She’s a lonely older lady

lonely old lady

Oh give over, she's probably my age.

MakeMathsFun · 04/08/2021 01:15

@Blossomtoes

But it's her house. And she lost rental money lending it to us when uk holidays are at a premium

Exactly. You haven’t got a leg to stand on. Either you go home or suck it up. At least you know you’ll never be in this position again because this is your last holiday there, isn’t it?

True, however the MIL has to understand that everyone has the right to 'time out' with independent personal space - without feeling offended. Furthermore, PRIOR TO GOING, the DH had a chat with her: "He chatted with her, mentioned that we really needed some family time to do water sports (which she hates) and surprisingly she told us to go ahead without her." So, she had agreed it, but then totally ignored him - and without any consideration for the fact that there may be no space for her. It seems to me that the MIL (despite being very generous) is very clingy, egocentric and lacks empathy. I think the DH has to have another chat with her, explaining that such repeated behaviour could result in reduced visitation rights.
Localocal · 04/08/2021 00:30

That sounds very annoying, but don't pack in the holiday - it's not fair to the kids, who had nothing to do with this kerfuffle. I'm sure the boys would rather sleep on the sofa and have their holiday than go home. Maybe when she wakes up to a sitting room full of teenage boy she will realise seven's a crowd and go home.

I'm thinking go along with this week for the kids and then ask if you and DH can have the house for a weekend (or week) alone in the autumn and would she stay with the kids at yours. She owes you a week of country chilling, and if you and DH WFH you don't even need to take time off.

saraclara · 04/08/2021 00:26

I'm staying, free of charge, in a flat in a seaside town, owned by some friends who only use it in the winter as they have a caravan locally for the summer. I arranged to meet them for a walk today, and though we arranged to meet here, they very deliberately waited outside, even though I asked if they wanted to come in. Same when we said goodbye.

They wouldn't even enter their own property for a few seconds, because it's 'mine' for the week.

Marriedatfirstyear · 04/08/2021 00:16

Taking the MIL aspect out of it, this wouldn't be ok even of it were a friend. I have a friend house-sitting at my place whilst I'm away. It's a holiday for her and her partner. I wouldn't show up unexpectedly on the premise of joining them. She should have asked if she can join you or given some notice. It's her place but she essentially lent it to you. It's an unfortunate situation but yanbu at all.

billy1966 · 03/08/2021 23:36

@Clymene

I don't care how old she is. Boundaries should be respected. The MIL has zero respect for the OP's job or time and has chosen to insinuate herself on her son's family holiday.

I can promise you I won't behave so badly when I'm her age.

Absolutely this.

She knows well what she is doing but doesn't care.

She is utterly focused on HER needs.

If that means she disturbs the OP at work, 3 times a week, so be it.

She knows well not to disturb her son.

She sounds like a massive PITA and selfish to boot.

The OP is a saint to put up with her rudeness.

She will end up as her carer if she does not cop on and establish some basic boundaries.

saraclara · 03/08/2021 23:27

no-one should not have to feel sorry for her

Ugh. Sloppy editing
No-one should not have to feel sorry for her

saraclara · 03/08/2021 23:25

@Lapun OP has already said that they see MIL at least once a week for a meal and that she comes round to their house for a cuppa very often (unfortunately when OP and her DH are working from home, but still up to now they've put up with it)

That is far more than many DMs and DMILs see their families, and no-one should not have to feel sorry for her (incidentally I am also a widowed DM and DMIL). I'm lucky that my DDs live near enough for us to meet up weekly for a coffee or a walk, but if I'm lonely at other times, then it's down to me, and not them, to occupy me.

We try to have a holiday or break together when we can, but no way would I invade a holiday that they and their partners have planned and not invited me on. And that would not change if I had a property that they were spending their own family time in.