Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I buy a drum kit when I live in a SD house?

116 replies

Drumkitsituation · 02/08/2021 18:37

The whole question is in the title really but to add a little more detail.....

I have recently fallen back in love with playing the drums after a twenty year break. I’m a forty year old mum of 2, and it feels hugely amazing to be doing something new and playful and not child or goal orientated.

I live in a semi detached house, neighbours are nice, they are currently WFH since pandemic, not sure of their long terms plans. They have grown up children.

I want a drum kit. The electronic one I play on in lessons is about 6k worth of stuff but according to my teacher I can get an entry level electronic one for about £500.

However, I want a real one, preferably a Pearl export like the one I had as a teenager! I can get a second hand one of these for £300 and wouldn’t want or need to upgrade that.

I’d probably play for an hour or so 4 ish times a week whilst the kids are at school/in afternoon at weekends.

The only room we could fit it in would be a room adjoining their house on the ground floor.

The houses are 30s, robust, thick walls, neither of us can really hear the other day to day.

YANBU - it’s your house, get the drum kit you want

YABU - selfish, think of your neighbours, save up for the electronic

Thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Drumkitsituation · 24/09/2021 08:46

Hi all
Just to let you know I bought the electric drum kit. It’s brilliant and I am so happy with it. Thanks for the advice

OP posts:
crumpet · 10/08/2021 18:31

(As in dont do it)

crumpet · 10/08/2021 18:30

Short answer: no

LondonFooser · 10/08/2021 18:27

I live in a SD (also about 1930s). We bought a piano and put it in the room adjoining our neighbour's house on the ground floor. It was very annoying for our neighbour so we moved it into the kitchen which is not adjoining and now things are fine for our neighbour. We also had a drum kit in our kitchen at one point - but we went for an electronic one and that was also ok for our neighbour.

user1491404899 · 10/08/2021 18:17

Its not just next door, it's the entire street! Two doors down has one, we all hate them

ShinyGreenElephant · 10/08/2021 17:30

I can hear our neighbours drumming. I quite enjoy it and it means I don't feel guilty about my kids playing noisily in the garden. Not in a tit for tat way more that they make noise so they obviously don't hate us for it. Or maybe they do and thats why they got the drum kit!

FizziWater · 10/08/2021 14:24

No. It's anti social.
Can you not use an electric kit with headphones?
Build a soundproof room?

DS2 yearned to play drums and I refused. To be honest listening to anyone practise is painful, not least recorder or violin but drums would just reverberate through the building.

Plumtree391 · 10/08/2021 14:19

Stick to an electronic one until you can afford a detached house or a suitable out building.

ProfSprout · 10/08/2021 13:59

DH is a drummer so he completely soundproofed the shed to be able to play his acoustic kit in there. It’s the only way to be reasonable to our neighbours - he’s very good but drums are loud and not everyone wants to hear them all the time!

He also has an electronic kit for inside the house, but even then plays in a room away from the neighbours’ house because it is still a repetitive tapping even if quiet.

You can’t play an acoustic kit in a semi detached house. It’s not ok.

nyprincess · 10/08/2021 13:51

As someone who has had to listen to next door (she's at the end of a terrace) kids learning & playing the violins for almost 5 years now,. youngest daughter has started as well, I would say please don't get them. We complained to her about it as they could play late at night. Now its an hour each once a day, sometimes 2. Tbh the violins aren't the worse noise as she shouts at the kids a lot, but even when they went out all as work was being done in her home, she still had them practice even though we'd had all day listening to buliding work going on etc. It really can drive you mad.

KarmaStar · 10/08/2021 10:53

That would be incredibly selfish .
Some fool around here has opened up an unregistered drum school.The noise or horrendous,can't work or concentrate on anything.
Either join a drum school ,start a group in a less populated areas of take up another interest.

MuddyStiletto · 10/08/2021 10:16

Save up
I think you'd be incredibly selfish to inflict this on your neighbours when there's an alternative

Flutteringwings · 10/08/2021 10:04

Also, electronic kits generally fold up so they don't take up as much space when not in use, and obviously they have the benefit of many backing tracks that you can play along to.

Flutteringwings · 10/08/2021 10:02

I think in this case an electronic is the way to go. Acoustic drums can be so loud and your playing could be affected if you are always conscious of the neighbours. You can get a reasonable nitro mesh set for around £350 including drum throne and earphones kit if you shop around and ask for a deal.

If you could afford it in the future, then add an acoustic drum kit as well, but limit your majority playing and practice to the electronic kit and only use the acoustic for 15 min bursts every so often and only if you are sure you can contain yourself Smile But I think it wouldn't be fair to your neighbours have an acoustic set as your only drum option.

lanthanum · 10/08/2021 09:41

Have a chat with the neighbours. They might be going back to the office soon, at least some days, in which case there might be no problem on those days. Also consider borrowing a kit and testing out the noise level with your neighbours.

However, something to bear in mind: you have kids. If there is a kit in the house, and they ask to learn, it might be difficult to say no. You might be able to time your playing for when the neighbours are out; the kids might not.

averylongtimeago · 10/08/2021 09:37

You want to play the drums in a room adjoining your neighbours?

Give them plenty of notice so they can get their house on the market ...

Or invest in a soundproof shed or electronic kit with headphones.

My neighbours son played the drums. We are 50 yards from his room-
We absolutely could hear him, I can't imagine how loud it would be in a SD house!

starrynight87 · 10/08/2021 09:26

God no.

BizzyIzzyfruitpie · 10/08/2021 09:16

My daughter plays an instrument. I’m aware it can be heard by the neighbours but she has to practice! One of my neighbours plays trumpet and one drums. It doesn’t bother me. It’s only a few times a week and usually only in summer when the windows are open that I can really hear it.

bravotango · 10/08/2021 09:10

I can't believe these posters! OP - I think it's absolutely fine - however not during working hours. It needs to be between 5 and 7pm for no more than 30 mins at a time, in a room with a carpet and some furniture against the party wall. And just let the neighbours know the rough time that you'll be playing and that they can text if it's disturbing them.

FWIW I had a neighbour with a piano who played all the bloody time and that was more annoying than the drums so...

Clawdy · 10/08/2021 08:00

The thickness of the walls means nothing, we lived in a solid old semi and could not hear voices or most sounds, but a pianist moved in, and from then on, our lives were hell, and we moved out within a year, after endless rows.

HeronLanyon · 10/08/2021 07:57

Yabu - it’s not just your neighbouring house who will hear you.
As for neighbours wfh the only way it might work is to discuss with them and have very clearly defined hour when you play and stick to it 100% (if there is such an hour that neighbours will be able to live with).

Coldilox · 10/08/2021 07:46

My opposite neighbours have a drum kit in their garage, one of their boys plays. The whole coil-de-sac can hear him when he does.

I quite like listening to him, he’s very good. He doesn’t play early morning or late at night.

FWIW I don’t think we should expect our neighbours to be quiet just because some people work from home. These are our homes not our workplaces. Noise in the day is fair game. I work nights sometimes but don’t expect my neighbours to keep the noise down so I can sleep.

AngelDelightUk · 10/08/2021 07:26

Could you build a sound proof shed for it?

Blossomsbloom · 10/08/2021 06:26

@MiddlesexGirl
If everybody followed the MN way then no-one would ever learn to play the drums or any other instrument that can be heard

It's not the MN way it's the decent human being way of showing consideration for others.
A violin is very different to a drum kit or bagpipes so not every instrument is a problem. No reason not to learn those instruments though, just do so where it doesn't affect other peoples right to peace in their own home.

2anddone · 07/08/2021 14:39

My ds (16) used to have a drum kit (sold it this week) we live in a sd house and had rules for when practice could be it lived in the conservatory.
He could practice for half hour at the most between 10am and 6pm.
I explained to the neighbours and they were ok with that as knew there would be an 'end' to it!
My dc also knew it wasn't a toy and they couldn't just bang it for the sake of it when friends were round!