Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Car crash in car park, who is at fault?

41 replies

Seldon · 02/08/2021 17:44

In a car park today, a van reversed into me while I was part way through a manoeuvre. Diagram attached. I was in some bays perpendicular to another set of bays.

I had reversed to do a three point turn around the back of a van. I had just stopped and was about to drive off, when the van just reversed into me and hit my side rear.

I was there first, and he reversed, but as I was in a manoeuvre and in an unexpected place, could he claim I was to blame? AIBU to think I was not to blame.

YABU - I'm not to blame
YANBU - It's a 50:50 accident

(I know life is a bit more non-binary than that, but interested for views).

Car crash in car park, who is at fault?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheSkatesOfCoachBombay · 03/08/2021 00:21

He should have checked before reversing out of the bay. He should be aware of his blind spot. As you say he's said you were stationary.

I mean for all he knew you could have stopped and be pulling in to a vacant bay. Your prior manouver doesn't matter.

You are in the through road, and he's just reversed in to you.

atlastifoundit · 03/08/2021 00:17

Well he reversed into you, because the back end of his vehicle hit the side of yours, and you were not moving at the time.

That makes it his fault.

Duchess379 · 02/08/2021 23:15

He clearly hasn't looked before reversing so he's at fault.

SoupDragon · 02/08/2021 20:10

@Seldon

Just to add the accident happened in France where we have left hand vehicles. I had a great position to see the van, and the van driver was on the other side
If you were in France, I'm not sure what would happen in the U.K. is necessarily relevant.
Seldon · 02/08/2021 20:04

I did just visit his house to sign the insurance forms and luckily he agreed to sign that I was stationary, he was reversing and he wrote he reversed without looking. This should hopefully be enough

OP posts:
FixTheBone · 02/08/2021 20:03

Feel sorry for you OP, it should be their fault but unlikely provable.

Incidentally, a good follow on to the why you should park reversing into the bay thread from a few days ago....

Seldon · 02/08/2021 19:58

It’s a tight car park, so no other way to get out

OP posts:
Sirzy · 02/08/2021 19:55

So you stopped in his blind spot for 10 seconds?

icedcoffees · 02/08/2021 19:53

@Seldon

Chances are you were in his blind spot and to be honest if you have pulled behind him from that parking spot I would be a bit hmm

But there’s literally no other way to leave the car park. Are you supposed to wait for the van driver to finish his supermarket shop?

I think PP is saying that your diagram makes it look as though you reversed out very widely?

To me it looks like you've reversed out right into his blind spot and so there was no way for him to see you when he reversed.

Seldon · 02/08/2021 19:50

Chances are you were in his blind spot and to be honest if you have pulled behind him from that parking spot I would be a bit hmm

But there’s literally no other way to leave the car park. Are you supposed to wait for the van driver to finish his supermarket shop?

OP posts:
Waspsarearseholes · 02/08/2021 19:41

You can't drive sideways into the back of a van so if the damage is consistent with a van hitting you then it should be pretty clear cut.

quizqueen · 02/08/2021 19:03

If your car was already in the main the driving area of the car park and he was in a parking bay, moving out, then he is to blame. Same as if, you were in a road and he was reversing off his drive.

delilahbucket · 02/08/2021 18:50

This will settle as 50/50. Chances are you were in his blind spot and to be honest if you have pulled behind him from that parking spot I would be a bit Hmm as to why your car was in that position considering where you have pulled out from. In most carparks, there will be giveway markings right where you have reversed over. Yes the van driver should have been looking, but if I were in his spot and saw you reversing out, I would not expect you to finish your manuoeuvre where you did.

Clangerschick1 · 02/08/2021 18:44

Any insurance company worth their salt can prove you were stationary with the accident damage. If you were reversing /moving at the time of collision the damage from the van would be scrapes and scratches all down the side of your car. If as you say you weren’t moving then there will just be a dent where he hit you. They will only need photos from the partner garage or will have it inspected.
If you weren’t moving you were not at all at fault.

Wjevtvha · 02/08/2021 18:36

You didn’t do anything wrong but I’d be prepared that you might end up 50:50

Needapoodle · 02/08/2021 18:33

As you were both reversing unless there is cctv it's going to be 50/50.

PigeonPink · 02/08/2021 18:31

He was in a parking space and you were using the road. He should have remained in his parking space until the road was clear for him to reverse out. You can’t just reverse out of a parking space and whack into someone. Totally his fault.

icedcoffees · 02/08/2021 18:28

If you were reversing right behind him, it's possible (as he's in a van) that he couldn't see you properly. Vans have a larger blind spot than cars do.

Seldon · 02/08/2021 18:25

Plan to go through insurance but no dashcam so difficult to prove and I was car on my own. May ask the shop for cctv if it’s get there

OP posts:
Mattsmum2 · 02/08/2021 18:13

Are you taking this through insurance and do you or him have a dashcam or any witnesses? I ask thus because I was stationary in a car park waiting for the traffic to clear and a car reversed out in to me. The insurance argued that no one could evidence that I was not moving also. I had to make do with insurance saying they’re accept a 50/50 blame without even consulting me. Now I have a dashcam. This claim was a long drawn out one which my insurance company didn’t stand up for me at all. Their explanation, it was not worth contesting. Good luck 😉

Cocomade · 02/08/2021 18:10

Is there CCTV in the car park?
This would be my first point of call.
I say he's to blame

Carthief · 02/08/2021 18:10

OP keep re-iterating that you were stationary to your insurance.

Even if you weren’t there when he started reversing he should still be checking that there’s nothing to drive into - it could be a car, it could be a child…

Looking at the diagram - any damage is on the side of your car yes? Is it all in one place?

If so - Cars don’t move sideways, you had to be stationary when he hit you otherwise the damage would be all down the side of your car which would happen if you hit his rear corner.

Aprilx · 02/08/2021 18:07

If you were stationary then yes it is the other persons fault, but it would be hard to prove that. I think it will be deemed 50:50 and I think it would be anyway as it is not worth the insurers time arguing about it anyway.

Seldon · 02/08/2021 18:07

Just to add the accident happened in France where we have left hand vehicles. I had a great position to see the van, and the van driver was on the other side

OP posts:
sbhydrogen · 02/08/2021 18:06

This exact thing happened to me in 2010. Sadly, I was the van in this situation and it was 100% my fault. It was unfortunate that my rear window was a bit steamed up and their car was the same colour as the sky at that particular moment.

We were the only two cars in the otherwise empty cat park 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread