Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be surprised that Laurel Hubbard didn't register a lift in the Olympics?

529 replies

Gladiolixoxo · 02/08/2021 14:21

I wonder if all the controversy around Laurel's participation led to her losing her nerve?

OP posts:
FluffyBattleKitten · 03/08/2021 07:37

Lung and heart size, hip placement are all factors unaffected by gender identity but affected by sex, with men having the advantage in sports.

DrSbaitso · 03/08/2021 07:26

As Janice Turner pointed out, the worthless testosterone requirement wasn't introduced because it was fair, but because it was achievable.

FluffyBattleKitten · 03/08/2021 07:22

Some physical facts

The IOC decided in 2015 that, for their purpose, a female is anyone who says they are, as long as their testosterone, the primary male hormone, has been below 10 nanomoles per litre (nmol/L) for the past 12 months. The typical testosterone level in females is less than 1 nmol/L.

Testosterone levels at the IOC therefore do not create parity between transwomen and women. Transwomen retain a physical edge.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 03/08/2021 07:19

Top class sport is immensely lucrative. the current rules say that someone has only to live as their preferred gender (however one does thaT given as we’re repeatedly told that you don’t need to present in a feminine way to be a TW!) for four years and in the case of TW lower their testosterone level to the required level which is still significantly higher than that allowed by women

right now, sports bodies and coaches in countries like China or Russia will be looking at the male teenagers they work with and ear marking those they will be talking too about presenting as a TW. Remember they don’t have to alter their appearance much or at all and lower their testosterone for a few years so they can compete. That would be all it would take. No woman is going to beat a fit young male who has been through puberty even with lowered testosterone. Ff to the 2024 & 2028 Olympics and those “TW” would sweep the board.

If you think that’s far fetched, consider the mass doping programmes of the soviet bloc. There’s no reason why some countries wouldn’t March straight through those loopholes

Bryonyshcmyony · 03/08/2021 07:18

Tbh I felt quite sorry for her in her interview as I felt she'd been used. She was clealrly not up to the standard and it was embarrassing from a sport pov for New Zealand.

Mandalay246 · 03/08/2021 07:16

I think Hubbard wanted to be noticed. Hubbard wanted to play out Hubbard’s fantasy of being a woman on the most public, international, high profile stage possible.

You don't know the first thing about Laurel do you?

Bryonyshcmyony · 03/08/2021 07:15

It was weird.

Just trying to think of another athlete at the Olympics who has fluffed their sport that badly and didn't seem to give a shit. Hughes false starting - stupid mistake. Dina not qualifying for final - clealry devastated. Any others?

littledrummergirl · 03/08/2021 07:15

Anecdotally, my ds1 and dd compete in the same physical sport. Ds1 is slightly older but dd is now taller than him, they are similar weight. If they were in the same category dd wouldn't stand a chance of winning due the differences in physique. That is why they are separated by sec not gender and should remain so. Otherwise many people will be hurt and that is not what sport is about.

FluffyBattleKitten · 03/08/2021 07:12

A few facts that may have been missed I that spectacular merail.

Laurel was injured, a career ending arm injury in 2018.

Laurel won the Pacific games gold in 2019.

With a personal best of 185kg lifted.

Laurel failed to lift 125kg repeatedly

Other lifters failed to lift 97kg first time and adjusted

Laurel must have a coach

Laurel did not act upset or worried as repeatedly the lift was not made- pushing Hubbard out of the competition.

Women competing with Hubbard were at physical peak and half Hubbard's age

Women competing against Hubbard looked in condition and had good technique

Hubbard could be seen to be using poor technique

Bryonyshcmyony · 03/08/2021 06:52

hundreds talented trans women that they can aim to participate in the Olympics in Paris 2024

Are there hundreds of talented trans women at Olympic level?

LadyGAgain · 03/08/2021 06:07

@Cam77

Storm in a teacup. Every single women's medal at the Olympics has been won by... a woman. And yet this is "the end of women's sports" etc etc. Get a grip!
Are you a man?

And, how do you know that? Do the trans competitors have to declare that?

Calling out the evilness of racism started generations ago yet the rise of BLM was needed in 2020.

It's called foresight. A shit ton better than hind sight. Prevention is better than cure. I'd rather we stopped this utter nonsense before we have generations of defeated and morally beaten sports women. How long would it take for women to say "what's the point?" when they know they are likely to be competing against biological males.

Your comment is humiliating. For you.

LadyGAgain · 03/08/2021 05:54

@SecondCityShark

Did anybody see the mixed relay the other night? The males absolutely thrashed the females, which was no surprise. But at least it was fair in the context of that event (2 males and 2 females in each team).

It didn't half demonstrate the differences between our capabilities though.

It absolutely did! And what happens in Paris when the X2 women selected are trans who ID as women. So effectively you now have x4 biological men? Win? High possibility when pitted against other teams with X2 of opposing sexes. But, anything for the win right? (Sweeping under the carpet the blatant irradiation of women's sport). I'm so sad for my daughters.
EdgeOfACoin · 03/08/2021 05:53

Felt really sad for her. But just her being at the Olympics will have given confidence to and inspired hundreds talented trans women that they can aim to participate in the Olympics in Paris 2024

Interesting. Why do you mention transwomen only? Do you not think transmen will be winning medals in the men's events?

Which transmen rising up through the ranks of men's sport should we be keeping an eye on?

Any transmen twice the average age of their competitors getting a spot at the Olympics? I look forward to hearing about them.

LadyGAgain · 03/08/2021 05:44

@Liberett0

Felt really sad for her. But just her being at the Olympics will have given confidence to and inspired hundreds talented trans women that they can aim to participate in the Olympics in Paris 2024 ❤️
Literally you've given zero thought to all the women who are at the peak of their game. Have battled and sacrificed (along with their families in many cases) and now who, despite being in the world elite, will not qualify as they are pitted against biological men who identify as women. I have nothing against trans. Be who you are. But in sport it is biological. And irradiating women for the trans agenda is a fucking disgrace.
NiceGerbil · 03/08/2021 01:38

I think checking that we all understand what it is being said that's meant in that post though. To avoid confusion.

NiceGerbil · 03/08/2021 01:37

I think there would be widespread suspicion of doping.

Not in equestrian shooting etc but the events where age is s massive factor. Which is most of them.

DeRigueurMortis · 03/08/2021 01:25

@AnyoneEveryone

Well, are you saying it about any other competitor?

I think that yes, there would be a discussion about any person who qualified for the Olympics despite being 20 years older, employing poor technique and having suffered what would have been career ending injuries for their direct competitors.

I think there would be a lot of questions about how that person was in a position to qualify and what had made that possible.

If you want to point me in the direction of any other person in the games who fits even one of these criteria - for example 20 years older than the average age of the rest of the field in their chosen sport then please feel free to give us a name.

Abouttoblow · 03/08/2021 01:11

I'll believe there is no issue when a transman in their 40's is in serious contention for a medal in the 100m sprint.

NiceGerbil · 03/08/2021 01:01

And can you just confirm what is being said?

Make sure on same page.

NiceGerbil · 03/08/2021 01:01

In this Olympics specifically, or in other sporting events / competitions?

AnyoneEveryone · 03/08/2021 00:58

Well, are you saying it about any other competitor?

NiceGerbil · 03/08/2021 00:56

No in fact everyone on MN who has said this is not right has just been told to grow up.

That other thread there were about 2000 people, mainly women I'm sure, whose concerns about this mean they are childish.

Overall it must be a vast number of women who are not on board with males competing against women.

Maybe women often stop progressing intellectually when they are children?

I know that was a popular theory in the past. (Victorian? Earlier? Only thinking about here).

Helleofabore · 03/08/2021 00:50

But you don't want a discussion on them in any depth? Or just to the depth you want?

We were told that a grown up discussion was wanted, yet nothing was ‘floated’ past one suggestion that was never explained to enable fairness between males and females (ie. Negate the male physical advantages that occur when the bodies are the same weight/height even muscle:fat ratio.

So, I suspect that this was supposed to be a theoretical discussion where reality was ignored and no experts have found a viable solution. But we aren’t grown up enough to have the conversation with.

NiceGerbil · 03/08/2021 00:47

'one that’s always discussed around the Olympics or any massive tournament,'

I have never seen it floated anywhere that the Olympics should have different categories for different speeds.

NiceGerbil · 03/08/2021 00:44

'What on earth would be the point of having endless administrative categories which would all need to be tested for and applied and constantly checked and rechecked and measured, when you have the very obvious natural division of male and female?'

That was answered earlier.

It's just admin.

('just admin' yep loads of women are familiar with that pov)

Swipe left for the next trending thread