Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Laurel Hubbard should not be competing against women - Part 2

110 replies

Belle82 · 02/08/2021 12:56

I am overwhelmed by how much support there has been on this post and that the majority of people agree with the unfairness of this decision, it is good to see the majority being able to have a voice without being silenced.

It breaks my heart that a less fortunate girl who has worked so hard was passed over for a middle aged transgender woman who was 203 in the world when competing against men. Sad

I can’t decide if I want this person to win, to give the argument a better standing on never letting this happen again.
I guess we will find out today…

OP posts:
nolongersurprised · 02/08/2021 14:10

Simple blood test, job done

Cheek swab or saliva test, even

Amaterasux · 02/08/2021 14:09

@sandysMam she crashed out - common for both sexes for this to happen.

But i am sure it will blamed on all the intense pressure she has been under from transphobic views...

Tuscancat · 02/08/2021 14:09

Why can't the rules just be that anyone with a Y chromosome is eligible for the mens category only. Simple blood test, job done. No tying ourselves in knots over it all. No woman has a Y chromosome.

Keepemguessing · 02/08/2021 14:05

There would be another where men are excluded, but women both cis and trans can enter.

Transwomen are men and should not be competing against women.

Whatwouldscullydo · 02/08/2021 14:05

So 4 percent of people still think Its OK that we have mens sports.

And we have mixed sports.

Name one good reason why women can't have their own sports and men amd males get a choice of 2.

That cant seem fair to anyone surely? Not unless you really hate women or think they should all get back in the kitchen and leave the sport to the boys?

ItsAllBlahBlahBlah · 02/08/2021 14:05

@Ozgirl75 killed me with that 🤣

SandysMam · 02/08/2021 14:04

Ignore my last post, I meant seen not seem!

nolongersurprised · 02/08/2021 14:04

Should add the Caster (XY chromosomes, 5 alpha reductase deficiency, testosterone high from internal testes) wasn’t banned from the 800m. Caster just didn’t like reducing their testosterone levels and wanted to “run free”. When testosterone was reduced Caster lost

SandysMam · 02/08/2021 14:04

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SandysMam · 02/08/2021 14:03

Sorry just seem Hubbard was DNF (did not finish). Can anyone catch me up on what happened?

nolongersurprised · 02/08/2021 14:02
  • forgot about the 1500!
Motorina · 02/08/2021 14:01

@jennywhitehorses

I can't help feeling there should be an easy solution to this problem. We're used to separate men and women's competitions. Instead of 2 there could be 3.

There would be a competition where anybody could participate. Women probably wouldn't bother because the men will win. There would be another where men are excluded, but women both cis and trans can enter. Then another where there are no trans women, no women with chromosomal abnormalities, and no women who just happen to have high levels of testosterone.

Many years ago there was a woman who ran in a men only marathon until she was detected and ejected. She is held up as a feminist hero. Today feminists spend a lot of time trying to stop trans women from competing against cis women.

She could have organized her own marathon. One for men and women, or one for women only. Nobody was stopping her from running a marathon and nobody is forcing cis women to compete against anyone they don't want to. The problem is there are organizations which control prizes and income. These should be willing to adapt because if they don't they can be replaced.

That would be Kathrine Switzer. At the time, there were no marathons which allowed women. Her running opened up endurance running to women and, yes, she did go on to organise lots of marathons for women.

Importantly, her presence (and the presence of the women runners who would follow her) did not disadvantage male runners.

What scares me is how recent this all is. Switzer's run was in 1967. Only a few years before I was born. The first woman's Olympic marathon was in 1984 - after I started running. Women weightlifters have only been allowed to compete in the Olympics since 2000. This is literally within the lifetime of most of the athletes competing.

And now they're being displaced by people with the biological advantages of men.

I absolutely support the right of transgendered individuals to live the lives they choose. To be treated with dignity and respect. To identify as they will. But there are fundamentals of biology which can't be escaped, and those fundamentals really matter when it comes to how much weight you can lift.

This is unfair and wrong.

nolongersurprised · 02/08/2021 14:00

i daresay the ban will end up being applied across the board, though

It’s not a ban. It’s an attempt to enable biological males with DSDs to be shoe-horned into female athletics. At present, they can still compete in the 400m and 800m, they do need to lower their testosterone (usually from internal testes) although levels are still higher than women’s levels.

The rule for 400m and 800m applies to athletes with male levels of testosterone who have XY chromosomes as part of their DSD and who have gone through a male puberty (ie are androgen sensitive).

CS is XY DSD with 5 alpha reductase deficiency. For some reason it couldn’t be “proven” that male levels of testosterone wasn’t an advantage at 200m (yeah right) but could be at 400m and 800m.

Ozgirl75 · 02/08/2021 13:57

Thanks @ferretface that makes a lot of sense.

Kittii · 02/08/2021 13:55

It works really well to have sports segregated by sex because sex confers the male advantage. There are two sexes so there should be two sex categories.

ferretface · 02/08/2021 13:53

@ozgirl75 They are all XY athletes with differences of sexual development (a male DSD). Their DSD means that they produce testosterone and are responsive to it. All 3 medal winning athletes in the 2016 Rio Olympics had this DSD and subsequently after new World Athletics rules were introduced were required to reduce their testosterone levels in order to be able to compete. The limit is set at 5nmol/litre which is still very very much higher than most women.

As they don't wish to reduce their testosterone levels (because they don't win then) and therefore can't now compete in 400, 800 or 1500m (the only distances to which the XY ruling currently applies) they have either gone down to 200m or up to 5000M. Or in caster's case chosen a different sport.

It's a slightly different issue to trans people in sport but this is still making an absolute mockery of women's sport.

Kittii · 02/08/2021 13:53

@jennywhitehorses "nobody is forcing cis women to compete against anyone they don't want to".

This is untrue. Unless you are saying that all the women in sections that include males should just give up their careers and Olympic dreams and not compete?

Ozgirl75 · 02/08/2021 13:53

Personally I think they should do it like they do at my children’s junior school; an “open” category and a girls category.
Girls are free to play in the open group (and some do, there is one girl in the A soccer team and 2 in the B team, tennis 1sts is mixed 5/3) but also have girl’s soccer, rugby etc and a few of their own sports (netball and touch rugby). Athletics is run together but timed separately.
Seems to work really well.

Ozgirl75 · 02/08/2021 13:49

I see, thanks @puffyisgood

Trampolean · 02/08/2021 13:48

Do we think there'll ever be a transman that competes in the male category? Wine

puffyisgood · 02/08/2021 13:45

[quote Ozgirl75]@ferretface do you know why that is? Why they can do the 200m but not the 400?[/quote]
the rule was, crudely speaking, devised as an anti Caster Semenya rule using fairly limited evidence that didn't enable the powers that be to conclusively rule that DSD conferred an advantage at the shorter distance. i daresay the ban will end up being applied across the board, though.

Crockof · 02/08/2021 13:44

I'm more concerned that you don't have to announce if you have transitioned. So LH may be the first openly transgender person to compete, but there maybe medalist already.

jennywhitehorses · 02/08/2021 13:44

I can't help feeling there should be an easy solution to this problem. We're used to separate men and women's competitions. Instead of 2 there could be 3.

There would be a competition where anybody could participate. Women probably wouldn't bother because the men will win. There would be another where men are excluded, but women both cis and trans can enter. Then another where there are no trans women, no women with chromosomal abnormalities, and no women who just happen to have high levels of testosterone.

Many years ago there was a woman who ran in a men only marathon until she was detected and ejected. She is held up as a feminist hero. Today feminists spend a lot of time trying to stop trans women from competing against cis women.

She could have organized her own marathon. One for men and women, or one for women only. Nobody was stopping her from running a marathon and nobody is forcing cis women to compete against anyone they don't want to. The problem is there are organizations which control prizes and income. These should be willing to adapt because if they don't they can be replaced.

Ozgirl75 · 02/08/2021 13:43

@ferretface do you know why that is? Why they can do the 200m but not the 400?

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 02/08/2021 13:43

My concern is that this is just the first wave, we'll get these 40 something not really fit for purpose male athletes paving the way for the real male overthrow of female sport. Its dystopian.

Swipe left for the next trending thread