Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I pay for everything and he’s asking for 4K

235 replies

Fridacat · 02/08/2021 12:01

Posting here for traffic

Partner helped me with a deposit for a house over a year ago it was 4K I have given some money back 1K but tbh he never really said at the time he wanted it back

Backstory we have one 6 year old child together who has autism been together 18 years but decided to live apart as we both like space he owns his own home and me and my son would live together

I pay for everything food rent bills my sons clothes literally everything. He pays for the odd McDonald’s happy meal and brings our son out which I am very grateful for as sometimes I need that break as I cannot cope at times. He’s is also filthy and I’m one of those who likes my house to be spotless

He has yet again told me today he wants the money back at a rate of 100.00 a month and is refusing to leave the home he’s been here since the start of lockdown which as I said above is great at times because I get a break when he takes our son out

I’m on universal credit and my son gets DLA I’ve never told his father I receive DLA or carers for our son as he would literally take the money from me he has always been very mean.

What am I asking is what would you do aibu to not give him 4K back over a period of time or should I just pay him I don’t know where the arsehole thinks I’m going to get the money from he obviously thinks I shit money.

He’s basically been living here rent free he owns his own house outright so he doesn’t have to pay a mortgage and he works he doesn’t buy our son clothes or anything

He has money he doesn’t have to work but got a job in the area I live in behind my back and told me 24/48 hours before he started. He’s due to be paid this week 2k yet he’s still abusing me about this money I ‘owe’ him

After typing this he really is a cunt in total it was 5K I’ve given him back 1K which he said I didn’t give back even when I proved I did with my bank statements

I literally cannot afford to pay back this money and tbh why should I he literally has been living rent free eating here for free gets his washing done etc

I don’t need any flaming please I’ve been crying in bed and recently come off my antidepressants and I’ll probably have to go back on them now due to the shit he is giving me about this money

OP posts:
Jelly0naplate · 02/08/2021 12:57

Change the locks when he goes out and claim maintenance and kick him to the curb.
Honestly if he's taking you for a ride and as for giving you an odd break and the odd McDonald's what a shit excuse a father. Put your foot down and sort it out

RandomMess · 02/08/2021 12:56

If it's your house in your name call the police and get him removed he has no right to be there.

Why have you not claimed maintenance from him?

QueeniesCroft · 02/08/2021 12:56

@PomPomSugar

You said the money was for a house deposit but you also refer to a Tenancy?

Ditch him and claim csa

Renters have to pay deposits too, usually.
chesirecat99 · 02/08/2021 12:56

So he owns 2 homes outright and is independently wealthy so he doesn't need to work, even though he does @Fridacat?

I would take legal advice. There is a chance you might be entitled to make a claim on one of the homes to house your child until he leaves home or a lump sum for care of the child, even though you aren't married, not just child maintenance.

www.stowefamilylaw.co.uk/blog/2018/06/11/how-can-unmarried-parents-get-financial-provision-for-their-children/

RB68 · 02/08/2021 12:55

Set it up to pay and let one go through then get him out into his house and change the locks. Sort out proper child maintenance through the system and clean break - he is a user

MyriadeOfThings · 02/08/2021 12:54

Why are you still clinging onto that relationship ? What is he bringing to your life apart from a small break from time to time?

He has no issue sponging a mother on benefits looking after a disabled child, HIS disabled child. He isn’t giving ANYTHING for his upkeep. What sort of father is he?

It’s not just that you need to kick him to his house.
I’d also tell him that the £4K is a part of the unpaid maintenance he never gave you - aka money for HIS child so he is dressed, fed and as a room over his head.
I’d also get rid of him altogether tbh.

PomPomSugar · 02/08/2021 12:54

You said the money was for a house deposit but you also refer to a Tenancy?

Ditch him and claim csa

1WayOrAnother2 · 02/08/2021 12:52

-How much have you spent on his food/use of water/electricity/heating etc. while he has been VISITING you? If he considers himself to be living with you... add rent to that too. (Subtract that from the owed deposit.)

-How much have you spent on his child? (Subtract - at least half- that amount from the owed deposit.)

-How much should he have been paying for child maintenance each month? (Subtract that amount from anything left of that deposit, and then make sure that he is paying this fair monthly sum going forwards.)

fruitbrewhaha · 02/08/2021 12:51

please kick him out and go to cms for proper maintenance form him.

I've never heard of anything so awful. He is completely sponging off you.

xsamix86 · 02/08/2021 12:49

I'd definitely be sending him on his way! The difficulty would be with CMS. You say he doesn't need to work, so nothing is really stopping him quitting his job to avoid paying. Not sure how whatever income he has that means he doesn't need to work would be weighted.

Honestly, he's a massive waste of space. He can go off to his 1st or 2nd home and arrange weekly time with his DC which would give you regular time out and a lot less stress without his extra costs in your home and his stinking attitude.

LuxOlente · 02/08/2021 12:49

I'm thinking a chat with Women's Aid might help, they might steer you towards advice for people in your situation. Navigating this will be tough.

supadupapupascupa · 02/08/2021 12:49

If you are rentingvtell him he can have it back when his son leaves home snd you move out

LuxOlente · 02/08/2021 12:49

Is this actually a relationship? I see he lent you money. You have a child together, but do not live together. He’s an ex?

He has never paid a penny apart from ‘the odd happy meal.’ This is not a partner, right there. This isn’t a father.

He ‘brings him out for which I am grateful’? He is ‘filthy’? He would ‘take money from you as he is very mean’?

This isn’t a relationship, this is a disturbing-sounding man in your life who demands money a lot and appears to be taking advantage of someone very vulnerable.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 02/08/2021 12:47

See what your legal status is regarding the money - unlikely he can get it back if no contract was signed, then bin him and claim CMA. Sod him.

Hekatestorch · 02/08/2021 12:45

Oh he has nothing in writing either?

Nah don't pay him a penny. Still get him out of the house.

8dpwoah · 02/08/2021 12:45

Just posting to cheer you OP, I don't know the best way to do things like other posters have knowledge but it's clear you need to find a way to get him out, keep him out, and claim maintenance from him. He'll wish he'd never even mentioned that 4k by the time he's paid a few months of what he should be.

user1471538283 · 02/08/2021 12:45

You need to tell him to leave. Calculate what it has cost you to keep him all this time and deduct it from what he says you owe him. If you've spent more keeping him then he owes you - not that you will get it. I would email it to him as well to keep everything in writing.

The thing is in his head this isn't clear cut. If you had kept a running count from the beginning it would be very clear to him.

Hekatestorch · 02/08/2021 12:44

Morally, no I don't think you should have to pay him back.

Not really sure that's the case legally (not sure legally is right word). It's your home tell him to leave.

If he insists on chasing the 4k or now 3k, pay him it back slowly. Get him out, split with him and claim through CMS.

Unless you have something that says you were going to keep him for x amount of time to pay back the money you borrowed, I don't see how you would win that one. Its 2 different things. I do think he should let the money go though.

Just get rid of him, out of the house.

IcedSpice · 02/08/2021 12:43

Min £300 per month over 17ish months, he owes you £5100 - tell him you'll kindly take your 'debt' out of it, so he only owes you £1100, which he can pay at £100 a month - on top of continuing to pay £300 per month rent if still staying with you.

including food? £300 no chance at least double that

IcedSpice · 02/08/2021 12:42

charge him rent / lodgings etc

and kick the fucker out

HTH1 · 02/08/2021 12:40

@OrangeElk

Charge him backdated rent from the beginning of lockdown, does he have his own room?

Min £300 per month over 17ish months, he owes you £5100 - tell him you'll kindly take your 'debt' out of it, so he only owes you £1100, which he can pay at £100 a month - on top of continuing to pay £300 per month rent if still staying with you.

Yep.
username18702 · 02/08/2021 12:40

@OrangeElk

Charge him backdated rent from the beginning of lockdown, does he have his own room?

Min £300 per month over 17ish months, he owes you £5100 - tell him you'll kindly take your 'debt' out of it, so he only owes you £1100, which he can pay at £100 a month - on top of continuing to pay £300 per month rent if still staying with you.

Do this.

OP you're with a man who would take your son's DLA from you. He sounds like a nasty piece of work.

frazzledasarock · 02/08/2021 12:32

money OP has paid back could be for anything, if there is no written loan agreement the money could have been a gift, his contribution towards housing his child, a loan he is repaying to OP could be anything.

I wouldn't pay him back a penny tell him he owes owe you for sponging off you for all this time. How much would renting somewhere have cost him over the past year?

When he steps out the house, lock the door.

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 02/08/2021 12:30

Firstly you’re grateful to him for taking “his” own child off your hands every now and then. So he damn well should be doing. This is his father why are you praising him for doing what he’s meant to do

PP is correct if there was nothing written down and signed that it was a lone and not a gift legally he won’t have a chance.
Plus the deposit could be seen as him putting a roof over his sons head.

He’s been there since the beginning of lockdown so just a little over 16 months ago.
He’s not paid so much as a chocolate gold coin or a monopoly note for any living expenses.

Plus you’ve already paid him 1K back. I think he’s more that had his 4K back, hasn’t he.

Also “he won’t go” I’d be damn hoofing him out, I can tell you.

CitrusIceCream · 02/08/2021 12:29

If you need to, OP, use UC as an excuse to get him out.

Tell him that they are under the impression that you are single & all payments would stop if they knew he was staying with you. Tell him he MUST return to his own home. Once he’s gone, change the locks.

Refuse point blank to repay one more penny of the money and yes, tell him that you think it perfectly disgusting that any decent father would want to be repaid for providing a roof over his own child’s head.

Then tell him your next call is to the CMA.

Please, please take some control here. You don’t need to be crying in bed over this pathetic tosspot. You really don’t.