Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I pay for everything and he’s asking for 4K

235 replies

Fridacat · 02/08/2021 12:01

Posting here for traffic

Partner helped me with a deposit for a house over a year ago it was 4K I have given some money back 1K but tbh he never really said at the time he wanted it back

Backstory we have one 6 year old child together who has autism been together 18 years but decided to live apart as we both like space he owns his own home and me and my son would live together

I pay for everything food rent bills my sons clothes literally everything. He pays for the odd McDonald’s happy meal and brings our son out which I am very grateful for as sometimes I need that break as I cannot cope at times. He’s is also filthy and I’m one of those who likes my house to be spotless

He has yet again told me today he wants the money back at a rate of 100.00 a month and is refusing to leave the home he’s been here since the start of lockdown which as I said above is great at times because I get a break when he takes our son out

I’m on universal credit and my son gets DLA I’ve never told his father I receive DLA or carers for our son as he would literally take the money from me he has always been very mean.

What am I asking is what would you do aibu to not give him 4K back over a period of time or should I just pay him I don’t know where the arsehole thinks I’m going to get the money from he obviously thinks I shit money.

He’s basically been living here rent free he owns his own house outright so he doesn’t have to pay a mortgage and he works he doesn’t buy our son clothes or anything

He has money he doesn’t have to work but got a job in the area I live in behind my back and told me 24/48 hours before he started. He’s due to be paid this week 2k yet he’s still abusing me about this money I ‘owe’ him

After typing this he really is a cunt in total it was 5K I’ve given him back 1K which he said I didn’t give back even when I proved I did with my bank statements

I literally cannot afford to pay back this money and tbh why should I he literally has been living rent free eating here for free gets his washing done etc

I don’t need any flaming please I’ve been crying in bed and recently come off my antidepressants and I’ll probably have to go back on them now due to the shit he is giving me about this money

OP posts:
thinkingaboutLangCleg · 02/08/2021 15:08

Ignore the fucker and then make a claim for child maintenance support. If it’s solely your house change the locks

This, 100%

Manista · 02/08/2021 15:00

The thing is Op - I've read all your replies and there's no indication that you have any intention to do anything about this situation. You've been warned that you're in danger of you being convicted of a crime. You've been advised that as you are the tenant you could just change the locks and put him out. It's been suggested that you invoice him for his lodgings. What are you planning to do? If anything.

JustLyra · 02/08/2021 14:59

Benefit fraud and accompanying blackmail is actually a surprisingly common abuse tactic.

Please speak to women’s aid @Fridacat

DeadButDelicious · 02/08/2021 14:56

You need to get him out of the house. If the tenancy is in your name alone then it's as simple as changing the locks and not letting him back in. You can bag up his belongings and leave them outside. He has no right to be there. He's there because you let him be there. He has a home. He can feel free to use it.

To be absolutely honest if the UC people catch wind of him living there with you without them knowing you will be in for a world of pain. Not least from all the money you will have to pay back. A conviction for benefit fraud is not something you want.

For your own sake and that of your child, get rid.

ShowMeTheSugar · 02/08/2021 14:54

Going forward you can tell him:

  1. Its over
  2. He's no longer welcome in your home
  3. He must a fixed amount towards his son or you can go through CMS

...I'd then either agree a monthly amount you can afford, or put in writing that you're quite shocked to have been asked to return the 4k gift which you understood to be a lump sum in lieu of years worth of child payments, but that once CMS confirm the minimal expected fee and what a backpaid sum would be you'll be happy to either pay or receive the difference.

Bookworm20 · 02/08/2021 14:50

@Couchbettato

If he gave you the money and didn't stipulate it was a loan, then it will be dealt with as a gift.

He can't ask for gifted money back. And if he took it to court theyd say as much.

This. He gifted it to help you put a roof over his childs head. Not at all unreasonable. If there nothing stating its a loan, if you didn't sign anything and he simply transferred you money, then its a gift. And to be honest if he took it to court, they'd look at it like this also, as no proof it was a loan and also he is the father of the child living there and he has money to burn, unlike you.

Not sure how you are going to get him out, but surely you want him out of your house and out of your life (except for visitation with your son)?

If he isn't contributing anything to your son, then you need to start claiming child maintenance from him.

I'd personally do this before he takes any sort of legal action to recoup his 4K. Because you can simply state that he is only doing so because you are asking for maintenance for the care of his child. He will come across as selfish and vindictive.

so my advice.

  1. ask him to leave, tell him you need him gone by the end of this week
  2. Tell him he needs to start paying for his son, or you will go down the CMS route.

If he refuses to leave, as you are the only one on the tenancy agreement, you can call the police to have him removed.
Failing that, next time he goes out, lock him out anyway you can and arrange to have the locks changed. He if gets angry/violent, call the police. Its not his house.

Good luck OP, I would hate to be in your position, but I think you know you can't just carry on with it. You clearly don't like him and your life will be much easier without him.

Taliskerskye · 02/08/2021 14:49

I mean he can’t come after the money unless he takes you to court and he can’t
And you can change the locks
And you can apply for CM
so that’s where you need to start

PearlFriday · 02/08/2021 14:48

I know somebody in Ireland who went to the DEASP and told them herself that her ''partner'' was blackmailing her and she couldn't get him out of the house. She told them that yes there was a man living in the house but not a man who ever contributed so much as half of a red cent and she was trying to get him to leave but he not only refused point blank but was blackmailing her, threatening to tell the DEASP on her. So she marched in and told them herself. Luckily they linked her up with services to get him out of the house. He'd planned to stay for ever by blackmailing her.

AmberIsACertainty · 02/08/2021 14:44

He will not help you if your benefits are stopped, then you’d really be in the shit.

She'd be in worse shit than that. Benefits won't just be stopped. All the benefits she's been paid since he's lived there, that she shouldn't have been entitled to because he was living there, she'll have to pay those benefits back plus a hefty fine on top. And they'll prosecute, so she'll have a criminal record and some sort of sentence too. She's literally ruining her life having him live there.

toocold54 · 02/08/2021 14:41

Benefit fraud

I wonder if you lose your benefits or get kicked out your home he’d put you and your son up rent free? I very much doubt it!

The first thing you need to do is get him out of your house!
After that you can sort out cms and him giving you a proper break from your son.
Him being in the same house is not a proper break.
Why are you allowing yourself to be treated like this I don’t understand. You need to start standing up for yourself and not let him treat you like such a mug.

DxHxSx · 02/08/2021 14:41

Tell him someone has called the DWP & told them you're a couple not a single claimant as declared. Bet he will move out very quickly

SixesAndEights · 02/08/2021 14:41

When are you chucking him out OP?

As soon as DWP get wind of this you'll be in major trouble.

If you don't chuck him out you'll have more than £4000 to worry about!

1Endeavour2 · 02/08/2021 14:41

Get a free session with a solicitor.
Contact CAB asap. You will get help to sort this out. Good luck.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 02/08/2021 14:40

Why are you with this man? I hope this thread has opened your eyes to exactly how bad this is.

The fact that you are 'grateful' that he deigns to take his child out occasionally speaks volumes.

Couchbettato · 02/08/2021 14:40

If he gave you the money and didn't stipulate it was a loan, then it will be dealt with as a gift.

He can't ask for gifted money back. And if he took it to court theyd say as much.

2bazookas · 02/08/2021 14:38

I would give him his son and go for a nice holiday rest while CSA sorts out your claim for child maintenance.

AcrossthePond55 · 02/08/2021 14:38

OP what is actually stopping you from locking him out? There must be some reason. Are you afraid of him?

I assume he has a key and he's not likely to voluntarily return it so your 'plan of action' needs to be coordinating a locksmith for a time when he will not be there. I think you said he's working so if he works regular shifts it should be easy enough. Or if you're handy you can change the lock barrels yourself. There are plenty of YouTube videos that show how.

I understand that he won't leave voluntarily, so there's really no point in continually asking or telling him to leave. That ship has sailed. Your only option now is to physically prevent him from re-entering the house. Ever.

Hekatestorch · 02/08/2021 14:32

@Jessica60

Benefit fraud
This.

Op could end up in a world of pain having him live there

CitrusIceCream · 02/08/2021 14:31

OP...this is a frustrating thread to read because you keep updating us with more details about what a shit he is without giving any indication that you’re taking any advice.

That’s up to you of course but be aware that if you are claiming UC as a lone parent and they find out that your son’s independantly wealthy, working father...who owns two properties...is living with you then you will a) have committed a criminal offence, b) have your benefits stopped, c) be unable to pay your rent, d) be evicted and e) won’t be able to ask the council for assistance because they’ll consider that you’ve intentionally made yourself homeless.

Is he worth it? If you’re scared of asking him to leave then say so and people can give you tailored advice to help you manage that safely.

Regarding the £4k....fuck it. If he takes you to court (the only thing he can legally do) and manages to get a judgement then the court will take into account that you’re a lone parent on benefits with a child who has a disability and tell you to pay £3.60 a month to him...or something like that.

No one can sort this mess out but you. No one.

BadNomad · 02/08/2021 14:28

As others have said you NEED to get him out because YOU are committing benefit fraud and will get into serious trouble. Contact the police to have him removed if needs be. That might support your case that there is no relationship between you when you get caught out that he's been living there.

Meraas · 02/08/2021 14:27

What are you actually going to do , OP?

It sounds like you just want to vent and then go back to putting up with him?

andweallsingalong · 02/08/2021 14:25

OP you absolutely must kick him out today.

UC won't care that he's a financially abusive arsehole. The first time he gives your address to a bank or similar or someone reports you they will recalculate your UC with his money. Then they will reduce / stop your UC without even talking to you, you will have nothing, no food, no rent and owe thousands in overpayments. If you try and deny he's living there then you will be prosecuted for benefit fraud and have to pay costs on top. You will also have to pay extra council tax as no longer entitled to the single person discount.

He's not worth it.

Fieldsofstars · 02/08/2021 14:24

@Jessica60 good point

Jessica60 · 02/08/2021 14:23

Benefit fraud

FatCatThinCat · 02/08/2021 14:22

Tell him to leave immediately. If he refuses, call the police and get them to remove him. He has no right to be there.

Forget the money you 'owe' him, you've used it to feed and house him throughout the pandemic.

Put in a claim for child maintenance straight away.

He's a pisstaker for sure, but he's only taking the piss because you're allowing him to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread