Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is right here?

512 replies

bakinbiscuits · 02/08/2021 10:42

I don't want to give away who I am in this situation so trying to be neutral.

Katie and John split up 2 years ago. 3 children who live primarily with Katie. John has regular contact, every other weekend and a Wednesday evening. Contact isn't set it stone so sometimes he has them more if work/plans allow. John has a girlfriend, Sarah, who he's been with for a year.

Katie's boiler has broken and John is a Plummer. Katie asked John if he would come fix the boiler as there is no hot water. John initially said yes but then changed his mind and he and sarah both think it's Katie's responsibility to fix the boiler herself as it is her house. John and sarah are happy to support by allowing the kids to bathe at their house until Katie gets the boiler fixed.

Should John help and fix the boiler or should Katie be getting another Plummer in to fix it.

OP posts:
bakinbiscuits · 02/08/2021 16:12

@walksen

Katie should have home emergency cover. It is not clear if John is a plumber or heating engineer and has any training or experience with the boiler in question, if he can work on it without affecting any warranty or guarantee claims.

He should probably be able to give some advice on the way forward but shouldn't have to financially subsidise an ex partners household costs.

If he didn't do the service or work on the boiler when he lived there he shouldn't do so now.

It is clear.. I said he's gas safe and it's his job.
OP posts:
walksen · 02/08/2021 16:09

Katie should have home emergency cover. It is not clear if John is a plumber or heating engineer and has any training or experience with the boiler in question, if he can work on it without affecting any warranty or guarantee claims.

He should probably be able to give some advice on the way forward but shouldn't have to financially subsidise an ex partners household costs.

If he didn't do the service or work on the boiler when he lived there he shouldn't do so now.

eekbumbler · 02/08/2021 15:59

I've been split from my partner for 12 years - lets call me Katie. John has had many different relationships over the years.

I can tell you from experience the only person stopping John from fixing the boiler would be Sarah.

John left Sarah when his best friend died and realised that Sarah was being a cow towards his child and ex and making life difficult. John said life is too short.

John and Katie are friends again and will even holiday again with their child. Sarah is a bitter old woman.

John sometimes does the bits of gardening Katie cannot reach.

ButYouJustPointedToAIIOfMe · 02/08/2021 15:55

I think it's fair to point out you have been dropping them off OP and shit-stirring Sarah can now pick them up. Or they have the kids witht hem until boiler is fixed (except I suspect he will then not pay maintenance?)
So I would drop them both at the house for showers and baths twice a day without towels but I am petty like that...

Grapewrath · 02/08/2021 15:51

Of course John should ensure his children have hot water at their home. No question.

hellcatspangle · 02/08/2021 15:48

If John is seriously refusing to fix the boiler at the house where his children live, John is a dick.

Datingandnoideahowto · 02/08/2021 15:48

@Clarice99 I’d be grateful if you wouldn’t quote or tag me. I’ve stepped away from this thread and have started my own thread for support.

Thanks.

Blueskytoday06 · 02/08/2021 15:46

@CH381

This!! God I’m glad I found this thread! I’ve been having this problem with my sister for years, she’s obsessed with receiving apologies. She will behave in a disgraceful way, a lot of the time drink, but when you pull her up on it she will play the victim, be extremely offended then demand apologies. She will milk it for months too. At the moment she is not speaking to my boyfriend. She speaks to me one minute then the next day send a tirade of abuse for no reason at all then complains to our friends that I’m not speaking to her. It’s exhausting! She is single and obsessed with meeting a man. When she’s drunk she will sit there slagging me off to my boyfriend telling him he can do better and then flirt outrageously. She has done it with other boyfriends so she has form. A few months ago I noticed she was texting my boyfriends phone. He shows me all of them, nothing to hide, but he agreed she did text him a lot considering they weren’t really friends. I told her it made me uncomfortable and could she not contact him as much. She kicked off on both of us, told my mum and all of our mutual friends that I’d accused them both of seeing each other (???) and now she’s dragging it on waiting for an apology from us both. I feel she owes me an apology for making me uncomfortable and not respecting my request. She has escalated it into this big monster now and brings it up at any possible opportunity, dragging on the pity party. How do we fix this without giving her the apology she craves but doesn’t deserve?? It’s awkward with our mum and mutual friends and my poor boyfriend is horrified and a bit scared of her. He says she is bullying me and I think he’s right
Wrong thread ??
Clarice99 · 02/08/2021 15:46

@Datingandnoideahowto

Because I’m in that exact situation with an ex who wants something for free.
That, my dear, is abundantly clear from your 'reactive' unhelpful posts Grin

John is arsehole. It's his children who are being caught in the middle of this.

Taliskerskye · 02/08/2021 15:45

Just stop helping him
You’re living in la la land if you think that your kind amicable relationship is going to continue now that someone else has decided he shouldn’t help you out.
Just say you can’t drop them off anymore

diddl · 02/08/2021 15:36

@Hankunamatata

Ask if john has a mate who can repair since he has now said no. Most gasfitters know each other and can someone to do for mates rates
Wouldn't asking for mate's rates be a bit cheeky when you could just as easily do it yourself?

Fine to ask for a recommendation of someone who is reliable & will do a good job though.

CH381 · 02/08/2021 15:34

This!! God I’m glad I found this thread! I’ve been having this problem with my sister for years, she’s obsessed with receiving apologies. She will behave in a disgraceful way, a lot of the time drink, but when you pull her up on it she will play the victim, be extremely offended then demand apologies. She will milk it for months too. At the moment she is not speaking to my boyfriend. She speaks to me one minute then the next day send a tirade of abuse for no reason at all then complains to our friends that I’m not speaking to her. It’s exhausting! She is single and obsessed with meeting a man. When she’s drunk she will sit there slagging me off to my boyfriend telling him he can do better and then flirt outrageously. She has done it with other boyfriends so she has form. A few months ago I noticed she was texting my boyfriends phone. He shows me all of them, nothing to hide, but he agreed she did text him a lot considering they weren’t really friends. I told her it made me uncomfortable and could she not contact him as much. She kicked off on both of us, told my mum and all of our mutual friends that I’d accused them both of seeing each other (???) and now she’s dragging it on waiting for an apology from us both. I feel she owes me an apology for making me uncomfortable and not respecting my request. She has escalated it into this big monster now and brings it up at any possible opportunity, dragging on the pity party. How do we fix this without giving her the apology she craves but doesn’t deserve?? It’s awkward with our mum and mutual friends and my poor boyfriend is horrified and a bit scared of her. He says she is bullying me and I think he’s right

Hankunamatata · 02/08/2021 15:34

Ask if john has a mate who can repair since he has now said no. Most gasfitters know each other and can someone to do for mates rates

diddl · 02/08/2021 15:29

It would be handy for them to stay with their dad-but maybe Op doesn't want that?

icedcoffees · 02/08/2021 15:28

Sarah needs to keep her nose out.
John should fix the boiler (or at least come and have a look and advise, as it may need replacing).
Katie should pay for parts (and send a message to John to make it clear that she doesn't just want a freebie).

sashh · 02/08/2021 15:25

John should

a) fix the boiler because he can and it is his children, he should charge for parts and labour and if he is a nice guy the labour would be at mates rates.

or

b) the children should go stay with John until Katie has arranged for a plumber, taken time off work, saved up the money to pay.

This is from the information supplied.

If John used to live in the same house then he should have known roughly how long the boiler would last and not wither replacing it or warning Katie is a mean cunty thing to do.

Bookworm20 · 02/08/2021 15:24

If not (which I suspect is the case) why should he do free work on someone else's house?

Because his KIDS live there?

And its not 'someone elses' house. Its the house where the mother of his children lives. Not some random stranger.

Sadiecow · 02/08/2021 15:17

@Datingandnoideahowto

Katie should either get another plumber or pay John the going rate.

If I was John I’d decline too because that’s blurring boundaries and suggest a mate Katie can get to fox the boiler.

Don't apply for a detectives role, she could be Sarah?

John should fix the boiler, if parts are needed Katie should pay for those.

Buffoonborisisatwat · 02/08/2021 15:16

Does John have any skin in the game ? ie does he still have a financial interest in the house with the broken boiler? If so, he probably wouldn't want to pay someone else to do the job he's trained to do for his own property.

If not (which I suspect is the case) why should he do free work on someone else's house? Katie shouldn't have asked John and just called a competent plumber without involving him, apart from maybe asking John for a recommendation.

if John has a financial interest in the house and refuses to fix the boiler which means you have to pay someone else, he's a mean arsehole, but there's nothing much you can you about it.

Sarah can keep her nose out of it all.

MrsMaizel · 02/08/2021 15:16

John needs to go and fix it so that his kids can live properly !

However are they separated or divorced ?

Is the house 100% Katie's ?

If John still has a financial interest in it then he should do it because of that . Even if he doesn't he should because he is their father ! Why make the mother of your children out of pocket for something as basic as this ?

Blueskytoday06 · 02/08/2021 15:13

Katie so you're not reliant on a bloke - just buy a policy that covers you for breakdown repairs. If you have to barter with an ex then you need to find an alternative, regardless of whether or not you think John should help, the answer is no. That way you just call the number & someone comes without argument.

Perhaps what's really peeving you is Sarah's opinion.

Bookworm20 · 02/08/2021 15:10

John is a knob. He has the skills to fix a problem in the house where his dc and the mother of his dc live and he isnt going to do it. What kind of a father would do that? Even if it cost him the parts ffs. He is their father and you are his children's mother.

Sarah is also a knob. What kind of woman wouldn't be berating her partner for NOT helping the mother of his DC in such a scenario.

I am separated from my DC's father and we are not always on the best of terms, it is sometimes quite strained especially since other partners came on the scene to add a degree of complication. But I know for a fact that if there was the same scenario and he had the skills to fix the issue he would be there in a shot.

And vice versa. He is the father of my dc and if he needed my help in such a situation and I was able to help, I would give it.
And both partners would not blink an eye. In fact I am confident that both would be appalled if the other didn't help.

I honestly can't understand the replies that say he shouldn't help because he doesn't live there. Just because parents have separated, as there are DC involved there is basically a lifelong responsibility there to ensure their wellbeing, and if that means fixing the sodding boiler in the other parents home, then that is what you do.

SmallPrawnEnergy · 02/08/2021 15:07

John's only obligation is to pay child support.
What a sad low bar you set with a statement like this.

3peassuit · 02/08/2021 15:06

Of course he should fix it. Any parts needed, he can charge at cost. Why on earth would a father not do that for a home his children share?

Herecomesthesun70 · 02/08/2021 15:04

John should fix the boiler. He's a prick if he doesn't. If Sarah is stopping him she's an even bigger prick

Swipe left for the next trending thread