Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is right here?

512 replies

bakinbiscuits · 02/08/2021 10:42

I don't want to give away who I am in this situation so trying to be neutral.

Katie and John split up 2 years ago. 3 children who live primarily with Katie. John has regular contact, every other weekend and a Wednesday evening. Contact isn't set it stone so sometimes he has them more if work/plans allow. John has a girlfriend, Sarah, who he's been with for a year.

Katie's boiler has broken and John is a Plummer. Katie asked John if he would come fix the boiler as there is no hot water. John initially said yes but then changed his mind and he and sarah both think it's Katie's responsibility to fix the boiler herself as it is her house. John and sarah are happy to support by allowing the kids to bathe at their house until Katie gets the boiler fixed.

Should John help and fix the boiler or should Katie be getting another Plummer in to fix it.

OP posts:
Intherightplace · 02/08/2021 11:09

But if John has to give up paid work, he's not just fixing the boiler, he's effectively paying for it to be done. I agree you'd like to think a solution can be reached where he can fit this in and get his children hot water without putting off other work, but I don't think he should have a financial detriment as a result

Mandalay246 · 02/08/2021 11:07

It's not John's house, why should he fix the boiler? Katie can pay a plumber to fix it. As for it being "essential to his childrens' welbeing" that's all well and good, but if John were a surgeon, or a lawyer, or anything else Katie would have to call in a plumber and I'm sure the children would cope - like all children who don't have a plumber as a father!

DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 02/08/2021 11:07

I don't want to give away who I am in this situation so trying to be neutral.

You can't be neutral when telling your own story. There's always a bias.

Katie wasn't unreasonable to ask, but John isn't unreasonable in saying no and facilitating his kids needs at his home instead.

DancesWithTortoises · 02/08/2021 11:07

@Intherightplace

Is Sarah unreasonable to have an opinion if John giving up paid work to do this job affects their household finances?
If she has that opinion it confirms my belief she's a miserable cah.
SmallPrawnEnergy · 02/08/2021 11:07

John should stop letting himself be pussy whipped by the latest girlfriend.

John should realise by fixing Katie’s boiler he is showing a civilised and respectful relationship between co-parents.

By NOT fixing the boiler he is showing Katie (and possibly the children) that his sad little girlfriends feelings are more important than his children and he is a petty little man.

Cadent · 02/08/2021 11:06

OP is almost certainly Katie. The story would be told differently if she wasn't grin

I hope so! The bit about 'happy to support by allowing the kids to bathe at their house until Katie gets the boiler fixed' made me wonder. How magnanimous!

Maves · 02/08/2021 11:06

Sorry Sarah should wind her neck in

MaMelon · 02/08/2021 11:06

Working on the assumption that Katie and John are reasonable people who have a reasonable relationship - John is being a complete dick by not fixing the boiler so his kids can have hot water.

Maves · 02/08/2021 11:05

His kids home no brainer. Katie needs to wind her neck in he has kids.

Intherightplace · 02/08/2021 11:05

Is Sarah unreasonable to have an opinion if John giving up paid work to do this job affects their household finances?

Sapphire85 · 02/08/2021 11:05

You're clearly Sarah in this situation.

Of course John should fix the heating/hot water in the house where his children live for the majority of the time if he has the means to do so.

If John originally agreed to this, what (who) changed his mind??

AnneLovesGilbert · 02/08/2021 11:02

Has Katie got form for asking favours instead of taking responsibility for her own home?

Skyeheather · 02/08/2021 11:01

Of course John should fix the boiler in his children's house (assuming he's qualified). Why would Katie pay full rates to have someone else fix it when John can fix it for the cost of parts/mates rates. This is the advantage of having friends/relatives in a trade.

Would John fix the boiler if it was one of his friends or relatives in this situation? Of course he would, his children are his immediate relatives.

He's not fixing the boiler foe his ex, he'll be fixing it so his kids can have hot water for a bath etc.

annacondom · 02/08/2021 11:01

You are Sarah, because you've given yourself a lower-case s to fade into the background (sarah), and also you spell plumber incorrectly. What are you afraid of? The sooner the boiler us fixed, the sooner you stop having the kids bathing at yours.

Intherightplace · 02/08/2021 11:00

@Cadent

I hope you are Katie. John and Sarah are knobs.
OP is almost certainly Katie. The story would be told differently if she wasn't Grin
Datsandcogs · 02/08/2021 11:00

Sarah’s opinion is irrelevant.

I think John should prioritise fixing the boiler. Katie should expect to pay. If John is kind then payment will be mates rates or less.

sprinkleyumnut · 02/08/2021 11:00

Sorry I meant Katie not Sarah

RitaFires · 02/08/2021 10:59

This is all a bit weird, if John is trained and certified to fix the boiler I think he should and Katie should offer him some kind of money towards it. I get the new partner wanting there to be a boundary about work done to what is no longer his house but that would be more reasonable about general DIY, not his professional area.

If I were Katie I'd find another plumber and get it fixed and if happy with the work would be giving online reviews and recommendations and if anyone asked mention that John had said he'd do it and then backed out so this new plumber was a lifesaver.

Hekatestorch · 02/08/2021 10:59

There's also a distinct possibility John can't do anything anyway.

Op says he is a plumber. Doesn't mean he can faff with the boiler. If the problem is actually the boiler and he isn't gas safe registered, it could cause issues if he messes it up.

sprinkleyumnut · 02/08/2021 10:59

If he can fix it, then it would be kind of him to do so. However even if his children he technically doesn't have to. It really is down to Sarah to get it fixed and all she can do is ask John but saying no is still in his rights even if they are his children it's Sarah's house and responsibility.

Intherightplace · 02/08/2021 10:58

I think John should do it, becuase it benefits his children, but he shouldn't give up paid work to do it and Katie should cover the cost of parts. I.e. Katie will have to live with the fact that he'll do it in an evening or weekend when his booked work allows.

MangoBiscuit · 02/08/2021 10:58

It's Katie's responsibility to get it fixed.

That said, assuming there is no back story and Katie and John have an amicable co-parenting relationship, I would think John was a bit of a dick for not helping if he could. Pretty big assumption without evidence though.

loopyapp · 02/08/2021 10:58

I cannot imagine how sad it must be to raise kids with someone who would refuse to help where and when they could.

HoppingPavlova · 02/08/2021 10:57

If Katie was calling John to do this and that in the way of odd jobs and he said no, I would understand completely. However, it’s a boiler. And he is a plumber. And the kids father. It’s a dick move on his part not to just get in, fix it and get out. Katie should however pay for any parts that may be required or obviously a new boiler if required.

Marmitemarinaded · 02/08/2021 10:57

There’s no “should” about it.

He is being very unpleasant

But he’s not obliged to do this at all.

You are responsible for the upkeep of yours and your children’s home.

I would also ask my ex in your situation. If he said no, I’d think “twat” and then call a plumber

Swipe left for the next trending thread