Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is right here?

512 replies

bakinbiscuits · 02/08/2021 10:42

I don't want to give away who I am in this situation so trying to be neutral.

Katie and John split up 2 years ago. 3 children who live primarily with Katie. John has regular contact, every other weekend and a Wednesday evening. Contact isn't set it stone so sometimes he has them more if work/plans allow. John has a girlfriend, Sarah, who he's been with for a year.

Katie's boiler has broken and John is a Plummer. Katie asked John if he would come fix the boiler as there is no hot water. John initially said yes but then changed his mind and he and sarah both think it's Katie's responsibility to fix the boiler herself as it is her house. John and sarah are happy to support by allowing the kids to bathe at their house until Katie gets the boiler fixed.

Should John help and fix the boiler or should Katie be getting another Plummer in to fix it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bouledeneige · 06/08/2021 10:40

I think he should fix the boiler as he is a plumber. But if it was the car or anything else I think she should sort it out herself.

FortniteBoysMum · 05/08/2021 23:56

I think it wouldn't hurt John to help Katie out here. His kids also need heat in their home. The boiler is not just for baths but heating, some washing machines run off hot water meaning Katie may not be able to do washing, no hot water for washing up either. It's about what's best for the children and it's possible Katie may not have the funds to fix the boiler especially at this time of year when children need new uniforms for the new school year.

MyTeenagersPissMeOffMostDays · 05/08/2021 23:10

I think John is a wimp and Sarah has thrown her toys out of the pram. They are his kids, why would you not fix it? His kids would have hot water and if he fixed it Katie wouldn't have to pay another plumber leaving more money for their kids

Runnerduck34 · 05/08/2021 20:16

John should fix the boiler, its the home where his children live and he is leaving them without hot water when he could easily sort it. Katie should pay for any parts.
Sounds like John changed his mind about fixing boiler after speaking to Sarah. If so Sarah needs to butt out and grow up and John needs to grow a pair.
If I was Katie I would now sort it myself and not ask again but this would be a line in the sand.

blubberyboo · 05/08/2021 16:40

Sarah is a twat as she obviously has manipulated John into saying no to something he would have been willing to do initially based on her own insecurities simply as Katie is the mother of his kids.

Of course he should fix the boiler as ultimately it keeps spare cash in the household where his kids live.

worldandsky · 05/08/2021 16:03

I think John should fix the boiler as it's in the benefit of his children, what's the point of him being a plumber when he won't use his skills to
Benefit his own children. He needs to grow up and stop being a twat just because he no longer is with Katie. I wonder what his kids will think of him when they are older.

sympatico1 · 05/08/2021 15:55

@ThePoppyClub

It sounds very similar. I doubt if Sarah is calling the shots, it sounds like Katie wants to think that as it makes her feel better about her ex not having the same feelings for her anymore.

How do we know if Sarah is calling the shots? We only have Katie's word for it.

Well - the fact that John asked Katie not to mention to Sarah that he would pay for the boiler repair does indicate that Sarah has a problem with John helping out his ex. Sounds like Sarah is calling the shots to me.
ShortBacknSides · 05/08/2021 15:08

Get it fixed yourself, you're not his responsibility and he pays maintenance for his children.

Oh yeah, like standard maintenance pays 50% of the cost of raising children. As if.

Clearly you’re like the Sarah, and that’s the problem. Once you have children with someone you have responsibilities.

ThePoppyClub · 05/08/2021 14:53

It sounds very similar. I doubt if Sarah is calling the shots, it sounds like Katie wants to think that as it makes her feel better about her ex not having the same feelings for her anymore.

How do we know if Sarah is calling the shots? We only have Katie's word for it.

marmaladehound · 05/08/2021 14:45

@MarcusRashford

If Sarah lives with John and therefore lives with the children when they visit then that does affect her. The ex wife's boiler is really not Sarah's. problem. I. was also a Sarah and I'd done nothing wrong to upset the Katie in our situation. She just hated that I existed and made my life a bloody misery.
But that's your personal experience of an ex not liking you. That's not really the same as Katie. I think she just doesn't want sarah calling the shots about what their kids father does abs doesn't do for his kids.
MarcusRashford · 05/08/2021 14:43

If Sarah lives with John and therefore lives with the children when they visit then that does affect her. The ex wife's boiler is really not Sarah's. problem. I. was also a Sarah and I'd done nothing wrong to upset the Katie in our situation. She just hated that I existed and made my life a bloody misery.

marmaladehound · 05/08/2021 14:39

@MarcusRashford

I've just read a bit more. I was Sarah in this situation, it was horrible being the butt of the ex wife's anger for doing nothing wrong apart from being alive. Leave her alone she's done nothing wrong to you. Your boiler problem is not her issue.
But then what he does for his kids has nothing to do with sarah.

Personally as someone who was once a sarah, I loved the fact that my OH put his kids first, it said a lot about him as a good, decent person and I would not have changed that for the world. In my opinion his kids were more important than me and that's the way it should be.

MarcusRashford · 05/08/2021 14:25

I've just read a bit more. I was Sarah in this situation, it was horrible being the butt of the ex wife's anger for doing nothing wrong apart from being alive. Leave her alone she's done nothing wrong to you. Your boiler problem is not her issue.

MarcusRashford · 05/08/2021 14:21

I'm not sure why you're bringing Sarah into the argument? Get it fixed yourself, you're not his responsibility and he pays maintenance for his children.

HappyGoLuckyLuLu · 05/08/2021 14:15

Did the mate come today? If not another message might be worth thinking about. Just say sorry for over-reacting but you would be grateful for his mate's and his help to get the boiler fixed. And if you wanted you could try to explain why you had such a strong reaction by expressing concern that his relationship will impact how he engages in situations that would impact the wellbeing of your DC.

In the long run the joint dinners and things may come to an end, but a health/safety/wellbeing issue should not cause a problem and contact ought to be possible in those instances.

And yes, maybe trying to not ask his help too frequently is your best way forwards - but for plumbing emergencies I think he really should be allowed to help you out.

Good luck!

Blueink · 05/08/2021 10:53

Stop focussing on/blaming Sarah, if u can OP, not healthy nor productive and everything to do with why you reacted emotionally.

MzHz · 05/08/2021 10:35

@madabouttheman

If an amicable split then John should repair the boiler as his children live there. Probably a lot more to this situation though.
No.

Just the arrival of Sarah.

bjjgirl · 05/08/2021 09:04

Op I like you have a great relationship with exp - my current dp does with his ex also so he understands the need to coparent to well and that being friends is possible.

However it can be really intimidating to new partners, exp had a girlfriend who was super intimidated until she met me and got to know it works for all parties, I would have the kids extra for their date night etc. She really struggled to understand that there was nothing more than friendship / no hidden agenda in our relationship- this eventually among other things caused their relationship to end.

I would advise not to pressure him about his relationship, but support. He has fixed the problem, just think of it as

"Not my monkeys, not my circus"

madabouttheman · 05/08/2021 08:55

If an amicable split then John should repair the boiler as his children live there. Probably a lot more to this situation though.

Hadenough2021 · 05/08/2021 08:48

Omg John needs to fix the bloody boiler. I’m sure he’d do it for his mate, these are his kids! Absolutely ridiculous. And as for Sarah it’s nothing to do with her!

ellyeth · 04/08/2021 23:08

I think John should fix the boiler. He's a plumber and they are his three children. It's not a cosmetic issue - having a working boiler is essential.

AnneLovesGilbert · 04/08/2021 22:36

We usually do things together for their birthdays, a party/trip/meal or whatever, I strongly suspect this won't happen anymore.

Things change. It’s sometimes better for children to do separate celebrations with their separated parents. It maintains healthy boundaries and doesn’t have to be a bad thing or upset the children.

Don’t borrow trouble by jumping ahead but it’s okay for him to want to change the dynamic you’ve had if he wants to. Considering his girl friends feelings is also normal and okay.

Sarcobaleno · 04/08/2021 22:31

I didn't say he had moral high ground, I said you lost it. I understand your fears about the GF influencing his behaviour towards you and kids, but I think you need to try and stay as calm and reasonable as possible otherwise you're playing right into that. You catch more flies with honey and all that. Good luck

bakinbiscuits · 04/08/2021 22:24

I don't think he has the moral high ground, he's lying to his girlfriend.

I have reacted emotionally and it's so out of character for me, this is actually the first hiccup we've had since splitting. It's always been really good between us despite what happened.

I think I'm upset because I feel like everything is going to change now. In her mind she's stopped this. I definitely will never ask him for help again and I will need to find the balance between putting my own boundaries in and ensuring the children aren't impacted. I just hope that her input doesn't effect our children. He's let her dictate this, I hope it doesn't then start being visits, or going to events together for them. We usually do things together for their birthdays, a party/trip/meal or whatever, I strongly suspect this won't happen anymore. If he isn't allowed to come fix the boiler to ensure our kids have hot water she's hardly going to like us going to dinner together is she.

OP posts:
Sarcobaleno · 04/08/2021 22:02

Text and say you over reacted and thanks for sorting. You nagged him for not putting kids first and now you've let your emotions take over best thing for kids. Well done for getting him to sort it in first place, but you've now lost the moral high ground