Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have done this in ‘public’? Unsupervised kids.

189 replies

WhatsAppening · 02/08/2021 09:43

NC for this as it’s incredibly outing.

For a few months now there have been two small kids playing in the road in our small estate. They have ZERO road sense. They have run in front of cars several times. They often just stop in the middle of the road in front of cars. They are 5 and 6 apparently.

Yesterday when leaving for work I had to slam on my brakes despite only going 5 mph round one of the three blind corners as the little girl sped into my path on her bike. I was really shaken, she was inches away from my bumper.

Not knowing who they belonged to I posted on the estate WhatsApp group to say what had happened, I said it’s not the first time (although the scariest) and that they need to be supervised.

The mum responded to say yeah but we live in a flat and they need outside play, and she can’t always be out there with them because she has to do housework.

I then got a flurry of private messages from other neighbours saying they’ve also had near misses and that the kids are sent out after breakfast and called in at tea time. Not one of them posted anything on the group.

Anyway I responded again saying that I appreciate they need outside time but that they need supervision. Got one line back saying ‘message me privately’.

I lost my rag a bit and said just supervise your kids ffs and I’m not interested in a private chat.

Anyway it all kicked off. Her husband chimed in, she said I’m parent shaming her and she has anxiety (not too anxious about the kids though are you hun) and basically left me feeling like the baddie.

So, was I being unreasonable to do this in the group? I had no idea who she was so couldn’t have messaged her to start with.

OP posts:
LaBellina · 02/08/2021 11:54

They sound incredibly entitled and their behavior has in the end probably caused a lot more anxiety for them then simply admitting they were at fault for not keeping an eye on their kids and apologizing for the nuisance so far. Also, what about your anxiety and the anxiety of your neighbors, each time you get in your car and hope it won’t result in an accident this time.
Your final response wasn’t great but overall I would say YANBU as I completely understand how annoying it must be to get the response that you did from them after what had happened earlier today. You’re right, there’s nothing to discuss privately, the point was clear but you could have picked your choice of wording it a bit more carefully.

ChainJane · 02/08/2021 11:53

Make sure you have a dashcam, in situations like this the presumption will always be that the driver was at fault even if the child jumps out in their path from behind a parked car.

There are lots of irresponsible parents out there and it's a numbers game - sooner or later someone will knock a child down. You just need to make sure that if it's you, you have the footage to show you were driving carefully and braked promptly.

Likeitornot1 · 02/08/2021 11:51

I'm not sure if you live where I do but was just about to post a very similar thread about 2 children playing unsupervised and what could be done as parents are just completely oblivious to the fact their children could get SERIOUSLY hurt one day. But I am not on a group chat so think it could be separate incident.
Anyway, I'm shocked that nobody else said anything if they feel the same way. If more than one person says something it shows that it is a problem and not just one person having a moan.
You did the right thing and the parents are idiots! I'm sure she can supervise them for a bit, go in and then go back out later. It's different if they were playing sensibly, but they are not!

Sceptre86 · 02/08/2021 11:48

Something very similar happened on our estate last week. Kids were running out in the road infront of cars on purpose. One neighbour posted very apologetically on the estate Facebook page, 'It's great to see kids playing outside especially after the year they have had but if your kids are playing at the bottom of the estate can you have words as they are running in the road infront of cars. Like I said I know it's just kids being kids but would hate for any of them to get hurt'. Most parents didn't bother responding, the one that did thanked the original poster for alerting her to the fact and had called her kids in. All the kids were under about 7 years old and the youngest looked about 3. This is an estate with decent sized gardens, green spaces and a small adventure playground. Why can some parents just not supervise their kids?

Yanbu and she clearly isn't that anxious if she chucks her kids out unsupervised all day. I absolutely would report to ss, both parents need to get a grip.

mynameisbrian · 02/08/2021 11:46

The law is clear that it is against the law to leave a child alone if it puts them at risk. This usually relates to being at home alone however given the two kids are on their own and at risk of being run over - would seem sensible to contact SS to raise concerns about their safety. Or you can all as a group of neighbours complain to each other privately about having nearly knocked them over and wait until one is....

ApolloandDaphne · 02/08/2021 11:46

@MyDcAreMarvel Actually I posted saying OP should report this and I am a retired SW. I think giving there was a near miss and the children are playing out all day while their parents are in a flat and not supervising SS may well pop out and speak with them. Usually they might call the school/nursery first to find out if there are any issues but they are closed now. I have made loads of visits like this over the years.

BFrazzled · 02/08/2021 11:39

@MyDcAreMarvel

There is an awful lot of very naive posters on this thread. SS are not going to visit because two young children are playing out.
Seriously?? Surely it is against the law to leave children this age unsupervised?
BFrazzled · 02/08/2021 11:37

You are not supposed to leave a 6 and a 5 year old unsupervised - cars are just one of the issues. How is it even a question? Call the police.

gogohm · 02/08/2021 11:33

The initial post was fine, I wouldn't have replied to her response publicly however much I felt it because that is publically shaming "supervise your kids" bit. If it continues, after all she is aware that they are causing a problem, I would call social services or the police to state there's two very young unsupervised children outside and leave it to them

Vanilla1Cookies · 02/08/2021 11:28

I would of done the same thing and I don’t think you were aggressive.
She’s a crap parent and doesn’t care about her kids by the looks of it.

Marriedtothesilverfox · 02/08/2021 11:28

I’d contacr social services, those children are at risk

stayathomer · 02/08/2021 11:27

Sorry I meant they were being unreasonable!!! You were totally reasonable!!!

stayathomer · 02/08/2021 11:26

You were definitely being unreasonable and it's a pity everyone didn't chime in. Saying that I'm sorry it's also a pity you didn't engage with them, some people need the talking to to see sense (not saying that's right just the way things are)

MyDcAreMarvel · 02/08/2021 11:25

There is an awful lot of very naive posters on this thread. SS are not going to visit because two young children are playing out.

billy1966 · 02/08/2021 11:22

Report it.
Also take shots of the messages from the others who confirmed that their is an issue.

A child hit at even 10 mph can die of internal bleeding.

It sounds like an accident waiting to happen.

steppemum · 02/08/2021 11:20

I would actually contact your local community police officer and ask them if they have any way of approahcing this? if they happened to stroll down the road when kids were out, and then wnet and atlkedto parents?

A child cannot judge the speed of an approaching car below the age of 10.
So they must be taught to not go in the road at all without an adult.

ButterflyCat2028 · 02/08/2021 11:19

If a five and a six year old have no road sense whatsoever then either, both parents have neglected their children by not teaching them basic safety concepts, or their may be some sort of developmental delay or autism. However none of those scenarios excuse their lack of parenting or accountability. Sadly social services won't do anything if it's just that.

The 'best' solution would be the parents getting it together. Unfortunately it sounds like any actual solution would pretty much mean you having to do their job. Next time you see one of the kids in front of your car on the road, stop completely and get them onto a path (sorry OP as utterly shit as that is to do)

Twintwix · 02/08/2021 11:15

I would phone the police and report. They can take it from there. Small kids playing on roads is a police matter. The parents are idiots. Where's the concern for their kids' safety? All about the mum's "anxiety".

JudgeJ · 02/08/2021 11:15

@RedHelenB

The last bit is what makes you unreasonable. No problem with pointing out that you had come close to hitting them but now you know they are often playing out and generalised it the only thing to do is to be really cautious when you drive in and out of your road.
Don't try to absolve the parents' neglect by implying it's the driver's fault! In these situations the only way to protect the children from their parents' neglect and disinterest is not to drive, at all and that's impractical. You can drive as slowly as possible, neglected children who enjoy playing chicken will jump out.
Pinkdelight3 · 02/08/2021 11:13

The woman was obviously willing to discuss. She just wanted to do it privately.

But there's nothing to discuss. It's not the OP's issue to get into beyond alerting the parents that it's a problem (which they should already know). The mum and dad needed to thank OP for flagging, stop making excuses and sort it out.

3scape · 02/08/2021 11:11

Stop car. Shout in street for parent. If the parent can't see or hear make a call to Social Services about unsupervised children in x street. If all your neighbours did this then they will get someone coming to tell them that leaving children that young unsupervised is dangerous as as parents they are apparently not able to make that assessment themselves. Poor kids. My childhood was like that. Home is usually worse than random strangers trying to teach you road safety.

eightyfourandahalf · 02/08/2021 11:11

@Lweji

An unsupervised small child playing in the middle of the road, at risk of being run over?

I'd have stayed with her and called the police to hand the child over to a responsible adult.
The police could call themselves or report to whatever service.

that's exactly what I would have done, or would do next!

Well done OP for at least caring about the children when their own parents don't.. Housework above your own children? I don't even have any word.

itsgettingwierd · 02/08/2021 11:11

What exactly is there to discuss in private though?

She's neglecting to supervise children who are below the age of road sense (8).

A message was sent to explain a possible fatal danger was being posed to kids.

The only things that needs to happen is the kids are supervised or play in communal gardens (which they are today).

There is no discussion needed. There is no alternative or compromise to be had here as it's about children safety against possible life changing injuries or death.

StrangeToSee · 02/08/2021 11:10

Does she realise her children could be killed riding unsupervised on dangerous roads like that? Imagine if you hadn’t seen her in time or were driving faster 😨

If it carries on I’d report to social services or the non emergency police because it’s neglectful and the children are at risk of being seriously injured or killed. A chat with a police officer might get some sense into the mum (and the kids) about the risks of riding in the road.

KittenKong · 02/08/2021 11:10

Shame you can’t do a poll...

“AIBU to call social services on #27 whose kids are always in danger on the roads...”

Swipe left for the next trending thread