Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you talk about with people who have no interests?

239 replies

TheBestPlansAlwaysFail · 02/08/2021 08:09

I am making more of an effort to make some new friends now that lockdown is over.
(We moved back to the city we now live in right before lockdown and most of the people I was friends with when I previously lived here have moved away - so rude of them! Wink)

Anyway, what I noticed is that there seem to be so many people who have absolutely no interests (and some seem to have no personality to top it off). I usually have no issue to find a topic of conversation but with some people, nothing seems to lead anywhere - arts, sports/fitness, science, reading, traveling, music, cooking, pets, gardening,....? They're not interested/scared/don't care. Stuff like politics, social equality, philosophy? They don't have an opinion on it. Work, family, etc? All good but there is not really much to talk about.

It is like drawing blood from a stone. What can you actually talk about with people like this? I am not looking for friendships for life right now, I just want someone to go to the pub and have a half-way decent conversation with - but by the end of these 'conversation', I am just drained and looking for an out. Maybe it is lockdown? Have people forgotten how to hold a conversation?

OP posts:
BlithePilgrim · 03/08/2021 14:12

@Notawriteryet

I am the mum and ex-wife of neurodivergent non-conversationalists. They literally have no interest in the other person. That’s not to say they’re unkind or think badly of the other person, they’re just disinterested. If you get them on to their special topics away they go and they’ll bore the arse off about gaming, or varieties of honeybees, or whatever. They sort of like other people’s company but don’t see the need to contribute to it. All of them can mask to a degree and when prompted can do the “have you come far?” schtick but they can’t keep it up for long.

For them the joy of company is what they get out of it. No concern whatsoever as to what the other person might be thinking. As far as they are concerned that’s not their business.

One of them is very number/list oriented. So one of his “openers” is “let me tell you my 4 facts about helicopters” and if he doesn’t get all 4 facts out, it’s almost painful! They have to be shared even if I’m shouting “no no no! Let me wee in peace!”

Luckily they are also very loving and funny and cute. Except the ex.

Only for the fact that you are definitely not my mother, you are describing my father here. I once witnessed as I was getting the hang of BFing a very new, baby in a car and couldn't move to rescue those involved my father spend a full twenty-five minutes giving a whistle-stop tour of his dental interventions in the car park of a visitor attraction to two complete strangers he'd somehow discovered went to the same dentist as him.

The aghast expression on their faces will stay with me.

My uncle has a similar style, and at the rare family gatherings where they coincide, they monologue at one another about their pet subjects.

It is very clear that the one who isn't talking at any one point is simply waiting for the other to stop so he can resume his disquisition on 'repairs to my CB radio' or 'strimmers and their capacities.'

Then again, I was in the middle of telling my father about the results of a pre-natal test for an obscure but worrying condition it looked as though DS might have, and he actually interrupted me in the middle of saying 'Good news, Dad, we just found out that the baby doesn't have ---' to cut me off to tell me about something someone he used to work with had done to his burglar alarm.

He just seems to have almost no theory of mind from his POV, he had got the information that our baby didn't have the condition, so why wouldn't he move on to another topic? We've had to have related conversations about him leaving his phone at home when he used to head out with my toddler DS and just disappear for hours on what was supposed to be a quick amble around the local park as he saw it, he knew DS was fine, so why would it be a problem that I didn't know?

Me saying patiently again and again that it's really not unusual for the parent of a small child to want to know where they are, (especially when they are with an insulin-reliant diabetic who has ocasionally collapsed and who has not brought nappies with him) just didn't register.

Shedbuilder · 03/08/2021 13:59

@Snoozer11

Maybe it's you, OP.
Nah, it's definitely you, Snoozer.

Another one here who's love to meet OP for a chat.

riromay · 03/08/2021 13:57

I may do this if I'm talking to someone who I don't really want to talk to. I avoid going into any subject so they would hopefully just leave me alone Grin

Of course everyone has interests, it might not be the same interests as you or they might not want to talk to you .. Simple really

Notawriteryet · 03/08/2021 13:41

Ooooo @Snoozer11 who’s an edgy girl then? Grin

Snoozer11 · 03/08/2021 13:31

Maybe it's you, OP.

Returnoftheowl · 03/08/2021 13:01

Stuff like politics, social equality, philosophy

If someone I had just meet started trying to discuss these topics I probably wouldn't add too much to the conversation. These topics are ones that wave red flags for me, lots of room for disagreement or finding out the other person has some "unusual" views.

Notawriteryet · 03/08/2021 12:59

I think a lot of such social ineptitude is not “can’t be bothered” and is much more “I didn’t really think I had to bother, I’ve turned up and been inoffensive, that’s enough isn’t it?”

OP you sound ace.

Iamthewombat · 03/08/2021 12:56

But you aren’t joining meet up groups, are you? That’s the difference.

adrianmolesmole · 03/08/2021 12:53

@YouJustDoYou

However, I just seem to have met a recent series of people who don't have any interests at all

Oh, they will do. They just don't want to have to talk to YOU about it.

I agree. I have a lot of interests but I'm pretty sure most people wouldn't be interested in them, I'm obsessed with crochet and embroidery for example but I don't know anyone else in my life who is, therefore I don't even mention it! I'm also very reserved and introverted and find it hard to get past boring small talk so I don't go out of my way to approach people. I'd rather just do my own thing most of the time.

Also if you've talked about your interests/opinions in the past but came across very judgemental attitudes you're less likely to venture your opinion anyway.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 03/08/2021 12:37

the ‘can’t be bothered, you do all the work’ option wouldn’t have been available to everybody else.

It would, but not to women.

Iamthewombat · 03/08/2021 12:00

@thecatsthecats

Blimey, if they're that hard to talk to, why are you bothering? Grin

Though I don't like talking about my interests really. My chief one being writing - people just ask very tedious questions.

I don't make a conscious effort with anyone to be honest. Either the conversation flows or it doesn't. But that's the big point - the conversation FLOWS. No long in depth conversations about anything. Books we read leads on to holidays, leads on to food, leads on to plans for next weekend, leads on to politics. Not forty minutes on the leading news of the day where we both ask incisive questions to understand our views. That's a seminar, not a conversation.

Another one who, despite all evidence to the contrary, thinks that the OP has joined meet up groups in order to deliver ‘seminars’ on her favourite topics to unsuspecting strangers.

And that it is the OP’s fault that the conversation doesn’t flow. Because she asks ‘tedious questions’. Or insists on talking for forty minutes, uninterrupted, about the leading news of the day (according to this poster, despite there being nothing in the OP’s posts to suggest that). It can’t possibly be the fault of the socially inept person asking no questions at all and waiting for the OP to entertain her. No. It’s the OP’s fault, OK?

In the social event situation, like the work dinner upthread where the PP ended up with the caravan couple, I sometimes wonder whether these people are so resentful at being, as they see it, forced into a social situation that they feel that they have to punish anyone who can manage the social side. By being difficult to talk to, then boring the arse off the person attempting to do so.

The weird thing is, that not so long ago a certain level of conversational proficiency would have been not just desirable, but expected. A PP spoke about learning the art of conversation at school. Good luck being taciturn and uninterested at dinner in the 1870s, for example. Or at a ball in 1800. Or in a tavern without Sky Sports. Of course, there would have been people then who were on a spectrum, but the ‘can’t be bothered, you do all the work’ option wouldn’t have been available to everybody else.

TheBestPlansAlwaysFail · 03/08/2021 11:14

I don't think they are all neurodiverse. Never say never and all that but I worked in that field a few years ago and would, at least in most cases, probably notice and adjust accordingly.

I don't know. This thread has given me some answers, although not quite how I expected. I think an important factor that drives people who don't want to be at these meeting to attend anyway is that stigma of not having friends. It makes you seem unlikable, lacking social capital, etc. At least that is my working theory. And I get it - I absolutely had those moments in life when I was working, studying, and a full-time carer, and by the end of the day my brain was fried and stringing coherent sentences together was just too much to ask.
I was lucky enough to have a good local support network and friends who I could just explain this to and who were happy to make it work but if you don't have that, then it would have been really friggin difficult to make new friends at that point in my life. So maybe that is all it is, which kind of sad.

OP posts:
Dacquoise · 03/08/2021 11:11

@Shedbuilder, I totally agree. I find other people quite fascinating and usually come away with something new and unexpected from their experiences. However, being able and willing to listen has its downsides as other people have pointed out, people like to talk about themselves.

A lady approached me in the park the other day and within five minutes I knew all about her children and her fall outs with them. It was quite bizarre. I think she just wanted to unload on someone, anyone.

Also the people who tell you details about other people, you haven't met and don't know. Why, just why? I am always thinking they must be using my life as fodder with other people. Not really conversation is it.

Shedbuilder · 03/08/2021 10:31

That explains a lot and makes me feel better about sitting silently and then making excuses to leave. Thank you. Interesting that that goes against the grain of so many responses here that the OP was being too pushy or not asking the right questions or was somehow at fault for it not working out.

I think the lack of interest is the crux of it. I'm interested in people — getting to know what they think, what they enjoy, their history and so on. It had never occurred to me that someone who had no interest in other people would want to go out socially in a group. But this explains the silent group of women in the pub, staring at the table, perfectly.

thecatsthecats · 03/08/2021 10:25

Blimey, if they're that hard to talk to, why are you bothering? Grin

Though I don't like talking about my interests really. My chief one being writing - people just ask very tedious questions.

I don't make a conscious effort with anyone to be honest. Either the conversation flows or it doesn't. But that's the big point - the conversation FLOWS. No long in depth conversations about anything. Books we read leads on to holidays, leads on to food, leads on to plans for next weekend, leads on to politics. Not forty minutes on the leading news of the day where we both ask incisive questions to understand our views. That's a seminar, not a conversation.

Notawriteryet · 03/08/2021 10:17

I am the mum and ex-wife of neurodivergent non-conversationalists. They literally have no interest in the other person. That’s not to say they’re unkind or think badly of the other person, they’re just disinterested. If you get them on to their special topics away they go and they’ll bore the arse off about gaming, or varieties of honeybees, or whatever. They sort of like other people’s company but don’t see the need to contribute to it. All of them can mask to a degree and when prompted can do the “have you come far?” schtick but they can’t keep it up for long.

For them the joy of company is what they get out of it. No concern whatsoever as to what the other person might be thinking. As far as they are concerned that’s not their business.

One of them is very number/list oriented. So one of his “openers” is “let me tell you my 4 facts about helicopters” and if he doesn’t get all 4 facts out, it’s almost painful! They have to be shared even if I’m shouting “no no no! Let me wee in peace!”

Luckily they are also very loving and funny and cute. Except the ex.

Shedbuilder · 03/08/2021 09:51

I think that this thread really has touched a nerve with some posters

I'm sensing quite a lot of Type Bs trying to explain why we Type As aren't asking them the right questions/ talking about the right things in order to enable them to talk. Very revealing.

Many years ago I moved into a new area and sought out a women's group that met once a fortnight in a pub in our nearest city. The first night there were five of them and they barely said a word to me or each other. There was a lot of gazing at the table. I asked a few fairly vague open questions, got no enthusiastic or engaged response so rather than feel like an interrogator I just sat quietly too. It was bizarre. Busy pub, silent table of women. I went back a month or so later and there was another newbie, a talker (hooray!), but no matter how much we tried to get conversation going it ended up with us having a good old natter while the other women just sat smiling to themselves.

The newbie and I started socialising together and found our tribe elsewhere. We'd occasionally call in and say hello to the silent group. Nothing seemed to change, they still sat there and said nothing while we talked. We used to hope that it was a joke and that as soon as we left the pub they'd be laughing about us interlopers and how they'd managed to repel us from their group.

Years later, after I'd moved away, I was at a women's gathering and a woman came up and said how lovely it was to see me and how much she'd enjoyed my company. She named the pub the silent group frequented — she was one of them. I was gobsmacked because she'd barely said a word to me. I tried asking her how the group was and whether they still met, but she'd said her piece and that was that — not another word. I think neurodivergence must have had something to do with it.

It would be interesting to hear from neurodiverse people what's going on for them when someone like me, a Type A conversationalist, starts talking to them.

Iamthewombat · 03/08/2021 09:46

Even the droners on (the caravan couple sound awful) are better than the type who won’t engage on anything, which is what the OP is dealing with.

Example of a conversation I had with one such person, whom I’d met at a social group and who wanted to be friends with me, as evidenced by asking me twice to meet her for drinks:

Me (having already done all the ‘how are you’ stuff): what’s the worst hairstyle you ever had? I was laughing at some old photos of me last week.

Her: I don’t know really.

Me: there must be something, we were both teenagers in the 1980s!

Her: I can’t really remember stuff like that.

Me: OK what about clothes? I had some shockers (brief description of terrible 80s fashion choices). How about you?

Her: I never really think about things like that, it was a long time ago (we were both 36 at this point).

Me: now you are making me suspect that you did the full Bucks Fizz.

Her: oh no, I didn’t do that.

She then clammed up and waited for me to introduce the next topic. It is exhausting.

Turkishangora · 03/08/2021 08:53

I have found some of this having recently started working in academia. I'll meet a fellow academic (the nature of what we teach means we're still doing a lot of face to face) who I've not met before and I'll ask about their background, where they worked before, what their speciality is etc and they'll often then drone endlessly at length about themselves and their achievements, hardly coming up for breath to ask me anything about myself. I just smile and make the right noises and nod. There's a lot of self importance and ego in academia I'm finding. Smile

DottyHarmer · 03/08/2021 08:35

The trouble with asking questions is a) it gets a bit wearing and b) you sometimes sound like an interviewer. I once sat next to a couple at a firm’s do of dh’s. I did the “Have you come far?” stuff and eventually established that they had a caravan. Cue me asking a million questions about caravanning, which they answered enthusiastically. I thought afterwards that they did not even know my name, let alone where I came from or anything else. Maybe they couldn’t care less, but did they really think I wanted to hear about them for two solid hours?

Iamthewombat · 03/08/2021 08:13

@ShippingNews

I'd stop the topic-based conversation - these topics are your preferred choice but maybe not everyone else's. Maybe start with "do you come from around here?" and then take what they say and expand on it - what was the reason for moving , what was the best thing about their previous home town or whatever. I find that the best conversations come from treating the person as if they are the most interesting person, whose story you are interested to know about. Rather than regaling them with your opinions about your favorite topics. It works for me !
I think that some posters are being deliberately obtuse. There is nothing to suggest that the OP has joined meet up groups as an excuse to ‘regale [people she meets] with her opinions on her favourite topics’.

She explains that she has tried a range of conversational gambits to get these people to, you know, talk!

I think that this thread really has touched a nerve with some posters.

MissKeithsNeice · 03/08/2021 07:45

Most of the people i enjoy talking to don't talk about topics. They're great to chat to cause they're funny, observant. It's the small stuff, the listening, the gentle to and fro that is the heart of conversation for me.

I also know people who like to talk about stuff: their opinions on world affairs, films, books etc. I appreciate thats their way of chatting and will always join in but in comparison its harder work and less fun: the potential for it all to get a bit sixth-form-cafe is ever present Grin

Elephantsparade · 03/08/2021 07:11

Some of these conversations sound like the other person might be neurodiverse. One of the bits in the diagnosis is where the clinician leave a closed conversational opener like 'i went on a plane yesterday' and the other person could say all sorts to that from 'what type of plane' to ' im scared of planes did you find it ok?' to 'did you come back from holiday' etc obviously lots of neurodiverse people learn to converse well naturally and some do it as a learned skill and its tiring but many would think you just shared a fact and it required no input.

BlithePilgrim · 03/08/2021 06:25

@ShippingNews

I'd stop the topic-based conversation - these topics are your preferred choice but maybe not everyone else's. Maybe start with "do you come from around here?" and then take what they say and expand on it - what was the reason for moving , what was the best thing about their previous home town or whatever. I find that the best conversations come from treating the person as if they are the most interesting person, whose story you are interested to know about. Rather than regaling them with your opinions about your favorite topics. It works for me !
Alas, the person upthread who said that Meet-Up groups divide into A types (socially competent, looking for friends in a new place) and B types (who struggle with social interaction and keep attending the open meet-ups for years, expecting someone to befriend them) is absolutely right.

In that case, @ShippingNews, your conversational gambits would go something like this:

‘Do you come from around here?’
‘From X.’
“‘Oh, is that a nice place to live?’
‘Dunno, bit boring.’
‘But you’re originally from somewhere else?’
‘Y.’
‘What was Y like to live in?’
‘Dunno, really, same as anywhere.’
‘And did you move here for work?’
‘Yes.’

After which, as a pp said, they appear completely unaware that they haven’t shown the remotest interest in he other person and follow them around for the rest of the meeting listening to them talking to other people, apparently waiting to be introduced to the other people.

BadLad · 03/08/2021 05:56

Stuff like politics, social equality, philosophy? They don't have an opinion on it.

Maybe they think better of sharing their opinions about those subjects. People nowadays can be extremely intolerant of any opinion that differs from their own.

Swipe left for the next trending thread