Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you talk about with people who have no interests?

239 replies

TheBestPlansAlwaysFail · 02/08/2021 08:09

I am making more of an effort to make some new friends now that lockdown is over.
(We moved back to the city we now live in right before lockdown and most of the people I was friends with when I previously lived here have moved away - so rude of them! Wink)

Anyway, what I noticed is that there seem to be so many people who have absolutely no interests (and some seem to have no personality to top it off). I usually have no issue to find a topic of conversation but with some people, nothing seems to lead anywhere - arts, sports/fitness, science, reading, traveling, music, cooking, pets, gardening,....? They're not interested/scared/don't care. Stuff like politics, social equality, philosophy? They don't have an opinion on it. Work, family, etc? All good but there is not really much to talk about.

It is like drawing blood from a stone. What can you actually talk about with people like this? I am not looking for friendships for life right now, I just want someone to go to the pub and have a half-way decent conversation with - but by the end of these 'conversation', I am just drained and looking for an out. Maybe it is lockdown? Have people forgotten how to hold a conversation?

OP posts:
Shedbuilder · 04/08/2021 16:35

[quote Nightlystroll]@Iamthewombat

"So why be insecure about some imagined ‘intellectual elite’ to the extent that you’re snarking about it on a thread that has nothing to do with intellectual capability and everything to do with social skills?"

Op wrote: Stuff like politics, social equality, philosophy?

It sounds like intellectually elite content to me.[/quote]
Just an idea of a few of the things that would fit under those headings:

Politics: potholes in the local roads, library closures, bins and recycling, strange things they're teaching kids in school these days, worries about how you're ever going to afford to retire/ buy a house, global warming, what was Trump about, wtf has your local councillor/ MP been saying this week, should cruise liners or. planes be banned, (and on and on ad infinitum)

Social equality: worries about getting a child into the best local school, broadband problems, BLM, have you seen the price of (insert product here)?!, women working, are cockerpoos middle-class indicators?, single parenthood, employment opportunities and issues, benefits, concerns with funding a university course, musings on why rich people/ Boris/ certain footballers get away with things and others don't, food banks, homelessness, transport issues, accents, ruddy public schools...

Philosophy: do you believe in fate/ god/ luck/ karma/ Father Christmas/ the Loch Ness monster? If so why? Have you ever thought about what happens when we die? Coincidence. Ghosts and spirits. Keep Calm and Carry On: good life advice or not? Is home really where the hearth is? Has modern technology changed the way we think and relate to each other? And most stuff that starts with 'I think' or 'I believe'. It doesn't all have to be about Aristotle or Kierekegaard.

You probably talk about and think about all those things at some point, you just don't classify them under the headings Politics, Social Equality or Philosophy.

Iamthewombat · 04/08/2021 16:25

She named several topics that she’d be interested in talking about. She didn’t say that she only wanted to discuss those things, or that anyone she was friends with would be required to talk about those things all night to the exclusion of anything else. You seem to be quite invested in the idea of a MN ‘intellectual elite’ looking down on you. Why is that?

Nightlystroll · 04/08/2021 15:22

@Iamthewombat

"So why be insecure about some imagined ‘intellectual elite’ to the extent that you’re snarking about it on a thread that has nothing to do with intellectual capability and everything to do with social skills?"

Op wrote: Stuff like politics, social equality, philosophy?

It sounds like intellectually elite content to me.

Shedbuilder · 04/08/2021 13:31

@robotcollision

I have a couple of friends who I realise I look forward to meeting up with more than others. Whenever we meet up they launch into a lively: 'Oh the other day I went to this talk/reads this book/went on a course about XYZ and it was so interesting because...' and we end up discussing ideas or new scientific breakthroughs or something. We're not scientists, we're not vastly intellectual but we prefer discussing what's going on in the world than gossiping about people we know. So I totally get OP's longing for people who just seem engaged with something more than their own family life. By contrast when I go to parties or out with friends who talk only about their families I feel drained. Much as I love their families and genuinely want to know what they are up to, I'd like the conversation to branch out a bit more.
Perhaps we know some of the same people because I love those kind of bouncy conversations. I listen to Radio 4 a fair bit and most days there's something on there that gives me food for thought and something to discuss with like-minded people who enjoy kicking ideas around.
robotcollision · 04/08/2021 12:37

I have a couple of friends who I realise I look forward to meeting up with more than others. Whenever we meet up they launch into a lively: 'Oh the other day I went to this talk/reads this book/went on a course about XYZ and it was so interesting because...' and we end up discussing ideas or new scientific breakthroughs or something. We're not scientists, we're not vastly intellectual but we prefer discussing what's going on in the world than gossiping about people we know. So I totally get OP's longing for people who just seem engaged with something more than their own family life. By contrast when I go to parties or out with friends who talk only about their families I feel drained. Much as I love their families and genuinely want to know what they are up to, I'd like the conversation to branch out a bit more.

Iamthewombat · 04/08/2021 12:21

Who said that you had to spend the entire evening talking about Kier Starmer, Brexit or books? Nobody.

Do people read these threads selectively, ignore the subject then think, “what can I say about ME even if it’s only peripherally connected”?

That might explain some of the stories we have heard on this thread.

JustDanceAddict · 04/08/2021 12:10

I don’t know if I have ‘interests’ as such. I read a lot, enjoy my pet, cinema, food, music. I can talk politics and ishoos, but I wouldn’t want to spend the whole night discussing Keir Starmer or Brexit! I’d find that tedious.
I find that with new people I either click with them or not, has nothing to do with interests although it helps if you both like similar things. I do enjoy talking about books but it’s more a 10 min part of a convo, wouldn’t base a whole evening around it!

ILiveInSalemsLot · 04/08/2021 09:07

Many people don’t have hobbies or interests but manage perfectly well to have conversations. Some people are terrible at listening to others or asking them questions. They just don’t seem to be interested in anyone but happily go on and on about themselves. I find if you don’t then ask the next question, they just stop talking, it gets a bit awkward and they start looking at their phone or something.
If, however, they can’t even talk when asked a question, there’s not much you can do.

Shedbuilder · 04/08/2021 09:06

@Nightlystroll

This is embarrassing to me because I don't think I have any particular interests either. Nor do any of my friends and yet we chat away for hours. But I can't tell you what about really. Just stuff. We'd be dreadfully boring to the intellectually elite of MN.
You don't have to have interests or hobbies — I think that's been a bit of a red herring. You just have to have an opinion or a preference or a point of view on something, anything, that you can talk about. That will almost inevitably lead to something else and if you're talking to someone who's a good conversationalist you'll be off on a good conversation. But you have to make a bit of effort, it's teamwork.

The 90-something gent I spoke to at an event at the weekend talked about his early life and his wartime experiences, but not in a boring or bragging or obsessive way, and he asked me about myself and my parents and related what he'd been saying about his own life to life now and things I and my parents had been through. We probably talked for half an hour, and because we were listening to each other and genuinely interested we had that lovely sense of a connection and a delight in each other that crosses age, sex, race and experience. We made each others' day: we both said that. It made all the other dreary conversations about peoples' grandchildren, the weather and the traffic worthwhile.

I'm still struggling to understand why people would want to gather in a pub, exchange a few 'hellos' and 'How are you/ I'm fine, thank yous' and then sit silently around a table together, looking at their drinks. Do they think this is what socialising is about? Do they go so that the next day at work they can say 'I was out at the pub with my friends last night'?

Is this retreat from conversation linked to the epidemic of loneliness I keep reading about? Are people who can't connect through conversation more inclined to be lonely, do you think? Or maybe they are the least lonely because they don't need the connection created by good communication.

Iamthewombat · 04/08/2021 08:36

@Nightlystroll

This is embarrassing to me because I don't think I have any particular interests either. Nor do any of my friends and yet we chat away for hours. But I can't tell you what about really. Just stuff. We'd be dreadfully boring to the intellectually elite of MN.
Where has anyone said that in order to participate in a proper conversation, you need to discuss ‘intellectually elite’ subjects?

The OP has joined a meet-up group to make new friends, as people do when they move house/job or experience other life changes. She’s met some people who seemingly want to be friends with her but want her to take full responsibilit6nfor the conversation whilst they sit there giving monosyllabic answers and contribut8ng nothing.

The discussion moved on to people who are hard work at social events, and when persuaded to talk seem capable only of talking about themselves and their interests with no concept that a conversation is a two way street.

It’s quite remarkable how people can read this and somehow find an insult. You’re clearly interested in something - your ‘stuff’ - or you wouldn’t be chatting for hours about it, would you? So why be insecure about some imagined ‘intellectual elite’ to the extent that you’re snarking about it on a thread that has nothing to do with intellectual capability and everything to do with social skills?

Toesies · 04/08/2021 05:04

@lokomojo

For one reason or another I've spent a lot of time on night shifts with people very different to me. At first, as a young woman, I really struggled to know what to talk about and how to relate to them, because I had only really known a very 'topic-based' way of talking to others. But you know, I discovered that everyone, everyone, is a whole human being with interests and dreams and stories. Everyone. You can find this out if you ask people, openly and without pre-judgment, about their lives and then really listen.

'Charm' is a difficult-to-define personality trait, but you just managed to describe it. Listening to others and feeling heard is so important and is one of the ways that makes a person seem 'charming' to others. If only more people were like you!

LoveFall · 04/08/2021 03:48

I think pretty much everyone is interested in something, but not everyone is comfortable just chatting. Covid has made this much worse. I read a lot, am doing art, and have views about a wide range of things. I can hold my own in a wide variety of topics. I am fortunate to be well educated and to have traveled a lot in the past few years.

But it is scary to bring up so many subjects now because of the woke thing. I feel I can't talk about holidays I'd like to have, cooking, places I'd like to visit in my province, health, the environment, etc, etc. I am constantly afraid I will offend someone and will be considered a cretin of some sort. Yet I am open to discussion and I love a good debate.

The news here in British Columbia, Canada is endless woke and guilt. I don't disagree with much of it, but it brooks no debate.

Sad really.

TulipsTwoLips · 04/08/2021 03:22

If you look at the amount of posts on aibu compared to the topic boards
you'll see that most people don't really want to talk about topics and hobbies, they want to give their opinion on if they think other people are doing life right!

TheGirlWhoWantedToBeGod · 04/08/2021 02:39

I’m naturally quite quiet, especially when I’m not already close to someone. It doesn’t really relate to the number of hobbies or interests I have!

What I have found though is that I’m very comfortable with some silences within a conversation, and don’t feel the need to immediately try and think of the next thing to say to break the silence. But some people (not all) seem to hate this and will desperately say anything just to avoid a brief silence. Which to me is really counterproductive as I find the awkward conversation that then ensues more awkward that a bit of silence would have been!

Dancingonmoonlight · 04/08/2021 01:44

but then it doesn't explain why they try to make me stay longer or keep asking to meet again

Any chance you are a native English speaker and they aren’t? I sometimes found people wanted a free English language class and did not want to be friends at all.

Shuffleuplove · 04/08/2021 01:24

Nightlystroll - chatting away for hours is wonderful. Sitting staring at the table in silence = not so much.

Nightlystroll · 04/08/2021 00:14

This is embarrassing to me because I don't think I have any particular interests either. Nor do any of my friends and yet we chat away for hours. But I can't tell you what about really. Just stuff. We'd be dreadfully boring to the intellectually elite of MN.

CorianderBee · 04/08/2021 00:03

Their families, their work, food usually work.

MsTSwift · 03/08/2021 21:25

I had the opposite deadly dull work colleagues school mums were fabulous fun still friends 10 years later. No one gave a shit about reading books

MrsSchadenfreude · 03/08/2021 20:57

The school gate Mums when the DDs were in primary school. None of them worked, and they were all quite high maintenance. They talked about:

Where they got their hair and nails done
When they got their hair and nails done
Which gym was better
Whose turn it was to host the next coffee morning
Which level book their child was on
Which ballet school was better
Whether it was true that two of the mothers were having a lesbian affair (they were).

They used to treat me as if I had two heads because I worked. I also ended up being class rep as none of the non-working Mums would do it - they were all “too busy”. I learned very fast that they didn’t want to go to the fabulous new Brazilian cocktail bar in town, or even to the new Italian in the next village for the end of term meal. No. They wanted to go to Het Park, because they always went to Het Park. I just went with the flow because it was too much effort to do anything else and got drunk with the TA.

TammyTwoSwanson · 03/08/2021 20:57

There are some members of my family like this and I HAVE to talk to them. They want to talk about EastEnders (did you see it last night? It was so good), Meghan Markle (they don't like her), the weather, a news story about something awful happening, about how their neighbour's cousin's sister-in-law died, their horoscope, they saw a ghost apparently, and about other stuff that bores the absolute shit out of me.

It is very tedious, but I just smile and make agreeing comments in all the right places.

Luckily I have lots of interests and passions and have plenty of other people in my life I can talk to about interesting stuff. Thank goodness!

BlithePilgrim · 03/08/2021 20:45

@MsTSwift

Believe me I would be more than happy to leave him alone! But if I am quiet and don’t bother either I am picked then up on it by in laws! So seems I am expected to be the entertainment!

Not sure it’s as simple as having interests makes you interesting either - it’s more nuanced than that.

Yes, exactly. I mean, I don’t care whether someone is a fanatic macramé addict or an obsessive free diver, and everyone knows a running bore who’s dying to get out their Strava at the drop of a hat— it’s more a capacity to function in a social situation in which you’ve chosen to put yourself (not talking about dentist’s waiting room, open plan office, or school run) in which silence is either not possible or not what you want, because you’ve joined a Meet Up group to make friends.
Amboseli · 03/08/2021 20:22

I know people like this. They come over to our house and have something to eat and just sit there not talking. They're DHs friends. I have no idea why or even how they're friends!

I think you will just have to keep meeting new people and eventually, statistically, you will meet some that can speak and hold a conversation.

I find it interesting that people have been taught social skills by their parents. I wasn't "taught" but just learnt by example as my parents are very sociable and we'd always have people round and vice versa.

I find with all my friends what we have in common is our sense of humour rather than any hobbies or interests.

MsTSwift · 03/08/2021 20:10

Not sure it’s particularly fair as an adult to put yourself in a social situation then not contribute at all.

MsTSwift · 03/08/2021 20:07

Believe me I would be more than happy to leave him alone! But if I am quiet and don’t bother either I am picked then up on it by in laws! So seems I am expected to be the entertainment!

Not sure it’s as simple as having interests makes you interesting either - it’s more nuanced than that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread