Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be horrified at how much waste we produce but think food producers are to blame?

194 replies

malificent7 · 01/08/2021 22:10

Dp, dd and I live here ft. Dsd lives here pt. Our bins were collected on Wednesday and already on Sunday the recycling and wheelie bin are full again.
Main culprits are bulky plastic milk containers, things like mushroom cartons, pepsi/ fizzy water bottles..cardboard packaging etc.

However, the council only collect wheelie bins every 3 weeks. I think the reasoning behind this is that peopke will ve forced to recycle more. Great in theory. In practice many things can't be recycled.
Really i think food companies need to think of alternative ways of packaging food...quite what i don't know.

OP posts:
Proudboomer · 02/08/2021 14:22

Again buying milk from a milk man is more expensive.
There is no argument that it is better for the environment using a glass recyclable bottle delivered in an electric vehicle but milk or more charge 81p a pint for their milk where as Tesco is 80p for two pints.
If you are on a limited income with young children then you are going to either have to cut your milk consumption in half which isn’t possible if you have young child or continue buying it with the weekly shop in Tesco.

QuestionableMouse · 02/08/2021 14:03

@EastWestWhosBest

Get milk from the milk man. It’s the best option as it’s closed loop recycling. As for fizzy water and Pepsi then get a soda stream. I only by fizzy drinks in either glass bottles or cans. Yes manufacturers are partially to blame but you can take some responsibility.
It's not that easy. My area used to have a milkman (who was my uncle 😂) but he retired and had to close the business because no one wanted to take it over. And I'm only going back maybe three or four years. No milkman now, and even the big companies don't cover my village as its not profitable for them. The village shop used to sell milk (and orange juice) in glass bottles but that's stopped too due to Covid as they can't (won't?) take the bottles back.
user1471523870 · 02/08/2021 13:56

@SisyphusDad

Sorry but I have to disagree. We're quite good at recycling - paper and plastics bins generally full for bi - weekly collection, and grey bin less than half empty.

What really winds me up is the way that we (me and two teenage DSs) waste bread. I try very hard to use what's in the bread bin before I buy any more but I have to admit that I usually fail dismally. I think the main thing is that we (I) lack discipline. Any suggestions very gratefully received.

Hi SisyphusDad, my suggestion would be to freeze it. We normally manage to eat between half and 3/4 of the loaf before it gets dangerously close to be off/mouldy. At that point I freeze it. Then, if it's sliced, I just put the slices straight into the toaster and if it's bread rolls I chuck them in the oven if I am baking/roasting something else or just leave it to defrost outside. No bread wasted this way. Hope it helps.
sweeneytoddsrazor · 02/08/2021 13:38

It is absolutely not a viable idea at all. The supermarket recycles what waste it can and disposes of the rest. The only thing you are actually doing is leaving rubbish for someone to clear up behind you. Dress it up however you want but essentially you are leaving your rubbish for another person to clean up. If you don't like the packaging buy something in different packaging or out loose.

Binnaggy · 02/08/2021 13:16

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

GreatAuntEmily · 02/08/2021 12:55

Do people really think leaving their excess packaging on a shelf in the supermarket will make changes. No all it does is create extra work for the person that has to remove it.
Makes no difference to the person- they get paid whether they clear packaging or stack shelves. The supermarket will have to pay to deal with the rubbish so it is a viable idea as it will cost them.

RubyGoat · 02/08/2021 11:35

www.friendlysoap.co.uk/product/lavender-geranium-shampoo-bar/

I've bought these bars in health food shops, they're £2.79 in my local shop. They do seem to last longer than a bottle of shampoo too. They do shampoo, conditioner bars, shaving bar, regular soap. I actually prefer the bars from soapnuts.co.uk but they are more expensive & you don't really see them in many shops, which is a shame.

I do wish we could get sodastream gas refills locally though. Nearest place that does it is over an hour by public transport. I don't drink pop/squash but DH & DD do. I would like to be able to drink fizzy water as more than a rare treat though, I usually don't because of the plastic bottles.

Caspianberg · 02/08/2021 11:18

You don’t pay for the replacement canisters each time though, you pay refills price once you buy the canister once.

We bought two canisters so we always have one full and no rush with empty. They cost €6 from our local supermarket as ‘refill’ which is basically just an exchange for a new one. We usually get refilled when we also have 10/15% voucher off shop so it’s lower again. Each canister does around 60litres.

Fifthtimelucky · 02/08/2021 11:04

@SisyphusDad

Sorry but I have to disagree. We're quite good at recycling - paper and plastics bins generally full for bi - weekly collection, and grey bin less than half empty.

What really winds me up is the way that we (me and two teenage DSs) waste bread. I try very hard to use what's in the bread bin before I buy any more but I have to admit that I usually fail dismally. I think the main thing is that we (I) lack discipline. Any suggestions very gratefully received.

We don't get through much bread so often have bits that are past their best. I freeze them and bring them out when making things like bread sauce, bread and butter pudding, summer pudding or if I want breadcrumbs for something.
Proudboomer · 02/08/2021 10:51

Aldi are the cheapest soda streams at just under £60 including one gas canisters that will need replacing. Argos sell the replacements at £15 each.
A bottle of cheap supermarket pop is around 50p so quite a large difference or are saying that only the richer in our society should be able to have a fizzy drink?

How about shampoo bars. The cheapest are the likes of wilkos for £8 (half price at £4 at the moment so stock up if you can) and their cheapest shampoo is £1. If you are on a limited budget that is a big difference. The bars last longer but you can’t not wash your hair whilst saving the extra to by a bar.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 02/08/2021 10:41

Do people really think leaving their excess packaging on a shelf in the supermarket will make changes. No all it does is create extra work for the person that has to remove it.

BarbaraofSeville · 02/08/2021 10:41

@Proudboomer

I love how everyone says get a soda stream. Even the basic soda stream from Aldi is £60. Not every one has a spare £60 to even buy the cheap one let alone the £150 to £200 for the real ones. The replacement gases are around £15 a pop in Argos so again not cheap. Over time there would be a cost saving but that is no good if you can’t afford the initial outlay.
There's plenty of soda streams available for £50 to £100 including gas, no need to pay up to £200 for a 'real' one whatever that means, the cheaper ones are just as real.

Maybe if you don't have enough slack in your budget for a relatively small discretionary purchase that will save you money in the long run and reduce your plastic consumption, you shouldn't be buying so much totally unnecessary fizzy pop to fill a bin with the bottles in a few days?

Proudboomer · 02/08/2021 10:37

@Meloncurse

Plastic covered cucumbers the most pointless plastic around

The shelf life of cucumbers is massively extended by wrapping in plastic (unlike some other fruit and veg) which has various implications for logistics. I'm sure I read an article that said that overall shrink wrapping cucumbers is worthwhile packaging.

Or you could buy unwrapped and put it in a Tupperware container which is reusable for years and will make your cucumber last.

Or if you have a small outdoor space even a balcony on a flat you can grow your own. Cost pennies for around 5 cucumbers per plant and easy to grow in a very limited space.

Proudboomer · 02/08/2021 10:32

I love how everyone says get a soda stream. Even the basic soda stream from Aldi is £60. Not every one has a spare £60 to even buy the cheap one let alone the £150 to £200 for the real ones.
The replacement gases are around £15 a pop in Argos so again not cheap.
Over time there would be a cost saving but that is no good if you can’t afford the initial outlay.

Caspianberg · 02/08/2021 09:51

Where we are things like multi packs of tins beans for example don’t exist, if they have offers on its simply from x amount of tins/ bottles you get the deal. So one tin 50p, if you buy at least 3 of same type 45p each

I think it’s fine to have to be more responsible for items yourself. Whilst we get certain items collected, we have to take all glass/ metal to collection points

Also, this is probably key, we don’t pay a council tax for bins, we are charged simply per bin collected and per weight! So if you choose to fill bin to top for general waste you will pay far more. Other Recycling collected for free.

Meloncurse · 02/08/2021 09:03

Plastic covered cucumbers the most pointless plastic around

The shelf life of cucumbers is massively extended by wrapping in plastic (unlike some other fruit and veg) which has various implications for logistics. I'm sure I read an article that said that overall shrink wrapping cucumbers is worthwhile packaging.

Polkadots2021 · 02/08/2021 09:00

@malificent7

Dp, dd and I live here ft. Dsd lives here pt. Our bins were collected on Wednesday and already on Sunday the recycling and wheelie bin are full again. Main culprits are bulky plastic milk containers, things like mushroom cartons, pepsi/ fizzy water bottles..cardboard packaging etc.

However, the council only collect wheelie bins every 3 weeks. I think the reasoning behind this is that peopke will ve forced to recycle more. Great in theory. In practice many things can't be recycled.
Really i think food companies need to think of alternative ways of packaging food...quite what i don't know.

I massively agree with you OP on all counts. I think though, and I'm including myself here, that sitting around lightly complaining makes us all part of the problem (me included). If we really care we need to choose a side and come down heavy on it - petitions, demonstrations, innovation, campaigning, making big noise for change. Else nothing will change.
HasaDigaEebowai · 02/08/2021 08:55

We need to be careful about paper packaging too. It’s actually worse for climate change in terms of the amount of CO2e used. Obviously there are also issues about plastic particles with plastic packaging and so it isn’t a simple issue but picking up a paper bag to put mushrooms in isn’t necessarily a better option.

Best option is to take your own packaging.

BarbaraofSeville · 02/08/2021 08:43

@MrsSkylerWhite

How on earth is leaving the packaging on the packing shelf in the shop littering. What a silly comment.

Do you think the manager throws it on the pavement?

Leaving excess packaging at the shop is the norm in Germany, which as a nation generally do very well in waste reduction and recycling.

My current bugbear is multipacks. The type of canned catfood we buy is good in that it is in a cardboard tray with a polythene overwrap, which is recyclable, but a lot of other multipacks come in the non recyclable stretchy plastic.

Must see if someone on Terracycle takes these, but I think food manufacturers should move away from multipacks, especially the ones that are wrapped in plastic. Pretty much every shop has a till system that could cope with multipack pricing without multipack packaging and some do it anyway. Often if you buy canned soup in Asda, there's a price for one can, and you can get 6 tins for £4 or 8 for £5. There definitely needs to be more of that.

Sparklfairy · 02/08/2021 08:40

@didireallysaythat thanks, I've always wanted one so this is a good excuse!! Grin

HasaDigaEebowai · 02/08/2021 08:40

Tissues would be better composted and sanitary towels switched for period pants. Then you’d only have plastic wrap which is amazing.

BarbaraofSeville · 02/08/2021 08:39

Have a look at Terracycle Royal.

As mentioned above, I set up a collection point because there wasn't one locally for a type of waste I wanted to recycle.

I also take the plastic bags from dry cat food to our vets who have a Terracyle collection point for these (we have 4 of our own and foster too so get through a lot of catfood).

Admittedly I don't recycle the single serve pouches because life is too short to wash and dry them. I do try to used canned or tetrapack food, which can be rinsed and recycled much easier as our council collect those, but most of our own cats won't eat the food in cans Hmm.

It's worth understanding the symbols on plastics and what your own council accept. As I said above, our council accept 1, 2, 4 and 5 type plastics.

This excludes the aforementioned cat food bags, and also overwraps from can multipacks - there is another symbol that indicates that the producer has paid a levy for using non recyclable material - this is what funds the likes of terracycle - it's a little swirl without a number.

Our council website is quite good in detailing how to recycle as much waste as possible. I do what I can and don't feel guilty about what is non recyclable because our council has a waste to energy incinerator, so it's not going to landfill anyway.

But I do have the odd 'what about' thought about the ethics of being involved in animal rescue with a no kill where possible policy, because we're facilitating the lives of animals that could be humanely PTS instead of going on to spend up to 20 years eating a lot of meat and producing a lot of waste.

DP needs quite a lot of medication, but I have discovered you can take old inhalers to some pharmacists for recycling, likewise blister packs of tablets.

Admittedly, to make this all worthwhile, you do need space to store things and be organised. We have a utility room and pantry where a lot of this stuff is stored, and I always have things like boxes of glass in my car, to be recycled next time I go out (our council doesn't collect glass from homes).

MrsSkylerWhite · 02/08/2021 08:38

How on earth is leaving the packaging on the packing shelf in the shop littering. What a silly comment.

Do you think the manager throws it on the pavement?

ChainJane · 02/08/2021 08:36

@MrsSkylerWhite

My mum unpacks to the bare minimum of packaging in the shop and leaves the excess on the packing shelf for them to deal with. If more of us did it (me included Blush) they’d probably address the issue.
I'm not sure littering is a good example. Hmm

I mean I could start taking excess plastic packaging and dumping it on the beach. If enough of us did it the authorities would probably address the issue.

MrsSkylerWhite · 02/08/2021 08:30

My mum unpacks to the bare minimum of packaging in the shop and leaves the excess on the packing shelf for them to deal with. If more of us did it (me included Blush) they’d probably address the issue.