Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect MIL to pay

235 replies

Muggymama · 01/08/2021 11:57

MIL never thought she'd have grandkids due to.my DH being lifelong batchelor but we did and she has 3; DD15, DS12 & DS10.
She never buys them anything or gives them even few pounds when they visit but is very comfortably off and currently having very extensive improvements to her house (which we have to constantly listen to hear her moaning about, mess, poor workmanship, not turning up when should yadda, yadda).
My parents on the other hand, have very little but are so kind and bring their favourite treats and contribute to trips, little luxuries, pocket money etc.
AIBU to be bit miffed with MIL?
She is from a generation when things were easier too, free higher education, good pension at very early age etc.
I know it's her money but can't help feeling she is being selfish and little treats time to time would show she cares, understands them & knows what they like/ need.

OP posts:
NeedNewKnees · 01/08/2021 12:40

Your initial post comes across as very grasping - like unless they are slipping the grandcxhildren a fiver every visit, grandparents don't deserve visits.

Some people express affection through gift giving, some through time together, and some are pretty hands-off. All of that is OK

You seem to resent her being well off.

Italiangreyhound · 01/08/2021 12:40

Her loss. Very sad. YANBU.

Muggymama · 01/08/2021 12:39

@RosesAndHellebores

Interesting. My mother, lots of presents, pocket money, ott at Christmas. MIL was tighter than a ducks bottom. And then decided to pay their uni fees. £27k each.v
That is so lovely of your MIL😊 Sure it is not this though.
OP posts:
Walkingthedog46 · 01/08/2021 12:39

She may think the kids have enough on a day-to-day basis and be quietly putting money aside each month into an account for the grandchildren. This is what a I do.

ancientgran · 01/08/2021 12:38

@Fluto

Our children are going to be saddled with debt on completing their education, not have the same opportunities and have to work well into their old age.

This is spouted often on here. To have gone onto further education back then you'd already be from a relatively well off family. The expectation for many was that they were contributing financially to the household as soon as possible, and college to study something vocational was usually the case.

Student debt is only paid back now if you earn over x amount, and even then its a small amount, I'm not sure where the idea that people are saddled with it comes from. If you don't go on to earn a decent wage following your degree then you don't pay it back, if you do, then although of course after x amount of time in the workplace you might be on the same wage as someone with a degree so it's not always the case, but having a degree usually leads to increased income over someone's working life, therefore you're still better off even with paying some back each month. It's then written off after 30 years and in some other circumstances, unless a very high earner most people don't pay back as much as they borrow. It doesn't affect getting a mortgage etc, aside from the monthly payment being taken into account, but it isn't like they say oh you owe £40k so you can't have a loan. Social mobility is very much easier than it was then, even though there is still a way to go.

Grandparents have no obligation to buy stuff for their grandchildren or to spend time with them.

Very true, depending on her age of course, things could have been very tough, 16% mortgages weren't great, women earning less than men for the same job (I only stood that in my first job as a teenager but it was common) small minority going to uni.
vivainsomnia · 01/08/2021 12:38

Did she get to bond with them as well as your mother? Do they themselves show love and care? Do they call her on her birthday, or do they tell her they love her?

Many kids don't bond much with grandparents and grandparents don't bond that well with them. It can be hard to get the kids things and get very little in return so it's actually easier to get them nothing so not to experience desappointment.

Muggymama · 01/08/2021 12:37

@Seeline

Does she live nearby? See the children often?
Not too far away and does visit weekly but then brings her newspaper or puts her programmes on. When we visit her we take lunch for everyone and there are no snacks, drinks etc. that the children like. She has never been hands on, changed nappies, taken children out etc. I suppose I thought she wasn't comfortable when they were younger but it would grow but sadly hasn't. My parents are the opposite so perhaps that's why I find it strange.
OP posts:
Disfordarkchocolate · 01/08/2021 12:37

I think it's perfectly normal for grandparents to buy the odd treat. It can be something little like favourite sweets or the odd £1 coin for their money box, it's that feeling of being though of when your not their that children like.

ancientgran · 01/08/2021 12:36

@RosesAndHellebores

Interesting. My mother, lots of presents, pocket money, ott at Christmas. MIL was tighter than a ducks bottom. And then decided to pay their uni fees. £27k each.v
Good point, she might be saving for something like that.
ancientgran · 01/08/2021 12:36

By the way I think the 15 year old would probably prefer the cash, the others might as well. My older GC love money and pick their own things.

RosesAndHellebores · 01/08/2021 12:35

Interesting. My mother, lots of presents, pocket money, ott at Christmas. MIL was tighter than a ducks bottom. And then decided to pay their uni fees. £27k each.v

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 01/08/2021 12:34

How is she with them? Is she good with them when they are there?

ancientgran · 01/08/2021 12:34

@FourEyesGood

She gives me cash & I have to get gifts, wrap them etc. It has always been like that and she never deviates.

I would love this instead of the weird shit that my in-laws buy for our children at birthdays and Christmas.

Oh yes, my late MIL would arrive with two big black bin bags of stuff for each child. Most of it never played with. She was all about volume and had some strange ideas. Money would have been such a relief or even asking for suggestions or taking the hint that 8 bin bags of random stuff for kids who also got presents from other GPs and aunts and uncles and even their parents was just too much.
Fluto · 01/08/2021 12:34

Our children are going to be saddled with debt on completing their education, not have the same opportunities and have to work well into their old age.

This is spouted often on here. To have gone onto further education back then you'd already be from a relatively well off family. The expectation for many was that they were contributing financially to the household as soon as possible, and college to study something vocational was usually the case.

Student debt is only paid back now if you earn over x amount, and even then its a small amount, I'm not sure where the idea that people are saddled with it comes from. If you don't go on to earn a decent wage following your degree then you don't pay it back, if you do, then although of course after x amount of time in the workplace you might be on the same wage as someone with a degree so it's not always the case, but having a degree usually leads to increased income over someone's working life, therefore you're still better off even with paying some back each month. It's then written off after 30 years and in some other circumstances, unless a very high earner most people don't pay back as much as they borrow. It doesn't affect getting a mortgage etc, aside from the monthly payment being taken into account, but it isn't like they say oh you owe £40k so you can't have a loan. Social mobility is very much easier than it was then, even though there is still a way to go.

Grandparents have no obligation to buy stuff for their grandchildren or to spend time with them.

Hoppinggreen · 01/08/2021 12:33

How much money do you think she should pay to see her grandchildren?
Some people like to spend money on other people and some don’t. If she doesn’t buy them anything for Birthdays and Christmas that’s a whole other thing but apart from that she’s under no obligation to spend anything- and neither are you

Grapewrath · 01/08/2021 12:32

There’s a strange thing on mumsnet that once adults are grown they shouldn’t have any expectations of their parents from a support perspective or as grandparents.
They aren’t obliged to make an effort with your kids however neither should they expect anything from you in terms of effort or care etc. I don’t mean financially but I’m general.
My parents have never bothered and while it’s not an obligation I do think they’re crap grandparents as a result.
My advice is to focus on those who love and cherish your kids

Seeline · 01/08/2021 12:31

Does she live nearby? See the children often?

Muggymama · 01/08/2021 12:31

@Eviethyme

I would be hurt because my mum spends every last penny of hers in my kids even when I say don't you dare. She just loves them so much and wants to treat them. It's constantly the toy they want or the food they want etc and even if she didn't treat that much I would be confused to have a grandparent not spend anything on the kids when they are well off.
This exactly is how mine are. I just genuinely don't understand her that is all.
OP posts:
Muggymama · 01/08/2021 12:30

@bluebeck

AIBU to expect MIL to pay??? Shock

What do you mean? She should be giving you money?

You sound really jealous of MIL

That is quite a funny and incorrect assumption! I do not want her money or need it and never have. My title was misleading, I accept that!
OP posts:
Eviethyme · 01/08/2021 12:29

I would be hurt because my mum spends every last penny of hers in my kids even when I say don't you dare. She just loves them so much and wants to treat them. It's constantly the toy they want or the food they want etc and even if she didn't treat that much I would be confused to have a grandparent not spend anything on the kids when they are well off.

RadandMad · 01/08/2021 12:27

I don't think it's about the money, is it? It's about the kindness and thoughtfulness for the grand kids, and wanting to build a relationship with them. Tbh, it sounds like she's just not bothered, so she'll get the relationship with them that she wants/deserves, because your kids will naturally gravitate to the grandparents who give a shit.

Inni632 · 01/08/2021 12:27

Does she do other nice things? Does she cook them their favourite meals? Want to spend time with them? Take them out?

My parents are very generous and always buy DS lavish gifts. My in-laws don't buy gifts at all but are constantly inviting us round and spoiling DS with love and attention. Always cooking his favourite food and baking his favourite desserts. FIL enjoys gardening so loves spending time in garden with DS. MIL is forever reading books and joining him with Peppa pig.

I don't expect any gifts from them. They do more than enough and DS knows how loved he is by both family

Muggymama · 01/08/2021 12:26

@ApolloandDaphne

Pay for what?
I started to wite post and didn't change title, I know that sounds all wrong and had only written that while thought of appropriate title. It is not about money, more an attitude to the grandkids that they don't matter.
OP posts:
IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 01/08/2021 12:25

It's knowing what their favourite things are, what they like to do, their interests etc. that's what I mean about knowing and understanding them

But you equated those things with treats not knowledge alone.

GenderAKAStereotypes · 01/08/2021 12:24

Finish the question I mean!